Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go and live in a cheap room for a month or two

136 replies

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 08:09

With my partner who I currently live with (providing he agrees)
We currently live in the city centre (this is very convenient for us as non drivers due to work locations).
Paying £1050 per month including all bills and council tax, however this is for a studio flat. I pay a bit more due to our incomes, so I pay closer to £600.
I also have to pay £55 to student finance each month (this is due to a period I was working abroad) £110 CC debt, and honestly it's killing me.
Our flat is lovely but absolutely tiny.
I've just changed jobs and gone from weekly to monthly pay which is also killing me atm. I only have around £600 n savings.
Our tenancy is due to end on the 1st September. Part of me is very tempted to go and live in a flatshare for a month or two, where rent will be more like £350 each including all bills. I have seen some where you can just rent on a month to month basis without having to sign a tenancy which will be ideal.
We'd also get the deposit back from our current place.
I'm not saving and I'm anxious about paying next month's rent. I just want a month or two to save up a few hundred, then we can look for a more affordable property. Does this sound like a good idea? We're in Manchester.
Obviously he has to agree too.

OP posts:
Hiddiddleyho · 28/07/2023 14:51

Miajk · 28/07/2023 13:58

Yep, but currently they're not splitting things that way. Which is fine, I'm all for splitting based on income.

But in that case OPs debt should not absolutely taken into account too rather than her paying more towards the shared expenses and then having debt to pay for too. You're being taken for a ride OP

I agree with this. Make sure you're splitting things right.

For me if you want a short term flat share fine, but make sure you will actually be able to get back into a solo flat after that. Will you be able to compete?

It might be better to get a summer job if you can.

Rachykins · 28/07/2023 14:37

You have so much disposable income as a couple after you’ve paid your bills. I mean.. saving money is great and yes you’d possibly save a lot more if you did decide to go into shared living but I’m struggling to find the appeal especially as from my point of view… you aren’t struggling for money each month? I’d much rather have my privacy and freedom as an adult than be sharing unnecessarily.

Miajk · 28/07/2023 13:58

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/07/2023 13:52

Well, quite. All rent and bills should be split 50/50. Then she covers 100% of her debt on top.

Yep, but currently they're not splitting things that way. Which is fine, I'm all for splitting based on income.

But in that case OPs debt should not absolutely taken into account too rather than her paying more towards the shared expenses and then having debt to pay for too. You're being taken for a ride OP

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/07/2023 13:52

Miajk · 28/07/2023 13:43

Why should OP fund his living expenses partially? Using your logic they're not married or don't have kids.

OP said she contributed more to rent than he does

Well, quite. All rent and bills should be split 50/50. Then she covers 100% of her debt on top.

Miajk · 28/07/2023 13:43

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/07/2023 13:41

Why should the partner share the cost of the debt repayment? They aren't married or have kids.

Why should OP fund his living expenses partially? Using your logic they're not married or don't have kids.

OP said she contributed more to rent than he does

Miajk · 28/07/2023 13:42

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 10:52

Thank you for the replies, argh I don't think some people have read the thread properly, I said it was just this couple of months. I'm not asking for advice about how I spend my money. I said I've gone from weekly to monthly pay and I haven't been able to work as much.
No, not all supply teachers can earn over £1800.
I will not be earning much over the summer holidays. I also have the £200 debts per month.
When you have about £1200, £600 rent, £200 debts, transport and food costs, you aren't really left with anything.
Anyway thanks for the advice and I will still be considering the flatshare.

We have read the thread properly but slapping short term plasters on long term problems keeps people poor.

Risking your current tenancy in a crazy rental market to save a few hundred would very likely end up costing you more down the line.

I think a lot of posters are just pointing out that you should review your spending/budget otherwise you'll always be in this situation.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 28/07/2023 13:41

Miajk · 28/07/2023 13:40

Considering your debt your partner should be contributing 50/50 surely as your salary is higher but your disposable income possibly isn't?

Why should the partner share the cost of the debt repayment? They aren't married or have kids.

Miajk · 28/07/2023 13:40

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 11:16

Ah that is good to know, thanks.
In this situation it's because I am missing payslips for when I worked abroad around 5 years ago. They were all paper, unfortunately I do not have every payslip for the time I was abroad, I have asked my former employer a couple of times but they have not provided them.
So Student finance state that I owe them around £1500. This has been worked out as £55 per month repayment for around 2 years. It's frustrating but not sure what I can do.

Considering your debt your partner should be contributing 50/50 surely as your salary is higher but your disposable income possibly isn't?

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/07/2023 12:00

Pinkitydrinkity · 28/07/2023 10:19

That’s so incredibly rude.

For one, you don’t know how old the OP is.

Secondly, the cost of housing has increased so much now. The average house is now what, 8 times the average salary and it’s impossible to get onto the property ladder. “Older people” had the benefit of buying houses 4x the average salary (if that!) plus you could take a 100% mortgage or even put the deposit on a credit card.

It’s not great that two working individuals should have to house share but that’s the reality of the housing market now.

Which older people are we talking about? You certainly couldn’t get a 100% mortgage nor even borrow 4 times a person’s salary when we bought. We were lucky as it was post the late 80s crash, which was crazy scary. In the late 80s, houses also were totally unaffordable. Things go in cycles and hopefully they will again without massively crashing again.

Food and clothes were way more expensive in income percentage terms. To compare prices, I bought a leather jacket for £100 in 1987. My winter coat, which came from a now defunct shop similar to Dorothy Perkins (I forget the name) cost £80 in 1990. Leather winter boots over £50 and needed as there was snow, which turned to ice on the ground for about 2 months. My 65 litre rucksack bought at about the same time was £80. We can get all of these items for the same price today over 30 years on.

Lachimolala · 28/07/2023 12:00

I think it’s a great idea, I would look at doing it for 6 months to 1 year in order to really save up a chunk of money.

AliceMcK · 28/07/2023 11:56

It definitely sounds very sensible.

dose your work have showers or are you a member of a gym? When I flat shared I wouldn’t always use the bathroom at home for showers, I’d either go to my gym in the morning or at one job I had the company had a couple of showers for staff to use.

I flat shared through my 20s & early 30s I only stopped when I finally had enough and needed my own space, my rent tripled, commute tripled and travelling costs more than doubled, but at 34 I’d had enough of flat sharing.

taxguru · 28/07/2023 11:55

We've had this discussion with our son who's having to move to live in a new city for his first job after graduation. He's hell bent on avoiding a flat/house share as he says he's already had 3 years of sharing in Uni accommodation and hated it, even though he liked his flat mates and generally got on with them - he'd far rather have had his own kitchen and bathroom as he hated the mess, people "borrowing" his stuff (bread & milk etc), conflicts over people spending too long sat on the loo or in the shower, having to plan meal times so they weren't trying to cook at the same time, etc.

He wants his own flat so that he's free to do what he wants, when he wants, etc and not go into the kitchen only to find the half pint of milk he had the evening before is now just an inch at the bottom of the container!

We've tried to tell him that "grown up" house/flat shares will likely be different, but he's not willing to take the risk, especially as the new city is a Uni city and he suspects there'll be students as his flat/house share mates!

He's happy to live on the outskirts and get public transport into the city every day if it means he can afford his own flat to rent.

As said above, Manchester has really good public transport options, so the OP should consider moving out and getting the bus, train or tram to work.

Mayhem3 · 28/07/2023 11:42

If your tenancy is coming to an end anyway then I’d try it whilst looking for something else.

I doubt you’ll get much UC because my brother earns about £1400 a month and pays rent, bills and child maintenance but isn’t entitled to anything because he’s a single adult.
And if you do get some then it won’t help you this month as they see how much you earn and then adjust it next month.
So I wouldn’t rely on it.

Some people don’t understand that sometimes you just don’t get enough money to cover all of the bills and still have lots left over.
Its not that you aren’t budgeting well.

My friend and her DP was in the same situation and they bought a caravan on a residential site and it was gorgeous and so spacious.
Her DPs dad lent the them the money to buy it though so they were lucky but perhaps this could be something you look into in the future. I’m sure there must be a way to get finance on them and they’re a lot cheaper than most flats/houses.

Magneta · 28/07/2023 11:34

It sounds really sensible and low risk. But if this is a special set up designed for short term then isn't it going to be more expensive than mainstream alternatives? Maybe do a cost benefit between that and having 6 months in a double room in a house share, and making a really good dent in the credit card bill or paying it off.

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 11:31

Yeah that's true, there are many risks.when I was single I lived in mostly pleasant ones but I've heard of bad ones.

OP posts:
Needmoresleep · 28/07/2023 11:31

I am a landlord and a tenant in a shared property owns his own place, which he rents out. He is a successful actor/musician so I assume that at some point during lockdown he decided to ensure he could pay his mortgage by renting his flat out and reducing his costs. He is a good (understanding!) tenant and seems to get on with his flatmates who are old friends. Two out of the four are a couple.

tallsmallmum · 28/07/2023 11:30

Imagine if it did "suck" ? as others have said you'd lose your tenancy in favour of this short term let; you might have a revolving door of people making life hell for you and not even able to relax on settee or bath I know not everyone likes baths then imagine how it'd impact your state of mind and affect your teaching? you might end up spending loads of money and effort on; cleaning materials and cleaning for everyone, locks/lockable boxes, earplugs, sleeping masks, shopping every day no batch cooking coz no freezer space, replacing staple foods that get taken, wet weather clothes for all the being out you have to do if unpleasant house "mates" I really couldn't risk my sleep and state of mind coz then risk my job too

Crikeyalmighty · 28/07/2023 11:24

@Ripsinead they need to know though that your income has dropped - (notify change of circumstances if you haven't)

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 11:22

Thank you. maybe we will get UC again end of next month, fingers crossed.

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 28/07/2023 11:20

If you aren't earning during the summer holidays (and I can see that's an issue) you would get a higher UC payment because of rent I would think

I don't disagree with you doing this by the way, but I think it might be more expensive than you think to do- many house shares will ask for a deposit too which you may well not get till 2 weeks after you leave from your current place.

If it's a short term thing I would just be looking at getting some temp work, even if it's a factory or something.

I appreciate you don't want advice on how to spend your money but I would still say is this all coming down to you? And why is your partner paying less rent as incomes look about the same ? That doesn't seem fair at all- I don't want you to get taken for a mug-- I've been there!!

If it's not just about money though and you prefer the vibe of more people around at this stage of life , nothing wrong with that at all - my son could easily afford a studio flat on his own- he doesn't want one, he likes living in a nice area and the company.

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 11:16

Ah that is good to know, thanks.
In this situation it's because I am missing payslips for when I worked abroad around 5 years ago. They were all paper, unfortunately I do not have every payslip for the time I was abroad, I have asked my former employer a couple of times but they have not provided them.
So Student finance state that I owe them around £1500. This has been worked out as £55 per month repayment for around 2 years. It's frustrating but not sure what I can do.

OP posts:
PuppyMcPupFace · 28/07/2023 11:11

If you're on a low income but have tipped into higher and triggered loan repayments, Student Finance will repay you. DD got £300 back after a tip on here.

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 11:11

Thank you, I'll look at alternative work options first.

OP posts:
Bottlesofhot · 28/07/2023 11:08

Sorry just read the update, could you get a bar job in the evenings? Honestly, I wouldn't lose a secure tenancy to save a few pounds in a risky short term house share in this market.

caringcarer · 28/07/2023 11:06

Sealover123 · 28/07/2023 09:10

I would do it for 6 months to a year. Get on track financially, save and then find your own place. It might suck but just think of the end goal 😊

Me too. Make sure you pay off your debts first, then save, then life will be easier for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread