Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go and live in a cheap room for a month or two

136 replies

Ripsinead · 28/07/2023 08:09

With my partner who I currently live with (providing he agrees)
We currently live in the city centre (this is very convenient for us as non drivers due to work locations).
Paying £1050 per month including all bills and council tax, however this is for a studio flat. I pay a bit more due to our incomes, so I pay closer to £600.
I also have to pay £55 to student finance each month (this is due to a period I was working abroad) £110 CC debt, and honestly it's killing me.
Our flat is lovely but absolutely tiny.
I've just changed jobs and gone from weekly to monthly pay which is also killing me atm. I only have around £600 n savings.
Our tenancy is due to end on the 1st September. Part of me is very tempted to go and live in a flatshare for a month or two, where rent will be more like £350 each including all bills. I have seen some where you can just rent on a month to month basis without having to sign a tenancy which will be ideal.
We'd also get the deposit back from our current place.
I'm not saving and I'm anxious about paying next month's rent. I just want a month or two to save up a few hundred, then we can look for a more affordable property. Does this sound like a good idea? We're in Manchester.
Obviously he has to agree too.

OP posts:
JessW1970 · 29/07/2023 19:57

Niftyswiftie · 28/07/2023 08:34

Is that even minimum wage? Are you both working full time? I'd rather work as many hours as I could than flat share.

On those sorts of figures per month each, that would be c.£17-18k each annually, so well above minimum wage!

DJT86 · 29/07/2023 09:30

I think it's a great idea. It will allow you to save and think about a long term goal. We wanted to move nearer family in Surrey so super expensive. The only way we managed is moving further away for several years to save money to then afford our long term goal of buying in Surrey. Your wages as you identified are due to go up. Do monthly savings plan you won't notice as you just won't have that money but it will soon add up. Good luck

Pollyfeeney · 29/07/2023 08:38

Buy or rent somewhere near a tram stop in Manchester - prestwich ?

Mrsmozza123 · 28/07/2023 18:22

Really sensible to consider reducing overheads if they are making you nervy.
one thing to consider is what the cost of renting a new place might be when you are ready. Often the best way to keep rent low is to stay put as rent increases are usually minimal for current tennants as landlords prefer to keep tenants rather than finding new ones. Renting the same or similar place down the line could cost more which negates any savings. That said it doesn’t sound like you love it where you are anyway.

curveball. Could you rent a 2 bed and sublet the spare room? That way you control who lives with you and, might even find a mid week only lodger. Just a thought.

camperjam · 28/07/2023 16:48

I was renting a flat with my boyfriend at the time and we went into separate houseshares to pay off debts and save for a deposit on a mortgage.
Short term pain for long term gain

Caroparo52 · 28/07/2023 16:29

You sound very sensible and grounded op. Yes, do it to save up a buffer amount. That will give you a bit of security and peace of mind.

YouHaveAnArse · 28/07/2023 16:26

Goldbar31 · 28/07/2023 16:24

I think it’s a good idea, but it would need to be for longer than a month or two.
My sister is currently doing the same in Chorlton.
Previously, she also rented a room from a lovely older chap, with the agreement that she assisted with some of his care/social needs - like having breakfast etc.

Good luck; I know the rental market is wild at the moment.

They're doing it as a couple, though, which might be tricky in terms of an arrangement like that (although that sounds like it would be good for someone who isn't working full time at present!)

Goldbar31 · 28/07/2023 16:24

I think it’s a good idea, but it would need to be for longer than a month or two.
My sister is currently doing the same in Chorlton.
Previously, she also rented a room from a lovely older chap, with the agreement that she assisted with some of his care/social needs - like having breakfast etc.

Good luck; I know the rental market is wild at the moment.

YouHaveAnArse · 28/07/2023 16:15

tallsmallmum · 28/07/2023 11:30

Imagine if it did "suck" ? as others have said you'd lose your tenancy in favour of this short term let; you might have a revolving door of people making life hell for you and not even able to relax on settee or bath I know not everyone likes baths then imagine how it'd impact your state of mind and affect your teaching? you might end up spending loads of money and effort on; cleaning materials and cleaning for everyone, locks/lockable boxes, earplugs, sleeping masks, shopping every day no batch cooking coz no freezer space, replacing staple foods that get taken, wet weather clothes for all the being out you have to do if unpleasant house "mates" I really couldn't risk my sleep and state of mind coz then risk my job too

I've been a lodger twice. The first time was great, we got on well and shared our space even though it obviously was their home that I lived in. The second one was with a LL that never ever left the house, and that started to drive me mad because I'm someone who really really needs their own space without other people in it from time to time. He'd work from home and then work in the corner of the living room, watching TV through a mirror, meaning that I never felt comfortable just being in there, and he would never go out either - it got to the point that I'd be taking annual leave just to be able to be in my home on my own. At one point he invited a friend of his to sleep in the dining room for several weeks without checking with us or letting us know (which, of course, he can as it's his house, but...).

The dynamic with a house share is different from being a lodger, but my god, do I feel lucky sometimes when I wake up in the morning and can walk around my flat in my underwear if I feel like it, or use the living room to work on the table, or have my DH go out and give me the place to myself on a Friday, and never getting ready for work and almost falling over some guy sleeping under the dining table. When I put our current rent into Rightmove all I seem to see now are rooms in houseshares for the same amount and the thought of doing it now in our forties as a couple is not appealing, I have to say.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 28/07/2023 16:08

Try to teach in a private school? Also do a bit of private tuition one evening and charge a lot. You can also sign up to a babysitting app. Lots of money to be made!

YouHaveAnArse · 28/07/2023 16:06

It's going to be a big adjustment for you both to go from a place of your own to the two of you basically living in one room, even if you are in a studio at the moment. Do either of you need to work from home? Could you both do so from your room if you went into a houseshare? It sounds like you plan for this to be short term but with the rental market in Manchester being insane right now it may end up being longer, so it's worth thinking about.

I haven't house-shared for a bit but if I went back to it I personally wouldn't want to live with a couple. Not sure what the dynamic is like the other way around, I guess it depends on you all getting on which is the real gamble with housesharing.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 28/07/2023 16:02

Depends. Are you sure you will be able to rent a comparable flat again in (about) 6-12 months? That would not be a given where I live... There is so much competition on the renting market currently.

Would you rent one room together or two rooms each? Sharing one single room, especially if there is no large(r) common area - which you would obviously have to share with your other flatmates - could put a massive strain on your relationship. I personally really would not want to do it unless absolutely necessary.

I agree with this:
Just to check, your joint income will be £3,200 a month in Sep and your total bills are £1,100 (housing) + £165 (debts) + £400 (average for food + essentials for 2 people) = £1,665. No travel costs. So if you have £1,535 left each month, why can’t you save some of it?

Usernamen · 28/07/2023 15:53

I flat-shared for 8 years and only stopped when I reached 30 and found I couldn’t stand it any more. Having my own space became more important than having more money.

However, 8 years of saving meant I had a deposit to put down on a flat and only spent around 8 months renting solo (which I believe to be THE most expensive living arrangement, especially in London where I live).

Good luck and make sure you find nice flatmates because you always ends up flat sharing longer than you think you will be.

2bazookas · 28/07/2023 15:45

I will still be considering the flatshare.

Just be careful who you share with. If one of the flat mates defaults on rent or shared bills , the ones remaining may be liable for those costs as well as your own.

DragonDoor · 28/07/2023 15:35

A room in a flat share for a couple, in central Manchester that including bills for £350? No tenancy? I’d honestly be concerned it could be a scam, or there would be a catch somewhere.

You are also underestimating the hidden costs of moving. Even if you do get your full deposit back from your current place, some of it could be eaten up again in extra costs.

The deposit on your next permanent flat could even be higher again, so you could end up in the red.

You may need to buy some new things/ storage, even if the new place is ‘furnished’. E.g lamps and storage.

Kitchen might not be effectively kitted out/ people may not do their dishes. You may need to buy kitchen equipment if you don’t already have it.

What will you do with your existing belongings? Have you factored in the cost of storage?

Also, next summer you may find yourself in the same position if you don’t have permanent employment ….

Would you not consider looking for a cheaper flat/ permanent room to live in longer term? Save over a longer period?

Moving somewhere for a month or two is a lot to go through for the sake of saving a small amount, when you could live frugally to get yourself though the next few months instead.

JaninaDuszejko · 28/07/2023 15:32

Pinkitydrinkity · 28/07/2023 10:19

That’s so incredibly rude.

For one, you don’t know how old the OP is.

Secondly, the cost of housing has increased so much now. The average house is now what, 8 times the average salary and it’s impossible to get onto the property ladder. “Older people” had the benefit of buying houses 4x the average salary (if that!) plus you could take a 100% mortgage or even put the deposit on a credit card.

It’s not great that two working individuals should have to house share but that’s the reality of the housing market now.

The OP is clearly young (late 20s, early 30s?), she has no kids, does not have regular work and from the sound of things hasn't been with her partner that long. That's why she should be in a houseshare. I lived in house shares all through my 20s, as did all my friends because that's what was normal in the 90s. Living in a houseshare means you reduce your living costs and had flexibility until you had more stability in your life. DH and I didn't buy a house until our 30s (in the early 2000s when prices were rising between the slump in the 90s and the crash in 2008).

As far as the cost of housing goes she lives in the NW where average house prices (£212,814) are considerably lower than the English average, and there's plenty of flats and terraces well below that in Manchester. So this isn't about how hard it is for young people in expensive areas to buy a house, it's about cost of living and how her RENT has increased dramatically and what she could do to ameliorate that.

ReadingSoManyThreads · 28/07/2023 15:29

Whilst I do think it's a good idea, I do think it would be better to do it for longer than just 3 months. Otherwise, you're not really getting much debt paid off or savings started. Is your current rent now at current market rates? Firstly, I would go back to your LL and say you can no longer afford the rent since the £200 increase (which in my personal opinion is a really big increase in one go), and try to negotiate it down to say £100 instead. It will cost your LL more to get new tenants in and if your LL is paying a letting agency, that'll cost a hefty re-let fee for LL, so really it's in LL's best interest to negotiate with you. Agree with other posters that getting back into a rental property will be tough as there is so much demand but if you have good credit scores, hopefully you'll get something eventually.

Mamucium · 28/07/2023 15:28

Completely agree with previous posters who have said you need to consider carefully if you’ll definitely be able to get somewhere else in a few months before you give notice. The rental market in Manchester is crazy at the moment - I just had a look on Rightmove and the cheapest non-sharing options I could find (in Chorlton and Gorton) were £650 per month. Assuming something similar were suitable/available and you didn’t have to offer over to secure it would you actually make a saving once you take transport costs into account?

JustAnotherOpinion123 · 28/07/2023 15:28

I was in a similar situation with Student Loans, not sure how it happened but the wrong payslips were used to calculate my loans one year and when I applied for postgrad study, they spotted it and set up a payment plan for me to pay it off. Might be worth getting in contact with them to see if you can reduce it further due to fluctuating income or even if you can pause the repayments until October? They definitely paused mine for a while when I was struggling to repay.

JustAnotherOpinion123 · 28/07/2023 15:23

You have my sympathy OP; I'm currently doing a review of bills etc because it feels like we should have a lot more disposable income than we do, and when you look at your bills, it's depressing to see how quickly the little bits add up - I found I was spending in excess of £100 a month just on quick trips to the local co-op for things I'd forgotten in a normal shop or for snacky lunch bits! Definitely spend a bit of time reviewing your expenditure before making any big decisions.

The houseshare sounds like a good idea but the rental market is absolutely bonkers at the moment, so your plan of "just a couple of months" may end up being more than that while you try to secure somewhere else. That's the only bit I'd be reluctant to risk.

ivykaty44 · 28/07/2023 15:15

Sorry just read the update, could you get a bar job in the evenings?

but then surely the boyfriends will be reducing his rental payments further whilst the OP increases her rental payments as they share the rent on the earnings percentage they both make?

ivykaty44 · 28/07/2023 15:08

the tram from zone 3 is £85 a month

sound sensible to down size for a while.

but with rental properties being much sight after, is it wise to let go of a tenancy ?

Strugglingtodomybest · 28/07/2023 15:05

Me and my now husband started off our live together 22 years ago in a house share, it was fine. I'd do it OP and save as much money as you can.

Catza · 28/07/2023 14:59

My biggest concern would be actually finding a suitable flat at a reasonable cost after you spent a few months in a flat share. The rental market is awful at the moment with as many as 20 applicants fighting for the same place and landlords jacking up the prices as a result. We are in an unfortunate position where we were served section 21 notice because our landlord wants to increase our rent by 65% and we only managed to secure another house from a client of my partner who asked us for 6 weeks deposit plus 2 months rent upfront. This is almost 5k gone just to be able to get somewhere to live. I would absolutely not leave a property voluntarily at this point in time.
If you struggle to afford rent over the next month, can your parents give you a loan? Then, you should be able to easily cover your expenses come September.
I would look at every conceivable option including extra job over summer, partner picking up some of the slack temporarily etc. before leaving a long-term tenancy.
I know you don't want money management advice but I would also seriously consider prioritising CC payments over savings once your work situation improves.

benfoldsfivefan · 28/07/2023 14:58

As you’ve got a flexible tenancy so can leave before it’s due to end, I would look for something now for at least six months as others suggest, so you can save more. To be blunt, not many landlords will take couples in flat or houseshares, but you’d eventually find a double room in a decent area for £500 exclusive of bills. Good luck!

Swipe left for the next trending thread