Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you were rich/very comfortable would you sit by and watch your kids struggle?

82 replies

WaxBar · 27/07/2023 23:13

Just a general query as I don't get if it's me or her who is more fucked up.

No wrongdoing on part of kids. Parents were ok on paper in childhood (i.e. all basic needs met in keeping up appearances style) but emotionally neglectful (NO cuddles, kisses, words of kindness or reasurance) with physical abuse (hitting with hands, wooden spoons, leather belts including the buckle when especially bad). One parent (my mum) financially controlling of the other (who has earned the ££££££).

They've made great efforts since with my DC and other grandkids (to make up for their failings with me and my siblings?). My mum disclosed childhood SA to me and since then I've felt I've understood her more and we've both felt our relationship has dramatically improved.

Anyway, I'm a single mum doing a very emotionally draining job in NHS. Pay is so low as to require UC top up.

My new mortgage rates have come through and are horrendous. I'm dealing with it. Have appointments booked for advice etc.
I told my mum and she's basically said tough shit and it's also hard for my brother (him and his wife are both on triple figure salaries so not really comparable).

I didn't and don't expect financial help but was I asking too much to expect a morsel of kindness and moral support?

I could never sit back and watch my DC struggle when I had more money than I could ever get through in this lifetime.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
drpet49 · 28/07/2023 12:48

Isthisreallyok · 28/07/2023 00:08

I would absolutely help if I had the means and my DC were struggling financially

This. What kind of person wouldn’t help their kids out.

TheDogthatDug · 28/07/2023 10:44

I would love to be in a position to help my DD with a house deposit. She is renting a tiny house and paying a ridiculous amount in rent and is struggling. I wish I could help her.

Hugasauras · 28/07/2023 09:09

I don't stop being a parent when my kids grow up. We look after each other in this family, and if we have more than we need and either or both girls could use some help to make their lives easier then we will do it without question.

My mum helped us out financially at various points in our lives and it allowed us to buy a much better house and for me to work part-time with young children, which has been amazing. I'd love to be able to do that for my own kids, and thanks to my mum being so switched on financially, she's left a substantial inheritance which will allow us to do that for our kids.

Sorry you are struggling, OP Flowers Small consolation but I think this kind of thing does make us better parents to our own children in a way, as you will never let yours struggle in the same way.

Jellycatspyjamas · 28/07/2023 09:08

Unempathetic people also tend to think: "well no one helped me, I had to do X - it was hard - but I was OK. Plus I've already helped in XYZ way, which is way more than I got."

I don’t think that’s necessarily a lack of empathy. I can empathise with someone in their situation but that doesn’t mean it’s for me to fix it for them. If I had given a substantial sum for a house deposit and was making great efforts with my grandchildren (as the OP says her parents are), I wouldn’t be wanting to contribute further tbh. There’s a point when help fosters dependency.

The OP also talks about her poor childhood as if her parents should be financially compensating her for their poor parenting, which feels quite off tbh.

diamondpony80 · 28/07/2023 09:07

I would expect them to work and I'd support them in trying to improve their financial position as much as possible themselves, but would definitely help out financially. We won't be taking it with us and if we can make life a little easier for our children then why wouldn't we. Life is hard enough as it is.

Ivalueloyaltyaboveallelse · 28/07/2023 09:05

i think you’ve been lucky. They gave you a deposit to get on the property ladder. DH parents are very well off and haven’t help us financially and I don’t blame them. DH used to be terrible with money and still isn’t the best. We’ve done everything on our own which I’m proud of. However saying that I know they’ve put money and property away for our Dc so I can’t lie they’ve done more than they should have for us.

GoingPostalTallyHo · 28/07/2023 09:00

I come from a similar background/relationship with my parents. They don't have much money, but I also can't imagine them helping in your situation if they did have a lot of money.

I myself have chosen to be childfree and recognise the same lack of empathy in myself. I sometimes have the (irrational thoughts) I list below when I hear - for example - of people's parents sending their kids a few hundred a month when they are at uni, or paying for driving lessons etc. (all these things I had to struggle to do myself with 0 help). At the same time, this is one of the reasons I've chosen to be childfree.

I wonder if it is about the regularity of the help? Sometimes, I think giving someone a lump sum (e.g. £20,000) is easier psychologically for an unempathetoc person than paying a regular amount for an unknown duration. Unempathetic people also tend to think: "well no one helped me, I had to do X - it was hard - but I was OK. Plus I've already helped in XYZ way, which is way more than I got." They might even feel jealous or unfair that [person] had help when they struggled, and resent giving help. In other words, they aren't really thinking about another person's needs or feelings, just themselves and their own feelings and hurt. That's my take anyway.

At the same time, I don't think it's right to feel that way. Even odder to feel it about your own biological child. But that is the kind of thing that might be going on in their head.

It is shit, and they should help. Surely everyone should want better for their children and should want to help of they can. Maybe try asking for a lump sum and then use the money to tide you over? It might be easier for them to process and rationalise. They might surprise you.

whumpthereitis · 28/07/2023 08:58

Well, they haven’t sat back and watched you struggle, have they? You’re on the property ladder thanks to them. Beyond that, perhaps they think it’s better for you to manage this yourself as the independent adult you are.

There’s been threads on here before about siblings resentful because their parents have taken on financial responsibility for a less solvent sibling. People tend to attach a lot of emotion to parental help, and just because your brother is better off doesn’t mean his family isn’t feeling the pinch, and it doesn’t mean he wouldn’t perceive favouritism if your parents stepped in to help you. Indeed, your parents may feel it wrong to offer help to one and not the other as well.

They may also be mindful of how much elder care costs.

Jellycatspyjamas · 28/07/2023 08:50

And as someone else who does, you should know that confidentiality is not just about whether you identify somone. It is also about people's stories not being yours to tell (other than obliquely) without their permission

And absolutely this, where are your boundaries OP, professionally and personally.

Jellycatspyjamas · 28/07/2023 08:49

I wonder where the duty on parents to financially support their kids ends. Mine aren’t there yet but I hope to be able to help them here and there - I won’t be able to find house deposits but will help them get on their feet if I can.

I wouldn’t be offering regular cash to support their monthly outgoings though, there has to be a point when they become financially independent. I’m not remotely mean, I’ve always been generous to people close to me but there has to be a limit to how much you’re expected to bail your kids out - I’d suggest that by the time they’ve bought a house and have children it’s time to stand on their own two feet.

saraclara · 28/07/2023 08:40

WaxBar · 28/07/2023 00:47

@saraclara Do you know what I almost included the word anonymously in that post but figured that no-one reading would be thick enough to interpret it as me sharing patient identifying information with a family member.

Apparently I was wrong.......

I too, had a career where confidentiality was important, and now have a retirement role where it is very much so. And as someone else who does, you should know that confidentiality is not just about whether you identify somone. It is also about people's stories not being yours to tell (other than obliquely) without their permission

If you are telling people's stories to the level that your mother is invested in individual patients' lives, then you are not respecting their privacy, and are close to using them as entertainment.

This was spelled out VERY clearly in my training. It's not just about identification. It's about respecting that you are talking about real people's lives and difficulties/trauma.

LunaTheCat · 28/07/2023 08:33

I always fail to understand meanness… mean with money= mean in spirit.
I have a friend who’s mum uses her substantial bank balance as a weapon over my friend.. it’s just awful.
I have no children but am generous with the people in my life .. I would rather give then hoard.

tuvamoodyson · 28/07/2023 08:20

She did get help. She was given money for a house deposit.

FoodFann · 28/07/2023 08:16

I would either help you, or spend the money. What I don’t understand is why some of the older generation sit on huge sums of cash (I’m talking about those with millions stashed away) and refuse to spend a penny of it. And then it goes to their kids in the form of inheritance, minus tax, when their kids are 60 and grandparents themselves, having missed out on the opportunity to actually enjoy it when they needed it! I just don’t get it at all.

malificent7 · 28/07/2023 08:14

Yanbu. My dad has always harped on about paying for my rental deposit 11 years ago. Very generous at face value but if I hadn't had to pay rent to stay at his house for a few months as a pregnant single mum I could have paid for it myself. I expect he was just pissed I was a pregnant single mum.

No way would he pay for a house deposit for me.

For context...I used to teach and now work FT for nhs. I've always worked hard.

Spacecowboys · 28/07/2023 08:06

Yes I would help out but ultimately one of my aims as a parent is to have taught my dcs the importance of financial independence, particularly by the time they have their own children.

HairyToity · 28/07/2023 07:48

My aunt helped my cousin and her husband buy a house to the tune of 250k deposit (basically passed on an inheritance she'd received). They got divorced. House got sold. Then my cousin went travelling and did another degree. Then got pregnant with her new boyfriend and was pleading poverty.

My aunt didn't have the cash for her second time round, and regrets passing over the money. I see the argument for insisting kids make their own way in the world. It's tough though.

Burningthroughthesky · 28/07/2023 07:45

Maybe she thinks that you're living beyond your means, partly due to them giving you a generous and life changing amount towards your deposit?

MiddleParking · 28/07/2023 07:40

*I didn't and don't expect financial help but was I asking too much to expect a morsel of kindness and moral support?

I could never sit back and watch my DC struggle when I had more money than I could ever get through in this lifetime.*

I don’t know why you say you don’t expect financial help when a) it’s very clear that you absolutely do and b) you’ve already had substantial financial help. It sounds like you think your mum should be offering to pay towards your monthly mortgage payments, which is a frankly insane expectation. My parents are about as generous as they come, gave me and my siblings a very substantial house deposit, pay for clubs for the kids, buy meals frequently etc. They would never dream of paying an actual monthly contribution to any of our mortgages. I don’t even think the bank would like that much at all. No one else I know who’s had a gifted house deposit gets ongoing help thereafter either. It’s just not a thing.

DeedlessIndeed · 28/07/2023 07:23

See, IMO your parents have given you a large deposit, which most children don't get. Like you say, this already is incredibly generous. Maybe they see that as them having helped and now it's up to you.

They should be offering sympathy and kindness for your situation though.

I know my parents loaned us £10K to cover some unexpected costs when we bought our house, and we repaid over 2 years. My sister is in a tough spot financially, and they help with the odd grocery shop etc. But they wouldn't help to get her on the housing ladder, that is down to her. She is now essentially stuck in expensive private renting.

I know how much my parent's have in the bank / pensions and they could buy us both family homes outright in cash whilst still maintaining a really decent income. But I think they have the opinion that they'll use whatever they need (rightly so!) and we'll eventually get any remainder when they sadly pass. I actually think that's fair, but can see I'm in the minority.

CornishAdventures · 28/07/2023 07:22

Unfortunately you can’t make people change and although this doesn’t help your situation now, all you can do is vow to be different when it comes to your children and grandchildren. That’s the promise I’ve made to myself

Zebedee55 · 28/07/2023 07:21

I have helped my kids and adult grandchildren, and will continue to, if I can. Not regularly, but things like home deposits, cars etc.

They all work hard, and the money doesn't get squandered.

But, you've already had a house deposit - how much more are you wanting?

Family helping is a massive favour - you should view it as an expectation.😗

tuvamoodyson · 28/07/2023 07:06

saraclara · 28/07/2023 00:43

me and my mum were getting on well. We speak weekly. She gets invested in patients on my caseload

What?! You discuss your patients with her? To the point that she gets invested in them?

I don't know what branch of health you're in, but what about patient confidentiality?

That immediately jumped out at me too! I’m a retired nurse and couldn’t believe what I was reading! 😲

WellPlaced · 28/07/2023 07:05

Wheretostartstitching · 28/07/2023 06:29

Op won’t ask because she drip fed they gave her deposit for a house which she describes as ‘life changing’.

They actually did help and I assume that’s the reason they haven’t been forth coming now.

Not necessarily and I did read that update.

Perhaps there are other reasons to not offer ongoing help.

BellaVita · 28/07/2023 07:02

Of course we would help them and already have. We have the means to do so and would hate to see them struggle.

Swipe left for the next trending thread