Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do people in the uk think insurance covers everything?

66 replies

bernieaa · 27/07/2023 23:03

I find that uk people think business are bound by hefty insurance and so are trades people.

Eg - I've seen it written that if a trades person such as a bathroom fitter breaks an item in the fitting, they should "claim on their insurance". They don't have insurance to cover such damage.

Or I'm pregnant woman wouldn't be allowed to use the hotel spa due to "limitations of insurance". If this was the case than people should be notified at the door and asked to sign in etc stating they aren't pregnant etc. i accept to protect the business against claims from pregnant women who potentially suffered ill health etc, but that's not a term of insurance.

Germany has got the reputation of insuring everything and being overly insured. I think people confuse laws and regulations with "insurance".

OP posts:
Spirallingdownwards · 29/07/2023 10:52

bernieaa · 29/07/2023 10:12

@Spirallingdownwards often if you are doing major works on your house, your own building insurance will put on hold and you won't be insured.

I meant if a tradesperson causes damage to your property or things THEIR insurance pays or THEY do personally not the homeowner .

Truemilk · 29/07/2023 10:41

I think a very mumsnet bingo style go-to if op has something lost, stolen or broken is to automatically suggest claiming on your home insurance

LakeTiticaca · 29/07/2023 10:40

People will (wisely) want to cover their backs for any eventuality, given that we live in such a litigious society, where people can and do sue at the drop of a hat. Who can blame them, given that somebody burgling yoir house and injuring themselves in the process, could potentially sue the householder for damages!!

thecatsthecats · 29/07/2023 10:35

bernieaa · 28/07/2023 00:01

Explain unethical? You mean uncomfortable?

Pregnancy tests would be considered medical records and as such they are protected by greater GDPR rules. So a business wouldn't be justified in asking people to take a test. Therefore people can self report.

Hot tubs and the like can be used in the second trimester. Women have hot baths.

Also no one is moderating the 15 min rule either.

I see your "people misunderstand insurance" and raise you "people misunderstand GDPR".

Because that would 100% be covered by both UK GDPR and the DPA 2018 as justifiable grounds for disclosure. A test isn't the same as a medical record, but it's in effect included in the disclaimer where you disclose if you're pregnant or not. Businesses don't insist you test because that would be frankly weird and awkward, but not because they couldn't on GDPR grounds.

bernieaa · 29/07/2023 10:12

@Spirallingdownwards often if you are doing major works on your house, your own building insurance will put on hold and you won't be insured.

OP posts:
bernieaa · 29/07/2023 10:11

HeddaGarbled · 29/07/2023 09:34

I don’t understand your beef here. You work in insurance and you’re cross because people who don’t work in insurance don’t know as much about insurance as you do? (But only if they’re “in the U.K”?)

Here’s an idea: when your specialist topic comes up on social media, use your expertise to help people, recognising that you’ll obviously know more than they do because you have professional knowledge which they don’t.

This thread is raising awareness

OP posts:
Spirallingdownwards · 29/07/2023 09:58

bernieaa · 27/07/2023 23:35

The trades person doesn't have insurance for what I described

Tradespeople should indeed have insurance for what yiu described or pay from their own pocket if they don't

HeddaGarbled · 29/07/2023 09:34

I don’t understand your beef here. You work in insurance and you’re cross because people who don’t work in insurance don’t know as much about insurance as you do? (But only if they’re “in the U.K”?)

Here’s an idea: when your specialist topic comes up on social media, use your expertise to help people, recognising that you’ll obviously know more than they do because you have professional knowledge which they don’t.

bernieaa · 29/07/2023 09:24

@Thatladdo I work in insurance, they don't. It's not required to get an electrician to change a cooker hood.

OP posts:
Thatladdo · 29/07/2023 03:57

bernieaa · 28/07/2023 10:18

@Thatladdo but insurance don't do that when there is a house fire.....

They will if they can, furthermore the police will persue that too if theres a death

bernieaa · 28/07/2023 10:18

Ladypenelopesdog · 28/07/2023 01:48

I work in a medical speciality and have to have very comprehensive insurance which is expensive.
It is a condition of my Professional Registration that I carry Professional Indemnity Insurance and Public Liability Insurance.

However, as mentioned, if I don't operate within my industry's Code of Practice then these policies could be nullified.

For my own peace of mind I also have Salary Protection Insurance.

Yeah and these are professional insurances you have. The examples I've given fall outside of this....

OP posts:
bernieaa · 28/07/2023 10:18

@Thatladdo but insurance don't do that when there is a house fire.....

OP posts:
Thatladdo · 28/07/2023 04:21

bernieaa · 27/07/2023 23:15

Another instance is someone on a forum asking for advice to change a cooker hood. Apparently this has to be done by an electrician and get "signed of" for insurance issues.

If your home insurance was so bothered they would be asking for electrical certificates when you buy houses and every 5 years. They don't.

They wont be interested until you try to make a claim bacause your house catches fire and its determined that was at fault, then they will want you to proove it was fitted, inspected and tested as safe and the details of who carried out the work, may well ask for the test certificate too.
Rentals must be tested, owned/morgaged not compulsary but recommended

Ladypenelopesdog · 28/07/2023 01:48

I work in a medical speciality and have to have very comprehensive insurance which is expensive.
It is a condition of my Professional Registration that I carry Professional Indemnity Insurance and Public Liability Insurance.

However, as mentioned, if I don't operate within my industry's Code of Practice then these policies could be nullified.

For my own peace of mind I also have Salary Protection Insurance.

bernieaa · 28/07/2023 01:30

DragonDoor · 28/07/2023 01:15

Eh? The examples you give can relate to insurance

Accidental damage is something that can be insured for in a variety of circumstances. Although that doesn’t mean that it always is.

Also, if a business doesn’t follow certain laws and regulations, their insurance policies will be void if there was to be an incident, or they could be considered liable for damages etc.

You misunderstand

OP posts:
DragonDoor · 28/07/2023 01:15

Eh? The examples you give can relate to insurance

Accidental damage is something that can be insured for in a variety of circumstances. Although that doesn’t mean that it always is.

Also, if a business doesn’t follow certain laws and regulations, their insurance policies will be void if there was to be an incident, or they could be considered liable for damages etc.

Barleysugar86 · 28/07/2023 00:40

Insurance person here... I think your post is a little confused OP.

Businesses will have legal liability cover and warranties to use equipment in accordance with manufacturer's instructions, which in the case of hot tubs no doubt exclude their use by pregnant women. They are paraphrasing when they say their insurance won't cover them but they aren't really wrong.

Any tradesman's insurance can definitely cover accidental damage, although he'd be silly to use it for a small amount, particularly if it was only just over the excess. (the thing I really want to teach people- don't touch that freezer contents cover on your house insurance. The £30 you may get back over your excess will not cover the increase in your premiums for the next five years. Resist the temptation!)

Main thing I find people struggle with is the wear and tear thing. Yes it's sad if your roof is leaking and needs replacing but of course your house insurance can't cover it unless something particularly freaky and unexpected occured (and storm winds is a high barrier to clear). All roofs will wear out and need replacing over time if left alone, it's pretty much certain. And you can't insure something you know will happen.

Reigndee · 28/07/2023 00:21

I'm disagreeing with your op because nearly all hotels spas will not allow pregnant people to use saunas and hot tubs, or at least have a disclaimer saying use at own risk, speak to DR etc. And this WILL be due to insurance liabilities and limiting risk

AlltheFs · 28/07/2023 00:05

bernieaa · 27/07/2023 23:46

It's not a legal requirement to provide an eicr to buy/sell a house; only to rent.

It might not be a legal requirement but the lender required it so we had to have it, both as sellers and buyers.

HeddaGarbled · 28/07/2023 00:04

Why do people in the uk think insurance covers everything?

Why do some posters on MN assume a whole country full of 67 million people, all think alike

Yes, what an odd OP. Is ‘not everyone being knowledgable about insurance policies’ a specifically U.K. failing?

bernieaa · 28/07/2023 00:01

Reigndee · 27/07/2023 23:52

No it would be unethical to force everyone to take a pregnancy test but the lifeguard or staff would step in if a 12 yr old was in the sauna or heavily pregnant person. And if someone tried to claim against the resort if their baby developed a Neural Tube Defect after using the sauna in early pregnancy. The hotel definitely would have liability insurance with disclaimers against people with certain conditions and ages using certain equipment

Explain unethical? You mean uncomfortable?

Pregnancy tests would be considered medical records and as such they are protected by greater GDPR rules. So a business wouldn't be justified in asking people to take a test. Therefore people can self report.

Hot tubs and the like can be used in the second trimester. Women have hot baths.

Also no one is moderating the 15 min rule either.

OP posts:
bernieaa · 27/07/2023 23:58

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 27/07/2023 23:49

Insurance policies are usually quite simple. They will pay your liabilities towards injury or damage for example as long as you've not acted illegally or recklessly. that's it basically. But to prove you've acted reasonably and complied with legislation you then have to do things like risk assessments, health and safety policy etc. Insurance policies don't specifically say to do risk assessments, but if you have done a risk assessment or have written safe systems of work etc etc it's much easier to defend a claim for compensation against you (which is true whether it's insured or not). And it's then the companies own risk assessments that lead them to a policy of not treating pregnant women for example. But that's too long winded to explain so people just say 'Insurance'

I once bought a small side table from next. I asked the sales person if they'd help me nip out to the car with it as it was an awkward shape not heavy. He said he couldn't as they weren't insured. It made me laugh as little shop package policies don't have a 'helping customers load their car' or any other relevant exclusion and even if they did, I'm pretty sure that the multi million pound global company next could negotiate an insurance contract without this in. It would be in their own risk assessments and training but not excluded in any way by Insurance.

But it does make me laugh on here when people say 'claim on the insurance' for things that would never be covered eg where a builder causes minor damage that will clearly be way below their excess or a travel policy where one of the group has basically changed their minds

Curry puts items in peoples boots....

OP posts:
bernieaa · 27/07/2023 23:56

Reigndee · 27/07/2023 23:52

No it would be unethical to force everyone to take a pregnancy test but the lifeguard or staff would step in if a 12 yr old was in the sauna or heavily pregnant person. And if someone tried to claim against the resort if their baby developed a Neural Tube Defect after using the sauna in early pregnancy. The hotel definitely would have liability insurance with disclaimers against people with certain conditions and ages using certain equipment

There is no insurance which covers them for that!

There are risks assessment which show the company has managed risks and it will state a 12 year old isn't allowed in the hot tub.

OP posts:
Reigndee · 27/07/2023 23:52

No it would be unethical to force everyone to take a pregnancy test but the lifeguard or staff would step in if a 12 yr old was in the sauna or heavily pregnant person. And if someone tried to claim against the resort if their baby developed a Neural Tube Defect after using the sauna in early pregnancy. The hotel definitely would have liability insurance with disclaimers against people with certain conditions and ages using certain equipment

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 27/07/2023 23:49

Insurance policies are usually quite simple. They will pay your liabilities towards injury or damage for example as long as you've not acted illegally or recklessly. that's it basically. But to prove you've acted reasonably and complied with legislation you then have to do things like risk assessments, health and safety policy etc. Insurance policies don't specifically say to do risk assessments, but if you have done a risk assessment or have written safe systems of work etc etc it's much easier to defend a claim for compensation against you (which is true whether it's insured or not). And it's then the companies own risk assessments that lead them to a policy of not treating pregnant women for example. But that's too long winded to explain so people just say 'Insurance'

I once bought a small side table from next. I asked the sales person if they'd help me nip out to the car with it as it was an awkward shape not heavy. He said he couldn't as they weren't insured. It made me laugh as little shop package policies don't have a 'helping customers load their car' or any other relevant exclusion and even if they did, I'm pretty sure that the multi million pound global company next could negotiate an insurance contract without this in. It would be in their own risk assessments and training but not excluded in any way by Insurance.

But it does make me laugh on here when people say 'claim on the insurance' for things that would never be covered eg where a builder causes minor damage that will clearly be way below their excess or a travel policy where one of the group has basically changed their minds