Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not forgive my MIL

108 replies

BrokeTheDietAgain · 27/07/2023 22:25

My mum died almost two years ago.

A few weeks before she died, my MIL said something REALLY horrible about her. I didn't react at the time, just changed the subject. But I can't get it out of my head.

Now each time I see MIL I just feel full of rage. I've always been pleasant to her, but recently when I see her I just struggle to be nice and polite. I mean, I am generally polite, but sometimes I'm a bit off because I just can't forgive. She probably doesn't even remember what she said

I'm seeing her this weekend. I just can't face it. I just don't like her, and that sense has increased since the last thing she said about my mum before she died was so horrible.

Don't even know what I'm asking! Maybe, how do I let this go?

OP posts:
Middleagedmeangirls · 28/07/2023 08:54

@BrokeTheDietAgain

When mum was alive I felt annoyed with my mum that she couldn't make an effort to be nice, for me. But now she's died, my anger has moved to MIL....

I think this tells us a lot - you say you have kept the peace for years and now you can't. Freud said that grief is a temporary form of insanity so it's understandable that you are experiencing feelings that are out of character for you. Are you (completely unconsciously) replicating your mums behaviour?

I think you have a lot of pent up anger and repressed words and the trauma of your mum's loss (and I am so sorry for that) is making it harder and harder to keep all that in.

You are as entitled to express your feelings and opinions as your mum or your MIL but you haven't been doing that. I think it's time for them to come out - but don't just explode at MIL and possibly say things that can't be forgotten. Do it in a safe way. Find a therapist, one experienced in dealing with bereavement and tell them how you feel. Once you have unburdened yourself in a way that can't hurt your family you will begin to see things more clearly and might be able to have a productive talk with your MIL. Or you might find you didn't need to any more.

Canthave2manycats · 28/07/2023 08:51

Georgiepud · 27/07/2023 22:36

I tried so hard to like my MiL, but the whole time I was thinking it should be my mum who was still around, not MiL. MiL wasn't at all likeable, and since the children were gaining nothing from her existence it was easier to just see her two or three times a year.

This is exactly how I felt. My mum was the best granny, and I always felt like the wrong grandmother had gone first. MIL was useless.

@BrokeTheDietAgain I think this might be the source of your anger - that MIL is still here and your lovely mum has gone. I get it.

I just sucked it up and tolerated as best I could. DH has elevated his mother to the sainthood, especially since she died 6 years after my mum did. Sometimes I have to insert my tongue very firmly in my cheek....

Wildlog · 28/07/2023 08:49

Perhaps it would make the in law haters feel better if they accepted that women find it harder to warm to in laws and step children. Men are far more tolerant in this respect. I am sure that anecdotally there will be lots of posters with valid reasons for ignoring in laws. However, many men put up with negativity from in laws and just live with it. Think of the poor son in law in Derry Girls. It is statistically so common for women to hate their MILS. It is so much easier to accept that relationships are challenging and make the best of them without driving yourself mad with fury

nearlyemptynes · 28/07/2023 08:40

I get it. I tolerate my MIL for the sake of my DH and 3 children who love her dearly. She and FIL are in their 80s with hardly anything wrong with them. My Dad is 10 years younger and has Alzheimers- it just seems so unfair. My parents and in laws dont get on at all, like wont even say hello to each other and it has caused many problems over the years. MIL is so patronising now about my dad. I just want to scream at her shut up, it should be you, which I know is unreasonable.

Inkpotlover · 28/07/2023 08:35

How does your DH feel when his mum attacks him? Instead of staying neutral, I wonder if he might actually like his wife to have his back? Then you can tell him what she said and he can help you deal with it, because presumably he’s had a lot of practice doing it!

diddl · 28/07/2023 08:29

If your husband takes the kids without you is she likely to say anything nasty to them or belittle them in some way?

I don't bother with my ILs & haven't for years.

We are in a different country so it makes it easier!

Wildlog · 28/07/2023 08:28

I shared research (there is a lot) that step mothers find relationships with step children much harder and more conflict driven than those of step fathers. The same is true of relationships with MILS and SILs. Women find it much harder to bond and form relationships with MILS and SILs and stepdaughters than men do. MN likes to deal in personal anecdotal evidence. It is the nature of a forum. However, statistically it is harder for women to embrace in laws than for me. I am sure that there are a lot of sociological reasons for this but it is worth bearing in mind that most women are more likely to be hostile to their MILS than to their mothers. If you can accept this and work with it, it makes relationships easier.

Pip1402 · 28/07/2023 08:28

@BrokeTheDietAgain Thank you. And yes, it is very hard. What helps me is knowing in my head that I'm putting on act and reminding myself it's all fake. Knowing that I'm not genuinely trying to be nice to this horrible person and I'm doing it for myself and dh to get through the event as best I can.

Seeing her does still cause me anxiety though so I understand why you don't want to.

Littlemissprosecco · 28/07/2023 08:28

BrokeTheDietAgain · 27/07/2023 22:49

Why and how have you done that? Do you regret it? Why?

When I was 21 my DF was diagnosed with MND, it was the quick type, so 6 months from diagnosis until he passed away. The day he died my then boyfriend and I were meant to be meeting her and his his dad for lunch, but my mum phoned and said ‘ you need to come’, so we apologised to my partners parents and went. She accused me of being dramatic and not appreciating that she’d been cooking all morning, he died later that afternoon. It was never mentioned again, she never said sorry about your dad, can I do anything, no hug, nothing….I’ve tried to pretend I like her for the sake of my husband and children. My eldest is 21 now and barely has a relationship with her. Over the years I’ve cooked meals, facilitated play with the kids( all on her terms of course) The problem is the pretence eats away at you and eventually ( it was when I hit 50) you realise that life is too short for fake relationships. I realise now just how untrue to myself I have been and how damaging it has been for my children and husband to witness such pretence fakeness and ultimately pain on my part. I wish I’d just broken down in tears called her out for the that she was and either way moved on. 25 years of sweeping it under the carpet really isn’t where you want to be
Good luck

Emeraldrings · 28/07/2023 08:20

Do you have to see her? My aunt didn't see her MIL for 20 years after MIL made judgy comments to my aunt.
My uncle and cousins still saw her, used to stay with her or she would come and visit when my aunt was away.
My aunt carried that on right until her MIL died, she has no regrets.

weirdoboelady · 28/07/2023 08:20

Would it help if you re-framed this distress as part of your grieving process? I feel that this could potentially help in two ways:

  1. In understanding it yourself, and letting you consider whether it was actually an awful thing MIL said, or whether/to what extent your grief is magnifying it
  2. (possibly more important) giving you a framework to approach your MIL, so that you can say to her something like "I would like to discuss something with you. I know it is part of my grief, but I keep thinking about what you said about my mum and it's really upsetting me. Could we discuss this, as it would help me work through it?" That gives her an opportunity to backpedal a bit and see what effect her words have on others, in a kind way.
RosesAndHellebores · 28/07/2023 08:20

It's complicated op and looking back I think I disliked mine the very most about 10 to15 years into marriage when all her true colours had come out. Thank goodness for MNet which has been a place to vent. It's more than 30 years now and she is a very old, widowed lady and behaves slightly better and I ignore her little digs. We have absolutely nothing in common.

Similarly to you my mother can be equally irritating and again thanks to MNet I think she is a classic narcissist which I didn't know growing up.

Mother used to put me down for not being pretty enough, not being a.party girl and for not having a high enough standard of living. MIL had numerous digs about "monied people's attitudes", "how super it was I was so practical rather than being academic" and her cracker after a string of miscarriages "such a shame you can't perform". The difference between them I think is mother doesn't necessarily do it on purpose and doesn't have a filter whereas MIL is far more crafty about it.

Looking back both of them have fallen out with numerous people over the years and have strained relationships with many members of close family. I might have the odd ruck.on here, where I speak my mind, but in RL I don't lose friends or family.

The lesson Intake from it is not to be a tit to my own DIL.

Flowers
Wildlog · 28/07/2023 08:15

Some posters see things in such black and white terms. They seem to think that people are all good or all bad. That just isn't true and is far too simplistic. If I asked everyone who knew you OP, many people would think you were lovely but some might be less than enthusiastic because you had inadvertently said something which offended them. We all do it. My husband loved his parents. I love my husband. I did a lot to support him with them. He did so much for my widowed mother. So many practical tasks for her. It is one of the many comforting things about a happy marriage. Mutual support.

Lovingleisuretime · 28/07/2023 08:11

What are some of these comments that these in laws are making?

As I've sometimes wondered whether I'm being a bit irrational, but it's been a slow drip over the years to the point I've had enough. We cannot have a single visit without fil making a snide remark.

Wildlog · 28/07/2023 08:09

When my father died unexpectedly, I was devastated. For 6 months to a year after he died, I was so resentful that my FIL was still alive. My FIL was in the early stages of dementia, he had very limited sight and was in a care home. I never told anyone I was resentful and after a while the feelings went and I was able to be loving and kind again. It is hard to lose a parent and it can mess up your relationship with others.
I was genuinely upset when my FIL died and I was so, so glad that I never told my husband and that I was able to grieve with him.

Brefugee · 28/07/2023 08:04

FWIW - i loathed my MIL because of how she treated her daughters but put her son on a bloody pedestal (I mean, my DH is fabulous, so i get it - but they did EVERYTHING for her)

Mind you, i don't like most (i have a fair few) of my SILs either. So i just engineered it that i never visited them and since they were too lazy to haul over to visit us the occasions i actually had to put up with them was extremely limited. One SIL I love dearly, she is like a sister, and we see each other a lot.

I literally don't care if i appear rude. I don't want or need to spend my time around bitchy, misogynistic (internalised) racists. So i don't. (to be fair, nor does DH)

Brefugee · 28/07/2023 07:58

Ella31 · 27/07/2023 22:32

You just have to, because you'll only hurt your husband and kids who I presume love her.

no, you don't OP. You can let your DH decide what his relationship with his mum is like, but you don't have to be a part of it. He can see her with your DCs and you can take yourself off somewhere nice for the day if she comes to yours, or not go with them when they go to hers.

And if she or he calls you rude? Repeat back to them what your MIL said about your mum, and then tell them you won't put up with her behaviour any more.

Wondeyr · 28/07/2023 07:58

Three years ago my MIL made a very hurtful comment, it was completely unnecessary and for me it killed our relationship.

I decided to completely step back. I no longer took any initiative in inviting her over, phoning her, sending her birthday card, keeping her updated, organising meals out etc.

My DH is 100% crap with any organisation so he doesn't bother. They do talk once a week though. Getting information out of him is like getting blood out of a stone, so she knows nothing really of our lives and just isn't involved or included.

Pigeon31 · 28/07/2023 07:57

OP, it is totally fine to not see your MiL if you don't want to.

I still remember nasty things my step mother said about my dead mother when I was 15, and even though both women have been dead for years, I will never forgive her for it.

Drenchend · 28/07/2023 07:50

@hot2trotter

If I had stood up to my Mil from the off set I do wonder what things would be like, better or worse.. However it was pretty relentless and constant as well! So it would have meant my entire time pushing back or making feelings known.

That's the issue with these people it's usually integral part of then!

Drenchend · 28/07/2023 07:48

Op I'm also in agreement with those who suggesting it's imperative that you 6 share what she said and how it's made you feel with your dh.

I'd go as far to say that's it's absolutely not fair to not share it?
Imagine your dh was hurting so much he came into an anonymous forum to share it?
How would that make you feel?

Don't bad mouth his mum just beautiful factual.

BTW darling, your mum said something a few months ago that I can't get out of my head. She said blah.

Unfortunately darling I don't feel loose seeing her for the time being.

End of.

chaosmaker · 28/07/2023 07:46

@BrokeTheDietAgain She sounds like Hyacinth Bucket to me. Do you really HAVE to see her? Could you be doing other things when she visits or go low contact? Does she air her views around your kids and when she does, do you disagree?

hot2trotter · 28/07/2023 07:45

Just RTFT and I'm surprised how many people are willing to put up and shut up when it comes to other people's shitty behaviour. It's mind boggling. At one time I probably would have, but as I've got older I've learnt to stand up for myself more, not be a doormat, and set my own boundaries - there's no way I'd be being polite or even neutral to someone who has crapped on me, more than once in some cases!

3isthemagicnumberrr · 28/07/2023 07:42

I totally get this. Fil said something awful related to dd and I hated him for it. After she died I didn’t want to tolerate him anymore. It came up during bereavement counselling and I decided I didn’t need to tolerate him or even see him until he knew how hurt I’d been by what he said. DH ended up speaking to him and he apologised. I still hate him but tolerate him again now, a few times a year, so the sake of DH.

hot2trotter · 28/07/2023 07:39

So what did your "D"H say? Surely he knows how much this has upset you and should be saying something on your behalf. Has he? It's his place to do something.
If I were you I'd cut MIL off completely, she sounds horrid anyway. Your DH can still take the kids to see her, but there's zero reason for you to have to.
I suspect this won't happen though and you won't dare rock the boat, your husband won't dare stand up for you, and you'll continue to see her.