Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

20 year old lazy, dirty son

532 replies

PissedOff2020 · 27/07/2023 14:10

Really at my wits end. Sorry this is a lengthily one.

We have 4 boys, eldest is 20 & dropped out of Uni after the first term - well over 18 months ago now. He didn’t tell us of course, had 5 weeks off over xmas and made no attempt to look for work. When we eventually found out and asked why the hell he hadn’t been looking for work he said he ‘wanted to chill and have the xmas break’. He was 19 then.

Mu husband eventually found him a job 2 months later, as ds’s effort was non existent. Zero hours contract and all good at first. His room was a dirty,dirty hovel with a smell coming out (think plates, food, rubbish etc all over floor). Carpet ruined, walls filthy.. clothes all over floor - can’t even open door there is that much shit. Anyway, that’s been a constant cause of arguments in house - just clean it ffs! He’s just got worse with that, we are quite house proud and I resent the smell upstairs- it’s a joke. He never contributes to household chores, despite countless conversations about it. Just does the bare minimum to get by.
Faat forward to now, his zero hours is currently working out at 8 hours a week. Been like that for 3 months and he’s not bothered to look for a job. We’ve told him he needs full time job, job hunted for him, sent him linked to apply - he does nothing. He sleeps all the time and games all night, sat in his filth.
Took him abroad last month, in the hope to speak to him away from the augments at home and also let him see life outside his bedroom. He slept all day, total waste of money. When I spoke to him about it he couldn’t see any issue with staying in his hotel room all day.
Over the last 2 months he’s got even worse, doesn’t even speak to us. Literally walks in a room and ignores us - we say hello, he has headphones on and so can’t hear anything, but makes no effort to acknowledge us etc. He eats meals if we cook, otherwise lives off sandwiches and cereal.
I have had enough, it’s intolerable. Constant tension and frustration in the house over it. Spoke to him and said I felt like he was treating us like doormats and he has no gratitude for what he has and enough was enough. Told him, the atmosphere in the house with him ignoring us was awful, just made us feel like he doesn’t give a shit about us. Asked why he wasn’t applying for jobs, he shrugged his shoulders. Told him we are not working our arses off, both working full time, for him to work a day a week and sleep all day. Then do not a thing around the house and blank us in the process.
Eventually it finished in a huge row after he snarled he’d apply for jobs but we shouldn’t speak to him at all anymore. Genuinely like he was angry we expected him to work. To add, even before his hours were really slashed he’s only ever worked around 25-30 hours per week at best. He’s had it so easily but he hasn’t a single bit of appreciation. We’ve spoken to him a year ago when he said he was unhappy at work - suggested all sorts, he was going to look into things but he never did.
I just don’t know what to try next. Explained to him over and over before yesterday this is his chance to build his career, we are supporting him whilst he does that. He’s not though, he is quite happy to do nothing and wait until it’s at breaking point - which is where I am at.
Anyone been here? Any advice from any others?

OP posts:
ontetwo3 · 28/07/2023 08:15

Your son is not coping. He has given up on university (as others said, perhaps he could not cope with the work load, demands of living away and so on). He cannot organise himself. He cannot save his dignity by finding more substantial employment.

As others have suggested, he may have mental health difficulties. He may be able to put on a 'couldn't care less' front and hide away behind his phone etc, but no-one would choose to live like your son, unless there was a reason.

I am assuming that this is new behaviour. After all, just over a year ago, he was able to pack up his stuff and set off for university. As others have suggested, he needs to be able to talk to someone. He needs to be able to work back into valuing himself again, and engaging with life a little.

The lack of communication, tendency to sleep all day, rather than engage in activities/social interaction, defensiveness, self neglect (rotting food in his room etc) all suggest (to me) that this is something more than just a lazy and unappreciative young man.

I have a 22 year old, who does not engage with life and will not look for work or even claim benefits. He is a broken soul, but he will put on an nonchalant ' don't give an F' front. I have tried the stick (do something or get out!) and the carrot (I'll pay for this, if you just try a little bit of that!) . Neither approach is effective (although both have there place). He does talk to me about his feelings, and what he tells me is frightening. Only now is he beginning to work with the MH services.

So, the first thing I would work on is trying to establish some form of communication. With my son, I noticed the music he was listening to and looked up the lyrics. It was Narrowhead, Li'l Peep and artists I had never heard of, but whose lyrics were dark. A simple question, such as 'is that how you feel?' opened up a conversation. Offer to help with the room, perhaps giving him a black bag or bin, just to put the rotten food in. Allowing him to see a large task can be tackled in small steps.

His behaviour is not excusable and there is no way that his behaviour should affect the rest of the family so negatively. However, it sounds like you son is really struggling with something, and, as other posters have said, this is, sadly, not uncommon among young people.

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:57

I'd like to see the stats from the developing world on this sort of thing. Id guess that less than 0.1% of 20 year olds would be living like this because there'd be no option for them to do it.

There'd be no parental tolerance of it AT ALL.

And the young people there know it too.

Naunet · 28/07/2023 07:53

Mollycox · 28/07/2023 02:00

not everyone is brainwashed sheep. Maybe he is woke and don’t wanna be a slave and work all his life.

That’s fine, as long as he’s not expecting mummy and daddy to slave for him and provide a roof over his head forever more. 🙄

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 28/07/2023 07:53

Ahsoka2001 · 28/07/2023 01:19

I couldn't agree more. Although - I feel like a lot of posters on here are deliberately harsher than they would be in real life cause...well...it's easy to be assertive and feel superior when you're hiding behind a keyboard. I feel like the high some posters are getting off slating this young man is like taking cocaine for them

Not enabling a 20 year old man who works 8 hours a week, lives in a midden and treats his parents disgustingly is not acting superior. Expecting more than that is acting superior? I don't even know how to respond to that. The OP says in her first post how uncomfortable this 20 year old man is making everyone in the house. Would I make him homeless? No, would be pointless when he's only working 8 hours a week. But fuck me, mollycoddling a 20 year old man who treats his loved ones like utter shit is not the way to go. I will say it again, no wonder there are so many women writing threads about living with useless manbabies. We expect nothing from them from a young age apparently. Expecting more is acting superior and makes someone a keyboard warrior.

Naunet · 28/07/2023 07:50

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I’m so sick of the whining, as if no generation has ever had to struggle before. He’s not even working full time, don’t act like he’s desperately doing his best, he’s not, he never has. Plenty of young people move out, part of it might involve giving up some luxuries that those spoilt previous generations didn’t have, you know, like their iPhones, Xbox, Netflix, and god forbid, but like previous generations, they might have to live in a shared house or somewhere that isn’t Instagram worthy. Horrifying stuff I know.

But instead of expecting them to at least try, many people on here seem quick to pathologies instead, labelling him with depression, ADHD, autism etc, because apparently they have diagnosis skills that far surpass those of trained professionals. Could he have depression etc? Sure, maybe, but that doesn’t excuse his behaviour. Getting him to a GP is just part of a bigger picture, expecting a 20 year old to grow up and start behaving in a decent manner is just basic, the cost of living is no excuse for treating other people like shit.

loislovesstewie · 28/07/2023 07:50

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:10

Well when he's in the local homeless shelter he'll realise how good he had it at home and sort himself out.

He won't be on the streets, but there'll be no sleeping all day, gaming all night going on when he's in a shelter.

Do you know how hard it is to get into a homeless shelter? He might well end up on the streets. From there it's a very short downward trajectory for some.

tidalway · 28/07/2023 07:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JudgeRinderonTinder · 28/07/2023 07:44

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:29

@tidalway no, not at all and it's sad that so many people with mental ill health are homeless.

That being said, it is by no means certain that OPs son is mentally ill. However, he is currently being enabled by her to live a half life.

If he's not mentally ill, a short sharp shock like potential homelessness would certainly help him shape up. And if he is, she can reassess the situation at a later point. I mean, if he's in a shelter for 3 months and still hasn't sorted himself out, maybe she can look at letting him back home.

But the current situation is untenable.

Nobody freely chooses to live like that. Not coming out of his room on holiday? Not speaking to his parents and locking himself in his room? Dropping out of uni? I completely accept some people are a bit lazy, but it’s highly likely there is something amiss with him given everything in the post. There MIGHT not be, but solutions need to be discussed first and foremost.

Some of these posts on here disgust me the amount of people who have said just kick him out etc. I have complete empathy as I have been through similar myself. People who think it’s perfectly easy for a mother to make her son, adult or not, homeless easily when he’s likely struggling is just beyond my comprehension. If my parents had done that to me at my worst I’m not sure I would have recovered from it. Your parents are supposed to be your strongest support, there is supposedly no one else in the world who loves you like them.

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:41

OK, well we can agree to disagree.

Young adults who know that their parents have (reasonable) expectations of them and that they have to meet them, aren't the ones ending up in homeless shelters.

OP is not being unreasonable by being angry that he's reeking her house out, treating her home with disrespect and living off her and her husband.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 28/07/2023 07:35

Online nastiness is online nastiness, even if it decides to get squirrelly and pretend it’s a principled stance.

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:32

AgathaSpencerGregson · 28/07/2023 07:24

I honestly wonder what people who post like this are getting out of their online behaviour. I can’t believe it’s a solution for what’s wrong with their lives.
im sorry this has happened to your thread OP. This situation must be so worrying. I agree with those who say the first step is a clear and reiterated message of love and concern. I also do think that many young men go through a phase of being a bit lost during adolescence (which is the developmental phase he very much is in). They come out of it.

What do you mean? Not sure what you mean by what im "getting out of my online behaviour".

I am giving advice to OP which some people (like yourself) find outrageous. Others find it sensible in the circumstances.

Would I kick my child out? Things would have to be at breaking point before I would even begin to consider it.

OP went wrong by allowing him home after quitting uni without a firm plan for what would happen with him working etc.

dayswithaY · 28/07/2023 07:31

I don’t know OP, obviously. But they are not going to let their son go into a homeless shelter (assuming there was a place available) to get her point across.

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:29

@tidalway no, not at all and it's sad that so many people with mental ill health are homeless.

That being said, it is by no means certain that OPs son is mentally ill. However, he is currently being enabled by her to live a half life.

If he's not mentally ill, a short sharp shock like potential homelessness would certainly help him shape up. And if he is, she can reassess the situation at a later point. I mean, if he's in a shelter for 3 months and still hasn't sorted himself out, maybe she can look at letting him back home.

But the current situation is untenable.

Jewel1968 · 28/07/2023 07:25

Have not read all of thread.

I would have conversation from the perspective of - I am concerned as you are clearly not functioning. It clear you are not functioning because X, Y and Z. Do you need help? He will probably say no.

On the room I would give him 3 deadlines and set that out at the beginning. By deadline 1 I want you to have made significant inroads (be specific) on your room, by deadline 2 more inroads and by deadline 3 room is finished. If by deadline 3 improvement is not achieved I and your father will enter with bin liners etc ... I would also put this in writing in an email to him.

And then say to him that if he doesn't achieve this there is clearly something wrong and urge him to seek help.

If he doesn't play ball after giving him a reasonable length of time (3 deadlines) and he doesn't seek help then I do think you will probably have to suggest that he will need to move out.

I think I would tackle room first. Then turn to employment.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 28/07/2023 07:24

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:10

Well when he's in the local homeless shelter he'll realise how good he had it at home and sort himself out.

He won't be on the streets, but there'll be no sleeping all day, gaming all night going on when he's in a shelter.

I honestly wonder what people who post like this are getting out of their online behaviour. I can’t believe it’s a solution for what’s wrong with their lives.
im sorry this has happened to your thread OP. This situation must be so worrying. I agree with those who say the first step is a clear and reiterated message of love and concern. I also do think that many young men go through a phase of being a bit lost during adolescence (which is the developmental phase he very much is in). They come out of it.

tidalway · 28/07/2023 07:16

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Dacadactyl · 28/07/2023 07:10

dayswithaY · 28/07/2023 07:07

I wonder where a 19 year old who works 8 hours a week is supposed to go if his parents do “kick him out”.

No real income, no deposit, no credit history, no guarantor. His parents love him, why would they want him to sleep on the streets?

Well when he's in the local homeless shelter he'll realise how good he had it at home and sort himself out.

He won't be on the streets, but there'll be no sleeping all day, gaming all night going on when he's in a shelter.

dayswithaY · 28/07/2023 07:07

I wonder where a 19 year old who works 8 hours a week is supposed to go if his parents do “kick him out”.

No real income, no deposit, no credit history, no guarantor. His parents love him, why would they want him to sleep on the streets?

Bagwyllydiart · 28/07/2023 07:00

Kick him out, change the locks and go NC for a year.

tidalway · 28/07/2023 06:27

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

tidalway · 28/07/2023 06:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Thepossibility · 28/07/2023 04:39

This man is an adult and needs to be pushed out of the nest.
He needs to be out experiencing how hard it is in the real world.
Tell him he has 3 months and he is out. He needs a room somewhere else and a job to fund it.
He can't grow as a person in this situation. He won't appreciate what you have provided for him until he has been forced to take responsibility for himself.

Mollycox · 28/07/2023 02:00

not everyone is brainwashed sheep. Maybe he is woke and don’t wanna be a slave and work all his life.

JogOn123 · 28/07/2023 01:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 28/07/2023 01:31

Because many of them haven't had a decent male or female adult role model in their entire lives.