Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

only fans

57 replies

abmac95 · 27/07/2023 09:17

posting on aibu as i need a quick answer.

i have recently found out that my partner has been using only fans for the last few months at least.

a few weeks ago i was using his computer and an email popped up. i got curious so had a look and there were a few emails. i asked him about it, in a casual way and he denied using only fans at all. said the emails were spam.

i believed him.

today i opened his phone, when he was in the car, to check details of something (he knew I was using his phone) and happened to see the tab with his credit card statement and it said 'only fans'. obviously curious, i then looked through the statement and saw multiple transactions.

i didnt say anything at the time and he didnt see me looking.

i know he has been lying - thats an issue
but do people think that him looking at content on only fans is a serious issue? i am not sure what to think. should i ask him about it? is it considered cheating.

we have been together ten years and have a 3 year old. since our childs birth i have had severe depression which has obviously impacted our sex life. he is a good man and brilliant dad.

OP posts:
BrownHairedGirlWithTheBrightestSmile · 28/07/2023 08:13

I have to be careful how I ask this as I'm trying to get to the bottom of 'why', but it might come out as victim shaming (not my intent)... how often do you have sex?

It seems like a daily thing in here where kids happen, menopause happens, mum is tired from baby/housework etc, and sex virtually disappears. Obviously sex is not an obligation, but there has to be a time where if it's that infrequent, the partner is going to look for some sexual release... masturbation, porn, companionship, cheating..

Wtaf? You even knew your thoughts were victim blaming and still wrote this! OP has said she has severe depression. Her partner should communicate like a grown man to his wife. He shouldn’t be paying for this and then also lying to her. But yeah, easier to blame her. You’re disgusting. I bet you’re a man! Either way, man or woman, how fucking dare you say this is in some way OPs fault.

Blossomtoes · 28/07/2023 06:31

Beneficialchampion2 · 28/07/2023 06:07

Whilst I admit he has done wrong (arguably)

The argument that paying for it makes it worse is bollocks in my opinion. Most free porn online relies on the exploitation of either women or replication of copyrighted material, meaning someone is treated unfairly as a result. Yet when someone pays for their porn and the content creator is fairly awarded for their work it is considered worse?

Your husband has been having a few cheeky tugs to pictures of someone else, hardly the end of the world, but if it makes you question your trust in him then it's realistically only going to head one way isn't it?

That’s pretty much where I am too. If getting off on erotic images of other women is cheating there can be very few men who haven’t cheated. One of my friends posed for a men’s magazine when she was young, she’d laugh uproariously at the idea she was a sex worker and even more that she was exploited. The money kept her for an entire term at art college.

The lying is the issue here. And I fully believe Only Fans was a topic of conversation among a group of women.

CherryMaDeara · 28/07/2023 06:29

abmac95 · 28/07/2023 01:21

Thanks everyone. I did ask him about it last night.

He said he was just curious and that he signed up to something that he is now unable to cancel - not sure I believe that.

Says that the women he works with, and he does almost exclusively work with women, all talk about it and he just wanted to see what it was all about.

Said he lied because he was ashamed. I do believe that. Also tried to turn it back on me, says it was boredom because I haven't really been interested in sex.

Still not sure what I make of it.

He’s basically responded with more lies.

Time to get rid.

Whosehername · 28/07/2023 06:29

You get to decide what you're okay with. I know lots of women who are okay with OF, I also know lots of women who aren't okay with their partner watching any porn at all - both are fine, they just need to be in relationships with men who are happy with those boundaries.

For me personally OF is a step too far. I have no problem with my DH looking at porn, but paying and communicating with women on only fans would make me very uncomfortable (my DH knows this, he agrees and is fine with that boundary). If we'd never discussed this and he'd somehow thought I'd be okay with it, though, I'd have likely thought it was a mistake and it wouldn't have been a huge issue...unless he then lied about it.

Lying would be a much bigger issue for me than the OF activity, tbh. If he'll lie to cover his own back over one thing, how can you trust he hasn't been doing that throughout the entire relationship, or that he won't do it again...possibly about something much worse?

Your partner has definitely been lying to you about this, do you trust him?

C1N1C · 28/07/2023 06:25

I have to be careful how I ask this as I'm trying to get to the bottom of 'why', but it might come out as victim shaming (not my intent)... how often do you have sex?

It seems like a daily thing in here where kids happen, menopause happens, mum is tired from baby/housework etc, and sex virtually disappears. Obviously sex is not an obligation, but there has to be a time where if it's that infrequent, the partner is going to look for some sexual release... masturbation, porn, companionship, cheating...

Beneficialchampion2 · 28/07/2023 06:10

GarlicGrace · 28/07/2023 01:36

The women at work all talk about it? Huh?? Does he work at a 'massage parlour'?

Women at work might talk about it in passing but it's hardly likely to be a big topic like, I dunno, Love Island or where they're having their holidays this year.

He was bullshitting you before and he's bullshitting you now.

FWIW, Only Fans isn't online porn. It's one-to-one sexual interaction with an individual, more like online prostitution.

I'm angry on your behalf, OP.

Not strictly accurate, as the partner of someone who has partaken in onlyfans content creation, 95% of subscribers are there just to look at content, interaction occurs with a very small minority. Usually subscribers pay additional premiums and tips to message or sext content creators

Beneficialchampion2 · 28/07/2023 06:07

Whilst I admit he has done wrong (arguably)

The argument that paying for it makes it worse is bollocks in my opinion. Most free porn online relies on the exploitation of either women or replication of copyrighted material, meaning someone is treated unfairly as a result. Yet when someone pays for their porn and the content creator is fairly awarded for their work it is considered worse?

Your husband has been having a few cheeky tugs to pictures of someone else, hardly the end of the world, but if it makes you question your trust in him then it's realistically only going to head one way isn't it?

TwoShades1 · 28/07/2023 05:59

Personally I wouldn’t care, but that’s a very unpopular opinion on mumsnet. I would say as long as the spending is appropriate for your income then I would leave it be. It’s disappointing he lied about it, but that implies that he doesn’t think you will react well to him using it.

Floppyelf · 28/07/2023 05:35

SunsetOverParadise · 27/07/2023 10:50

Only you know the criteria set for your relationship and where your boundaries are.

For me, he would be gone. I don’t care how ‘great’ he is in another area. These are my reasons:

  1. He lied, and not just by omission but to your face. That’s a huge deal.

  2. He is using finances that could be better spent on his children to look at women in sexual situations. So I actually don’t think he is a great dad.

  3. He thinks it’s acceptable to commodify women. IMO this also makes him a shit dad. I would not want his lack of values being passed down to my children, who I would wish to learn how to respect other people and not see them as possessions to be bought and sold.

  4. He is applying his sexual focus, deliberately, by choice, outside of the marriage. A decent man, when confronted by sexual issues that may have resulted from the woman he loves having his children, will do whatever it takes to make her feel comfortable, safe, relaxed, and beautiful in order to work on making the conditions right to have better sex. It’s a piss poor excuse to look elsewhere, to turn a blind eye to his wife’s pain, and neglect his commitments.

To be blunt, you need to respect yourself more because to allow this to slide tells him that he can treat you however the hell he wants and get away with it. If you are fine with being treated that way - without respect, and you are fine with him seeing women the way he does, then carry on.

I would be gone. He’s shown you who he is. Believe him.

this times a million

ZekeZeke · 28/07/2023 05:32
  1. He is a liar
  2. He is trying to pass the blame to you.
  3. He is taking money that could be used for family
  4. He is paying for personal sexual gratification -that's cheating in my book.

He is not a good father or partner

SunsetOverParadise · 28/07/2023 05:22

So it’s the fault of the women at the office and your fault? But not his? He’s just innocent and stupid and incapable of googling to cancel something?

Sure. If you believe this pack of bullshit then frankly, you two deserve each other.

Come on, OP. He’s still lying!

Miranaboll · 28/07/2023 02:58

Despite the innocuous stupid name it’s still porno.

decaffonlypls · 28/07/2023 01:54

He lied - directly to your face. This means you can't trust him.

He's getting sexual gratification else where and paying for it.

I'd pick a time to have a serious conversation about your relationship and wether it's working.

Only you can decide if this is a deal breaker

BrownHairedGirlWithTheBrightestSmile · 28/07/2023 01:41

He’s a sleazy bastard and a liar. Wouldn’t be good enough for me, I’d get rid of him.

AIBot · 28/07/2023 01:39

A friend is on there as a content creator and people (mostly men) subscribe to her channel. There are photos and short videos of her included with the membership that any subscriber can see. It’s porn, as others said, a modern version of the top shelf magazines. She charges extra on top of the monthly membership for anything personalised, but as I understand it not all creators offer this.

Younger women in office environments are for sure discussing this. As her friends we have spoken a lot about it as she has set aside a graduate career to focus on it full time as it’s been so lucrative! So I would try to work with him to move past it.

GarlicGrace · 28/07/2023 01:36

The women at work all talk about it? Huh?? Does he work at a 'massage parlour'?

Women at work might talk about it in passing but it's hardly likely to be a big topic like, I dunno, Love Island or where they're having their holidays this year.

He was bullshitting you before and he's bullshitting you now.

FWIW, Only Fans isn't online porn. It's one-to-one sexual interaction with an individual, more like online prostitution.

I'm angry on your behalf, OP.

ntmdino · 28/07/2023 01:36

abmac95 · 28/07/2023 01:21

Thanks everyone. I did ask him about it last night.

He said he was just curious and that he signed up to something that he is now unable to cancel - not sure I believe that.

Says that the women he works with, and he does almost exclusively work with women, all talk about it and he just wanted to see what it was all about.

Said he lied because he was ashamed. I do believe that. Also tried to turn it back on me, says it was boredom because I haven't really been interested in sex.

Still not sure what I make of it.

Well, there's an easy solution to one of those issues...

https://www.roqqett.com/how-to-delete-your-onlyfans-account

abmac95 · 28/07/2023 01:21

Thanks everyone. I did ask him about it last night.

He said he was just curious and that he signed up to something that he is now unable to cancel - not sure I believe that.

Says that the women he works with, and he does almost exclusively work with women, all talk about it and he just wanted to see what it was all about.

Said he lied because he was ashamed. I do believe that. Also tried to turn it back on me, says it was boredom because I haven't really been interested in sex.

Still not sure what I make of it.

OP posts:
VeridicalVagabond · 27/07/2023 10:56

I consider paying a sex worker cheating and I'm always baffled by the women who are more inclined to compare it to porn. He's literally paying for personalised content from a sex worker, I don't think it's comparable at all.

Regardless of whether you personally think using a sex worker is cheating or not, the lying would be the biggest deal-breaker for me. I can't stand liars.

TMI2000 · 27/07/2023 10:55

I think it really depends on what your opinion is and how it makes you feel. Sexual content is always a hot topic as some would view it as cheating and some wouldn't depending on how it makes you feel.

I would be definitely having it out with him over the lying because that makes it seem even more that there is something to hide and that's where it would feel really shifty, personally I have no issue with the watching of sexual content but paying for specific people is where it gets a little much for me personally.

If it's something you want to work through I would define the boundaries around what you are comfortable with, even if that is nothing at all and let him know how not okay it is to lie to you about it.

edenhills · 27/07/2023 10:54

Blossomtoes · 27/07/2023 10:44

I personally think Only Fans is the modern equivalent of top shelf magazines. It’s sleazy definitely, not anywhere close to cheating though. The lying would be my problem with it.

I completely disagree. There is something very personal about the interactions on only fans which is why it is so popular. I don't have a problem with a partner looking at porn (ethics aside) but would be very unhappy if they were using only fans.

CreationNat1on · 27/07/2023 10:53

I think you need to view this as something that can be worked on, treated and healed. He is viewing content, not touching someone else S body.

You are possibly both a little depressed, it's escapism. I wouldn't immediately throw the relationship away.

ntmdino · 27/07/2023 10:53

Blossomtoes · 27/07/2023 10:44

I personally think Only Fans is the modern equivalent of top shelf magazines. It’s sleazy definitely, not anywhere close to cheating though. The lying would be my problem with it.

Exactly this - and it comes with the same stigma, so it's not entirely surprising that he'd deny it. That doesn't make the lying OK, but it is understandable.

A practical, calm and non-accusatory conversation would probably solve this - more of "OK, it seems like there's a problem here, can we solve it together without you resorting to spending money on OF and trying to hide it?" than "HOW DARE YOU???".

araiwa · 27/07/2023 10:52

He lies to you. You like to him

Stick together

Siameasy · 27/07/2023 10:51

I’d find it creepy and off-putting but not cheating. Take some time to think about it and the two of you have a chat. The lack of sex life is going to be an issue that needs to be resolved as IME it causes resentment.