Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd thinks i'm tight. I think I'm sensible.

270 replies

malificent7 · 27/07/2023 08:49

Dp ( soon to be dh)and I earn £65,000 pa between us.We are lucky enough to have a mortgage and we went abroad last year.
Due to the rising cost of living we are scaling back. This year we are holidaying in a caravan holiday park in Cornwall for 5 nights. I shop at Lidl ( always have) and a bit of Tescos. I'm always looking for the cheapest product in supermarkets etc. Dd would live to shop Waitrose ( not happening and I love Lidl anyway.)

We have ditched our big white wedding for a simple registry office and restaurant with a 3 night stay in Devon air b and b for honeymoon.

Dd (15) is a bit sneery about this and says I'm tight. For context, some of her school friends are much better off and are going on a string of exotic holidays, festivals, shopping sprees etc. Some of them she describes as " old money."

Recently I went for a slightly better paid job but decided it wasn't for me as the commute was horrendous. I didn't get it anyway...Dd was incredulous that I didn't want a 2 hour hour commute each way for £5,000 extra a year.

She does work as a waitress so she knows how hard it is to earn ££. She wants to be super rich...fair play to her but Dp and I are starting to feel inadequate.

Aibu to think that I am being sensible...not tight and dd needs a reality check.

I do feel bad anyway that I didn't chase ££ younger but that was explained on another thread.

OP posts:
Blanketpolicy · 27/07/2023 10:58

ds(19) is similarly "tight", I would call it being financially aware, but it is a good thing.

There were a couple of things that taught him this. The first was giving him what appeared to be lots of money each month (from age 11), but with responsibilities to go with it - he had to budget his school lunches for the month, phone data, barbers, spotify, netflix, etc. If he over spent at school lunches he wouldn't be able to afford something else he really wanted to do and bore the consequences.

The second one was going over with him 6 months worth of bank statements and school lunch parent pay and showing him where his money was going and he got a shock how much (for example) lots of little PS5 purchases, or regular bottles of juice at school added up to and how he could have had that cash in his bank still to spend on something significant instead.

If your dd has never had to develop a saving or budgeting habit, or had consequences when she ran out of money I can understand why she won't just get it. The way it luckily worked out for us ds learnt this before he got his first PT job so it is now a habit with him, I think once they have a job and a load of disposable income they don't learn this lesson.

Mirabai · 27/07/2023 10:55

DD wants to be super rich eh? Is she working her arse off at school to get the grades for finance? Is she techy and expanding her IT knowledge? Is she stunningly beautiful so that supermodel career is viable? Is she very business minded and already coming up with business ideas?

If none of the above just nod and smile.

TheaBrandt · 27/07/2023 10:55

“old money” is a big thing on SM weirdly.

Agree with being careful etc live within your means but don’t go too far the other way. Through my work I see extremely wealthy elderly people penny pinching with hundreds of thousands in the bank yet they seem unable to spend or enjoy their money because they are so set in their miserly ways.

Magenta65 · 27/07/2023 10:49

This might be a good learning opportunity for her. Be transparent sit her down and explain your monthly income vs expenditure. Her attitude makes me think as she increases her earning she may not make sensible decision. She’s old enough to understand and take a better approach to money and how far it goes

Hibiscrubbed · 27/07/2023 10:48

She’s 15. Just roll your eyes.

You have a very modest income and lifestyle, she’s at the age where you’ll always be wrong, and she’s at the age where she’s heavily exposed to wealth and materialism via social media and tv.

If it prompts her to work hard and make sure she’s financially extremely comfortable, great.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 27/07/2023 10:47

itsmeafterall · 27/07/2023 09:09

If use this as a learning discussion.

Sit down with her and a spreadsheet.

Run through all the bills and food costs.

Show her what's left.

Show her how much the holiday cost and how many months it took to save for it.

Encourage her to set up her own spreadsheet to plan and manage her spending.

That should do it.

Certainly worked with mine who are now very sensible financially!

This. Absolutely. It’s a brilliant opportunity to educate kids on home finance and economic realities

make sure she does the Martin Lewis money course that’s free- there’s a kids course and text book now if she’s not done it at school

I’d pitch it, “so, we can sit down and I’ll show you how money works and explain why we haven’t had holiday/didn’t want to take other job, or you can just stop with the rude comments and keep your naive and hopelessly ignorant opinions to yourself until you’ve grown up and have some financial experience. At which point we can have an adult debate of pro and cons of my choices over my financial affairs.”

Mmhmmn · 27/07/2023 10:47

MintJulia · 27/07/2023 09:31

YANBU.

DS (15) told me I was a bit mean recently.

So I shared with him the bills that came in this month - £500 car insurance £190 car tax, Mortgage, council tax, utilities, new school blazer, shoes, sports kit, etc etc. Food, petrol, his sports classes.

He was horrified at the amounts and apologised.

I think when they get to teens, a little glimpse of reality is a good thing.

This! Definitely needs doing.

If DD had to buy a single item from Waitrose herself she'd soon realise why you don't do the shop there.

JessieJoJames · 27/07/2023 10:47

I think it depends on whether you can afford it or not? Money is so subjective - depends on your mortgage, location, debts. It isn't just about what you earn.

If you could comfortably afford to shop at M&S or go to Florida etc but chose not to, then I do think you could be seen (esp to a teenager) as tight. If on the other hand you can't afford it - you are not tight, you just can't afford it.

As someone who grew up very very poor - I know what is is like to see others with things so I think there is a distinction.

Mmhmmn · 27/07/2023 10:45

Maddy70 · 27/07/2023 09:13

You sound normal to me.
I am fortunate that we do have several "exotic" holidays every year but I always shop in Lidl or Aldi. Why wouldn't you ?

She's being a normal teen. You know you are there to be sneered at and mocked. Everyone else's parents are infinitely better than hers. All her friends are sneering at their mum's too. "Why do you always go to Waitrose, everyone else goes to Lidl etc

🤔 Never felt that way towards my own parents. At any point.

Namw · 27/07/2023 10:40

Why does she know how much you earn? It’s absolutely none of her business.

MoonLion · 27/07/2023 10:39

DanceMumTaxi · 27/07/2023 09:03

15 year olds think they know everything … in reality they know nothing.

This!

Mayhem3 · 27/07/2023 10:37

theleafandnotthetree · 27/07/2023 10:07

65k combined income is not really 'very comfortable' unfortunately (which is crazy)

A 65k combined income is definitely very comfortable.

TeddyFluff · 27/07/2023 10:37

65k isn’t a lot of money these days. Sounds like you’re sensibly living within your means.

MzHz · 27/07/2023 10:34

theleafandnotthetree · 27/07/2023 10:07

65k combined income is not really 'very comfortable' unfortunately (which is crazy)

Well, it's all relative, round here that would be enough that a 3 bed rental would cost half the take home. If you lived near where my boss lives, commuter belt surrey, I doubt it would go as far as that.

Add to this running cars, eating, heating, and kids, it gets very UNcomfortable PDQ

@malificent7 You are doing the right thing, living how you feel comfortable. cutting your cost for a big white wedding for something you think is more appropriate and affordable is the right thing to do. Your DD doesn't know much about the world at all. Show her the numbers and also talk to her about unforeseen expenses and the need to be careful with money, especially at the moment.

Middleagedmeangirls · 27/07/2023 10:31

She's 15. She's differentiating herself from you. It's an important part of becoming her own person. Whatever you do will be wrong atm. So if your spending ethos was different she would probably judge you for being wasteful!

Maintain boundaries around respectful speech in the home (making sure you hold yourself to the same standards you expect of her) and then agree to differ.

malificent7 · 27/07/2023 10:31

No...i said...a mortgage. A small one. For context..i rented for years. So yes...i consider myself lucky.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 27/07/2023 10:28

Mine’s 17 and honestly I’ve found teen parenting intense. Getting them launched as isn’t easy. We have some of our best conversations in the car.
They are in a world where they are seeing what their friends have and social media but don’t have the life experience to see the bigger picture or realise what else may be going on.
DD’s teen friend was given an Audi with a big bow on for her birthday.
But it wasn’t new, dad has his own business and was leased through it and she’s driving herself and siblings to school (they are rural) saving expensive bus passes plus mum can work more hours as she’s not ferrying the kids about to hobbies after school.
Adults can see that, all teens see is omg ‘Katie’ got an Audi she’s so lucky.

malificent7 · 27/07/2023 10:28

We are not having a registry office wedding to put on a bizarre show of "poverty!" How odd! 😅
We had savings so were going to do a big do but several expensive car breakages and repairs later and we decided it was insane to spend £8000 on 1 day and it was making us miserable. No point starting married life in debt when many marriages fail due to money issues. A big spendy wedding did not fill us with joy.

OP posts:
JustAnotherUsey · 27/07/2023 10:25

As an ex teacher I can confirm that a lot of kids are on another planet when it comes to money and wages. A lot believe they will be footballers, YouTubers etc! No grasp on reality yet! So just ignore her. One day she will wake up and realise that earning big money isn't easy

MissHoollie · 27/07/2023 10:24

You are a parent.
She is a child.
Live your life how you feel any . It sounds like you are teaching her money isn't everything

pamplemoussemousse · 27/07/2023 10:24

She's fucking 15, hasn't got a clue and probably won't until she's 35 and has finally saved up enough to move out and buy her own place 😂

mondaytosunday · 27/07/2023 10:23

If she lives at home she has no concept of how much it costs to keep things afloat - just look at the other thread about minimum household expenses! My son moved out a year ago and it's been tough realising how much council tax, utilities, food, petrol, laundry, haircuts and so on add up!
She needs a reality check. Never too soon to learn how budgeting works - maybe show her your incomings and outgoings so she can learn.

Justashley · 27/07/2023 10:23

You don't sound tight, you sound sensible. 15 year olds often assume that they know it all, I can't imagine even then speaking to my parents this way though, so disrespectful. Its good to have big aspirations but she will find out soon enough that the costs of running a home all add up- plenty of bills and things to buy which I'm almost certain she won't have considered; even the price of a food shop nowadays is wild.

HerMammy · 27/07/2023 10:21

A good way for her to learn cost is give her £80 and send her for a weeks food shopping, let her have a shock at the rising costs. Sounds like she has no grasp of the COL.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/07/2023 10:19

The commute one is a good example. She just thinks £5000.
If you break it down after deductions it’s say £400 a month extra but it’s x miles so petrol will cost £y. Plus I’ll need a newer more reliable car £Z, plus I’m spending another 10 hours driving so can’t work then eg no overtime and knock on eg more likely to buy takeaway as knackered.