Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dd thinks i'm tight. I think I'm sensible.

270 replies

malificent7 · 27/07/2023 08:49

Dp ( soon to be dh)and I earn £65,000 pa between us.We are lucky enough to have a mortgage and we went abroad last year.
Due to the rising cost of living we are scaling back. This year we are holidaying in a caravan holiday park in Cornwall for 5 nights. I shop at Lidl ( always have) and a bit of Tescos. I'm always looking for the cheapest product in supermarkets etc. Dd would live to shop Waitrose ( not happening and I love Lidl anyway.)

We have ditched our big white wedding for a simple registry office and restaurant with a 3 night stay in Devon air b and b for honeymoon.

Dd (15) is a bit sneery about this and says I'm tight. For context, some of her school friends are much better off and are going on a string of exotic holidays, festivals, shopping sprees etc. Some of them she describes as " old money."

Recently I went for a slightly better paid job but decided it wasn't for me as the commute was horrendous. I didn't get it anyway...Dd was incredulous that I didn't want a 2 hour hour commute each way for £5,000 extra a year.

She does work as a waitress so she knows how hard it is to earn ££. She wants to be super rich...fair play to her but Dp and I are starting to feel inadequate.

Aibu to think that I am being sensible...not tight and dd needs a reality check.

I do feel bad anyway that I didn't chase ££ younger but that was explained on another thread.

OP posts:
watersprites · 27/07/2023 11:37

You are not tight at all!

CherryBlossoms88 · 27/07/2023 11:36

I think it’s really important to educate our children about money. Schools don’t really discuss these life skills needed to function in the real world.
I understand some families can be quite private about their finances from their children but in my opinion the more open about it you are, the better.
From my experience my mum was open about the bills that needed to paid and showed me how she would write it down in her notepad, totalling each month. She would then allocate a budget for each expense. It really was a valuable lesson growing up and has helped me manage my money to this day.

BlackBarbies · 27/07/2023 11:35

MoggyMittens23 · 27/07/2023 11:31

I find this quite bizarre. Is your children seeing other places/cultures/lifestyles not important to you? if you couldn't afford it then fair enough but you said you can. Having a holiday every year is not important. Quality over quantity. If you just didn't have your shared family holiday in Cornwall or wherever every year (sound dull as hell) then you could not have one for a few years spend that money on a bigger holiday. Each to their own and that's just my opinion which I am sure you don't care for but I find your attitude so weird! Your teen must be so bored of your 'holidays'!

Yet here you are judging someone else’s holiday in the UK as ‘dull as hell’ because they’re not going abroad. Does every holiday have to be abroad just because you can afford it?

Do you think that if I’m from London and I visit Scotland there isn’t going to be change in the place/culture and lifestyle. You should ignorant

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 27/07/2023 11:34

She's 15 and bluntly, knows nothing. I wouldn't entertain her sneery comments at all.

If she's old enough to be told the ins and outs of a role you have applied for, then she's old enough to be told that not only will the extra £5k be mostly swallowed up with commute costs, but that you're also allowed to have some quality of life. Also who will ferry her about if you're driving home from work?

HolidayPlansAPlanning · 27/07/2023 11:33

Let her put your wage if she knows it into this

https://ifs.org.uk/tools_and_resources/where_do_you_fit_in

That will help her figure out where you land compared to others. Plus show her a salary calculator taking all that tax and national insurance, talk to her about pension contributions, monthly household bills from rent/mortgage (you could go on Rightmove so she can see the reality of wages vs what you can buy locally) utilities including water, council tax, broadband, mobile phone contracts, your food bill and petrol costs. also for us Denplan for the dentist. Then the yearly stuff like buildings and contents insurance, car servicing, tax and tv licence costs. Also any glasses prescriptions, school uniform costs, general clothing, how much household items costs like sofas, washing machines etc.

I think they love the idea of money coming in, what they don't consider is it going out. Both of mine when they were teens were told all of this. Ds1 is at uni and had money already in a LISA for a house deposit. They know that one meal out is 1/2 our weekly shopping bill. Have a lovely wedding day.

Your household's income : Where do you fit in? | Institute for Fiscal Studies

When you think about your income, do you feel rich, poor, or just plain average? Find out where you lie in the UK income distribution.

https://ifs.org.uk/tools_and_resources/where_do_you_fit_in

BlackBarbies · 27/07/2023 11:32

malificent7 · 27/07/2023 11:17

I don't feel intimidated...just irritated and it triggers my feelings of inadequacy about my career/ financial choices.

She’s 15. Why does it matter what a 15 year old thinks of your lifestyle choices?

MoggyMittens23 · 27/07/2023 11:31

springtome · 27/07/2023 09:46

We have never taken our two teens abroad. Youngest isn't bothered but oldest is. I just can't justify they expense. We take them away every year in the UK. Usually shared breaks with family which keeps the main cost to under £1000 for a week.

We have looked to go abroad but we can't stomach spending £2500 as a minimum plus spending money on a week- this years holiday is £960 in cornwall plus petrol money.

I was talking to a colleague and they are off for a weeks all inclusive and that's costing £2,200 EACH! So nearly £9,000 😨 our brand new car was just over £18,000, there is no way we could justify spending half the cost of a car on one week.

It's not even that we couldn't afford it. I k ow we could if we tightened up. I just prefer to spend our money on other things.

We have told our son the same. When it's his money he can choose to spend it on what he wants to.

I find this quite bizarre. Is your children seeing other places/cultures/lifestyles not important to you? if you couldn't afford it then fair enough but you said you can. Having a holiday every year is not important. Quality over quantity. If you just didn't have your shared family holiday in Cornwall or wherever every year (sound dull as hell) then you could not have one for a few years spend that money on a bigger holiday. Each to their own and that's just my opinion which I am sure you don't care for but I find your attitude so weird! Your teen must be so bored of your 'holidays'!

Peony654 · 27/07/2023 11:28

You sound sensible especially in current climate. DD is 15, she needs to learn how to budget and prioritise spending for when she has to support herself. And be grateful for what she has which is a lot - a house, food; a holiday. You were right to turn down the job, that commute would be awful and eat up most of the pay rise. She needs to understand that being rich does not necessarily make you happy

anyolddinosaur · 27/07/2023 11:28

She's a teenager who thinks your only role in life is to provide for her. Point out that you would be a lot better off if you had never had her or did not spend so much on things for her. Keep track of what you spend on her for a few months, I would bet she has a disproportionate amount of your money.

Shodan · 27/07/2023 11:27

A lot of raising teenagers, I've found, involves a lot of deep breaths, eye-rolling and some disbelieving snorts- and that's from the parents.

Teenagers, bless their little cotton socks, have no idea how the world works-but they do have LOTS of opinions on things they nothing about, too. It can be very tedious- but this is how they learn.

My go-to response for anything like you describe was a brisk "Oh dear. I'm sorry you feel hard done-by. Look on this as your tale of woe and hardship. One day you'll be able to tell your children how very much you suffered growing up."

hevs03 · 27/07/2023 11:26

When my DD was around the same age, I can recall her and her friends chatting in the garden about how cool it would be when they got to 18 and they could get their own place. I couldn't help but laugh and I asked them how much they thought they would need to move out and live in their own home, they had no idea and none of them realised that you paid for water because in their words "it comes out the tap why do you have to pay for it". I listed a few of the usual bills and the rough costs and they were gob smacked. I've sat with my DD a few times and discussed the bills, cost of living etc. Fast forward 4 years and my DD is now looking for her first job having completed her diploma at college and the first thing she said to me was that she would be happy handing me half of her wages to help with the bills as she knows how tough it can. I won't be taking money off her though she will pay for her mobile and Netflix, but it made me proud when she offered. We are not well off at all, however it is often those who don't have much who go on to have a rich & fulfilling life. Your DD will be fine just sit her down and learn her about bills and finances.

BumpyaDaisyevna · 27/07/2023 11:25

She's 15. I wouldn't set much store by her opinion?

Teens think their parents are wrong/ idiots. They grow out of it.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/07/2023 11:24

Mayhem3 · 27/07/2023 10:37

A 65k combined income is definitely very comfortable.

Well it depends on the mortgage and the post code. There's no set answer. 65k in our house would be comfortable.

Mutabiliss · 27/07/2023 11:23

What on earth does it matter what a 15 year old thinks? She has no experience of the world.

Manage your money however you want and remind her of this when she's 30.

SleepingStandingUp · 27/07/2023 11:22

Are you happy with your wedding or are you moaning lots about all the stuff you can't have?

I do think there's possibly room for compromise. You budget sensibly, you earn decent money but you don't seem to get the enjoyment at the other end - so perhaps to her it defeats the object of working hard. Do you do any treat things as a family or is she constantly told you can't afford it?

And tbf 5 nights in a caravan in the rain is my idea of hell.

iamenougheveryday · 27/07/2023 11:21

I have no idea why you are giving any of this headspace @malificent7 . When did you let your child have so much power over your decisions?

ilovesooty · 27/07/2023 11:19

malificent7 · 27/07/2023 11:17

I don't feel intimidated...just irritated and it triggers my feelings of inadequacy about my career/ financial choices.

That's your issue.

She's a teenager who knows nothing.

hot2trotter · 27/07/2023 11:18

She sounds like a brat

malificent7 · 27/07/2023 11:17

I don't feel intimidated...just irritated and it triggers my feelings of inadequacy about my career/ financial choices.

OP posts:
CheekyHobson · 27/07/2023 11:12

I think you're sensible but maybe should have a think about why you seem to feel intimidated by the opinions of a 15-year-old who has next to no experience of how the world works.

I would be telling her politely but firmly that you're sorry neither of you were born into 'old money' as that would certainly make a grand living a lot easier, but you won't be tolerating her sneering at your perfectly reasonable financial choices any longer.

When she has actually made enough money to afford the kind of fancy lifestyle she aspires to, she can cast judgement on your decisions. Until then she can button her lip or talk to thin air after you've walked away.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 27/07/2023 11:04

65k is a good or tight budget depending on where you live and number of kids. It’s all subjective

if you’re in London with average family house price at £800k, that’s a hell of a different outgoing than Wigan where a 4 bed house is possible at £350k or even less.

it also depends on commuting - as Op has pointed out

I do wish people wouldn’t go on about what is comfortable in terms of income

im retired now, pension less than half of what I earnt. But I’m way better off in terms of lifestyle than when I was earning. Obviously.

StormShadow · 27/07/2023 11:00

Mayhem3 · 27/07/2023 09:44

We have ditched our big white wedding for a simple registry office and restaurant with a 3 night stay in Devon air b and b for honeymoon.

YANBU but I do see her point a bit.

You are very well off but it seems you are doing things to almost show everyone else you are not.

If you want a registry office wedding and a honeymoon in Devon then absolutely carry on but you had originally planned to have a big white wedding and I find it odd that you’d go to one extreme to the other, when you can afford it.

Having a holiday in Cornwall is often more expensive than going abroad so you are not saving money.

You can save as much money as you want.
I think people who shop at Waitrose are mad because it’s double the money for the exact same product you get elsewhere and your DD is being a bit of a snob here.

But I think you are being a bit of a money martyr to put on a show to others.

What’s your DH like?
Is he happy to not have a holiday abroad for the honeymoon and go to Devon instead?

Ehhh, I don't think you can assume OP can easily afford expensive weddings and holidays based on the info given. 65k household income doesn't mean that. They'll likely be fine with bills etc and some treats, but it doesn't strike me as a martyrish level of money management not to have a big wedding or an expensive honeymoon on that money.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 27/07/2023 11:00

itsmeafterall · 27/07/2023 09:09

If use this as a learning discussion.

Sit down with her and a spreadsheet.

Run through all the bills and food costs.

Show her what's left.

Show her how much the holiday cost and how many months it took to save for it.

Encourage her to set up her own spreadsheet to plan and manage her spending.

That should do it.

Certainly worked with mine who are now very sensible financially!

I agree about getting her to set a budget

With our dc, form age of 12 we gradually gave the, more autonomy over what was spent on them . We gave them a monthly allowance and told them what it covered, how we’d determined those costs, and that they were expected to account for their spends bs budget if they ever wanted a raise.

at 12 it was mostly about entertainment stuff, by 15/16 it included non school clothes, makeup, plus entertainment and odd meal out with friends (McDonald’s or whatever) , after 16 it included All clothes, shoes, undies, phone, transport (bus train), entertainment, going out, and money needed to buy gifts for close relatives/friends. We didn’t make them work , encouraged it with an every £10 you earn, well top up by £1 and also encouraged it to get experience on their applications. Both did get small jobs, but mainly focused in holidays rather than evening .

this carried into university when we paid them their maintenance money - we’d review budget together at that age once per year but again, we expect to see evidence of why it wasn’t enough if they said it wasn’t enough.

These days were still passing on experience to them now they’re in late 20s, loans, investments, using tax allowances, pensions, house buying….they’ll call us to ask how stuff works when needed.

we never, after age of 12, passed money to them without having a clear budget. They knew if they ran out they’d have to provide evidence of how and why-it only happened twice when eldest was being fleeced by landlord for big deposit and 8 weeks advanced rent 😱, and when youngest managed to drive over his phone in the car 🤷🏼‍♀️🤣

Traceyislivid · 27/07/2023 10:59

YABU discussing it with her. Is it really any of her business how much you earn and how much you turned a job down for. Sh needs to crack in and make her own money and not get you to bank roll her if she want to ‘be rich’.

HaddawayAndShite · 27/07/2023 10:59

Christ I wouldn’t have dared to be so sneery about my parents. Reality check needed. She sounds like a spoiled brat