Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or is DH - Bin bag on bin day!

118 replies

blahblahlandgoogoodoll · 27/07/2023 08:41

This is obviously lighthearted.

It's bin day today in our house. Our general waste is being collected. All bathroom bins have been emptied (only gets done once a week).

DH says the kitchen bin should be emptied and a new bag put in even though it's less than a 1/4 full just because it's bin day. It usually gets changed every 1-2 days.

I say it's only 1/4 full and no need to change it earlier and waste the liner just to send it away with the general waste collection.

Our general waste wheelie bin is never ever full. Usually less than half.

Who is BU?

YABU = all the bins should be emptied regardless of how full they are on bin day

YANBU = emptying a bin that's 1/4 full is wasteful of the liner etc and unnecessary.

What does your household do?

I can't actually see the voting as I'm on the mobile app but I'm sure someone will be kind enough to tell me the results in a question in a while!

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 27/07/2023 15:09

Kitchen bin almost always has something potentially smelly so it goes out even if not full. “Clean” trash could stay for weeks or even months until the bin is full and I do have a bin that in a hobby space.

Batshit1 · 27/07/2023 15:03

Depends.. if there was something like a roast chicken in there then I would make a point of emptying it. If it was just general floor sweepings etc I’d probably leave it.

BugsyDrakeTableScape · 27/07/2023 14:47

Dombasle · 27/07/2023 14:33

Can you not just tip the contents out and save the bin liner for another weeks worth?

This is the sensible answer

Dukeydo · 27/07/2023 14:45

PotteringAlonggotkickedoutandhadtoreregister · 27/07/2023 08:42

I’m with your DH here - always empty the bin on bin day!

Use kitchen bin bag to empty all the other bins into?

all bins are emptied on bin day just just all recycling is put out

Onesnowynight · 27/07/2023 14:44

Empty on bin day. Ours get collected every 2 weeks, cardboard every 2 weeks, food bin every week, and paper/glass weekly.

Dombasle · 27/07/2023 14:33

Can you not just tip the contents out and save the bin liner for another weeks worth?

Ohthepressureofaname · 27/07/2023 14:31

Our black bin is emptied fortnightly. As others do we recycle food waste and paper / plastic etc so nothing smelly or gross goes in there. We don’t use bin liners, there’s no need so we empty whether it’s full or not and give the bin a wash out.

hot2trotter · 27/07/2023 14:19

God I see a lot of shite posted on here.

But yes, I agree with DH.

amyds2104 · 27/07/2023 14:11

All bins emptied here on bin day and put in kitchen one if 1/4 full.

Ariela · 27/07/2023 12:59

We compost, and there is NO food in the waste bin in the kitchen (separate food waste which I only need to use if we have bones - rare- as our dog eats pretty much everything else, so that goes out every 1-3 months if that).
I recycle most weeks - card, paper, glass, plastic etc. Soft plastics go to supermarket, tetracycle via local waste collector to raise funds locally etc
Kitchen bin is emptied about once every 2-3 weeks into main bin, main bin goes out about every month to 2 months. There is nothing to smell or stinky, so it can be emptied to main bin when full - no point in making work.

Myfavouritecolourisanimalprint · 27/07/2023 12:18

Our kitchen bin is tiny but I hate to waste the bag if it's not full. We tend to go round the house with a large bin bag though, so that does bathroom/bedroom bins, change the cat litter on the way past, then we just empty the kitchen bin into that so that we can keep hold of the bag that is already in it. It's not especially smelly (apart from the cat litter obvs) as we recycle and compost a lot more than we throw out. Our residual bin is emptied fortnightly and is rarely more than half full

TenderDandelions · 27/07/2023 12:01

Our kitchen bin gets emptied when it's full or when the cleaner comes. Bathroom bins get emptied when the cleaner comes (every 2 weeks). No way am I emptying a bin that's got loads of room left just because a half empty bin is being collected before the next half empty bin collection.

If your wheelie bins stank and were outside your front door I might have a different opinion, but ours are tucked away outside round the side of the house, so even if a bag has to sit in it for 2 weeks, it doesn't cause any issues.

longtompot · 27/07/2023 11:53

I empty the bathroom bins, if they just have a few lightweight items in, and poo bags from the garden and final cat litter change into the kitchen bin if it's only partly full. If the kitchen bin is only a quarter full, unless it's smelling, and the bathroom bins needs a complete bag change, then I'd leave the kitchen bin. Bin bags, especially good 30L kitchen ones, are really quite expensive.

gingercat02 · 27/07/2023 11:35

We don't use bags in the small bins so everything from bathrooms (no menstruating women), bedrooms and lounge go in the big kitchen bin and then that one bag goes in the wheelie bin full or not, as it only goes out every 2 weeks

Ohhmydays · 27/07/2023 11:32

Yeah empty all bins on bin days regardless of how full, however i use smaller bags during the summer and put out at night as the house ends up full of fruit flies otherwise

Mischance · 27/07/2023 11:30

No - I would not put a bin bag out into the outside bin unless it was full. There is enough plastic being put into landfill.

I live alone and have system where my indoor bin has a liner and then I put a small biodegradable bin liner on top of that - so I fill the small one and take outside, and the big liner stays put.

WeWereInParis · 27/07/2023 11:29

We always empty it. But because we have nappies and our bin is only collected once every two weeks our general waste wheelie bin is often fairly full. So we can't leave rubbish from the previous fortnight to be added to the next fortnight's bin.

TinyTeacher · 27/07/2023 11:26

Depends what's in it. At a quarter full, we probably wouldn't bother unless there was something really stinky/unpleasant.

MonumentalLentil · 27/07/2023 11:21

@ReviewingTheSituation

Slightly tangential, but this thread makes me wonder how many local councils collect food waste separately...

All our food waste is collected weekly by the council, so none of that makes it into the kitchen bin, so there's nothing in there to go off/smelly/manky.

But this thread is making me think we're in the minority here - other councils must surely collect food waste? It's one of the biggest problems in landfill because of the gas it gives off as it decomposes. Or are people still putting food waste in their kitchen bin even if their council collects food waste?

Our kitchen bin contains cat food pouches, random bits of kitchen roll and films off the top of things (yogurt pots, trays of meat/fish), non-recyclable food wrappers, and I think that's about it. I wouldn't empty it just for bin day if it was less than half full.

Ours used to go in the garden waste bin, at the time there was a box for glass and one for paper.
Then the boxes were stopped and all recycling went into a new big bin. Then we were given a food waste bin. I discovered I had been given a faulty one with a hole in the centre of the caddy when it was finished off. In spite of several requests they never bothered to give me a replacement so I never used it as it leaked.
Then they changed it again, stopped food waste and we have to put it in general waste. I put as much in compost as I can.

Cat food pouches can be rinsed and recycled in some places, there is info online if you want to recycle them, and crisp packets. I am using less pouches now as I buy tins from Zooplus, a 200g tin will last 2 days with a smaller pouch (cat is on a diet and it is easy to work out that way). Larger sizes are cheaper and if I had a larger cat or 2 cats I would get the 395/400g ones some come in 800g sizes too.

Ponoka7 · 27/07/2023 11:07

It depends on what's in the bin. My DD lives on frozen chicken and my stuff is usually recyclable. So in mine I wouldn't put t out. In my DP's were there is plastic trays that mince, steak etc has been on, I would. My DD has fish cat food wrappers, s that definitely needs to go out. I used to get around partially used bin bags by using my wheelie bin with a wheelie bin bag in, or very perishable food.

Catspyjamas17 · 27/07/2023 11:00

I think if it's only slightly full then it's wasteful to use a bin bag up for it. However full bins should always be emptied and I have to remind DH of that every few weeks.

ReviewingTheSituation · 27/07/2023 11:00

@CecilyP We live in a small village - it's our whole district which is covered by the waste contract, so we all get:
Landfill waste - 3 weekly
Recycling (and garden waste if you pay for it) - 2 weekly
Food waste - weekly

A couple of my neighbours don't put out any food waste which irks me - food waste is terrible for landfill (and if they're putting it with their green waste that's bad too, as garden waste is only composted at low temps here, which is no good for (cooked) food waste).

Collecting and putting out a small bin of food waste each week is really no big deal at all. There's no excuse not to, if your council offer the service.

MyrtleSmurf · 27/07/2023 10:58

My household rubbish and food waste (separate) is collected weekly, then we have paper/card one week and plastic/glass the other. It's a pretty good system tbh. I find my kitchen bin is rarely full now with all the stuff that gets recycled, and it never smells.

I wouldn't put a 1/4 full bin out, but only because of the above. If there was anything stinky or gross it would go straight out.

stopringingme · 27/07/2023 10:51

We put our bin bag out on bin day - but we only have bin bags no wheelie bins.

If we had a wheelie bin it would not be put out till full.

Swipe left for the next trending thread