Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did anyone have irrational stress around sending baby/child to nursery and did you get used to it in the end?

91 replies

stressedpot · 27/07/2023 08:16

My baby will go to nursery four days a week at 11 months. I am SO conflicted by it all. I could stay at home longer and re apply for jobs in another six months but I like my company and want to stay ideally. Then I feel selfish wanting that when I don’t strictly need to go back. Considered a nanny but I know I would be checking up on them etc in the house while I worked from home so don’t think I would get much work done.

I am getting so worried about this I can’t sleep! He seems so little still. I worry about him being harmed (I know this is unlikely), I worry about abuse and if he will be left alone (not literally but I mean not played with for a while as they are so busy). I worry if he will eat properly. At the same time I am going a bit mad at home with him and feel drained everyday. Starting to feel I shouldn’t have had dc if I can’t cope with this! I love him so much and feel whatever I do will be wrong.

OP posts:
S72 · 28/07/2023 18:22

Yup. I looked at around 6 nurseries in my area. Hated them all and felt so uneasy.

I ended up taking a few months unpaid leave following maternity and started looking at childminders instead.

I met a lady and clicked within the first couple of minutes. I knew in my gut she was the one I wanted taking care of my child.

My child ended up staying with her instead of nursery or preschool. She did so much - days out, forest school, various clubs, crafts, lots of learning and so many activities. She carried on providing before and after school care until he started high school.

She is still part of our lives to this day. Started as a childminder and ended as a dear friend.

Nodancingshoes · 28/07/2023 18:18

I've been a nursery nurse for 25 years and we have NEVER lied about what children have eaten. Why would we? Children often copy what their peers are doing which means that they try more foods than at home. And we actually ARE good at getting children to sleep. My 2 babies were a nightmare going to sleep for me at home but I can get a roomful of toddlers to sleep easily at nursery.

Loz2323 · 28/07/2023 18:13

strongcupofTea · 27/07/2023 11:29

That's because they say they've settled well and eaten tomato and cucumber because they have to do a write up for ofsted and they don't want parents to worry and pull them out.
I'm not saying they come to harm there, but the awkward lies some members of staff told to parents made me leave the childcare industry.
And when mums on MN say 'nurseries are magic' it makes me die a little inside because I know it's just not true.

Don't know where you have worked but no nursery or pre school have to do any write up's for Ofsted

Loz2323 · 28/07/2023 18:10

stressedpot · 27/07/2023 08:40

@Eileen101 this would make me think they are pretending she’s eaten! 🤦‍♀️

Kids do eat foods and drink at nursery and pre school that they don't at home. Quite a few times we have told parents 'oh X ate blah for snack today and drank blah' and they'll turn round and say but X won't eat that at home!

Snail92 · 28/07/2023 18:06

I felt exactly the same when I sent my boy to nursery when I went back to work, it was a week before he was 9 months old. I hated it. But it is without a doubt one of the best decisions I’ve made so far. He will be 2 in September and LOVES nursery so much and his key workers. He has even started saying names of his little friends who he sees there which makes me feel so happy. Although I still find drop off difficult and have serious guilt for leaving him 🙃
I feel like Mums always feel guilty no matter what they do, can’t win!

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 28/07/2023 17:40

Hugasauras · 27/07/2023 15:34

I think you either want to be a SAHP or you don't at the end of day, taking all the possibilities of whether you can afford it or not out of it. It either appeals to you or it really doesn't. We could afford it if I really wanted to, but being a SAHP is not for me at all, so my kids go part-time to nursery, and are both happy, well-adjusted (as far as I can tell), no behavioural issues, bright, exceeding milestones, and very attached to DH and I. I think we as parents put a disproportionate amount of worrying into the effects of being a SAHP v nursery when what we should be thinking about is the quality of the care they receive at either/both. There are plenty of SAHPs who do not parent particularly well, just as there are inadequate childcare settings.

It seems a bit taboo to admit that you find being at home every day with small children draining, as if you're saying you don't love your kids or something (well, if you're a woman - men don't seem to have to justify not wanting to be SAHPS in any way). I love my kids a lot, but I don't want to spend five days a week year-round looking after them and doing nothing for myself. On my deathbed I certainly won't look back and wish I had being a SAHP, because it would send me doolally.

From your lips to all the new mums ears

Ndhdiwntbsivnwg · 28/07/2023 17:37

I went back to work when DD was 10 months old. She was in nursery 5 full days a week.
She’s 3 now, amazing social skills, a lovely young child and she is enjoying nursery a lot. We have an amazing bond, and we get to be present all weekend and mornings/evenings because all the housework is done, our batteries are not empty and it just works.
For us anyways. I never felt guilty. My DH is super supportive as well, and I get to be the professional I want to be for 8 hours a day and the rest I get to be a mum. Perfect balance for me

OMalleytheAlleyyCat · 28/07/2023 17:04

Mine started at nursery at that age recently, here's how I coped:

  • We found a nursery that we LOVED - not just liked. It was extra pricey but the staff are professionals, not like other places I'd seen where it's just local school leavers working there. Whether it's nursery or nanny - love them or leave them.
  • Choose childcare where you have one main person looking after your child - our pricier nursery has this. Eventually they bond with their person and it's lovely.
  • Ease in gently. Mine started settling in sessions a month before I went back to work. The first week we did an hour or two, with me in the cafe next door on hand if needed.
  • Remind yourself of the positives and why you're doing it. It's great for them especially at 11 months - mine just follows the older kids round all day fascinated. And like I say, the staff are professionals so my baby is learning so much more than I could teach. And you want or need to work!

The last point is especially important when they clock on that you're leaving them there and they do the "please don't leave me" face/cry. Because 10 minutes later the nursery are sending a video of them laughing and they're fine for the rest of the day.

megletthesecond · 28/07/2023 16:49

It's OK to be anxious but he should settle quickly and have a lovely time spudding around doing things he wouldn't be able to do at home. Mine never wanted to come home so I'd end up sitting there while they finished playing.

Doone21 · 28/07/2023 16:44

It's normal for it to feel really hard. I left mine at nursery 3 days a week from 6 months. He's grown up really social, makes friends easily, outgoing and confident.
I was anxious for about a year. But grit your teeth and get stuck in. Pick the best nursery you can then enjoy your work life.

BlibBlabBlob · 28/07/2023 09:21

I think I carry actual parental trauma from the nursery years, ages 1 and 2 at least. DD managed a little better from age 3 but I could still never leave her easily (by which I mean she couldn't leave ME easily).

Every morning, sobbing in the corridor out of her sight and hearing while she screamed for me in her keyworker's arms, having been literally pulled off me. It didn't matter whether I spent an hour settling her into the room to help her feel safe or whether I did the 'bright and breezy and speedy' drop off. Nothing worked, she was absolutely distraught. Three days a week. For over TWO YEARS.

BlibBlabBlob · 28/07/2023 09:19

I wish I hadn't had to (for financial reasons) send DD to nursery at 11 months. She was there three full days a week and with her grandmother the other two. Granted there was part of me that enjoyed the break from toddler parenting, as I never got one overnight (cosleeping, breastfeeding through the night well into the preschool years) or at the weekend. But mostly it was just awful for both of us. She never settled well at all, which makes sense now as it turns out she's autistic - back then she was just labelled a 'high need' baby/toddler - and she has never coped well with nursery/preschool/school. If I could have kept her with me until at least two years old, I would have done. I think she'd have gotten something out of part-time nursery perhaps at 2 though, and certainly at 3. It probably wouldn't have helped her in the long run to keep her at home with me until she started primary school.

Obviously most kids aren't like mine, most will settle after a while but as others have said they get so much more out of it after 2. Before that they really just want to be with the familiar trusted adults who've been there since they were born (mum, dad, maybe grandparents etc).

But given DD's difficulties, I got a unique insight into nursery life. Our nursery was wonderful at recognising how hard she was finding it to settle and encouraged me to be in the building with her as much as needed. So even after I was back at work, after our rather unsuccessful attempts at settling before I was due to go back, I was there for up to an hour in the morning and also in the evening - autism means transitions are difficult so, although she was thrilled to see me when I came back for her, she struggled to leave quickly! So we'd sit and have a cuddle, she'd have some milk from me, we'd read a book, she'd want to play with things in the room that she couldn't enjoy in the same way when I wasn't there to help her feel safe.

This meant that I sat and watched many drop-offs in the morning. Yes many kids were fine, even at 12 months old, and settled really well. But a significant minority didn't, they'd sit there and sob and not even really have anyone actually try to comfort them because the keyworkers had learned that they couldn't really do anything other than wait it out. These kids just wanted their parent to come back. I was also there at the end of the day, when these kids were being collected, and watched the staff breezily tell the parent that they'd been absolutely fine all day, settled really quickly as soon as the parent had gone, etc etc. Which made the parent feel better, obviously. Which is why they do it. But IT WASN'T TRUE. So I don't believe that all nurseries and their staff are 'magic', at least not for all children.

If I had my time again and any choice in the matter, I would have stayed at home with her until 2 or 3 and then gone back to work part-time. If you have that option OP it is definitely worth considering. Listen to your gut.

Hugasauras · 27/07/2023 15:34

I think you either want to be a SAHP or you don't at the end of day, taking all the possibilities of whether you can afford it or not out of it. It either appeals to you or it really doesn't. We could afford it if I really wanted to, but being a SAHP is not for me at all, so my kids go part-time to nursery, and are both happy, well-adjusted (as far as I can tell), no behavioural issues, bright, exceeding milestones, and very attached to DH and I. I think we as parents put a disproportionate amount of worrying into the effects of being a SAHP v nursery when what we should be thinking about is the quality of the care they receive at either/both. There are plenty of SAHPs who do not parent particularly well, just as there are inadequate childcare settings.

It seems a bit taboo to admit that you find being at home every day with small children draining, as if you're saying you don't love your kids or something (well, if you're a woman - men don't seem to have to justify not wanting to be SAHPS in any way). I love my kids a lot, but I don't want to spend five days a week year-round looking after them and doing nothing for myself. On my deathbed I certainly won't look back and wish I had being a SAHP, because it would send me doolally.

SouthLondonMum22 · 27/07/2023 15:11

howtowriteahaiku · 27/07/2023 13:50

@stressedpot is there a childminder you could send your baby to instead? My dd goes to one where the childminder has two helpers and it’s a lovely environment and not as busy or big as a lot of nurseries. Not that all childminders are going to be amazing, that’s where it can be helpful to get a recommendation.
babies all have their different personalities too, does yours like interacting with people and does she like a lot of stimulation? If she’s high needs / needs a lot of down time /is easily over-stimulated, nursery could be a more challenging environment for her.
I also think 11 months means that she’s had almost a year of building a strong bond with you and getting lots of lovely one-to-one care. I think that counts for a lot going forwards whatever your decision is.
It’s funny how people like to talk about how they don’t want to send their baby off to be looked after by strangers. The thing is everyone is a stranger until you get to know them? My ds went to a nursery age 2 onwards, he of course got to know the staff as did we, his key worker adored him and even now aged 8 he has happy memories of her and of nursery, he felt so loved and happy there and had so much fun. He still giggles over some of his memories and his key worker was almost in tears when he moved on to primary school. My dd’s childminder was also a stranger, now she is one of dd’s favourite people and I like her very much too, I see my dd’s face light up when she sees her. I am glad my children had the lovely experience of these other people in their lives as well as their parents, we could’ve said “No strangers!” but I love working part time and getting to spend some of my week working and childcare has worked out well for us. Ok so those nurseries where there’s a high turnover of staff and maybe they continue to all feel like random strangers, I can see how that would feel different!
anyway good luck choosing and explore various options if you can and see what feels like a good fit for you and your baby

Exactly. Teachers are strangers too before a child starts school but they build a relationship with them and it’s the same with nurseries.

My baby loves his keyworker. They have a great bond. Certainly not a stranger.

howtowriteahaiku · 27/07/2023 13:51

Apologies I just realised I have said “she” throughout when it’s a boy you have.
should have checked first

howtowriteahaiku · 27/07/2023 13:50

@stressedpot is there a childminder you could send your baby to instead? My dd goes to one where the childminder has two helpers and it’s a lovely environment and not as busy or big as a lot of nurseries. Not that all childminders are going to be amazing, that’s where it can be helpful to get a recommendation.
babies all have their different personalities too, does yours like interacting with people and does she like a lot of stimulation? If she’s high needs / needs a lot of down time /is easily over-stimulated, nursery could be a more challenging environment for her.
I also think 11 months means that she’s had almost a year of building a strong bond with you and getting lots of lovely one-to-one care. I think that counts for a lot going forwards whatever your decision is.
It’s funny how people like to talk about how they don’t want to send their baby off to be looked after by strangers. The thing is everyone is a stranger until you get to know them? My ds went to a nursery age 2 onwards, he of course got to know the staff as did we, his key worker adored him and even now aged 8 he has happy memories of her and of nursery, he felt so loved and happy there and had so much fun. He still giggles over some of his memories and his key worker was almost in tears when he moved on to primary school. My dd’s childminder was also a stranger, now she is one of dd’s favourite people and I like her very much too, I see my dd’s face light up when she sees her. I am glad my children had the lovely experience of these other people in their lives as well as their parents, we could’ve said “No strangers!” but I love working part time and getting to spend some of my week working and childcare has worked out well for us. Ok so those nurseries where there’s a high turnover of staff and maybe they continue to all feel like random strangers, I can see how that would feel different!
anyway good luck choosing and explore various options if you can and see what feels like a good fit for you and your baby

Luxell934 · 27/07/2023 13:28

I worked in nurseries for years, we were always over ratio even in the baby room. Sometimes we would have 12 babies with only 3 staff members, and this was a nursery that charged higher than normal fees and had a well known reputation for being "the best". It wasn't. The staff were a mixed bag, mostly young girls out of college with little experience, a few older more experienced ones and some really awful ones.

We were encouraged to only tell parents positive things when settling in. So it was always that there child had settled well, eaten "most" of their lunch and had a good day even when they had screamed all morning, ate one bite of lunch and slept all afternoon from exhaustion.

Most children do settle in after a few weeks though, I found the babies who only did 1 day a week the most difficult to settle.

It wasn't a horrible place for babies to be, they got to play with toys and other babies, occasionally do messy play/painting, got fed, played with, and were safe.

But after working there it made me realise that it wouldn't be a place I'd want to send my own baby. An older child 2+ would get a lot more out of it than a young baby.

Pinkypurpleflowers · 27/07/2023 13:20

My 11 month old started nursery last month, 4 days a week. I feel exactly the same. I was made redundant on maternity leave and had to start a new job, and haven't been there long enough to negotiate part time yet.

I hate it, and feel so guilty, and am constantly thinking about packing in my job. But it's local and flexible and well paid, and I'm not sure I'll find something as convenient in the future. So I'm persevering for now and taking things one day at a time.

I guess you've got to weigh everything up and make a judgement call. The way I see it, it's worth giving work and nursery a go - I can always change things in the future.

ReluctantFishLady · 27/07/2023 12:45

I always suspected I would become a SAHM after my mat leave was up and that is exactly how it panned out. It didn't feel right to leave him with strangers and go back to work. I sent my son to preschool when he was 3 as I thought he would benefit from it at that age. I understand not everyone has this choice however.

BeaumontLivinston · 27/07/2023 12:30

stressedpot · 27/07/2023 12:10

@BeaumontLivinston what age would you say is youngest to go?

It depends on the child but I would honestly say 2. I sent mine for 3 hours a day.

I got to working from home doing what I do so I did it around that.

Career is important, I really need to get back into it since neglecting it to be focused on my child and that has its own drawbacks, but if you're going to choose one I would choose the child every time.

I'm not seeking a job where I can mingle with people instead of kids all day. I have been working but it's been a bit difficult and we're not well off. Now she's going into a bigger year with more after school activities I'm looking for roles but I'm not young and it's a big career gap but I believe it's possible and even if it wasn't, I spent those years nurturing my child and the bond we have is brilliant because of it.

I can't compare it to a different situation as I've only had one.

I wouldn't send before 2. I'd be doing groups and parks and soft plays. They're funny places, you should find a good one with a nice cafe, maybe join some home ed groups or local groups or a church to gain a group you could organise things with. (you can get in with the home ed groups as your child isn't in school) they can be an interesting bunch and I've made some good friends that way.

When I look back on the years she was a baby I'm so glad I was there for all of it. It creates a secure attachment and they don't mind leaving you when the time comes. Mine walked happily into nursery and seemed to enjoy every minute. She's very good at making friends, perhaps it took her a few weeks to settle in since she'd never been in a nursery, but we did spend the first year in baby groups and the second with other groups including kids and adults so she wasn't isolated.

But I am somewhat isolated. Not having a job, every single school run, appointment, entertaining friends, constant tidying and cleaning. I cannot wait to get into an office or something!

Perhaps your company will give you more time?

Or is there the possibility you set yourself up in whatever it is you do so that you can do it remotely, independently, contractually, in a role that is 100% remote, or retrain?

stressedpot · 27/07/2023 12:10

@BeaumontLivinston what age would you say is youngest to go?

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 27/07/2023 11:50

Nurseries are there for a reason and I didn't think it was healthy to put stress onto my child no matter how much parents try and hide it babies and kids know when their parents are stressed

I happily did drop off's and happily did pick ups, there is no medal we get for how much we can't be without our babies

Morag273 · 27/07/2023 11:46

advise*

Morag273 · 27/07/2023 11:46

All totally normal feelings and there is no right or wrong answer. Feel empowered to make whatever decision is right for your family.

If you are happy with your nursery choice and it’s a lovely setting then I promise you all babies settle at nursery and it is best to have a quick AND CHEERFUL goodbye - let baby see you positive and happy and confident handing them over.

I would advice going back for 3-6 months if everyone is happy and you’ve found a routine that is working for you - great! If not, sack it all off and stay home with your baby. It’s your choice. No decision is final and you can change your mind at any time!

Good luck.

continentallentil · 27/07/2023 11:45

It’s tough OP!

But he’ll settle in fine.

Personally - and it is just a personal preference - I think a child minder or nanny is better for the under 2.5s. If a nanny is too expensive or you think it would drive you crackers at home, then you could look at a child minder or a nanny share at someone else’s house.

But hood nurseries can be very good too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread