Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Did anyone have irrational stress around sending baby/child to nursery and did you get used to it in the end?

91 replies

stressedpot · 27/07/2023 08:16

My baby will go to nursery four days a week at 11 months. I am SO conflicted by it all. I could stay at home longer and re apply for jobs in another six months but I like my company and want to stay ideally. Then I feel selfish wanting that when I don’t strictly need to go back. Considered a nanny but I know I would be checking up on them etc in the house while I worked from home so don’t think I would get much work done.

I am getting so worried about this I can’t sleep! He seems so little still. I worry about him being harmed (I know this is unlikely), I worry about abuse and if he will be left alone (not literally but I mean not played with for a while as they are so busy). I worry if he will eat properly. At the same time I am going a bit mad at home with him and feel drained everyday. Starting to feel I shouldn’t have had dc if I can’t cope with this! I love him so much and feel whatever I do will be wrong.

OP posts:
Nowthenhere · 28/07/2023 22:53

Your 'worries' are built in animal instinct to protect your baby. It maybe common to send babies away for long periods of time but it's not natural.

Listen to your body, trust yourself. All the worries that you're feeling need to be addressed and for you to be reassured before you can move forward.

You are more than capable of making an informed decision on whether a place is safe and you feel comfy leaving your child with staff.

But do not ignore your animal instincts. Write them down and tick them off when you feel reassured. If you don't, you need to look at alternative options.

Mummyof287 · 28/07/2023 22:36

Another ex- nursery worker here, and also have experience of being both a SAHM with my 1st, and a part time working parent who sent my 2nd into childcare (childminder) at 10mths.

I personally missed working abit the first time, the only reason I didn't go back was because I had post natal anxiety and couldn't bear to leave DD1 or trust anyone to care for her properly, especially emotionally but that was very different the 2nd time around, felt much more relaxed, so have sent DD2 to an amazing childminder.She has definitely benefitted from it, socially and developmentally.She is has been there nearly a year now and loves going still.

I am not denying that there are some good nurseries but there are also sadly alot of bad ones.Unfortunately the childcare profession is all too easy for people to get into who aren't really that passionate about children, or knowledgable about their needs, and as they have multiple staff you do tend to often get some good and some bad.
It's true that children often do eat better at other settings than at home, so I wouldn't worry too much about that.

What I would beware of, is people telling you 'they will be absolutely fine'.This may well be the case but it is often not, especially with babies and toddlers.
And things can be covered up.At the nursery I worked (which had its good points but in general had alot of issues) we were incredibly overstretched, on occasions I was left in the babyroom with six under 2s on my own.I rarely was within ratio and trying to meet all their physical and emotional needs was impossible.Some babies and toddlers did OK, but many between about 9mths and 2 really struggled in such a busy, noisy and impersonal environment.

If I was you, I would definitely consider a childminder.They are much better for babies as it's a homely environment, one person, who is always there (not like keyworkers in nurseries who can be off sick/on training/on holiday which can leave their keychildren inconsolable) and you know exactly who is looking after them all day.Also, if they are a good childminder, your child and family as a whole will build up a lovely close, trusting, personal relationship with them, and they will love your child as their own.

Wherever you choose, I would say they should definitely do the following 3 things.If they don't do these things, reconsider.

  1. it's normal to feel abit anxious and nervous when leaving your precious child, but these feelings should be able to subside with reassaurance from the setting- phonecalls/messages, sending photos of them having fun etc....if you continually feel panicky or concerned, or don't feel like they are sensitive and empathetic to your feelings, reconsider.

  2. They should be flexible with settling in.They should be willing to let your child gradually build up their sessions (be prepared to pay for that though) to get used to the setting and people.Afew BRIEF tears or unhappiness at drop off, which quickly subsides and the child is happy the rest of the day and when collected is normal, but no setting should be expecting parents to be leaving inconsolable children with people they barely know yet- it is incredibly traumatic for both parent and child, and they should not be spending long periods upset.A child being abit upset for a short time and then reassured and effectively comforted by someone they have had time to build up a close, trusting bond with is different.

  3. Go with your gut....visit multiple settings, see what feeling you get.If the person feels 'right' you will likely know pretty early on.Don't settle or compromise with someone you are not comfortable with.You can always test the water and if you still don't feel comfortable with sending him yet maybe don't go back to work til he is older, at least you might find a setting you can use in future :) Good luck, and you're not irrational, and you should definitely have had DC's....you sound like a very caring and devoted mummy!

Libra24 · 28/07/2023 22:11

Some of these are concerns born of unfortunate events that are true. Some of the weight of it you are feeling is anxiety. Leaving your kid is hard. No two ways around that. But it's not impossible. Maybe try and work through it with someone. I'd advise being mindful of how you approach it though because not everyone has options. I feel you know some of this is "you" because of how you'd treat a nanny as well with the checking up but some of it is just parenthood and the hard choices we have to make on the daily. Good luck x

TaylorSwifting · 28/07/2023 21:51

I would take extra time off if you can do it and look at pre schools for when your child is 2, they are SO much nicer than nurseries with generally older experienced staff and at 2 a child is usually talking. It’s miserable dropping off your baby who is often crying going into nursery and from your post, you sound very wary as it is - would you ever really trust them?

Outliers · 28/07/2023 21:48

You'll be surprised how quickly you'll go from being scared to counting minutes till you can dump them at nursery.

Shry · 28/07/2023 21:44

It is hard! We put so much pressure on ourselves to be super Mum.

My DD went to nursery at 5 months old (went on mat leave very early due to sickness and only took the 9 months)

This is different for everyone, but i felt that the opportunities nursery could give DD would be better than what i could give her if i stayed at home with her. Im not very social, get anxious around new people so baby groups were out. I didnt want my own anxieties to hold her back from her social development etc and so i dont regret sending DD.

Your LO might get hurt at nursery, infact he probably will at some point!! But he can get hurt at home whilst with you, accidents happen. I think whats important is how nursery respond to the accident and what the accident actually is. For example, DD pulled a book shelf down upon herself once and got a bruise on her head. She seemed fine except for the bruise but they still called me and I had to collect her as it was a head injury and the nursery removed the shelf and reviewed all other shelves around the nursery. So in this instance yes the accident happened and some might argue it was preventable, but I felt the actions they took were correct, they called me straight away and they removed the risk for future happenings.

It does take trust though, if you dont trust anyone but yourself to look after LO (not a criticism btw) then you will have a hard time with childcare providers. Maybe a childminder might feel better for you? At one point my DD went to both a childminder and nursery and i couldnt have asked for a better childminder, she was so kind and my DD adored her.

Mummyof287 · 28/07/2023 21:33

BlibBlabBlob · 28/07/2023 09:21

I think I carry actual parental trauma from the nursery years, ages 1 and 2 at least. DD managed a little better from age 3 but I could still never leave her easily (by which I mean she couldn't leave ME easily).

Every morning, sobbing in the corridor out of her sight and hearing while she screamed for me in her keyworker's arms, having been literally pulled off me. It didn't matter whether I spent an hour settling her into the room to help her feel safe or whether I did the 'bright and breezy and speedy' drop off. Nothing worked, she was absolutely distraught. Three days a week. For over TWO YEARS.

Why did you not move her if she was that unhappy?! :-/

Holidaydreamingg · 28/07/2023 21:25

FrogRainMoon · 28/07/2023 21:09

Hi! My little boy started nursery at 11 months old, 4 days a week. He is nearly 4 now (starting school in Sept) - and I can honestly say nursery has been the making of him! He absolutely loves it there. His speech and language has come on leaps and bounds, he's got a lovely group of friends, all in all he's a happy, confident little boy and I owe so much of that to nursery. Don't forget they are trained professionals who can support your DC in all the areas they need. I work in a school too and I can tell you everyone in this industry puts their heart and soul into it (cos let's face it nobody works in childcare/education for the money 😂). Trust your gut, don't be afraid to explore a few settings to find one you feel will be right for you, and once you find the right setting, they really will start to feel like family to you, corny as I know that sounds. Best of luck with whatever you decide xx

Of course your son’s speech has come on leaps and bounds… he was 11 months old when he started and is now 3 - this would have also happened had he not been in nursery!

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/07/2023 21:24

Tryingtokeepcalmandcarryon · 28/07/2023 20:41

Nope, I couldn’t send my child to nursery as a baby, it just didn’t feel right to me. Yes, absolutely, from the age of 2/3 onwards a child benefits from some socialisation, various types of play, routines etc but of course a 9 month old baby doesn’t need to be socialised, they want their parents and to be at home. The nursery staff are stepping into that role but I used to work in a nursery and hated seeing a room full of small babies who never left the nursery gates for up to 10 hours a day.

I think babies benefit from happy, fulfilled parents and for some that will include working parents and going to nursery.

Babies also don't know what is best for them. My baby could ''want'' me at home all he likes but the reality of it would be a bored, miserable, unfulfilled parent and I fail to see how that would be good for me or for him.

I also feel that he benefits so much from nursery. They have resources I'd never have at home and do so many different activities I'd never think of doing.

It also felt completely right to send him.

FrogRainMoon · 28/07/2023 21:09

Hi! My little boy started nursery at 11 months old, 4 days a week. He is nearly 4 now (starting school in Sept) - and I can honestly say nursery has been the making of him! He absolutely loves it there. His speech and language has come on leaps and bounds, he's got a lovely group of friends, all in all he's a happy, confident little boy and I owe so much of that to nursery. Don't forget they are trained professionals who can support your DC in all the areas they need. I work in a school too and I can tell you everyone in this industry puts their heart and soul into it (cos let's face it nobody works in childcare/education for the money 😂). Trust your gut, don't be afraid to explore a few settings to find one you feel will be right for you, and once you find the right setting, they really will start to feel like family to you, corny as I know that sounds. Best of luck with whatever you decide xx

Tryingtokeepcalmandcarryon · 28/07/2023 20:43

(I wouldn’t worry about harm or abuse though, the staff have a duty of care to your child and there are always (or should always be) multiple adults in the room with at least one qualified)

Tryingtokeepcalmandcarryon · 28/07/2023 20:41

Nope, I couldn’t send my child to nursery as a baby, it just didn’t feel right to me. Yes, absolutely, from the age of 2/3 onwards a child benefits from some socialisation, various types of play, routines etc but of course a 9 month old baby doesn’t need to be socialised, they want their parents and to be at home. The nursery staff are stepping into that role but I used to work in a nursery and hated seeing a room full of small babies who never left the nursery gates for up to 10 hours a day.

MRex · 28/07/2023 20:19

You're fretting because you're trying too much too soon, and it panics you. This is absolutely not an all or nothing decision. Work out a plan for the hours that would work for your child and you. If that's 5 mornings, or 2 days - fine. If it's about building up over a year to gradually add days - fine. Then try and work out that compromise with your employer. Start with a number of hours that feels genuinely doable for you.

MissingGrandstand · 28/07/2023 20:13

@ClinkyWotsit exactly this! For people that don't want or need to go back to work then great, make the choice that is right for you. But so many people on here seem to be suggesting I should feel terrible for putting a 9mo in nursery - it was 100% the right choice for me and my family, not just from a financial point of view but because I am a much better mother for it.

My mum send me to a childminder from 16 weeks and I would defy anyone to find a closer mother/daughter pairing than us.

Zanatdy · 28/07/2023 20:12

Mine are 18 & 15 now and I was so worried before DS started. I have a group of friends who I got the train with from the nursery and our kids started from 3 months - 12 months; all well adjusted young adults all at university now. Most of them barely remember a thing about nursery, which means they wouldn’t have remembered a thing about staying at home too and it would have driven me insane! All great kids who are very close to their parents. It’s normal to worry, completely normal but it will be fine

Ginandtonic1234 · 28/07/2023 20:11

Nursery from 10/11 months was wonderful for both my children. They flourished with the routine and the caring staff and have grown into content, confident, independent children. The nursery staff are great at settling them and getting them to sleep and eat and it makes you enjoy and appreciate your time with them when you pick them up.

I missed them but I knew that they were having lots of fun and nursery becomes a home away from home. They did activities that I wouldn’t have done with them at home and they ate a more varied diet. The worse thing was all the bugs they catch in the first 6 months. The plus side to that is that they were rarely ill when they went to school as they had been exposed to so many bugs.

Working and having young kids in nursery was hard but it meant that the transition to school was easy for them and my career hadn’t suffered when they were more independent and I wanted to progress.

We did change nurseries a couple of times to find the right one. I’d definitely suggest going by recommendations.

Coffeecup123456 · 28/07/2023 20:07

BeaumontLivinston · 27/07/2023 11:39

I've worked in a nursery with very young babies and they don't want to be there, they want their parents. The workers are very young and inexperienced with babies. I sent mine at age 2 and it was perfect. There's absolutely no need to learn social skills when you're a baby. All they want and need is their mother and their milk.

I completely agree and also used to work in nurseries. Why Love Matters is a great book to read to get an in-depth view.

HVPRN · 28/07/2023 20:06

Gosh, I think a lot of these responses make me feel guilty/worse.

I too have to leave my baby at 9 months to return to work/uni. There will be an opportunity only when she is 2y for me to reduce my hours. I KNOW I should be with her. Believe me. But this is not the way society is built, especially not now with how greedy the western world is.

I worked in nurseries for years before career progression. And let me tell you, I adored those children and babies. I played and kept them entertained well. I comforted them like I would my own. I let the parents know EXACTLY how their babies day went. The most difficult age to settle children was around 2y.

user123212 · 28/07/2023 19:47

Also, every time i went into nursery during settling in period, i also saw one kid who was constantly crying. Every time. I asked the staff, and they said "oh he's always like that". I took my kid, walked out and didn't look back.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 28/07/2023 19:46

I would go and have another look around the nursery at an open day there for reassurance

ClinkyWotsit · 28/07/2023 19:45

DD is 3 now, started nursery at 10 months old (4 days per week). I was ready to go back to work, by the end of our day off together each week I’m not the mum I want to be because my proverbial cup is virtually empty so a SAHM life was not for me. Luckily she settled easily into nursery, makes friends easily, many of whom will go with her to school, and I can count the number of times she’s struggled with drop off on one hand over 2+ years. The nursery is at the end of our road so I was lucky enough to get a sneak peek regularly into her daily routine when she was in one of the rooms and nothing I saw ever gave me cause for concern.

On the topic of eating, I went to a stay & play session the nursery ran at Easter and one of the other mums watch in amazement as her child happily demolished an afternoon snack of veg sticks despite the fact she would barely tolerate them on the table at home, let alone try them. So it’s not always fibs 😊

MissingGrandstand · 28/07/2023 19:43

I sent mine at 9 months and now at 18 months she runs into nursery without a backward glance at us, she absolutely loves it. She equally runs out laughing her head off when we pick her up because she is happy to see us - we have an amazing bond but she also enjoys nursery.

Re concerns of abuse, I felt more comfortable with a nursery than a childminder because there are more staff around (increasing the likelihood that abuse or neglect would be spotted).

She also eats better at nursery and I know the nursery cook personally (via family) so I know this is true, not just them telling me she eats when she doesn't.

Most nursery staff are trained in child development - I know I'm certainly not. So I think she's better off there a few days a week, with me feeling like I've kept my career and the time I spend with her being proper quality time (not the same for everyone but I completely lost myself during mat leave and am a much more present parent for spending part of the week at work around other adults).

user123212 · 28/07/2023 19:41

My gut (and baby) screamed at me to not send ds to nursery so young. I'm glad i listened to it. The nursery seemed OK but had high turnover of staff. I waited till 2.5 yrs to a different lovely nursery - zero tears.

Segway16 · 28/07/2023 19:08

I’ve felt like this with them all once it was time to start nursery or preschool. They’ve all loved it (outside of the initial period where they’re getting used to being away from their mum) and have really thrived, and I’ve always enjoyed going back to work.

Snowdaysandhappydays · 28/07/2023 18:24

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request