Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be SO frustrated by threads like this…

53 replies

Firstworldprobs · 26/07/2023 19:11

First of all I want to make it crystal clear that I am not frustrated with the OPs of these threads, I am frustrated for them. I don’t blame them one bit.

There seems to be a steady stream of threads that go something like this:

OP: Asks if she is being unreasonable then describes the situation whereby it is indisputable that it’s in fact her DH / DP who is being unreasonable.

PPs: With their spidey senses tingling as they detect potential gaslighting / narcissism / manipulation / abuse / coercive control / fuckwittery, ask OP for more details and also ask what the DH is usually like, and reassure OP unanimously that she is not being unreasonable.

OP: Gives more background info and history that confirms that PPs were correct, there is a pattern of abuse / fuckwittery and/or a whole childhood full of neglect / abuse - meaning that OP is completely brainwashed and browbeaten and believes that this behaviour is normal and she cannot trust her gut and has to put up with it (and so do her kids).

PPs: Rally round OP, explaining (again, unanimously) that OP does not need to endure the abuse / mistreatment / misery for one day longer and would be completely justified in LTB no matter what he says. Suggest if she cannot find the strength to leave for herself, them do it for her children who deserve to live happily and have good role models - advice to break generational cycles.

OP: Is terrified at the idea, due to having zero self esteem, no support, or having been gaslit and manipulated to within an inch of her life into believing she needs DH to survive and won’t find anyone else, can’t afford to leave etc and is convinced she and her kids are trapped.

PPs: give reassurance that OP can LTB. Give OP details of practical, real life support agencies, websites, Women’s Aid, Freedom Programme, books, scripts for what to say to police / DH, advice on legal aid for solicitors, getting ducks in a row, securing important documents, confide in real life friends or family etc etc

OP: Starts backtracking and offering examples of how her DH is not that bad / is a good dad / might be depressed or ND / can be really nice to her sometimes / always apologises etc.

PPs: Continue to reassure OP that her relationship is toxic / abusive and damaging her and her kids and there are ways to leave and support out there.

OP: Never returns to the thread, perhaps deciding that their bar is lower than they realised and they are doomed to this life.

Very occasionally, the OP will return to confirm that they have found the strength to leave, have taken PPs’ advice, called Woman’s Aid or a solicitor, and have ended the relationship. These threads are so satisfying, PPs rejoice that OP has taken their advice and changed her life for the better, one less abused woman! One more single shitty man. Amazing. But they are the minority.

What are we doing when girls are raised to be compliant, nice, submissive, people pleasing ghosts? How do we raise girls to be sure of their value, have high standards and expectations, unwavering instincts and the confidence to listen to them, and to refuse to put up with this toxic bullshit from men? How do we raise boys to have integrity, to see girls as human beings, to be non violent, unselfish, compassionate people?

I am so frustrated on behalf of all the OPs out there who, despite unanimous, practical and compassionate support on MN, cannot appreciate their value or raise that bar for what they will tolerate from a man?

I don’t blame the OPs one bit - I blame their parents, previous partners, and society. It’s utterly heartbreaking.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Firstworldprobs · 26/07/2023 19:35

Take heart, the relationship advice given on MN is never wasted even if the OP isn't ready to hear it at the time they post.

Thank you, this is what I tell myself whenever another one disappears back anonymously into their [awful] real life.

OP posts:
FOJN · 26/07/2023 19:32

I wondered where you were going with this and then near the end of your post you ask, what I think, are the right questions. We definitely need to give girls confidence in their worth and the encouragement to trust their instincts.

The conditioning continues into adulthood and sadly too many women participate in it. There are so many threads here where women will discuss being taken for granted by numerous different types of people and there will always be plenty of posters telling OP she's being selfish, they would be fine with the situation described or a request for OP to quantify the harm or inconvenience caused by putting someone else first. It's quite depressing sometimes.

However the benefit of the type of threads you're highlighting is that there may be other women reading who find the OP's situation relatable and use the advice given to change their own lives for the better. Sometimes it's takes a while for the OP to absorb the reality of her own situation once it's been pointed out but it does ultimately lead to her leaving even if it's not immediately.

Take heart, the relationship advice given on MN is never wasted even if the OP isn't ready to hear it at the time they post.

CatchItDerry · 26/07/2023 19:20

Completely agree.
It starts young, with casual sexism starting as babies, continues through primary school where girls have higher expectations on behaviour, and it’s not uncommon to find girls seated next to boisterous boys to try to calm them down.
Then onto secondary school, where sexual harassment is rife and schools rarely handle incidents appropriately. (Eg at DD’s school a boy (who gave me the chills from age 13) would go up behind girls and pretend to choke them, often hurting them. School called it “monkey love” - a boy behaving badly towards girls because he didn’t know how to handle his emotions and feelings - and nothing was done about it.
Fast forward to adulthood where banter and rape jokes are normal, where any suggestion that men should be held responsible for crap male behaviour results in lots of “NAMALT” and “not my Nigel…”.
It’s the elephant in the room that cannot be discussed in the depth that is required.
Meanwhile women who’ve learnt their lessons well are unable to escape truly shit situations because they’ve been taught so well to be kind.