Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being AIBU not wanting brother to visit with his kids?

146 replies

Chocolatelover87 · 26/07/2023 16:19

So my brother has two kids aged 7 and 13.

We live an hour apart and they don’t visit often but on the last two occasions there have been some issues.

The kids will often just wonder in all the bedrooms and go through all my things, they run riot around the house and the 7 year old broke two of my cats toys.

The house was almost flooded as one of the toilets is severely blocked ( the kids wouldn’t of known this ) but I thought thought they they would of used the toilet first seeing as it is an en-suite in my bedroom.

I find the visits very stressful because the parents don’t seem to discipline the kids and afterwards the kids will leave a huge mess leaving me to clean up after them and I have to keep watching the 7 year old as he is very naughty and loves breaking things.

I don’t particularly like my SIL as she is quite rude and bit of a stirrer.

My brother and his wife have just invited themselves over and I’m not sure if I should just make an excuse or address the issues but this is the 3rd time they have invited themselves over and I have made an excuse.

My brother and SIL also never invite me or my sister to there house and all these meetings seem to be at my house which I think is a bit unfair.

OP posts:
1993GoToo · 27/07/2023 15:29

Sounds like you have nothing to lose, and everything to gain, by being upfront with them.

Tell them clearly they can't come to you house as they make a mess and the kids are out of control. Offer to meet at a park halfway if they are that bothered seeing you.

Chocolatelover87 · 27/07/2023 15:22

HappenstanceMarmite · 27/07/2023 14:33

What do they say when you suggest going to their house instead?

I have never suggested going to his house as I would feel uncomfortable inviting myself to his house.

OP posts:
HappenstanceMarmite · 27/07/2023 14:33

What do they say when you suggest going to their house instead?

tootallfortheshelf · 27/07/2023 12:58

Dozycuntlaters · 27/07/2023 12:33

Your brother and his wife/kids sound dreadful. You don't have to have a bond with them at all and to be honest, if he was abusive to you when you were a kid why would you even want to? Would you spend time with him if you weren't related by blood?

Just decline. Be honest. Tell him you don't enjoy his unruly kids trashing your house and you don't want them to come over. If you do want some semblance of a relationship then meet somewhere neutral but if I were you I would not be having them in my house.

He fully deserves to be told just how unruly his kids are, but at the same time I'm not sure that being confrontational with him is the best long-term strategy?

I say this because he sounds horrible and as if he will do anything he can to punish you whatever you do, might it be better to gradually ghost him and his family so that you drop off their radar and don't get hassle from them?

They sound domineering and completely undisciplined I wouldn't want them sniffing around trying to make trouble when I had a new baby, I think he will be jealous of anything that's good in your life and he will try and ruin it for you OP.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 27/07/2023 12:33

So your brother is an arsehole, as is his wife and kids. He has no respect for you and this has clearly led to the behaviours you see with his children as they can see that.

Quite honestly, I would take steps now before your baby arrives to simply say that they are not welcome to visit your home.
"We're going to come over and see you for the afternoon"
Choices:
"Happy to come to you or meet you somewhere but I'm not hosting you all again.."
"Why not"
"I've repeatedly asked you both to control your children in my house and you have pointedly refused to do so. They are far too old to be rifling through other people's stuff and to be this destructive. So I'm done."

Or the evasive but repetitive and wearing approach
"Sorry I'm busy/already have visitors coming/on holiday/will be at parents helping clean/garden"

Dozycuntlaters · 27/07/2023 12:33

Your brother and his wife/kids sound dreadful. You don't have to have a bond with them at all and to be honest, if he was abusive to you when you were a kid why would you even want to? Would you spend time with him if you weren't related by blood?

Just decline. Be honest. Tell him you don't enjoy his unruly kids trashing your house and you don't want them to come over. If you do want some semblance of a relationship then meet somewhere neutral but if I were you I would not be having them in my house.

tootallfortheshelf · 27/07/2023 12:32

Chocolatelover87 · 27/07/2023 12:10

Yeah I understand what your saying and I agree it is important having a relationship with them.

I think a lot of the issues are deep rooted as my brother who is 12 years older then me made my life hell as a teenager.

He threw me out of my parents house when I was 17 ( for drinking and having boyfriends ) and I really struggled in my late teens and early 20s.
Him and my cousins were quite abusive too me, so I find it hard repairing a relationship with him and his family.

It's not your job to repair this relationship they are the ones who have sabotaged it.

Your brother is despicable bully, he threw you out of your own home when you were just 17 years old, that's awful absolutely awful-who the fuck does he think he is??
He's trying to do the same thing now, make you feel as if you have no power over what happens in your own home.
I notice it's the same old dominaring male script, trying to get in control of you when you are vulnerable because you're pregnant, he will let his children bully your child just like he bullied you.
You have to put a stop to this pull up the drawbridge don't let them in, keep them out of your life.

Intercrapper · 27/07/2023 12:24

HIS children!

& congratulations!

Intercrapper · 27/07/2023 12:24

I read your update op. Sounds like allowing your children to destroy your stuff is more of a power trip for your brother. Don’t let them in!

Irridescantshimmmer · 27/07/2023 12:18

Just be firm, as well as direct and say no.

They caused enough bother last time, make it clear they are not welcome.

Just be assertive, its your home so they don't trash it again.

Ohhmydays · 27/07/2023 12:13

If someone is at mine with there kids and there doing stuff they aren't meant to be doing i have no problem telling them to stop doing what they are doing or they will have to sit next to there parent for the duration of the time they are here. I also have no problem telling my sister to get her kid in check if he starts playing up

tootallfortheshelf · 27/07/2023 12:12

Jk987 · 27/07/2023 11:46

You're still their Aunty so having a good bond is important. Good that the family want to see you and make an effort.

I'd go out to the park with them and take a picnic. Say to your bro about the behaviour though.

It's important to have a good bond with people who are assholes have no boundaries and treat you like shit?
I don't think so ... unless you fancy life as a door mat?

tootallfortheshelf · 27/07/2023 12:10

. . . don't let them visit distance yourself from them, you don't want them around when baby gets here, they sound like arseholes !

Chocolatelover87 · 27/07/2023 12:10

Yeah I understand what your saying and I agree it is important having a relationship with them.

I think a lot of the issues are deep rooted as my brother who is 12 years older then me made my life hell as a teenager.

He threw me out of my parents house when I was 17 ( for drinking and having boyfriends ) and I really struggled in my late teens and early 20s.
Him and my cousins were quite abusive too me, so I find it hard repairing a relationship with him and his family.

OP posts:
tootallfortheshelf · 27/07/2023 12:08

Am I being am I being unreasonable??

GardeningIdiot · 27/07/2023 12:06

Jk987 · 27/07/2023 11:46

You're still their Aunty so having a good bond is important. Good that the family want to see you and make an effort.

I'd go out to the park with them and take a picnic. Say to your bro about the behaviour though.

Shit parenting makes being an involved aunt really difficult.

Drenchend · 27/07/2023 11:59

Op you don't have to tell off the child.

But has anyone said "Jim, why did you just do that." hard stare... Why did you deliberately spill /break /leave plate on the floor...

That makes me feel like you didn't respect me or my home.
Is that true?
Would you like to come here again? I really enjoy seeing you but I dint like it when you do xyz...

If you want to come back ( thunk of something fun to do) then you need too stopped this

Sounds like parents don't know how to manage them and they are struggling.

Chocolatelover87 · 27/07/2023 11:51

GardeningIdiot · 27/07/2023 11:35

Definitely worth setting some boundaries with your brother now - the last thing you want is this family trying to insist on visiting when you have a newborn.

There's no harm in telling him the truth, if he gets offended that's OK too. It's his choice to let them run wild.

Yes I think it will cause problems as my sister and her family will be visiting me but her kids are very well behaved and they are of similar age to my brother’s kids.

OP posts:
Drenchend · 27/07/2023 11:47

It sounds awful op but also clear you don't have a relationship with them.

Is there anything you could do to 1:1 try to engage them?

Share somethings you are interested in with them?

Try and bond because they will be possibly easier to manage...

Jk987 · 27/07/2023 11:46

You're still their Aunty so having a good bond is important. Good that the family want to see you and make an effort.

I'd go out to the park with them and take a picnic. Say to your bro about the behaviour though.

GardeningIdiot · 27/07/2023 11:40

This might be helpful, OP: www.scienceofpeople.com/how-to-set-boundaries/

GardeningIdiot · 27/07/2023 11:35

Definitely worth setting some boundaries with your brother now - the last thing you want is this family trying to insist on visiting when you have a newborn.

There's no harm in telling him the truth, if he gets offended that's OK too. It's his choice to let them run wild.

Chocolatelover87 · 27/07/2023 11:27

whatstheagendatoday · 26/07/2023 21:34

Do you have kids op? You're allowed of course to not want kids in your house, but just that the things you described do not necessarily sound like bad manners but just normal, clumsy kids. Cats toys broke? They leave plates on around? I mean, these are kids and your nieces. But each to their own. Maybe you aren't close to your brother or family, or don't know how kids are. That's ok, but a, I wouldn't label them bad mannered based on what you've said and b, you'd be unreasonable to want to have brother over without the kids. Kids come first and it's normal your brother wouldn't want to come otherwise.

Sorry I’m not sure why having kids is relevant to my post?
And I never mentioned kids not being allowed?

I have plenty of kids over to my house who don’t go through all my things, go into my bedroom, steal my things and damage my property.

To me the above behaviour is bad mannered and shows a lack of respect for other people’s property.

Like I have mentioned I find the visits stressful and it is me who has to replace things that have been damaged.

OP posts:
Lottapianos · 27/07/2023 09:03

'Its clear from your post you are childless - so with respect its possible you don't have much tolerance for some normal (though be it - annoying) behaviours. I was the same before my kids I promise!'

There is nothing 'normal' about a 7 and a 13 year old going into bedrooms that they have been told to stay out of, and rooting through drawers! And they are plenty old enough to be told to pick up after themselves and not leave plates all over the floor

The parents sound ridiculously wet OP. Not a chance they would be setting foot in my house again after that

Thepossibility · 27/07/2023 07:14

I'm currently refusing sleepovers with my niece. I say no and remind her of such and such behaviour that resulted in the ban. Just tell them you're anxious about keeping your house nice after previous experience of their visits and would rather meet elsewhere. They can't force their way into your house!