Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being AIBU not wanting brother to visit with his kids?

146 replies

Chocolatelover87 · 26/07/2023 16:19

So my brother has two kids aged 7 and 13.

We live an hour apart and they don’t visit often but on the last two occasions there have been some issues.

The kids will often just wonder in all the bedrooms and go through all my things, they run riot around the house and the 7 year old broke two of my cats toys.

The house was almost flooded as one of the toilets is severely blocked ( the kids wouldn’t of known this ) but I thought thought they they would of used the toilet first seeing as it is an en-suite in my bedroom.

I find the visits very stressful because the parents don’t seem to discipline the kids and afterwards the kids will leave a huge mess leaving me to clean up after them and I have to keep watching the 7 year old as he is very naughty and loves breaking things.

I don’t particularly like my SIL as she is quite rude and bit of a stirrer.

My brother and his wife have just invited themselves over and I’m not sure if I should just make an excuse or address the issues but this is the 3rd time they have invited themselves over and I have made an excuse.

My brother and SIL also never invite me or my sister to there house and all these meetings seem to be at my house which I think is a bit unfair.

OP posts:
SaysRelaaxxx · 31/07/2023 08:01

They are your nephews. You have to see them for a few hours in the arse end of never. Your brother lives with this daily. Say a silent prayer that you have cats, suck it up and just try and enjoy seeing your family! Kids do make mess and they are loud and your house will notice, but then they will leave.

Dontfeedtheplant · 31/07/2023 07:53

YANBU!
100% agree it's time to start setting boundaries with your brother. But also understand that is easier said than done, knowing you've had to put up with his unchecked abusive behaviour all your life. It won't be easy.
But just take small steps. Like refusing this visit. When I had to start setting boundaries with family members, it didn't go down well. I read a quote once - "the only people who won't like you setting boundaries are those people who benefited from you having none!"

Expect push back from your brother and Sister-in-law, they won't like that you're recognising the dynamic is bad and trying to do something about it.

I'm sorry you're having to go through this while you're pregnant but it's better that you start now then having to deal with this behaviour when you have your own child.

OhcantthInkofaname · 30/07/2023 18:54

Tell them what you told us!
They know their children and how they behave.

zerofuchsgivenTBH · 30/07/2023 18:50

Just saw your recent update. Birth order is meaningless when everyone has grown up. Older kids no longer have the right to bully younger ones as payback for daring to be born and stealing their thunder. Harder for bullies to accept than those who were bullied, but that's how it is!

zerofuchsgivenTBH · 30/07/2023 18:47

Just stop the visits. They won't be happy as they probably like the fact that the kids range around and someone else has to clean up the mess, but that's not your problem.
Make excuses - oh, we're in a mess this week doing some tidying up before the baby comes or some other excuse. Text if it's easier.
People like this are very direct about their needs ie coming to your house without being invited, and that gives you the right to be very direct back. More than once if necessary. They will eventually get the hint and the habit of your place being one that they can use and abuse will gradually die off.

Stillcantbebothered · 30/07/2023 18:42

whatstheagendatoday · 26/07/2023 21:34

Do you have kids op? You're allowed of course to not want kids in your house, but just that the things you described do not necessarily sound like bad manners but just normal, clumsy kids. Cats toys broke? They leave plates on around? I mean, these are kids and your nieces. But each to their own. Maybe you aren't close to your brother or family, or don't know how kids are. That's ok, but a, I wouldn't label them bad mannered based on what you've said and b, you'd be unreasonable to want to have brother over without the kids. Kids come first and it's normal your brother wouldn't want to come otherwise.

What hogwash, those are badly behaved kids with no boundaries. You sound like one of those parents who think the sun shines out of their kids arses and turn a blind eye to everything they do with the excuse they are just kids.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 30/07/2023 17:29

He is still bullying you by how he and his family treat you. He expects you to put up with it.

Is there a cultural reason that you won’t stand up to him?

PandaExpress · 30/07/2023 16:55

So these kids of your brothers are your nephews. You are their auntie. You are allowed to tell them not to go in your room. If they aren't listening you don't have to do the nicey, nicey "We don't do that here" speech. You can tell them off! And you can tell your brother too. At this point, if it causes a fall out, it doesn't sound like it would be a great loss. A bit of mess or plates of food wouldn't bother you so much if you actually wanted a relationship with them. So telling them straight i.e "I'm sick of telling you/your kids, to stop going in my room!" will be win, win either way. It either changes their behaviour or you don't have to see them again.

Chocolatelover87 · 30/07/2023 12:47

LavenderfortheBees · 30/07/2023 12:31

Why are you moving closer to parents then? What is the purpose of forgiving and forgetting? You don't owe them anything due to your history so do they enhance your life now? Would you let them babysit your precious DC given how they treated you and fail to mind your nephews behaviours?

Fuck all of that.

Why not move further away and go low to no contact with the lot of them?

It is my home town and I have several cousins that live there whom I am extremely close too and unfortunately it is also where parents and brother live.

Since I was a teenager it has been embedded in me that I am a bad person and that I am always in the wrong hence why I tried to repair a relationship with them, but having counselling earlier in the year made me analyse things and give me the strength to finally stand up for myself.

OP posts:
LavenderfortheBees · 30/07/2023 12:31

Why are you moving closer to parents then? What is the purpose of forgiving and forgetting? You don't owe them anything due to your history so do they enhance your life now? Would you let them babysit your precious DC given how they treated you and fail to mind your nephews behaviours?

Fuck all of that.

Why not move further away and go low to no contact with the lot of them?

Chocolatelover87 · 30/07/2023 11:56

5foot5 · 30/07/2023 09:19

Not the point of the thread I know, but why did your parents let your brother throw you out of their house? What were they doing while this was going on? We're they scared of him too?

Parents stood back and did nothing, they themselves were awful parents and were quite abusive to myself and my siblings.

My brother used to be quite an aggressive bully when he was younger and as he is the eldest child he think’s he can control people.

I really struggled in my late teens & early 20’s and was forced to grow up quickly.
Somehow I managed to find my own place, get a job, save money and eventually meet Mr Right.

I was willing to forgive them and make amends and made an effort with them at all, brought the kids presents at birthday and Xmas’s etc, but now I feel differently.

Family gathering at my house are defo off limits and if they invite themselves over again I will just be honest & tell them how I feel, if feelings get hurt then so be it.

Nobody cared about mine at 17 when I was homeless.

A lot of helpful and supportive advice, much appreciated! Xx

OP posts:
user123212 · 30/07/2023 10:20

Holds not holes... sorry typo 😅

user123212 · 30/07/2023 10:18

Not sure you really want to keep a relationship with them? I mean do you want those kids to be friends with yours when older, if they haven't changed? Btw you're pregnant, which means no holes barred - you and baby come first. Keep them out your house!

ohdamnitjanet · 30/07/2023 09:28

You don’t have to have any relationship with anyone who treats you badly, adult or child. Why would you want to be close to these children? They will grow up just like your abusive brother and will not be kind to your baby.
Why would you want to be close to an abusive relative? I agree with the poster who questioned the family dynamics with your parents and sister who seem to condone his past and present behaviour by keeping silent. Even if you do move closer to your parents you do not have to have contact with him. Babysit those little shits? Hell would freeze over first. And I understand how difficult it is to say no. And if you do cut contact and he is angry, that rather proves the point that he is horrible bully with no remorse for past or present behaviour.

Naunet · 30/07/2023 09:27

Its clear from your post you are childless - so with respect its possible you don't have much tolerance for some normal (though be it - annoying) behaviours. I was the same before my kids I promise!

Jesus Christ 🙄

5foot5 · 30/07/2023 09:19

Not the point of the thread I know, but why did your parents let your brother throw you out of their house? What were they doing while this was going on? We're they scared of him too?

SuperCam · 30/07/2023 09:00

Don’t listen to the people telling you that kids are just being kids when they make a mess. 7 and 13 year olds are perfectly capable of sitting nicely, not chucking food about and understanding that you don’t go rifling through drawers in other people’s houses.

As for throwing plates on the floor that’s just ridiculous and your brother and SIL are clearly either failing to parent or deliberately encouraging their kids to behave like this in your house, which given your description of your brother’s behaviour towards you would not be surprising.

don’t ever have them in your house again and take steps to limit contact with them. Just because they are family doesn’t mean you have to have any sort of bond or interaction with them!

Happiestinmygarden · 30/07/2023 08:53

Being pregnant/having a tiny baby/toddler gives you the perfect excuse not to have them over and should be able to spin that excuse out long enough for the 7yo to stop rifling through your stuff. Surely there must be a national trust place/beach/nice park/woodland where you can meet for lunch and the kids can run riot? The deep rooted issues with your brother are a different thing, why did your parents allow him to kick you out? I can’t imagine a time where my son calls the shots in my house, particularly about the welfare of his sister

Manthide · 30/07/2023 08:30

whatstheagendatoday · 26/07/2023 21:34

Do you have kids op? You're allowed of course to not want kids in your house, but just that the things you described do not necessarily sound like bad manners but just normal, clumsy kids. Cats toys broke? They leave plates on around? I mean, these are kids and your nieces. But each to their own. Maybe you aren't close to your brother or family, or don't know how kids are. That's ok, but a, I wouldn't label them bad mannered based on what you've said and b, you'd be unreasonable to want to have brother over without the kids. Kids come first and it's normal your brother wouldn't want to come otherwise.

I have 4 children aged between 15 and 32 and I assure you they have never gone upstairs in a house without permission and would never go into someone's bedroom unless accompanied by the person. They also never made a mess, or if they did and they were young I would have cleared it up myself.

Branwells77 · 30/07/2023 08:23

My DH has a grown up niece who has 3 children 5,4,2 and they are an absolute nightmare they have no respect or manners, they are now no longer allowed in our home because after a few visits and our home been disrespected we had enough we told the niece she needs to discipline the children but she just ignores us.
We now meet them at local parks the bonus of this is when we have had enough we can just leave when they used to visit us they would definitely over stay their welcome and conveniently be around for meal times I don’t mind giving anyone a meal but feeding an extra 5 people is pushing it.

Newestname002 · 28/07/2023 22:44

@Chocolatelover87

You need to be very clear indeed about your boundaries and be prepared to defend them against your family, including your mother I'm afraid. Start now, this minute, with them invading your home and disrespecting your personal space. If they blow up then they do: if you don't assert yourself you will always be rolled over and not just by your nasty brother and his wife.

Perhaps write a pros and cons list about what you don't tolerate and how to deal with the pushback. How will you respond to their entitled behaviour?

I have heard "what doesn't kill you makes you stronger". I don't think that's 100% the case, but I think it is in this situation. 🌹

LookItsMeAgain · 28/07/2023 18:26

@Chocolatelover87 : you say "I will be moving closer to my parents at some stage and so that also means closer to my brother who will no doubt be asking me to babysit the kids as that is what he does to my parents a lot."

Why do you have to move closer to your parents and your brother? Surely there must be homes that would be close to your parents but in the opposite direction to where your brother lives, unless he already lives around the corner from your parents?

You can politely decline any sort of requests for babysitting by stating "Just because I'm moving closer to Mum & Dad, doesn't mean that I'll be available for babysitting. I have activities that I'm involved with and I'm not giving them up. Also my time is mine to decide what to do with it, so I think it's probably best for you to look elsewhere for a babysitter".

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 27/07/2023 19:27

Bit of a drip feed there OP, re your brother’s abusive behaviour when you were younger!!

In that case I don’t think you should try too hard, keep them at a distance. People like that don’t change just because you pull them up on their behaviour, he may even get worse.

But practice saying ‘No.’ Also practice not giving a reason why - ‘I can’t do that’ is enough, doesn’t allow wiggle room for him to tell you why your reason isn’t good enough.

The whole thing is dysfunction then, if your parents allowed him to treat you that way and your sister is on good terms with him. Watch out for yourself first, try not to damage other relationships as much as possible as that will hurt you, but having been in situations with very toxic relatives I can tell you there’s no real gain in having a ‘close’ relationship with them - it just means everything happens on their terms, so keep a distance.

jannier · 27/07/2023 19:17

Chocolatelover87 · 27/07/2023 19:00

Hi there defo is some deep routed issues between me and my brother.
I can see your points of views on quite a few things.

The thing is the parents never discipline the kids or tell them off.
When they used to visit the parents would just be talking and let the kids run riot.
At no point did they ever check on the kids.

On the last occasion I brought the kids garden toys especially to play with to keep them out of the house, to no avail unfortunately.

The 7 year old will deliberately throw plates on the floor, and I will repeatedly tell him not to do such and such but he will still do it.

I will be moving closer to my parents at some stage and so that also means closer to my brother who will no doubt be asking me to babysit the kids as that is what he does to my parents a lot.

I defo do not want the 7 year old near the baby as he is quite aggressive with people/animals in general.

Im not sure how I would go about building a relationship with the kids to be honest, it would mean frequent contact with my brother and SIL.

Thank you for your kind words and advice.

On another note Mumsnet is very useful and great for gaining other people’s views/advice/opinions on things.

If he asks for a babysitter just say no your children don't listen to me and do not respect boundaries once you sort that I'll think about it.

smartiesnskittles · 27/07/2023 19:07

It sounds like your brother is continuing to bully you in a different way still. Allowing his kids to trash your house and inviting themselves over unwanted is domineering and intimating behaviour, given the history. And given your history, it's a firm no thanks, no way. They should not be in (and disrespectful of) your personal and safe space. It's a continuous attempt to have power and control over you. He threw you out!! Why should they come to you?!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread