Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you be with a partner who doesn't believe in climate change?

616 replies

ToDoLists · 26/07/2023 16:17

DH doesn't really think it's all that bad. He thinks we should be recyling more and caring for the planet as makes sense and is just the right thing to do - but that climate change as a disaster is an exaggeration and not based in science. And that people are utilising it for their own agenda, woke brigade & so on.

We have young kids.

AIBU to find this position increasingly problematic?

People are going to say people are allowed different opinions but he seems geniunely unconcerned about future of planet for our kids - and I find that hard to swallow.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
CrazyLadie · 28/07/2023 13:27

ToDoLists · 26/07/2023 16:17

DH doesn't really think it's all that bad. He thinks we should be recyling more and caring for the planet as makes sense and is just the right thing to do - but that climate change as a disaster is an exaggeration and not based in science. And that people are utilising it for their own agenda, woke brigade & so on.

We have young kids.

AIBU to find this position increasingly problematic?

People are going to say people are allowed different opinions but he seems geniunely unconcerned about future of planet for our kids - and I find that hard to swallow.

I guess it depends on how strongly ya feel about climate change, if it was a new relationship would this be a deal breaker for you? I think it would for me along woth voting tory, I am single disabled Mum and have been shat on the tories from a high height, someone voting for them is also voting to bring single parents, people on low incomes and disabled people to their kness!!

CrazyLadie · 28/07/2023 13:25

Nousernamesleftatall · 26/07/2023 16:24

All the predictions thus far have been wrong so I am with your DH on this. Now if the government wanted to fixate on the corporations causing pollution in this world I would be first in line but they don’t. They want you to pay more money and lower your standards of living to change the weather. The planet has been heating and cooling since time began. This time they have the media propaganda machine behind them for this agenda 2030.

Been wrong? Have ya nae seem that Europe is on fire? New highest tp in the world was over 53° 🙄

Zippeedidodah · 28/07/2023 12:54

There's always going to be climate change, the earth has went through many through billions of years, plus we were all taught continents are on plates that move. What some people don't believe is that humans are responsible for the climate shifting and that's fine just like some people think humans are responsible-that's fine also.
Everyone has different opinions no use in falling out about it.

glowfrog · 28/07/2023 12:46

Herejusttocomment · 28/07/2023 11:37

I despair, the predictions didn't come true because action was taken to prevent it 🤦‍♀️

Yep - it's the Y2K and ozone layer hole all over again.

Fluffmum · 28/07/2023 12:05

He’s allowed his own opinion. My parents both voted for different parties but they still loved each other.

OneTC · 28/07/2023 11:55

There are some non negotiable opinions from a partner but this wouldn't be one of them.

A huge red flag would be a partner that required alignment on everything, fucking hell that'd be proper tedious. My OH believes things I don't and vice versa. I have friends that hold views I find frankly insane but we just talk about disco or something instead

AIBot · 28/07/2023 11:42

CHIRIBAYA · 28/07/2023 11:00

'They want you to pay more money and lower your standards of living to change the weather'.

What utter bollocks. The government do not give a flying fig about the climate; they want to 'lower your standards of living' so that they can maintain the status quo, i.e. their own privilege.

YANBU to find his approach increasingly problematic. What you are refering to here are broader core values and these matter. Do we treat the environment with respect; see ourselves as being in reciprocal relationship with it and understand the basic inter-connectedness of all living things? Or do we treat it in a narcissistic, exploitative, abusive way, taking only what we want with no thought of the consequences? Personally I don't need science to tell me how to behave in relation to something that allows me to survive and gives to me in innumerable ways. Tribal people are much more understanding and appreciative of their place in this web of connection; they are the true caretakers of the earth.

As for children, we are giving their tomorrow for our today.

You’re right, it’s about his core values
not aligning with the OP’s.

And for me, his inability to source reliable factual information would be a massive ick factor. Ignoring evidence from bodies comprised of top scientists, such as top universities in the world, NASA, the UN, IPCC etc, puts his judgement on par with a nut job conspiracy theorist.

Herejusttocomment · 28/07/2023 11:37

I despair, the predictions didn't come true because action was taken to prevent it 🤦‍♀️

ChristmasCurry · 28/07/2023 11:23

I remember the following climate disasters-

Acid Rain - shown to be a myth but industry did clean up its act.
Hole in the Ozone Layer - removal of CFC's is fixing that.
Global Cooling - not happened so far.
Global Warming - they got bored of that name.
Climate Change - been happening for 4.5 Billion Years.

I'm waiting for an VEI-8 Volcanic Eruption to occur that will give everyone something to moan about - happens about every 50,000 years, only 23,000 years to go !

CHIRIBAYA · 28/07/2023 11:00

'They want you to pay more money and lower your standards of living to change the weather'.

What utter bollocks. The government do not give a flying fig about the climate; they want to 'lower your standards of living' so that they can maintain the status quo, i.e. their own privilege.

YANBU to find his approach increasingly problematic. What you are refering to here are broader core values and these matter. Do we treat the environment with respect; see ourselves as being in reciprocal relationship with it and understand the basic inter-connectedness of all living things? Or do we treat it in a narcissistic, exploitative, abusive way, taking only what we want with no thought of the consequences? Personally I don't need science to tell me how to behave in relation to something that allows me to survive and gives to me in innumerable ways. Tribal people are much more understanding and appreciative of their place in this web of connection; they are the true caretakers of the earth.

As for children, we are giving their tomorrow for our today.

TheKeatingFive · 28/07/2023 10:58

I'm not sure it really matters. His actions seem to be mostly in keeping with a lot of people who profess to believe. Ultimately actions speak a lot louder.

CatchItDerry · 28/07/2023 10:54

midgetastic · 28/07/2023 10:36

The climate warnings have not been proven wrong

They are proving remarkably accurate - we are tracking the major predictions made in the 1970s very well

In my lifetime there have been predictions of London being underwater by 2000, then regularly updated to various years up to now.

There were predictions that we were heading into an ice age.
Predictions that various glaciers would be gone by 2010 +

There are plenty of warnings that have not come to fruition.

That’s not to say we shouldn’t be acting, but punishing people into action is not the way.

The vast majority of children are in school - they should be taught to look forward and look for solutions, not more and more ways to limit already struggling people’s lives.

I fully agree with Konstantin Kisin in this respect. Whatever we’ve been doing for the last few decades have produced a bunch of young people who think that “Just Stop Oil” is going to make a difference without having any problem solving ideas. Sod the carrot, it’s all about the stick. Look how well it’s going.

PaulineFG · 28/07/2023 10:42

Absoloutely agree with DH. There are many many complext cycles and variations which contribute to world climate. The sun is the main driver however (probably not too surprising when you think about it!). The Milankovich cycles, for example show that when the earth's orbit is more elliptical than circular the climate changes up and down.

To return to the original worries about DH. Firstly, let's not tie this kind of viewpoint in with "cranks" though of course many of the latter have driven scientific and philosophical thought forward! And no, I am not a Trump supporter or flat earther!!

Secondly what is wrong with debate in the family? I was always thoroughly questioned by my parents particularly over political points. I regard this as helpful and stimulating and it taught me never to accept things unquestioningly.

This has stood me in good stead. I have always done this myself and my son aand I continue to have excellent debates (notice, they are NOT arguments).

mixedpressings · 28/07/2023 10:39

I'll come back to the thread later as have to work but I am:

An environmentalist/climate scientist, that's my job
Have a sort of non believing other half

So that's interesting...

Mama678 · 28/07/2023 10:37

Tinkeress · 28/07/2023 10:26

The 'real' experts all agree that climate change or climate shift as I prefer to call it, is one of the foremost important issues for the planet so yes please look to experts and not the newspapers, social media, the left or the right.

As a physics lecturer, my one main conscience arrow to my students is making them realise that humanity is merely a temporary greasy stain on the planet.

All of us as humans are born, bred and educated by the system to believe that WE are so important, that we are the life blood of earth and that earth = humanity, but in actual real terms, humanity is as important to this planet as an ant is to what we are eating for dinner tonight.

If you believe climate change IS real and increasing rapidly as I and many of my colleagues around the world do, then worry about the future for humanity but do not worry about the future of the planet.
Even if climate change wipes every human from the planet, the planet will in time bring on it's next phase (without the pesky humans).

In time, the carbon chokehold would reduce, seas absorbtion of carbon dioxide would help the gradual restructuring of balance in the atmosphere and ground chemical balance.

It would take around 3 million years to get back to the pre-extinction baseline where large bodied mammals would one again walk the earth and areas like the US, southern Europe and South America would become mega temperate zones with perfect conditions to respawn animal life that would largely consist of DNA altered new species derived from the very few surviving species such as tardigrades (water bears).
The new evolution to the new "humanity" could theoretically be walking worms. That is pot luck as to how nature uses the last surviving and living cell soup and what recipes develop.

We are a quick visitor and even if humanity survives another million years which is by scientific reasoning and current technological advances resulting in almost guaranteed mutual destruction, more or less impossible, we will still have been a fly that landed on the backside of earth, puked up, wrecked parts of the natural order and the planet, then flew off 2 seconds later, only to drop dead.

When humanity and each individual person gets to grip with just how insignificant we are in the clock of the universe, we might just start to love each other, respect each other, stop the self destructive wars and appreciate just how time really is fleeting.

If we do all that, we might just finally live as a decent society and not the absolute hateful and selfish society that is becoming worse every decade.

Agree with everything you have written here!

midgetastic · 28/07/2023 10:36

The climate warnings have not been proven wrong

They are proving remarkably accurate - we are tracking the major predictions made in the 1970s very well

CatchItDerry · 28/07/2023 10:32

Haven’t rtft.
I’m not a climate change denier, but since the 60s there have been many catastrophic climate change warnings, every single one has been revised. Even Greta Thunberg has been deleting past tweets because they’ve been proven very wrong.
Living in fear constantly is not the answer. Innovation and inspiring young people is the answer, but global governments seem hellbent on keeping the status quo for the wealthy and putting the fear of god into everyone else.

Tinkeress · 28/07/2023 10:26

The 'real' experts all agree that climate change or climate shift as I prefer to call it, is one of the foremost important issues for the planet so yes please look to experts and not the newspapers, social media, the left or the right.

As a physics lecturer, my one main conscience arrow to my students is making them realise that humanity is merely a temporary greasy stain on the planet.

All of us as humans are born, bred and educated by the system to believe that WE are so important, that we are the life blood of earth and that earth = humanity, but in actual real terms, humanity is as important to this planet as an ant is to what we are eating for dinner tonight.

If you believe climate change IS real and increasing rapidly as I and many of my colleagues around the world do, then worry about the future for humanity but do not worry about the future of the planet.
Even if climate change wipes every human from the planet, the planet will in time bring on it's next phase (without the pesky humans).

In time, the carbon chokehold would reduce, seas absorbtion of carbon dioxide would help the gradual restructuring of balance in the atmosphere and ground chemical balance.

It would take around 3 million years to get back to the pre-extinction baseline where large bodied mammals would one again walk the earth and areas like the US, southern Europe and South America would become mega temperate zones with perfect conditions to respawn animal life that would largely consist of DNA altered new species derived from the very few surviving species such as tardigrades (water bears).
The new evolution to the new "humanity" could theoretically be walking worms. That is pot luck as to how nature uses the last surviving and living cell soup and what recipes develop.

We are a quick visitor and even if humanity survives another million years which is by scientific reasoning and current technological advances resulting in almost guaranteed mutual destruction, more or less impossible, we will still have been a fly that landed on the backside of earth, puked up, wrecked parts of the natural order and the planet, then flew off 2 seconds later, only to drop dead.

When humanity and each individual person gets to grip with just how insignificant we are in the clock of the universe, we might just start to love each other, respect each other, stop the self destructive wars and appreciate just how time really is fleeting.

If we do all that, we might just finally live as a decent society and not the absolute hateful and selfish society that is becoming worse every decade.

ToDoLists · 28/07/2023 10:26

Well, at least I know if me and DH do break up there is no shortage of women to replace me...I'll let him know about the swathes of "open minded tolerant" mumsnetters rallying against the "liberal elites" and veganism. He'll be out the door quicker than a wildfire.

OP posts:
BestBeforeddmmyy · 28/07/2023 10:26

All climate change deniers …. What would be the benefit for scientists to pretend there was climate change? How ridiculous. I really despair.

Asiatoyork · 28/07/2023 10:13

The whole place is every bit the total disaster predicted, not some sort of evidence that scientists overplay things just because they enjoy the drama

Hey - who told you that actual knowledge was allowed in this conversation?!

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/07/2023 10:00

No because a lot of people who hold that opinion have outlandish opinions about other things too.

shadylane · 28/07/2023 09:59

Climate change isn’t a matter of opinion, much as racism isn’t.
Assuming you live in a western country, and are privileged, it’s true you may not directly suffer the consequences as others in developing nations will, however that is a theory that itself is dwindling- you only need to Google rise in UK floods to see this.

woke brigade? What a charmer.

horseyhorsey17 · 28/07/2023 09:59

sweetdreams33 · 28/07/2023 09:39

Everybody seems to be hyperventilating over this issue. If you look through history, the world has had many instances of our climates instability. I really do think there is an agenda at play here, and that is to monetise and abuse this issue for personal gain.This hysteria is ridiculous. The terrestrial news programmes are extremely guilty of this. You look at the weather maps and it looks like the world is on fire. No wonder people freak out. We really need to stop and look to the real experts and get a grip

The world is on fire. Wildfires are normal but not this level. I’m in Turkey and even the locals are saying it’s too hot. It takes an extraordinary level of sticking your head in the sand to look at all the data - including record temperatures in the UK last year - and conclude that scientists are making things up and everything is fine really.

Also as a sensible person I believe scientists rather than random posters on Mumsnet.

angela99999 · 28/07/2023 09:55

sweetdreams33 · 28/07/2023 09:39

Everybody seems to be hyperventilating over this issue. If you look through history, the world has had many instances of our climates instability. I really do think there is an agenda at play here, and that is to monetise and abuse this issue for personal gain.This hysteria is ridiculous. The terrestrial news programmes are extremely guilty of this. You look at the weather maps and it looks like the world is on fire. No wonder people freak out. We really need to stop and look to the real experts and get a grip

Of course, there's instability and there's permanent change. And "real experts" agree that the climate is getting hotter, apparently because of the atmospheric changes due to humans. Even if it is reversible, think of how long the earth was frozen in the ice age before it reversed - the human race isn't likely to survive.