Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you be with a partner who doesn't believe in climate change?

616 replies

ToDoLists · 26/07/2023 16:17

DH doesn't really think it's all that bad. He thinks we should be recyling more and caring for the planet as makes sense and is just the right thing to do - but that climate change as a disaster is an exaggeration and not based in science. And that people are utilising it for their own agenda, woke brigade & so on.

We have young kids.

AIBU to find this position increasingly problematic?

People are going to say people are allowed different opinions but he seems geniunely unconcerned about future of planet for our kids - and I find that hard to swallow.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
sweetdreams33 · 30/07/2023 11:08

Yes gullible.

Isitjustmeoriseverythingshit7970 · 30/07/2023 10:21

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 09:34

You do know this involves huge amounts of money, including taxpayer money?

And that regulation is a barrier to entry, allowing big business to grow and keep other business out?

This is pointless.. check out what corporate courts can do for big business away from public justice

ToxicBiennial · 30/07/2023 09:57

This story is based on a paper which just decided to change the standard for temperature measurements; from an air temperature measurement made liquid in glass thermometer 2m above the ground to satellite measurements

The satellite measurements have shown polar ice loss of over 6 trillion tonnes adding 17mm to the global sea since the 1990s. Also they are measuring increases in CO2 and methane very accurately and they are rising all the time.

Isitsixoclockalready · 30/07/2023 09:55

CurlewKate · 30/07/2023 06:58

@EmilyBrontesGhost "SingingNettles
Didn’t the UK just have it’s hottest June on record??

Nope."

Yep. Hottest June on record. Met Office said so.

This is the biggest problem with climate change scepticism - people take an isolated incident and use it to reinforce their (flawed) belief. Scientists have always been reluctant to attribute an isolated event to climate change because they look at it in a holistic way. We are now at the stage where it is clearly obvious that ALL the data (not just "it snowed today" or "that was a bad storm") points to human driven climate change. I totally understand why people believe in conspiracy theories - climate change is scary and it's more comforting to believe in a shadowy conspiracy to control us but I'm afraid that climate change is true - yes , the climate has changed over the millennia but this is unprecedented.

I don't understand how people don't get the basic science that we've been pumping unprecedented amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere since the industrial revolution and that it wouldn't have an affect.

Ultimately people can bury their heads in the sand but it's happening.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 09:48

AIBot · 30/07/2023 09:44

And your point is?

My point is, I have an excellent memory.

AIBot · 30/07/2023 09:44

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 09:38

"Historically, as well as 1976, the summers of 1959, 1949, 1930, 1915 and 1911 were some of those that had Britain truly sweltering over the last century and more. In the final few days of August 1930, extreme high temperatures hit the towns and cities of Britain, including Newcastle. The Chronicle reported a rocketing demand for ice cream as Tyneside sweltered in Mediterranean conditions."

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/history/remembering-long-scorching-summer-1976-24526001

And your point is?

AIBot · 30/07/2023 09:43

Huromjuicemaker · 30/07/2023 09:38

This story is based on a paper which just decided to change the standard for temperature measurements; from an air temperature measurement made liquid in glass thermometer 2m above the ground to satellite measurements of ground temperature, this introduces a massive bias to the measurements, guess which narrative it favours. It’s disingenuous work like this that makes me doubt a lot of things we’re told to believe, but the barrage of data is so great that it is impossible to review everything

Please link to the study you are talking because the article @ToDoLists shared does not mention one.

ToxicBiennial · 30/07/2023 09:39

Would depend on his other views. If it was just climate change that was the main big thing we disagreed on I’d probably be ok with that as other pp have said it’s very unlikely as the dominant species on the planet we’re going to be able to do anything meaningful about it now. Too selfish. Too far.

But if it was indicative of other unsavoury values and attitudes then no.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 09:38

"Historically, as well as 1976, the summers of 1959, 1949, 1930, 1915 and 1911 were some of those that had Britain truly sweltering over the last century and more. In the final few days of August 1930, extreme high temperatures hit the towns and cities of Britain, including Newcastle. The Chronicle reported a rocketing demand for ice cream as Tyneside sweltered in Mediterranean conditions."

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/history/remembering-long-scorching-summer-1976-24526001

Remembering the long, scorching summer of 1976 - and other North East heatwaves

Nearly five decades on, those blazing eight weeks of unbroken sunshine in the summer of 1976 reside in the collective memories of everyone who lived through the time

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/history/remembering-long-scorching-summer-1976-24526001

Huromjuicemaker · 30/07/2023 09:38

ToDoLists · 30/07/2023 07:17

So I guess the problem is I tend to believe news like this published just 2 days ago https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-66322608 (can share numerous other sources and places if people have instant dislike for BBC), over mumsnetters or my DH saying they remember a hotter summer in the 70s or that they think July has been rather wet where they are this year.

"Don't listen to the science or data, listen to my memory of the weather" seems like a barmy position to have.

This story is based on a paper which just decided to change the standard for temperature measurements; from an air temperature measurement made liquid in glass thermometer 2m above the ground to satellite measurements of ground temperature, this introduces a massive bias to the measurements, guess which narrative it favours. It’s disingenuous work like this that makes me doubt a lot of things we’re told to believe, but the barrage of data is so great that it is impossible to review everything

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 09:34

Isitjustmeoriseverythingshit7970 · 30/07/2023 09:04

Gullible?? Do you think there is a conspiracy involving the entire science community, the UN, naturists, David Attenborough and vast amounts of data including footage are made up then? You are entirely bonkers but when climate catastrophe comes knocking at your door or the doors of your children you will realise you were wrong and it will be too late.

You do know this involves huge amounts of money, including taxpayer money?

And that regulation is a barrier to entry, allowing big business to grow and keep other business out?

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 09:32

Isitjustmeoriseverythingshit7970 · 30/07/2023 09:04

Gullible?? Do you think there is a conspiracy involving the entire science community, the UN, naturists, David Attenborough and vast amounts of data including footage are made up then? You are entirely bonkers but when climate catastrophe comes knocking at your door or the doors of your children you will realise you were wrong and it will be too late.

David Bellamy was honest. He lost everything. David Attenborough went along to get along.

Huromjuicemaker · 30/07/2023 09:29

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 26/07/2023 16:20

No, generally people of that opinion tend to have some other pretty tedious traits and problematic opinions too.

Judging, prone to superficial knee jerk reactions and facile comments?

That sort of thing?

neverbeenskiing · 30/07/2023 09:27

EmilyBrontesGhost · 29/07/2023 23:40

Except the OP hasn't said her husband thinks the earth is flat or that vaccines cause autism.

So why would you make that up?

I'm not making anything up, OP's DH is in denial about climate change and I was giving examples of similarly batshit opinions. IME people who refuse to accept that climate change is real often subscribe to other internet-fuelled conspiracy theories like the ones mentioned. But according to some on this thread it doesn't matter what utter nonsense your DH believes anyway, even if he's an apologist for vile misogynists like Andrew Tate you should just count yourself lucky he's not a cheater or an abuser apparently.

Isitjustmeoriseverythingshit7970 · 30/07/2023 09:25

ToDoLists · 30/07/2023 09:13

See its weird being called intolerant this whole thread when I haven't insulted anyone and yet people feel free to insult me eh @EmilyBrontesGhost

God how intolerant and narrow minded I am but yet if I say what I believe I'm called gullible. I think someone posted about 10 times called me middle class/snobby etc which is funny if you knew me at all.

It's OK though I don't take insults very seriously from people who share stories about being hot a summer 40 years ago as evidence of anything. @EmilyBrontesGhost

I'm with you all the way and I hope you can see there are many of us who also see where you are coming from. Climate catastrophe is the single biggest issue affecting humanity but half of us don't want to look up, hence the movie!

ToDoLists · 30/07/2023 09:13

See its weird being called intolerant this whole thread when I haven't insulted anyone and yet people feel free to insult me eh @EmilyBrontesGhost

God how intolerant and narrow minded I am but yet if I say what I believe I'm called gullible. I think someone posted about 10 times called me middle class/snobby etc which is funny if you knew me at all.

It's OK though I don't take insults very seriously from people who share stories about being hot a summer 40 years ago as evidence of anything. @EmilyBrontesGhost

OP posts:
AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 30/07/2023 09:11

ToDoLists · 30/07/2023 07:17

So I guess the problem is I tend to believe news like this published just 2 days ago https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-66322608 (can share numerous other sources and places if people have instant dislike for BBC), over mumsnetters or my DH saying they remember a hotter summer in the 70s or that they think July has been rather wet where they are this year.

"Don't listen to the science or data, listen to my memory of the weather" seems like a barmy position to have.

Does he actually deny climate change or he just doesn't believe we're all doomed?

Are there changes you want to make to your home/lifestyle to help with this and he's not agreeing?

Isitjustmeoriseverythingshit7970 · 30/07/2023 09:04

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 08:51

Goodness, you're gullible.

Gullible?? Do you think there is a conspiracy involving the entire science community, the UN, naturists, David Attenborough and vast amounts of data including footage are made up then? You are entirely bonkers but when climate catastrophe comes knocking at your door or the doors of your children you will realise you were wrong and it will be too late.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 08:51

ToDoLists · 30/07/2023 07:17

So I guess the problem is I tend to believe news like this published just 2 days ago https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-66322608 (can share numerous other sources and places if people have instant dislike for BBC), over mumsnetters or my DH saying they remember a hotter summer in the 70s or that they think July has been rather wet where they are this year.

"Don't listen to the science or data, listen to my memory of the weather" seems like a barmy position to have.

Goodness, you're gullible.

ToDoLists · 30/07/2023 07:17

So I guess the problem is I tend to believe news like this published just 2 days ago https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-66322608 (can share numerous other sources and places if people have instant dislike for BBC), over mumsnetters or my DH saying they remember a hotter summer in the 70s or that they think July has been rather wet where they are this year.

"Don't listen to the science or data, listen to my memory of the weather" seems like a barmy position to have.

A woman uses a fan to cool down as the faithful wait for Pope Francis' Angelus prayer, amid rising temperatures, at Saint Peter's Square, Vatican City, 23 July 2023.

Climate change: July set to be world's warmest month on record

UN chief says we are in an "era of global boiling" as July set to be world's warmest month on record.

https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-66322608

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 30/07/2023 06:58

@EmilyBrontesGhost "SingingNettles
Didn’t the UK just have it’s hottest June on record??

Nope."

Yep. Hottest June on record. Met Office said so.

Ukrainebaby23 · 30/07/2023 05:36

sidebirds · 28/07/2023 17:59

Q: When does the 'climate emergency' end? A: The moment you turn off your television and stop reading the papers.

That doesn't mean there isn't appalling pollution caused by greed & carelessness. Installing, for example, tens of thousands of wind turbines that kill birds en masse, and disorientate whales leading them to ground themselves on beaches, is hardly 'environmentally conscious', never mind the fact that these machines can only be disposed of as landfill. I could go on.

It's a scam and a lie. The earth's climate has always been in a state of flux. The entire planet was once a tropical paradise. At other times, covered in ice. The ice-caps at the North & South Poles are the residue of the last Ice Age. If they melt, the sea will undoubtedly rise, but human misbehaviour will have very little or nothing to do with it.

This is my extremely clever, DHs pov. He does believe I'm climate change, but not that is caused by him being confused where to put his waste cardboard. He doesn't subscribe to conspiracy theories but he does have contempt for authorities who impose rules he doesn't see as fair or reasonable. Other than YouTube for diy tips, he doesn't do sm.

I disagree with some of his views but I respect him enough to value his opinions.

SingingNettles · 30/07/2023 01:43

Something else to consider. Let’s say that there wasn’t a 99-100% consensus among climate scientists and, instead, pretend that 50% believed in anthropogenic global warming (and predicted potentially dire consequences as a result thereof, in the near future) and the other 50% thought we could carry on as we are and everything will be fine.

Bearing in mind the stakes, surely erring on the side of caution would be warranted?

SingingNettles · 30/07/2023 01:37

Hawkins0001 · 30/07/2023 01:14

There in lies the error over confidence in the sources yes that's not to say it's not correct, chances are it is, but too much faith and belief could also be a fallacy.
That said with the climate change, we need machines to counter it.

When the evidence is so strong that there no longer exists any meaningful debate, the sensible thing to do is assume that the evidence is correct.

For example, if you’re pondering jumping off a building in the hope you might fly rather than fall, it’s probably best to consider the available evidence and make your decision based on it. Who knows, the science may be wrong, and there are few if any certainties in science but the overwhelming evidence is that you’re going to hit the ground.

Yes technology is needed to combat climate change (and huge strides have already been made) but we’re not there yet, and the world is continuing to get hotter.

There are a few ideas as to technologies that could be deployed if we fail to curb climate change but they’re currently perceived to be risky (for example, geonengineering might work and warrants further research, but we currently don’t understand it well enough to be sure that it won’t make things worse).

Hawkins0001 · 30/07/2023 01:14

SingingNettles · 30/07/2023 01:10

It is true that there are no certainties in science. There are theories and the evidence that supports them - however, when the evidence is overwhelming, so is the probability that the theory is correct.

And the evidence for climate change is so overwhelming that there is no longer a debate among climate scientists.

Some people just have difficulty accepting science that they don’t like. They’re usually woefully inconsistent about it though. For example, we’ve had several posters suggest that the Medieval Warm Period is evidence against climate change. They will very happily accept the science that has been able to ascertain the likely global temperatures during the Medieval Warm Period, but the second the science become incompatible with their personal beliefs, they throw it out the window.

There in lies the error over confidence in the sources yes that's not to say it's not correct, chances are it is, but too much faith and belief could also be a fallacy.
That said with the climate change, we need machines to counter it.