Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you be with a partner who doesn't believe in climate change?

616 replies

ToDoLists · 26/07/2023 16:17

DH doesn't really think it's all that bad. He thinks we should be recyling more and caring for the planet as makes sense and is just the right thing to do - but that climate change as a disaster is an exaggeration and not based in science. And that people are utilising it for their own agenda, woke brigade & so on.

We have young kids.

AIBU to find this position increasingly problematic?

People are going to say people are allowed different opinions but he seems geniunely unconcerned about future of planet for our kids - and I find that hard to swallow.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Chatillon · 31/07/2023 08:44

Herejusttocomment · 31/07/2023 08:13

The last three winters are the coldest I've known in my (long) lifetime.

I just spilled my coffee 😂😂😂
I've been in the UK for about 15 years, even my first winter here was colder than the last 3!

Yes! I didn't bother going back and challenging once they said East Midlands and "long" life.

And also "mother nature knows best" in the same post as:

"The mature trees are now putting themselves into dormancy in spring to protect themselves and start coming into leaf around a month later than usual"

What complete rubbish.

Middlelanehogger · 31/07/2023 08:42

If anyone is reading this and genuinely is concerned about how to talk to their "denier/denialist" loved ones about climate change...

...please take some time to consider your strategy. Shouting about how 97% of experts agree that it's humans' fault is not going to be effective. Shouting about how they're a "denialist" is not going to be effective. Shouting about ever-more hysterical end-of-days scenarios is not going to be effective.

Please try to understand the actual point of disagreement first (how many people got called "COVID denialists" as if they didn't believe COVID existed, when they simply disputed our policy on, say, when to reopen schools?)

Please try to understand what they are concerned about as well (if they are very concerned about imminent war with Russia, they probably aren't keen on solutions that involve us weakening our energy security position). Listen to them and why they are worried we're not accounting for that issue

Please try to talk in terms of "going forward, what's the plan?" rather than "whose fault is it?". How do you think international/UK/local/your own household actions should be different? It's much more productive than sitting around blaming each other and much less likely to go in circles.

Herejusttocomment · 31/07/2023 08:13

The last three winters are the coldest I've known in my (long) lifetime.

I just spilled my coffee 😂😂😂
I've been in the UK for about 15 years, even my first winter here was colder than the last 3!

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 15:33

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 15:20

The tories have made everyone poorer by failing to govern in the best interest of the country. I'm also not sure they've increased government or regulation tbh.

But as I said that's another issue. Climate change and climate action are global issues that require global coordination and cooperation. Regulation is part of that, especially as businesses who are responsible for most emissions, have repeatedly shown they are unable or unwilling to regulated themselves.

The impact this will have on the average person's life in the UK may or may not be noticeable but, and again I'm moving away from the topic of the thread, the average person in the UK (and the developed world in general) leads an unsustainable life and will need to change one way or another. Even if we didn't have a climate crisis to contend with rising living standards in the developing world means our days of overconsumption were limited.

We can manage that change and make it a fairer and more equitable transition, we can manage it and make things even more unequal, or we can ignore it and hope we're dead before the shit really hits the fan.

I know what I'd prefer.

Appreciate the depth of your response, thank you.

On global co-operation. Yes, I see that from where you are coming from that might seem like the least bad option.

The trouble is the potential for abuse. Historically refugees have somewhere to go. Supposing Idi Amin or Pol Pot had had global reach, what then? Where do you go? Country leaderships always keep an eye on people leaving, if only to preserve the tax and labour base. Without that’s discipline they can do what they like. Global co-operation removes that discipline. Absolute power etc.

Nanny0gg · 30/07/2023 15:29

ToDoLists · 26/07/2023 16:51

Given this is your 5th comment in 20 minutes - I would say you'd know something about discussing things constantly.

What are you doing about CC and what do you want him to do about it?

Although until China and India get onboard we're pissing in the wind anyway

ILoveMontyDon · 30/07/2023 15:28

I don't know who is right or wrong, but it could do with warming up in the UK at the moment.

I don't see world leaders/climate evangelists changing their behaviours - so frankly, I think it's all bollocks.

Look at covid as an example. Not reporting on the excess deaths are they? Something they knew was no deadly that the flu from the beginning - and wrote notes on how they were going to scare us into compliance.

Corrupt government and media. This is the same thing - and is why they changed it from 'Global warming' (because we are freezing in summer) to 'climate change'.

If you believe this stuff you are a fool.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 15:20

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 14:44

The Tories have certainly made everyone poorer by increasing Govt and regulation.
Possibly labour would have been more restrained had they been in power.

But you are arguing for more of it anyway. Life isn’t easy in big Govt countries you know.

The tories have made everyone poorer by failing to govern in the best interest of the country. I'm also not sure they've increased government or regulation tbh.

But as I said that's another issue. Climate change and climate action are global issues that require global coordination and cooperation. Regulation is part of that, especially as businesses who are responsible for most emissions, have repeatedly shown they are unable or unwilling to regulated themselves.

The impact this will have on the average person's life in the UK may or may not be noticeable but, and again I'm moving away from the topic of the thread, the average person in the UK (and the developed world in general) leads an unsustainable life and will need to change one way or another. Even if we didn't have a climate crisis to contend with rising living standards in the developing world means our days of overconsumption were limited.

We can manage that change and make it a fairer and more equitable transition, we can manage it and make things even more unequal, or we can ignore it and hope we're dead before the shit really hits the fan.

I know what I'd prefer.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 15:10

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 14:47

Err so your plan is to prevent those people from existing? That’s extreme.

But hadn’t you realised that the people at the top view you in the same way?

Thats quite a conclusion to jump to, where exactly have I said anything about preventing people from existing exactly?

Huromjuicemaker · 30/07/2023 15:04

AIBot · 30/07/2023 09:43

Please link to the study you are talking because the article @ToDoLists shared does not mention one.

https://www.esa.int/Applications/Observing_the_Earth/Copernicus/Sentinel-3/Europe_braces_for_sweltering_July

Since I read it a disclaimer has been added, so make of that what you will. The “hot take” pre update has already been splashed out and we’re onto wildfires and record temperatures in Sardinia but I wonder what one would find if they had the time to scratch the surface of those stories?

Europe braces for sweltering July

Temperatures are sizzling across Europe this week amid an intense and prolonged period of heat. And it’s only just begun. Italy, Spain, France, Germany and Poland are all facing a major heatwave with air temperatures expected to climb to 48°C on the is...

https://www.esa.int/Applications/Observing_the_Earth/Copernicus/Sentinel-3/Europe_braces_for_sweltering_July

Huromjuicemaker · 30/07/2023 14:59

ToxicBiennial · 30/07/2023 09:57

This story is based on a paper which just decided to change the standard for temperature measurements; from an air temperature measurement made liquid in glass thermometer 2m above the ground to satellite measurements

The satellite measurements have shown polar ice loss of over 6 trillion tonnes adding 17mm to the global sea since the 1990s. Also they are measuring increases in CO2 and methane very accurately and they are rising all the time.

If you want to compare measurements you must be sure that you are measuring the same thing. Otherwise it’s a waste of time (at best).

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 14:47

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 14:36

We don't need to assume a or b. It is the scientific consensus and is as close to fact as you're likely to get.

But regardless, you do realise all the things you're concerned about will be result from the lack of action to address climate change and not becuase of action to tackle it, right?

The availability of resources including land, food, and water will be reduced significantly if we do not change our ways.

How do you think you and your children will cope when as many as 3bn people are displaced by climate related events and extreme weather and are looking for a new place to live?

How will they cope when 1 in 4 people will be living in areas of extremely high water stress, as is predicted to be the case by 2040? And this won't just be some far off places, England specifically is looking down the barrel of a gun with that one, with 12/17 regions expected to face extreme water stress by 2040.

What will they do when global food systems start to collapse? Almost 40% of all calories consumed by humans come from 3 crops (wheat, corn, and rice) and for 2 of them (corn and rice) yields are either predicted to reduce or already are (24% for corn by 2050 and 10% for every 1°C increase in temperature for rice).

If you actually cared about your kids future you would be demanding action now not arguing for the status quo because you think change is hard.

I also think it's a bit disingenuous to say talk about making our kids lives harder when the country has kept the tories in power for the last 13 years, but that's another matter.

Err so your plan is to prevent those people from existing? That’s extreme.

But hadn’t you realised that the people at the top view you in the same way?

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 14:44

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 14:36

We don't need to assume a or b. It is the scientific consensus and is as close to fact as you're likely to get.

But regardless, you do realise all the things you're concerned about will be result from the lack of action to address climate change and not becuase of action to tackle it, right?

The availability of resources including land, food, and water will be reduced significantly if we do not change our ways.

How do you think you and your children will cope when as many as 3bn people are displaced by climate related events and extreme weather and are looking for a new place to live?

How will they cope when 1 in 4 people will be living in areas of extremely high water stress, as is predicted to be the case by 2040? And this won't just be some far off places, England specifically is looking down the barrel of a gun with that one, with 12/17 regions expected to face extreme water stress by 2040.

What will they do when global food systems start to collapse? Almost 40% of all calories consumed by humans come from 3 crops (wheat, corn, and rice) and for 2 of them (corn and rice) yields are either predicted to reduce or already are (24% for corn by 2050 and 10% for every 1°C increase in temperature for rice).

If you actually cared about your kids future you would be demanding action now not arguing for the status quo because you think change is hard.

I also think it's a bit disingenuous to say talk about making our kids lives harder when the country has kept the tories in power for the last 13 years, but that's another matter.

The Tories have certainly made everyone poorer by increasing Govt and regulation.
Possibly labour would have been more restrained had they been in power.

But you are arguing for more of it anyway. Life isn’t easy in big Govt countries you know.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 14:36

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 13:41

Ok. Let’s assume that warming is
a) caused by humans, and
b) bad.

So policies are made to restrict our lifestyles and reduce our numbers.

I’m amazed that the majority of people want this.

This is Mums Net. You have kids. You want policies that make your kids lives harder. To make it less likely that they can have children of their own. To make it more likely that resource constrained societies will go to war. Why is this ok for you? Your kids will have to live through it, if they can.

We don't need to assume a or b. It is the scientific consensus and is as close to fact as you're likely to get.

But regardless, you do realise all the things you're concerned about will be result from the lack of action to address climate change and not becuase of action to tackle it, right?

The availability of resources including land, food, and water will be reduced significantly if we do not change our ways.

How do you think you and your children will cope when as many as 3bn people are displaced by climate related events and extreme weather and are looking for a new place to live?

How will they cope when 1 in 4 people will be living in areas of extremely high water stress, as is predicted to be the case by 2040? And this won't just be some far off places, England specifically is looking down the barrel of a gun with that one, with 12/17 regions expected to face extreme water stress by 2040.

What will they do when global food systems start to collapse? Almost 40% of all calories consumed by humans come from 3 crops (wheat, corn, and rice) and for 2 of them (corn and rice) yields are either predicted to reduce or already are (24% for corn by 2050 and 10% for every 1°C increase in temperature for rice).

If you actually cared about your kids future you would be demanding action now not arguing for the status quo because you think change is hard.

I also think it's a bit disingenuous to say talk about making our kids lives harder when the country has kept the tories in power for the last 13 years, but that's another matter.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 14:24

Chatillon · 30/07/2023 13:34

Not in the UK then?

Yes in the UK.

East Midlands.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 14:20

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 13:30

Of course the climate is changing, I've never said otherwise.

The climate has always changed.

Currently the planet is cooling down as we are entering a Grand Solar Minimum.

I don't get how you can understand that reduced solar activity can impact climate but not understand that increasing the ability of the Earth's atmosphere to trap solar radiation will do the same.

Also, geologically speaking, the Earth is warming not cooling as it entered an interglacial period around 12,000 years ago which would normally be expected to last several thousand - several hundred of thousands of years.

I say normally because it's not clear how human activity will impact this cycle.....just like it is impacting climate!

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 13:41

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 13:16

So you admit the climate is changing? That's a step in the right direction at least.

Out of interest why do you think your "excellent memory" and personal experience trumps actual scientific research and do you apply that type of thinking elsewhere in your life?

Ok. Let’s assume that warming is
a) caused by humans, and
b) bad.

So policies are made to restrict our lifestyles and reduce our numbers.

I’m amazed that the majority of people want this.

This is Mums Net. You have kids. You want policies that make your kids lives harder. To make it less likely that they can have children of their own. To make it more likely that resource constrained societies will go to war. Why is this ok for you? Your kids will have to live through it, if they can.

Olderandolder · 30/07/2023 13:35

Isitsixoclockalready · 30/07/2023 09:55

This is the biggest problem with climate change scepticism - people take an isolated incident and use it to reinforce their (flawed) belief. Scientists have always been reluctant to attribute an isolated event to climate change because they look at it in a holistic way. We are now at the stage where it is clearly obvious that ALL the data (not just "it snowed today" or "that was a bad storm") points to human driven climate change. I totally understand why people believe in conspiracy theories - climate change is scary and it's more comforting to believe in a shadowy conspiracy to control us but I'm afraid that climate change is true - yes , the climate has changed over the millennia but this is unprecedented.

I don't understand how people don't get the basic science that we've been pumping unprecedented amounts of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere since the industrial revolution and that it wouldn't have an affect.

Ultimately people can bury their heads in the sand but it's happening.

Historically, humans flourished in warm times and struggled to get through cold times.

Chatillon · 30/07/2023 13:34

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 13:08

The last three winters are the coldest I've known in my (long) lifetime.

The mature trees are now putting themselves into dormancy in spring to protect themselves and start coming into leaf around a month later than usual.

(smaller trees and shrubs are unaffected, it's the really mature trees doing this)

Nature always knows.

Not in the UK then?

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 13:30

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 13:16

So you admit the climate is changing? That's a step in the right direction at least.

Out of interest why do you think your "excellent memory" and personal experience trumps actual scientific research and do you apply that type of thinking elsewhere in your life?

Of course the climate is changing, I've never said otherwise.

The climate has always changed.

Currently the planet is cooling down as we are entering a Grand Solar Minimum.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 13:16

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 13:08

The last three winters are the coldest I've known in my (long) lifetime.

The mature trees are now putting themselves into dormancy in spring to protect themselves and start coming into leaf around a month later than usual.

(smaller trees and shrubs are unaffected, it's the really mature trees doing this)

Nature always knows.

So you admit the climate is changing? That's a step in the right direction at least.

Out of interest why do you think your "excellent memory" and personal experience trumps actual scientific research and do you apply that type of thinking elsewhere in your life?

AIBot · 30/07/2023 13:13

@ToDoLists , your DH’s response is most likely to be due to a deep fear of change. It’s normal to worry about how climate change will change our family life, lifestyle and livelihoods, but ignoring it in the face of overwhelming scientific consensus plays to the industries who are most responsible and is letting his family down.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 13:08

Chatillon · 30/07/2023 12:50

Do you remember the long cold winters we used to have in the 1960's and 1970's when snow would happen at Christmas and every January you could walk across canals?

Now we have flowers growing all year round in our garden.

The last three winters are the coldest I've known in my (long) lifetime.

The mature trees are now putting themselves into dormancy in spring to protect themselves and start coming into leaf around a month later than usual.

(smaller trees and shrubs are unaffected, it's the really mature trees doing this)

Nature always knows.

Chatillon · 30/07/2023 12:50

EmilyBrontesGhost · 30/07/2023 09:48

My point is, I have an excellent memory.

Do you remember the long cold winters we used to have in the 1960's and 1970's when snow would happen at Christmas and every January you could walk across canals?

Now we have flowers growing all year round in our garden.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 30/07/2023 12:38

It's mind boggling just how deep in denial so many people are.

Powell 2013 examined 2258 peer-reviews papers from 9136 authors and found 1, yes 1, that didn't agree that human activity was contributing to climate change. doi.org/10.1177/0270467616634958

Powell 2019, look at 11,602 different articles and found 0, yes 0, dissenting views that humans were contributing to climate change. doi.org/10.1177/0270467619886266

But because @sidebirds has heard someone talk about the natural climate cycle and jumped to a random conclusion or @Ukrainebaby23's DH is very clever actually scientific concensus doesn't matter.

Nobody bats an eyelid when pretty much 100% of biologists say that the human body is made up of billions and billions of cells, 100% of physicist believe in special relativity, or 100% of chemists say that molecules are made up of elementary atoms but, when almost 100% of climate scientists tell you they believe in anthropogenic climate change it's a conspiracy.

Those views say a lot more about the person that holds them and their internal bias than it does about the science of climate change.

Swipe left for the next trending thread