Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you be with a partner who doesn't believe in climate change?

616 replies

ToDoLists · 26/07/2023 16:17

DH doesn't really think it's all that bad. He thinks we should be recyling more and caring for the planet as makes sense and is just the right thing to do - but that climate change as a disaster is an exaggeration and not based in science. And that people are utilising it for their own agenda, woke brigade & so on.

We have young kids.

AIBU to find this position increasingly problematic?

People are going to say people are allowed different opinions but he seems geniunely unconcerned about future of planet for our kids - and I find that hard to swallow.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
Ponoka7 · 27/07/2023 13:20

HadalyEve · 26/07/2023 17:21

Insulate Britain were wrong too.

Before Insulate Britain started protesting the government had green grants for homeowners to insulate their homes for free or at an over 50% discount.

After Insulate Britain’s protests the government ended all these grants.

Their protests not only did not help, they caused a backlash that has set things back.

JSO protests are having the same impact. Why do you think our PM is U-turning on U.K. environmental commitments? It’s because of the JSO lunacy.

The grant was always going to end in March 2021, that was declared when it started. You think that the PM could be justified on changing plans that will affect the whole plant because a tiny portion of the population of one country is behaving badly? That just wouldn't be accepted in parliament.

27Mankinis · 27/07/2023 13:06

DontEatCrisps · 27/07/2023 08:25

It was primarily inspired by EmilyBrontesGhost, who has taken a break from posting anti-vax stuff on one of the covid threads to come here and explain to everyone how science funding works (not sure whether she's actually claimed to be married to a scientist, to be fair).

It's just such a weak and spurious appeal to authority and one which often crops up on threads on subjects I'm an expert in- "well, my husband is an X and he says..." followed by some garbled, half-understood thing. And it's so easy to lie about- after all, no one can question the poster because it's not her who knows anything.

It's very striking on this thread how many people are claiming to be married to scientists who are all apparently climate sceptics, and yet there's no one claiming to be a scientist who's a climate sceptic herself. It's odd. Perhaps it's partly that people are happier to claim authority on behalf of a non-expert spouse than that spouse would be to claim authority for himself (there's someone up the thread presenting her geologist husband as an expert, ffs- hard to imagine a geologist joining a debate on climate change by announcing "well, I'm a geologist..." as if that carried any weight). Partly it's people making stuff up.

yeah the one married to a geologist is me.

Thing about geologists. They have a understanding of how the planet works over time. Quite a long time. We are currently in an inter-stadial period. These are relatively warm periods between glacial periods. Inter-stadials can last around 10,000 years. Give or take.

Anyway. I certainly can imagine a geologist entering into a debate on climate change. They kind of have the long view. Based on how the earth has changed over millions of years.

Either that or they are just jumped up gravel monkeys. (To quote Big Bang Theory)

HadalyEve · 27/07/2023 12:35

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 10:26

Technically an average of 6% reduction in emissions has been measured in ukez zones

Well yeah, that’s due to less traffic overall not due to traffic that emits less CO2. So, you’re 100% right in that sense, I did not think of the traffic calming side effect. I take back what I said.

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 10:26

Technically an average of 6% reduction in emissions has been measured in ukez zones

HadalyEve · 27/07/2023 10:19

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 10:14

The ulez is actually about air pollution which kills children today

It's side effect is lower carbon emissions

Technically, ULEZ doesn’t lower CO2 emissions because the vehicles banned have to meet higher CO2 emissions standards to even pass their MOT tests, ULEZ lowers N2O which is also causing climate change and particulate emissions which cause deaths from air pollution.

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 10:16

Plastic bags in shops - it's not really a tax it's a voluntary purchase

they just are not allowed to give harmful things out for free

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 10:14

The ulez is actually about air pollution which kills children today

It's side effect is lower carbon emissions

HadalyEve · 27/07/2023 10:14

Having two children per couple isn’t killing the planet 🫤

I think people seem to forget that we humans are mammals and are therefore part of the planets current eco-system and food chain. Many species have symbiotic relationships with us such that we depend on each other for survival. It’s not good for the planet for humans to go extinct.

Humans are not toxic waste, or pollutants- we are Earthlings as much as any mouse or bird or Daisy. We belong and our lives are just as valuable.

Reproducing at replacement level (zero growth) is manageable for the planet because when balanced against those who do not want any children at all, we then are reducing our population globally (negative growth) to more sustainable levels. In a century or so, it will be better for us and the planet for those who want children to have on average 3 children so we can be at zero growth overall.

Popworld · 27/07/2023 10:09

The ulez is a b.s tax in the name of climate change

Charging for bags in shops is a licence to print money tax with some shops charging 60p per bag

Like I said "climate change" is a great excuse to tax the plebs

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 10:00

Yip

It's a great Pity they aren't increasing taxes on the basis of climate change
Pity they are not using taxes to combat it

( and yes tax rises need to be targeted not at the poorest )

Popworld · 27/07/2023 09:55

"Climate change " is a great reason to increase taxes

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 09:49

"You had concerns about climate you had children"

What are you implying here ?

That it's impossible to bring up children to have a low impact lifestyle ?

That you should be so depressed about climate progress that you won't bring children up to die young?

Both rather defeatist viewpoints

JudgeAnderson · 27/07/2023 09:40

You're so concerned about the climate you had children 😂

It's not like his opinions actually do any practical harm. He's not out burning down the rainforest. But if he's given you the ick and you're not into it any more than it is what it is. You don't need our permission to end your marriage.

continentallentil · 27/07/2023 09:14

I think that anyone who thinks that has to be a bit thick, as the weight of evidence doesn’t support the view.

I wouldn’t want to be with anyone thick, so yes it would be a problem.

midgetastic · 27/07/2023 09:13

Nothing as a single individual matters
But something from many individuals does

Like the climate itself there will be a tipping point at which it becomes unacceptable to have a high footprint , at which you can't make your business work if it's not clean

So many thing worked like that - smoking for example

Emissions are not be down because not enough individuals are taking enough action, too many people paint us as cranks wanting to return to the stone age

SunsetOverParadise · 27/07/2023 09:12

I’m with your DH, so nope. Wouldn’t be an issue for me.

CurlewKate · 27/07/2023 09:04

@spitefulandbadgrammar "This has made me remember that DP is a neuroscientist, I must ask him his views on the climate crisis."

If he's got a moment, could he have a look at my ankle? I think I might have broken it.....

AIBot · 27/07/2023 09:04

From the Met Office this morning.

If he is not capable of properly evaluating evidence or the quality of the sources of information, it’s concerning. What’s to stop him believing batshit racist or antisemitic conspiracy theories?

I would try to get to the bottom of his thought process, because it could drive a wedge between you.

Record breaking 2022 indicative of future UK climate

2022 was a record-breaking year for weather and is a sign of the UK’s changing climate.

https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/press-office/news/weather-and-climate/2023/record-breaking-2022-indicative-of-future-uk-climate

HadalyEve · 27/07/2023 09:00

“I don't think the narrative surrounding climate change is very helpful. It's pushed on us that it's our fault but that we can improve things by changing our behaviour. This is unhelpful because it's not true, nothing we do as individuals will make a big enough difference. Nothing we could do as an entire country would make a big enough difference. Only extreme radical measures like eliminating several billion people (and the "right" people, those in countries with far worse climate changing emissions than us) would make a difference and that idea isn't acceptable. Once you start talking about genocide, climate change seems like a much smaller deal.”

While it is true that the contribution of each of us is a drop in the ocean, and the contribution of the entire U.K. (all 70 million of us) is less than 1%, this doesn’t mean that only extreme radical measures like genocide or collapsing civilisation back to a romanticised pre-industrial Stone Age are the answer.

The reason why climate change is so difficult is because we need all 7 billion of us to be contributing our drops, and we need every nation doing their bit to beat this. And even though the U.K. being so small can’t make a major difference we can still be a role model and example of how it is done. Which we have been doing for decades now-we have invested in green technologies and infrastructure and much of our foreign aid revolves around sharing that with other countries. The issues right now are that countries more powerful, richer, and more populous than us are not doing their bit. In that sense nothing we do will make a difference UNTIL they start doing their bit too. We are not going to sit and say that Qatar or Russia or Australia or USA or Canada or China you go first…we are out there with a few others who are going first. Because it is the right thing to do for the planet, for all the animals and children depending on us to sort this out.

So far global CO2 emissions have not started to go down even though we have cut ours almost in half, the only progress is that their growth has slowed to a snails pace. I hope every year when the data is published that we have passed the peak and there will be a decline. I hope one year we will get there. The more countries that join our ranks of cutting CO2 emissions and pushing for this at COP & UN meetings and the more likely it will happen. I think it might have if it weren’t for Putins stupid Ukraine war which pumps as much CO2 as we emit in a year every two months.

ToDoLists · 27/07/2023 09:00

@Tribute219 does it count as virtue signalling on an anonymous forum?

OP posts:
midgetastic · 27/07/2023 08:43

Most media outlets may be exaggerating what they are presented with

But being a scientist in the field I can tell you that things are probably much worse than the bbc reports-

  • told to avoid scaring people because it won't help action
  • told to paint a positive picture and never present anything that could damage businesses who make the right noises

As an example - radiative forcing - the problems of water released by airplanes on the upper atmosphere- for decades this wasn't included in the scenarios made public and used to drive policy

An an example - look how many climate scientists are being arrested and jailed for action - they are the most scared

Dotjones · 27/07/2023 08:36

It would depend on their reasons and their agenda. If their point is that the climate has constantly changed, that's fine. If they don't care about climate change, that's fine. If they think that climate change is part of a global Jewish conspiracy to take over the world and that incidentally 9/11 and the moon landings never happened, and JFK wasn't only not shot, he never even existed, that would be a problem because the climate change opinion is part of a pattern of them either being an idiot or a total twat.

I don't think the narrative surrounding climate change is very helpful. It's pushed on us that it's our fault but that we can improve things by changing our behaviour. This is unhelpful because it's not true, nothing we do as individuals will make a big enough difference. Nothing we could do as an entire country would make a big enough difference. Only extreme radical measures like eliminating several billion people (and the "right" people, those in countries with far worse climate changing emissions than us) would make a difference and that idea isn't acceptable. Once you start talking about genocide, climate change seems like a much smaller deal.

That's the thing. People don't want to accept that they can't make a difference. They're arrogant enough to assume that because they want to make a difference, because we need to make a difference, that it must somehow be possible to make that difference. It's not, not without taking obscene measures resulting in the destruction of huge numbers of people and entire countries.

We'd be better off long term to embrace climate change and work on developing things to help us cope with it - shields to deflect the sun's heat back into space, coastal defences to cope with rising sea levels, the idea I have to dig a massive fucking hole in the Sahara and flooding it with seawater to lower sea levels.

If only protesters would take out their anger on the people who could potentially make a difference - the scientists - humanity might actually have some hope. But tell a Just Stop Oil thug to demonstrate outside the homes of prominent scientists instead of irritating the general public and they'll look at you contemptly and go and block another person trying to get to a hospital appointment.

HadalyEve · 27/07/2023 08:28

Superfans · 26/07/2023 22:45

Science is never “settled”. Climate is a complex system and can’t be predicted using current technology. The BBC reporting is far from factual on many issues and there is a very clear bias and agenda around the climate change reporting. We all need to be open minded and willing to listen, rather than demonising those who disagree as stupid or mentally ill.

Yes. For example, I see people thinking books like “Uninhabitable Planet” as scientific fact regarding climate change & the state of the planet, that it is a peer reviewed reference book written by a qualified climatologist when it isn’t.

It was a popular science book published by a journalist who dabbled in climate change for a couple years before deciding to cash in by writing a sensationalist climate doomism book that cherry picks and misstates the actual science while going on on wild speculations that he peddles as ‘scientific consensus’ when it’s not- it’s his own imaginings. Popular science books don’t have to be peer reviewed. They don’t have to be factual. They don’t have to not be misleading. The only requirement is that they be not entirely fictional.

DontEatCrisps · 27/07/2023 08:25

MrTiddlesTheCat · 27/07/2023 07:12

Is that aimed at me? If it is, I've been very open in my 10+ years on MN about my DH being a scientist. Lots of MNetters have had direct contact with him for advice due to his field (nuclear chemistry and industrial recycling). It's not my fault if that makes you feel inadequate.

It was primarily inspired by EmilyBrontesGhost, who has taken a break from posting anti-vax stuff on one of the covid threads to come here and explain to everyone how science funding works (not sure whether she's actually claimed to be married to a scientist, to be fair).

It's just such a weak and spurious appeal to authority and one which often crops up on threads on subjects I'm an expert in- "well, my husband is an X and he says..." followed by some garbled, half-understood thing. And it's so easy to lie about- after all, no one can question the poster because it's not her who knows anything.

It's very striking on this thread how many people are claiming to be married to scientists who are all apparently climate sceptics, and yet there's no one claiming to be a scientist who's a climate sceptic herself. It's odd. Perhaps it's partly that people are happier to claim authority on behalf of a non-expert spouse than that spouse would be to claim authority for himself (there's someone up the thread presenting her geologist husband as an expert, ffs- hard to imagine a geologist joining a debate on climate change by announcing "well, I'm a geologist..." as if that carried any weight). Partly it's people making stuff up.

HadalyEve · 27/07/2023 08:20

Fawful · 26/07/2023 20:47

After Insulate Britain’s protests the government ended all these grants.
Their protests not only did not help, they caused a backlash that has set things back.
JSO protests are having the same impact. Why do you think our PM is U-turning on U.K. environmental commitments? It’s because of the JSO lunacy.

Wow. Where did you read this? That's such a weird argument. The government is u-turning on its environmental commitments because it thinks it will play well for the next general election to describe Labour as lentil-weavers who want you to be poor and have no fun for no good reason. At the stage the government is at, and given its place in the polls, that's the only card they can play against Labour if they want to maybe remain power.
They'll know that in doing so they will have the backing of the tabloid press who will love to have screaming headlines over how much going green would cost YOU (It wouldn't, but what's a little lie? People clearly forgive and forget).
As for the "climate change is cyclical" argument - yes there was change before, but there's never been change that fast. Last time it got hot, it took 5000 years (iirc).
How do we know? Well scientists know - they same way they know pretty much how old the Earth is (4.5 billion years). Or do you think it's just as likely the Earth is 5000 years old? Do you also have an opinion on the Big Bang, the size of the universe, quantum physics? If most scientists agree on something (this unprecedented global warming of +1.5° in 150 years is man-made, the universe is very big), why not go with the 99.9%, why go with the fringe 0.1%?
This pisses me off so much.

I didn’t “read” it anywhere these are bald facts. And it is my opinion so many people are pissed off at JSO that yes they will vote for the party that is going to stop those twats and that means set backs on the green movement. Caused by JSO. If JSO had not done their idiotic shenanigans that pumped tonnes more CO2 in the air, worsening climate change, the PM would likely not have felt a need to take a stand against them and by proxy everything they claim to stand for (but don’t really).

If you look at our record in terms of fighting climate change as a county, there is no party more green than the other so this isn’t a Tory vs Labour thing. The PM’s u-turn isn’t to get on over on labour at all. It’s all about being tough on eco-fascists that are crippling the capital and various refineries and major depots around the country- and that gets the votes from everyone pissed off at JSO.