Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could you be with a partner who doesn't believe in climate change?

616 replies

ToDoLists · 26/07/2023 16:17

DH doesn't really think it's all that bad. He thinks we should be recyling more and caring for the planet as makes sense and is just the right thing to do - but that climate change as a disaster is an exaggeration and not based in science. And that people are utilising it for their own agenda, woke brigade & so on.

We have young kids.

AIBU to find this position increasingly problematic?

People are going to say people are allowed different opinions but he seems geniunely unconcerned about future of planet for our kids - and I find that hard to swallow.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
17
RachelNoire · 27/07/2023 23:13

Why did you choose to have kids if you’re worried about climate change out of interest?

Question specifically for the OP (although I’m sure some arseholes won’t be able to stop themselves from replying).

SingingNettles · 27/07/2023 23:06

Planting billions of trees would likely help in the long term but, given that is takes forests about 100 years to grow, it simply isn’t a realistic stand alone strategy. It might even lead to further warming in the short term.

(The above is a tad trite but it’s a complex issue - https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2927/examining-the-viability-of-planting-trees-to-help-mitigate-climate-change/ )

Examining the Viability of Planting Trees to Help Mitigate Climate Change – Climate Change: Vital Signs of the Planet

A recent study estimates the global potential of restoring forested lands as a possible strategy for mitigating climate change.

https://climate.nasa.gov/news/2927/examining-the-viability-of-planting-trees-to-help-mitigate-climate-change/

EmilyBrontesGhost · 27/07/2023 23:04

ToDoLists · 27/07/2023 22:58

@EmilyBrontesGhost what does TPTB mean?

The Powers That Be

The people who runs things. Governments, big business, big banks etc.

ToDoLists · 27/07/2023 22:58

@EmilyBrontesGhost what does TPTB mean?

OP posts:
MrsMarni · 27/07/2023 22:50

EmilyBrontesGhost · 27/07/2023 22:38

It's a different question to the one asked by the OP, which was about climate change. (The climate's always changed and always will, nothing to do with us)

Shoesonthefloor is asking about the environment and pollution (completely different thing to "climate change") and this is where I think we need to differentiate.

We (not you and me but TPTB) do not give a toss about the environment. They are destroying the environment in the name of "climate emergency".

I actually care VERY MUCH about the environment, about pollution, about the loss of habitat, about the destruction of so much that is natural in our world.

So when trees and hedgerows are ripped out to "plant" rows of solar panels in fields it enrages me. Those solar panels will be in landfill in ten years, they can't be recycled.

If they care about the planet they would plant MORE TREES to absorb Co2, but no, they destroy habitat instead.

Tis a destructive and ungodly way to behave.

Exactly

Chezza2502 · 27/07/2023 22:45

End of the day that's his opinion as is your opinion yours, and in reality there is nothing ordinary joe public can do about it as damage was caused years and years ago and big oil and fuel corporations don't give a toss. I noticed it in 1976 but who am I. The best contribution he is offering it to continue recycling because mother nature got fed up decades ago. I defo wouldn't put climate change before my relationship and my family.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 27/07/2023 22:45

BTW has anyone heard from the Maldives yet?

They must surely be making plans to evacuate, right? From their six newly-built runways constructed at sea level.

(I don't think any of you know what "lowest, flattest place on earth" actually means and the implications, or what even sea level means in this instance, in fact I know you don't)

crowisland · 27/07/2023 22:39

Truly shocking what a limited grasp of science, scientific method and critical reading/thinking many posters display. A profoundly sad outcome of the dismal state of education in the UK.
Sounds like OP’s DH may be on a slippery slope to becoming a nonsensical conspiracy theorist. Q-anon followers begin with such ignorant claims. I could NOT be with someone like this.

EmilyBrontesGhost · 27/07/2023 22:38

StillWantingADog · 27/07/2023 22:23

also waiting for responses on this.

It's a different question to the one asked by the OP, which was about climate change. (The climate's always changed and always will, nothing to do with us)

Shoesonthefloor is asking about the environment and pollution (completely different thing to "climate change") and this is where I think we need to differentiate.

We (not you and me but TPTB) do not give a toss about the environment. They are destroying the environment in the name of "climate emergency".

I actually care VERY MUCH about the environment, about pollution, about the loss of habitat, about the destruction of so much that is natural in our world.

So when trees and hedgerows are ripped out to "plant" rows of solar panels in fields it enrages me. Those solar panels will be in landfill in ten years, they can't be recycled.

If they care about the planet they would plant MORE TREES to absorb Co2, but no, they destroy habitat instead.

Tis a destructive and ungodly way to behave.

StillWantingADog · 27/07/2023 22:23

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 22:01

To the non believers, I don't think this thread will age well.

I've followed climate change for 45 years, I've not just jumped on the band wagon, albeit it's interesting to see my views have slowly become mainstream.

I'm interested in asking the deniers, how many people do you think we can possibly cram on to the planet before life becomes unsustainable and before the planet itself begins to die off in parts? I'm genuinely interested as to what you think? Do you believe the planet can just keep regenerating or replacing as we chop, pollute and consume our way through it? Do you appreciate that to go from 1 billion population around 100 years ago to nearing 10 billion in 25 years time must have a detrimental effect? I honestly want to know.

also waiting for responses on this.

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 22:21

StillWantingADog · 27/07/2023 22:16

The consequences of giving up fossil fuels, restricting people's movement for most ordinary people and making women's lives especially more difficult are dire.

this could well be. I am certain that the consequences of NOT giving up fossil fuels will be far worse. I’m pretty sure having a climate that food can actually grow in, and that we can have enough fresh water to drink, is fairly essential. And for those that think “oh it will be ok here”, again that may well be but what do you think is going to happen when North Africa and then southern Europe’s crops fail? It will be a thousand times worse than the “small boats” issue we are currently dealing with.

Totally agree when everyone's eyes turn towards the small, grey rock that still has plentiful fresh water and summers haven't yet reached 50 degrees.

SingingNettles · 27/07/2023 22:20

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 22:08

Not really given that we're now highly unlikely to keep warming below 1.5 degrees

But, not so long ago, there were a lot of predictions that temperatures would raise by more than 4 degrees, which is when things start to become truly apocalyptic.

Since then, significant efforts have been made to reduce global warming. Even if efforts stagnate, that leaves us looking at (most likely) - a 3 degree increase.

That is still very, very bad and every effort should be made to limit that increase.

We are not going to achieve the best case scenarios. We have probably avoided the worst outcomes. We are left with a range of likely outcomes that are between ‘bad’ and ‘really awful’, but ‘absolutely horrific’ is likely off the table. Unfortunately, so is ‘not bad’.

But doomism doesn’t help. The more urgently we take serious actions the better, and doomism doesn’t tend to breed positive action, just increasing nihilism.

StillWantingADog · 27/07/2023 22:16

The consequences of giving up fossil fuels, restricting people's movement for most ordinary people and making women's lives especially more difficult are dire.

this could well be. I am certain that the consequences of NOT giving up fossil fuels will be far worse. I’m pretty sure having a climate that food can actually grow in, and that we can have enough fresh water to drink, is fairly essential. And for those that think “oh it will be ok here”, again that may well be but what do you think is going to happen when North Africa and then southern Europe’s crops fail? It will be a thousand times worse than the “small boats” issue we are currently dealing with.

MrsMinMax · 27/07/2023 22:13

Grammarnut · 27/07/2023 21:58

Agree with you. The doom merchants are full of 'emergency' but e.g. wild fires happen in Greece every year. The consequences of giving up fossil fuels, restricting people's movement for most ordinary people and making women's lives especially more difficult are dire.

spot on

MrsMinMax · 27/07/2023 22:09

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 21:48

See NASA chart I've just posted above, what am I supposed to be in denial about exactly?

so how was then all the ice melted? the ice that used to connect UK with mainland Europe, for example? If you really want to analyse data properly, look at the change in temperature not just the absolute, just a hint from someone who does this for living :-) Data interpretation is quite a science by itself and can be very misleading

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 22:08

SingingNettles · 27/07/2023 22:06

I do agree that climate doomism is unhelpful. We have already likely avoided the worst case predictions of 20 years ago, through postitive global action. We are still currently on a bad course, though.

Not really given that we're now highly unlikely to keep warming below 1.5 degrees

SingingNettles · 27/07/2023 22:06

I do agree that climate doomism is unhelpful. We have already likely avoided the worst case predictions of 20 years ago, through postitive global action. We are still currently on a bad course, though.

MumUndone · 27/07/2023 22:05

CurlewKate · 26/07/2023 16:29

People are entitled to their own opinions.They are not entitled to their own facts.

THIS!

SingingNettles · 27/07/2023 22:03

EmilyBrontesGhost · 27/07/2023 21:22

Can't believe people are saying it's "the science" when we've had the last three years of covid "science" which was all completely wrong.

Some scientists were completely and demonstrably wrong on Covid.

Prof John Ioannidis of Stanford is an obvious one. He argued that governments were overreacting to Covid and predicted that deaths is the US would not exceed 10,000 - a figure that ultimately was less than 1% of the total deaths in the US.

I expect, though, that you are referring to anyone who predicted a greater number of deaths than ultimately occurred.

Arguments like that usually misunderstand what the science was.

For one thing, Covid 19 was a new virus and, although scientists could refer to similar viruses to extrapolate how it might evolve, it is not something that could be predicted with certainty. Scientists could also not predict what measures governments would introduce to limit the spread.

Accordingly, predictions had to be made with references to variables. I.e., what would a best case scenario look like (Covid quickly evolving to become less lethal, strong measures in place to prevent the spread) versus a worst case scenario (Covid evolves to become more lethal, and no serious measures are put in place).

Of course, Covid did become less lethal over time (which was always viewed as the most likely scenario) vaccines were created, and most countries introduced strong measures to prevent its spread.

Just because the worst case scenario doesn’t come to pass every time (particularly when active steps are taken to prevent the worst case occurring) doesn’t mean the science was wrong. If a better outcome than the best case scenario, or a worse outcome than the worst case scenario occurs, then it’s reasonable to ask what went wrong - but neither of those things happened.

(I imagine there are several scientists like professor Ioannidis that were completely and demonstrably wrong, but that does not equate to ‘all of the science being completely wrong’.)

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 22:01

To the non believers, I don't think this thread will age well.

I've followed climate change for 45 years, I've not just jumped on the band wagon, albeit it's interesting to see my views have slowly become mainstream.

I'm interested in asking the deniers, how many people do you think we can possibly cram on to the planet before life becomes unsustainable and before the planet itself begins to die off in parts? I'm genuinely interested as to what you think? Do you believe the planet can just keep regenerating or replacing as we chop, pollute and consume our way through it? Do you appreciate that to go from 1 billion population around 100 years ago to nearing 10 billion in 25 years time must have a detrimental effect? I honestly want to know.

Grammarnut · 27/07/2023 21:59

He obviously cares. He wants to control pollution, which is far more of a threat than the climate emergency, which is no emergency but will make the super rich super richer. Listen to him.

Grammarnut · 27/07/2023 21:58

HadalyEve · 26/07/2023 16:26

Agree with you. The doom merchants are full of 'emergency' but e.g. wild fires happen in Greece every year. The consequences of giving up fossil fuels, restricting people's movement for most ordinary people and making women's lives especially more difficult are dire.

MrsMinMax · 27/07/2023 21:52

AIBot · 27/07/2023 21:01

From todays headline

In a roadmap to net zero emissions drawn up by the International Energy Agency, there should have been no new oil and gasfields approved for development from 2021. Instead, governments including the US, UKand Australia have granted licences to drill for more.

Marina Romanello, a climate and health researcher at University College London and head of the Lancet Countdown, said: “We have data showing how the very foundations of health are being undermined by climate change and, despite that knowledge, we’re seeing governments and companies still prioritising fossil fuels.

“But we still have time today to turn the tide and to ensure a liveable future for us and our children.”

not sure what is this proving? but hey, you have all the right to believe in human caused climate change, like I have to not believe it.. free country, no?

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 21:48

MrsMinMax · 27/07/2023 21:47

Yup, quite serious! Aren't you in denial though?

See NASA chart I've just posted above, what am I supposed to be in denial about exactly?

MrsMinMax · 27/07/2023 21:47

Shoesonthefloor · 27/07/2023 20:43

You cannot be series? I'm just mind blown that people can be so in denial?

Yup, quite serious! Aren't you in denial though?