Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is unfair and that I wasn’t given a fair chance at my new job.

164 replies

Sunnysideup95 · 26/07/2023 13:16

Recently I started a new job at a recruitment agency, for what would have been my first proper job. I was interviewed for an office administration position. A few days later I received a call from them and they said the position has gone to somebody else but there is another department within the same agency who need an administrator and they could take me on.

On my first day I arrived and soon found out it wasn’t an office admin job but was to call up nursing staff and see if they were available to take a job in care home that the agency had on their lists. A lot of the times I was ringing up and they would say they are not available to work that day. I felt pressure as I was just given a list of names and contact numbers and had to ring anybody on the list. I had no training and nobody helped or really told me what I needed to be doing

A few days later I was called in to the office by office manager who said he had been listening to my calls and thinks I’m not right for the job. But I was never told what to say to the nursing staff on their lists and was just trying my best

Aibu to think this isn’t fair

OP posts:
eggsandbaconeveryday · 27/07/2023 13:05

Its just not the right job for you on this occasion . Go back to the agency and say that it's not the kind of role that you are looking for and that you didn't realise that cold calling would be involved.
Having been a manager in the care industry I know how this kind of thing works. Most have a list of staff that they can use to cover sickness and holidays etc. What they should have got you to ask is " can you please tell me your availability for the next 2 weeks. Most work on a 2 week rota and can plan for this.
It certainly wasn't fair of them to just throw you into it without any training and they need to give more feedback. Good luck 😀

viques · 27/07/2023 12:25

Cold calling is a miserable job. I worked for one day trying to sell carbon paper ( yes, it was a long time ago, please feel free to google carbon paper if you are under 40) , I was given a page ripped out of a trade phone book and told to start dialling ( feel free to google this reference). It was unfortunate that my page covered company names beginning with Sch….. and it was a Jewish holiday, but even without that hurdle it was clear by lunchtime that it wasn’t the job for me. I lasted until 4.00 pm.

AccountantMum · 27/07/2023 12:13

I wouldn't worry about it - sounds like the job you wanted was not available and you were offered to try another and both you and the employer agree you aren't for the job.

If it's a cold calling type job even without training they may have been able to see that the job wasn't suited for you due to telephone manner / confidence so no need to waste your time and their time taking it further. There are a lot of jobs that don't require cold calling and you will build skills as you work so I'd just focus on looking for something that you do want to do.

Walkaround · 27/07/2023 11:55

Ladybug14 · 27/07/2023 11:04

You're not right for the cold calling job

Few people are good at cold calling ime, so dont feel bad about that

Make sure you see a job spec before you accept a job in future

Put those 3 days behind you and thank your lucky stars that you don't have to do it anymore

Nobody is right for a cold calling job, because 100% of cold calls are unwelcome and f*cking irritating, imvho.

MimiSunshine · 27/07/2023 11:34

ComtesseDeSpair · 26/07/2023 13:57

It sounds like the agency wanted you to make a bit of a running start and show some initiative. So if the nurses you phoned responded they weren’t available today, e.g. ask if that was medium or long term unavailability or whether they wanted remain on the list to receive calls about work available in the short term, any work or locations they didn’t want to be considered for, and update the list accordingly. Were you doing that?

If you’re applying for office admin jobs, particularly in the recruitment industry, this sort of thing is pretty standard, they generally expect you to know at least the basics without extensive training. Is this a new industry for you? What has your previous experience been? What skills can you transfer from that to a role and industry which might suit you better than admin in recruitment?

That’s all well and good but you k own that from experience of working.
mots not innate knowledge that the OP is somehow lacking.

your post comes across as sneery, everyone has to start somewhere and anyone who hires someone into a role and doesn’t provide any training or just expects them to know exactly what’s needed is a shit boss / employer.

Coffeetree · 27/07/2023 11:33

Gosh that was my first job back in the 90s!

This housing agency. My first day and I was handed a list of people who were due to move in the following week, but their units weren't ready. I was 21, new to the agency, had no idea why their units weren't ready, when they would be ready whether they'd be refunded for deposits. I was left alone in a room and my boss left the office.

My boss returned the following day and fielded some flow-up calls, and got to be the good guy: "I'm so sorry you didn't get the full information yesterday...of course you'll be refunded..."

But it was a really good lesson on how people preserve their reputations by getting others to do the dirty work.

Pr1mr0se · 27/07/2023 11:28

Sorry this has happened to you, it's not a good start to work life but it's not always like this. It doesn't sound entirely fair but they offered you the job and you accepted. If you weren't sure what to say on the calls you could have asked but that takes experience and confidence. I'd put it down to experience and next time you get offered a job ask more questions sooner. Good luck with your job hunt, I'm sure you'll find something better.

Hoppinggreen · 27/07/2023 11:16

IndysMamaRex · 27/07/2023 10:59

Not only was what happened to you unfair but if you get let go as a result it’s illegal and you would have a strong case for unfair dismissal. Speak to citizens advice.

On what grounds exactly?

Anewuser · 27/07/2023 11:10

Funny enough, my son and his girlfriend were talking about this the other day. They and their friends are just out of uni so looking for jobs. The said recruitment companies can’t get people because no one wants to do cold calls. So they advertise a different job then ‘just move you over.’

Don’t worry there are plenty of jobs out there.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 27/07/2023 11:07

Sunnysideup95 · 26/07/2023 14:02

Yeah I think they think I’m not being ‘pushy’ enough, if that’s the right word. apparently I’m just accepting that are not available on that time or date and they said that I should be encouraging them to accept the job but a lot of them are saying they’re already working elsewhere etc

Op, next time, make sure you have a formalised job description before you sign a written contract.

don’t go to any job without either.

Ladybug14 · 27/07/2023 11:04

Sunnysideup95 · 26/07/2023 14:02

Yeah I think they think I’m not being ‘pushy’ enough, if that’s the right word. apparently I’m just accepting that are not available on that time or date and they said that I should be encouraging them to accept the job but a lot of them are saying they’re already working elsewhere etc

You're not right for the cold calling job

Few people are good at cold calling ime, so dont feel bad about that

Make sure you see a job spec before you accept a job in future

Put those 3 days behind you and thank your lucky stars that you don't have to do it anymore

Youarethemasterofyourdestiny · 27/07/2023 11:02

Sounds like you dodged a bullet. They wouldn't of been good employers & you likely wouldn't of enjoyed it. I suspect what they wanted from you was to harrass, bully, manipulate and intimidate nurses into working a shift that day and because that's not what you done & not how your personality is, they have let you go. They are looking to employ a bully. You are better off away from it.

I had similar happen to me only It was on my first day, i had 10 years of experience and i was told 'change your telephone voice or you won't have a job by the end of the day'. I was then made to practice answering the phone with a smile on my face and pretend I was talking to customers, over & over again - infront of the full office. It was by far the worst job & people I have ever worked for. It was hellish. There was so much bullying. I didn't last long.

Honestly, they have done you a favour. Hope you find something else soon. Wishing you luck 🤞

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 27/07/2023 11:00

Middleagedmeangirls · 27/07/2023 10:58

@AngryGreasedSantaCatcus

Some recruitment agencies are incredibly professional and well run.

Others (particularly at the lower paid end of the job market like catering and care) are the Wild West -run by cowboys who don't give a shit about procedures and protocol but who are very good at fast talking people into low paid jobs at a moments notice. They aren't going to waste time in training or record keeping because that doesn't earn commission. They won't care about reputation because even on the management side, staff turnover will be so high that no one will remember in a months time what agency it was that misinformed them.

Exactly, so crappy company with crappy management, not OP's fault or lack of ability.

IndysMamaRex · 27/07/2023 10:59

Not only was what happened to you unfair but if you get let go as a result it’s illegal and you would have a strong case for unfair dismissal. Speak to citizens advice.

Middleagedmeangirls · 27/07/2023 10:58

@AngryGreasedSantaCatcus

Some recruitment agencies are incredibly professional and well run.

Others (particularly at the lower paid end of the job market like catering and care) are the Wild West -run by cowboys who don't give a shit about procedures and protocol but who are very good at fast talking people into low paid jobs at a moments notice. They aren't going to waste time in training or record keeping because that doesn't earn commission. They won't care about reputation because even on the management side, staff turnover will be so high that no one will remember in a months time what agency it was that misinformed them.

Sunnysideup95 · 27/07/2023 10:57

There was one comment from somebody who said they were being made to work shifts that didn’t suit them and then if they didn’t do it they would not be contacted again

OP posts:
Sunnysideup95 · 27/07/2023 10:55

Thank you everyone for taking time to comment.

Time to start looking for something new

It seems I have dodged a bullet as a lot of reviews from people on their lists say they are an untrustworthy company and there has been lots of issues around them paying the temp staff etc

OP posts:
GreenLaurel · 27/07/2023 10:55

This kind of work needs real training. I used to do a cold calling job and I had two weeks of training, and shadowing staff. It’s not fair, OP, and it’s not def not an admin job. Good luck with the next step.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 27/07/2023 10:43

bunchofboys · 27/07/2023 10:13

What exactly did you think admin in a recruitment company would be? That sounds completely like an admin job, and I suspect its not that you didn't persuade them to take the job but that you didn't get info out of them as to when they would be avaliable and what there skills are so that next time you don't have to call everyone on the list.

Everything should be stored on a database to ensure it is kept confidential. There are no bits of paper to shuffle (and most places have a no print policy these days).

Then why wasn't the nurse who was travelling to Australia flagged anywhere?

Lolojojonesi · 27/07/2023 10:42

Recruitment people can be unbelievably pushy, it’s really a sales job, and these take a particular type of person / range of skills. I think you were treated really badly, but you should be relieved you don’t have to work there any longer.

decaffonlypls · 27/07/2023 10:25

You haven't done anything wrong. Ypu weren't trained for the role and you should have been. It sounds like they expected you to bully people to work. And we're not willing to train, guide or support you. I personally would not want that job.

decaffonlypls · 27/07/2023 10:22

2bazookas · 26/07/2023 13:45

it wasn’t an office admin job but was to call up nursing staff and see if they were available to take a job in care home that the agency had on their lists. A lot of the times I was ringing up and they would say they are not available to work that day. I felt pressure as I was just given a list of names and contact numbers and had to ring anybody on the list. I had no training and nobody helped or really told me what I needed to be doing

From what you say, it was pretty clear what you were supposed to be doing.

Calling qualified people to ask if they were available on date A , location B, to do job C. With no training/help, I'd just have written my own own pleasant and professional script.

It's obvious many calls would result in "no". For reasons nothing to do with you so no need to "feel pressure".

How you responded to refusal reflects on the agency, and on you.

It's the op's first job

Walkaround · 27/07/2023 10:19

It sounds like an awful job, OP. You do not want to end up stuck in a job like that, with no training or support. Maybe the woman quitting the role thought it would be a foot in the door to becoming a recruitment consultant, but clearly not, or she wouldn’t be so sour grapes about it and might actually be helpful. It’s just the role of trying to flog the work the agency knows nobody on its books wants to do. They clearly do not work in the interests of their clients or their employees.

bunchofboys · 27/07/2023 10:13

What exactly did you think admin in a recruitment company would be? That sounds completely like an admin job, and I suspect its not that you didn't persuade them to take the job but that you didn't get info out of them as to when they would be avaliable and what there skills are so that next time you don't have to call everyone on the list.

Everything should be stored on a database to ensure it is kept confidential. There are no bits of paper to shuffle (and most places have a no print policy these days).

luckydaytoday · 27/07/2023 10:07

Can't believe the responses from people proud that they'd put up with this treatment and get on with it. Just demonstrates why shit employers get away with being shit. OP you can do so much better.