Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this is unfair and that I wasn’t given a fair chance at my new job.

164 replies

Sunnysideup95 · 26/07/2023 13:16

Recently I started a new job at a recruitment agency, for what would have been my first proper job. I was interviewed for an office administration position. A few days later I received a call from them and they said the position has gone to somebody else but there is another department within the same agency who need an administrator and they could take me on.

On my first day I arrived and soon found out it wasn’t an office admin job but was to call up nursing staff and see if they were available to take a job in care home that the agency had on their lists. A lot of the times I was ringing up and they would say they are not available to work that day. I felt pressure as I was just given a list of names and contact numbers and had to ring anybody on the list. I had no training and nobody helped or really told me what I needed to be doing

A few days later I was called in to the office by office manager who said he had been listening to my calls and thinks I’m not right for the job. But I was never told what to say to the nursing staff on their lists and was just trying my best

Aibu to think this isn’t fair

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PopGoesTheWeaselYetAgain · 30/07/2023 17:30

JudgeRudy · 27/07/2023 21:27

YABU - it really doesn't sound like there was much training needed. You were given a list of names and numbers and your job was to try to get these people to take the shifts (and earn the company revenue). It's a recruitment agency, surely it's not hard to understand how they make money. Your job was to overcome objections and sign them up.
Persuasive skills can he improved l guess, through experience/trial and error and possible seeing a skilled person in action however generally speaking you've either got it or you haven't. They clearly don't see enough potential to invest any further in you.
Dont feel bad. Not everyone can sell, just like everyone can't manage, organise, de-esculate, present, reassure, create etc. We all have a different skills set. It might be worth seriously considering what your inherent skills/traits are as much as your vocational experience/skills. It's a shame you didn't approach them once you realised you weren't delivering....we're you actually aware you weren't?

You sound like a total arse. Do you work for a recruitment agency, by any chance?

As you can see, OP, most people don't last a day doing this kind of work. Some people might be good at it, or even like it, but it's most people's worst nightmare.

Johnnybegood2 · 28/07/2023 18:20

I wouldn't describe office administration as cold calling though. Definite difference.

MeMeV · 28/07/2023 17:05

OP I had a very very similar experience when I was 18/19. Started as admin, was told I was being re distributed due to changing in teams and I would have to cold call. I was awful at it and was told that I should resign or they would find a reason to sack me without a reference. I handed my notice in and left. You have got lucky, lots of recruitment company’s have conveyor belt staff and aren’t particularly moral. Who wants to make someone take a job that don’t want?
Don’t let it knock your confidence, onwards to better things!

angela99999 · 28/07/2023 09:59

You have to be petty pushy in a job like this, maybe it just isn't for you?

When I was a student I worked in an employment agency. No training, you just needed a natural aptitude to push round pegs into square holes so that they could place people in jobs they didn't really want. I lasted eight weeks and was glad to leave.

Hoppinggreen · 28/07/2023 07:54

Icepinkeskimo · 27/07/2023 20:49

Are you always this nasty?

Apologies to OP if she felt I was being nasty.
I actually thought I was just being factual

LakieLady · 28/07/2023 07:22

Walkaround · 27/07/2023 11:55

Nobody is right for a cold calling job, because 100% of cold calls are unwelcome and f*cking irritating, imvho.

Yep, cold calling requires a thick skin and a degree of ruthlessness that is bordering on psychopathy imo.

Outside of specialist fields, recruitment is basically a selling role. You're selling (mostly shitty) jobs to potential employees and people to employers, regardless of whether they've got the skills and experience to do the job.

Jack80 · 28/07/2023 06:58

I would leave, I have worked in a recruitment agency and did reception duties and faxing, filing etc. Your job role sounds like one of the recruitment consultants.

NoNonsensePotato · 28/07/2023 02:31

JRM17 · 28/07/2023 02:26

If you think you were going to be doing an office admin job and not making/taking calls you're deluded and clearly not right for the job. I think you and the company both dodged a bullet.

Calls from colleagues maybe. An admin job is not the same as a call centre role. Not even slightly. **

JRM17 · 28/07/2023 02:26

Sunnysideup95 · 26/07/2023 14:05

@2bazookas I have said up the thread that the original job I applied for was for office duties such as paper work, sending out letters etc. no phone calls, in a different area of the recruitment agency. I was just told it was another admin job in a different department, then when I arrived I was told I would be making the calls

If you think you were going to be doing an office admin job and not making/taking calls you're deluded and clearly not right for the job. I think you and the company both dodged a bullet.

WitchesCauldron · 27/07/2023 23:34

I suppose you've never made a mistake? Tone down the self righteous act.

JudgeRudy · 27/07/2023 23:12

Yes I've acknowledged that some training is useful to improve skills, but you need something to work with. I've worked in offices where staff had said they hate answering/talking on the phone. They seem to have a problem with literally talking. Some people really aren't cut out for it. I'm sure within 3 days it's apparent if there is or isnt some raw talent to work with. It's quite possible they already have another candidate lined up, one more suited to this type of work. If it's a temp/unskilled position they might not have the inclination to waste time and money 'training' someone. That's not necessarily bad. If I ran a restaurant/cafe and employed a new waitress I wouldn't necessarily spend time 'training' them how to take an order,I'd expect basic skills to be able to converse with customers. I might give some top tips later on ways to carry plates or how to upsell side dishes, but not much more. If they were no good, I'd think 'next'.

IndysMamaRex · 27/07/2023 22:31

Failure to provide adequate training.

Failure to put a proper performance plan in place to allow employee improve performance

Not following proper probation plan

unprofessional conduct on part of management

quite a bit has been poor practice on the employers so as I said a strong case for unfair dismissal if it comes to it

NoNonsensePotato · 27/07/2023 22:16

'abroad' not 'a broad' 😂😂😂

NoNonsensePotato · 27/07/2023 22:16

So in this particular job, my guess is that it's not just about randomly calling potential staff. It would be wise to try and somehow ascertain whether they're actually likely to accept future offers or whether they only do it occasionally.

You could then create a hotlist and focus on the ones that seem more lucrative. The other staff seem to already have an idea of who's who as they mentioned that one woman being a broad.

NoNonsensePotato · 27/07/2023 22:11

JudgeRudy · 27/07/2023 21:27

YABU - it really doesn't sound like there was much training needed. You were given a list of names and numbers and your job was to try to get these people to take the shifts (and earn the company revenue). It's a recruitment agency, surely it's not hard to understand how they make money. Your job was to overcome objections and sign them up.
Persuasive skills can he improved l guess, through experience/trial and error and possible seeing a skilled person in action however generally speaking you've either got it or you haven't. They clearly don't see enough potential to invest any further in you.
Dont feel bad. Not everyone can sell, just like everyone can't manage, organise, de-esculate, present, reassure, create etc. We all have a different skills set. It might be worth seriously considering what your inherent skills/traits are as much as your vocational experience/skills. It's a shame you didn't approach them once you realised you weren't delivering....we're you actually aware you weren't?

Disagree and I've done cold calling, face to face business development, and led large bids for a top 3 fm provider. Some people have the gift of the gab but others benefit massively from a script.

My first boss explained to me how you start with open neutral questions and then funnel down. Also what they used to call 'the hamburger approach' - it's all about the meat but it's not appetising without the bun either side.

You need to make it difficult for the prospect to just fob you off with a simple "no". So you don't say "have you got any projects lined up?" Instead you ask "what projects have you got lined up?" The latter encourages them to stop and actually think.

Basic stuff but that's just scratching the surface.

AngryGreasedSantaCatcus · 27/07/2023 21:53

JudgeRudy · 27/07/2023 21:27

YABU - it really doesn't sound like there was much training needed. You were given a list of names and numbers and your job was to try to get these people to take the shifts (and earn the company revenue). It's a recruitment agency, surely it's not hard to understand how they make money. Your job was to overcome objections and sign them up.
Persuasive skills can he improved l guess, through experience/trial and error and possible seeing a skilled person in action however generally speaking you've either got it or you haven't. They clearly don't see enough potential to invest any further in you.
Dont feel bad. Not everyone can sell, just like everyone can't manage, organise, de-esculate, present, reassure, create etc. We all have a different skills set. It might be worth seriously considering what your inherent skills/traits are as much as your vocational experience/skills. It's a shame you didn't approach them once you realised you weren't delivering....we're you actually aware you weren't?

If there's not much training needed then why do good companies(big and small) offer it? You know, explaining the system, giving scripts,offering the opportunity to listen some calls etc?

This is such bullshit, covering employer incompetence by making it sound that the employee is somehow lacking.

JudgeRudy · 27/07/2023 21:27

YABU - it really doesn't sound like there was much training needed. You were given a list of names and numbers and your job was to try to get these people to take the shifts (and earn the company revenue). It's a recruitment agency, surely it's not hard to understand how they make money. Your job was to overcome objections and sign them up.
Persuasive skills can he improved l guess, through experience/trial and error and possible seeing a skilled person in action however generally speaking you've either got it or you haven't. They clearly don't see enough potential to invest any further in you.
Dont feel bad. Not everyone can sell, just like everyone can't manage, organise, de-esculate, present, reassure, create etc. We all have a different skills set. It might be worth seriously considering what your inherent skills/traits are as much as your vocational experience/skills. It's a shame you didn't approach them once you realised you weren't delivering....we're you actually aware you weren't?

Icepinkeskimo · 27/07/2023 20:49

Hoppinggreen · 26/07/2023 13:22

To be fair you arent right for the job are you?
Maybe you would be with some help or training but they can’t or won’t offer it so you need to find something else

Are you always this nasty?

riceuten · 27/07/2023 20:02

It's one step up from cold calling - AVOID ! AVOID !

HB8 · 27/07/2023 19:11

This is a very mean reply the lady wasnt trained or given a chance

NoNonsensePotato · 27/07/2023 15:41

Had another annoying interaction too when selling my pickup truck. I'd been offered a pretty low price by a dealer - at least a grand less than the going trade rate. They have mechanics too so I knew they'd just spend a day sorting the little niggles and sell it for £2k more.

I declined but then called them back 2.5 weeks later as I was working an hour from home and spending £30 a day on fuel - I figured I'd soon be worse off than just taking the hit and didn't have time to mess about with private sellers as was working evenings for the next month or two.

They then said "oh, but we'll have to knock the price down by a further £500 due to the extra mileage from the last fortnight." I said no you're getting a bargain, don't take the piss. The salesman after trying to bullshit me unsuccessfully then gets shirty and says "look, I can't be arsed to mess around here". I said well you know the asking price and he eventually agreed, albeit somewhat huffily, but on the condition they collect next day.

So I had to cancel my plans and lose the PT session I'd paid for, and when they turned up the driver tried to pay me £500 less and said that was the final price and couldn't negotiate! I'd already expressly warned them that I wouldn't be negotiating further upon collection as they'd priced it with full knowledge of all the defects.

Guy gets all pissy when I refused to lower the price and started moaning that they'd driven the truck over/paid for fuel etc. Eventually drives off without collecting.

The original salesman then calls me back two days later and promises to give me the originally agreed price. I'd actually by a stroke of luck sold it for £800 more to one of the builders at work by that stage - it was still a good deal at that price. Salesman sounded real pissed off and I was loving every moment tbh. Properly fucked himself over by trying to mug me off lol.

Bearthepooh · 27/07/2023 15:41

I work in a small niche recruitment firm and our admin support didn't handle the phones until about 6 months in. It sounds like it was an easy task but not for someone who's not used to handling the phones and especially not so early on.

Working in recruitment is a great opportunity to learn those admin skills and generally quite easy jobs to get. But at a guess, is it a large chain firm you went to? They're known for being brutal tbh and I'd avoid at all costs. If you want to have another go, try a smaller more niche agency as you'll get more support.

Katiebaby3009 · 27/07/2023 15:24

Sounds like a horrible job and I know I would be bad at it so please don’t let it put you off. Not all jobs are like that!

NoNonsensePotato · 27/07/2023 15:16

Find a better job IMO. I've done a fair bit of cold calling in my youth and funnily enough I was also misled and told it was 'managing engineers calendars' when it was actually calling up and pestering them to book a demo trial.

A lot of companies want you to be pushy but that just pisses people off and makes the job shit. Even as somebody who's been on the other end I still get annoyed by pushy callers.

Had a call from one the other day about
a temporary concrete job. I'd just left my employer that week due to repeated late/wrong payment and already had loads of permanent options but at £1200 a week and close to home I thought it could be a good shout and give me time to consider my options.

So I filled in all the paperwork and explained I was only interested in this opportunity and not general agency work. Heard nothing for a week so accepted a perm position.

Woman then texts me yesterday out the blue and says 'can you work tomorrow?' I explained I'd now accepted a perm job. She then asked if I could work in the meantime and I said I was having a few days off as I've not had a single day off since last Oct aside from xmas.

She was trying her best and I just firmly said no thanks. So today, first weekday in months I've not been up at the crack if dawn, and she tries to call at 7am. I cancel call and roll back over. She immediately calls again and I cancel call again. She then tries again 15 mins later and I pick up phone and say "fuck...off!!!" before putting it down.

No doubt she was just trying to hit her target but she was being a real pushy pain in the arse.

Strawberrysprinkless · 27/07/2023 13:32

I once had a job cold calling to try and set up funeral plans for people. Worse job I’ve ever had! I had to promote each funeral plan and tell people which kind of coffins we had available and all sorts and had to ask if they wanted cremation or burial for themselves. I understand it’s an important thing to have in place for many people but not many of them wanted a phone call out of the blue about it.

I remember the tally on the wall with all our names, documenting how many we had managed to set up each day and regular one to ones with the manager who would play our phone call recordings back to us and tell us what we could have said or done differently. He would publicly shout our name out and tell us to keep up if we didn’t have a score on the board by mid day!

some people are great at this type of thing but it definitely was not for me

Swipe left for the next trending thread