Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think rental policy is stifling the market

142 replies

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 09:38

I'm wondering if all this rental regulation is actually doing more harm than good to the supply of rental homes. I say this as someone who rented for years before buying and definitely suffered at the hands of bad landlords, but now I think that there is maybe too much regulation and it could be putting potential landlords off. In London where I live, demand is outstripping supply and pushing up prices.

For personal reasons I'm having to move out my home which I own and I was considering putting it on the rental market to cover my mortgage. I got quotes from estate agents which sounded insanely high, but when I tabled the rough costs:
40% tax on total rent minus the below costs:
Estate agency management fees
Electricity & gas safety certificates
EICR
Inventory & Check In
Tenancy agreement cost

I was only just going to break-even (n.b. you cannot offset your mortgage anymore).

While I was weighing up this and working out, my area has introduced new licencing for landlords which costs £900 and could be denied! Now at this point I felt like it wasn't worth the headache.

There's also the consideration that other new regulation makes it hard to give tenants notice, so if I need to move back into my property or sell it then I might not be able to easily. And that's if you don't encounter problematic tenants.

I can totally see why landlords are being put off and this probably isn't helping supply.

I'm not sure if the purpose is to force landlords to sell, but for instance I can't sell as I'm in the middle of a 5 year mortgage term and I'm not ready to buy another place yet.

Instead I'm looking at doing Air bnb or something like that which I've done before and found it easy and profitable.

I rented out a flat before and think I'm a good landlord - I make sure everything is taken care of super quick and look after my tenants. My house would have made a lovely long term rental and I know there is demand, but I just don't think I can afford to do it and I'm worried about the hassle as well.

OP posts:
Smidge001 · 26/07/2023 22:44

I agree with you OP. I ended up having a flat empty for 2 years while I was trying to sell it, as I didn't want the risk of tenants making the sale more difficult than it already was.

My parents have an empty granny annex, which they used to rent out but now find the cost and risks not worth the money they would earn.

This is not helping renters.

Wattiss · 26/07/2023 22:43

Obviously it's a hassle for people such as you. But ultimately the market doesn't need people such as you. It will be better for everyone all round, tenants included, if we can get rid of hobbyist landlords. Maybe there will still be a place for you all on Airbnb.

WTFAreYouForReal · 26/07/2023 22:42

Yanbu. It was obvious this was going to happen when they proposed all these regulations.

Add in the fact that you can barely evict bad tenants and its hardly rocket science.

3BSHKATS · 26/07/2023 22:41

clarebear111 · 26/07/2023 14:52

As someone who is going through an absolute nightmare trying to get my family home back from tenants who are behind with the rent and can only be contacted through lawyers, please only rent out your property if you can afford to be without rent for at least a year, as that is how long it will take to get before a judge and get the possession order/ warrant you will need, certainly in London.

All we want to do is move back in to our family home, which was always the plan, and these were tenants who came recommended through someone my mother had known for 60 years. No one gives two hoots that me and my family are stuck in a property that is not suitable for our needs, whilst these people have actually bought a family property and are now doing it up (!), presumably to move into. My experience of the system is that it is utterly broken.

Well if they’ve bought a house, your best bet is to get a CCJ against them. They will be very keen to clear that. Otherwise they won’t be able to reMortgage or get any further loans to fix up their own house.

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 22:40

TeenagersAngst · 26/07/2023 14:47

They actually want large corporate providers to move into the PRS because they think this is more 'professional'. The idea that these will create stable communities is laughable. I'm not saying the PRS sector is perfect by any means but this government with its revolving door of housing ministers are quite clearly not capable of developing a fit-for-purpose housing strategy.

My neighbours houses are both rented from ad-hoc (older) landlords and the tenants much prefer it. Their landlords keep everything in check, don't raise the rents for years and are friendly to deal with. If it was commercialised they'd be squeezed for every penny and made to feel much more uncertainty.

Both of my neighbours could afford to buy but for personal reasons prefer not to. It doesn't suit everyone.

OP posts:
3BSHKATS · 26/07/2023 22:39

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 26/07/2023 14:08

Some will be left empty as a result. Some will become short term lets / air bnbs.

Rental properties also have higher occupancy on average compared to owner occupied properties.

Fewer rentals adds up to less capacity in UK housing stock.

My mortgage is absolutely buttons. I could happily leave it empty or use it as storage facilities or just when I go up to visit family.

Or, alternatively, it could house a family.
Just depends on how much hassle is doesn’t it?

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 22:33

clarebear111 · 26/07/2023 14:52

As someone who is going through an absolute nightmare trying to get my family home back from tenants who are behind with the rent and can only be contacted through lawyers, please only rent out your property if you can afford to be without rent for at least a year, as that is how long it will take to get before a judge and get the possession order/ warrant you will need, certainly in London.

All we want to do is move back in to our family home, which was always the plan, and these were tenants who came recommended through someone my mother had known for 60 years. No one gives two hoots that me and my family are stuck in a property that is not suitable for our needs, whilst these people have actually bought a family property and are now doing it up (!), presumably to move into. My experience of the system is that it is utterly broken.

That sounds awful and exactly the sort of situation I want to avoid! Hope everything thing turns out OK in the end for you.

OP posts:
Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 22:32

Beetleback · 26/07/2023 18:34

@Bunny44 - you mention not being able to sell because of your existing mortgage (presumably early repayment fees?). Does this mortgage actually allow you to rent out your property? Most standard residential mortgages don’t.

I've requested a consent to let which my mortgage provider allows. Doesn't allow Air bnb but to be honest I'm not sure how they'd find out. Sure their priority is me not defaulting on my mortgage anyway.

Honestly sometimes feels there are just so many hoops to jump through and as I mentioned I'm only doing this temporarily to ensure I have a have a home for myself and my child when I return to work.

OP posts:
Beetleback · 26/07/2023 18:34

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 15:41

I'd rather rent to working people long-term, but like I said it's not feasible due to government policies making it harder and harder.

I'm not a commercial landlord, I just need to cover myself so I don't default on my mortgage while on mat leave.

@Bunny44 - you mention not being able to sell because of your existing mortgage (presumably early repayment fees?). Does this mortgage actually allow you to rent out your property? Most standard residential mortgages don’t.

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 15:41

Bananasandcorn · 26/07/2023 14:29

Its an issue because, like your doing and quite a few others, is using AirBnB short term holiday style rentals instead of long term renting to working people.

Don't blame people for doing this but it doesn't help those who cannot afford to buy.

Govt policies are fucking useless.

I'd rather rent to working people long-term, but like I said it's not feasible due to government policies making it harder and harder.

I'm not a commercial landlord, I just need to cover myself so I don't default on my mortgage while on mat leave.

OP posts:
ShadowPuppets · 26/07/2023 15:15

I live on a small 1950s housing estate that is very close to a University, a research park and a hospital. Standard semi detached houses - there's about 100 houses on the estate and approximately half are currently rented out.

When we bought here in 2022 there were only 2 houses on the market, both of which were clearly owner-occupied. We viewed both, bought our favourite. Just checked Rightmove and there are currently 6 on there, all added to Rightmove in the last month when the university term came to an end.

Selfishly I'm sort of hoping they'll be bought up by young families and the area will revert to what it was designed to be (rather than student central, they can go live in the town centre where it's acceptable to have loud music at 2am!) but once I put my NIMBYism to one side I can absolutely see that this is going in a really bad direction for renters. I'm 34 and we got on the ladder 6 years ago (and only 'thanks' to an inheritance from a parents' untimely death) - renting is recent enough in my memory. It was fairly crap then and it sounds really crap now. The gap between the 'haves' and 'have nots' is just getting bigger.

clarebear111 · 26/07/2023 14:52

As someone who is going through an absolute nightmare trying to get my family home back from tenants who are behind with the rent and can only be contacted through lawyers, please only rent out your property if you can afford to be without rent for at least a year, as that is how long it will take to get before a judge and get the possession order/ warrant you will need, certainly in London.

All we want to do is move back in to our family home, which was always the plan, and these were tenants who came recommended through someone my mother had known for 60 years. No one gives two hoots that me and my family are stuck in a property that is not suitable for our needs, whilst these people have actually bought a family property and are now doing it up (!), presumably to move into. My experience of the system is that it is utterly broken.

TeenagersAngst · 26/07/2023 14:47

Mythoughtextract · 26/07/2023 14:41

They want stable communities which housing associations and charities provide but fewer private landlords can as they might want their house back or to sell it. House price rises are pricing and hoc landlords as well as potential owner occupiers out

They actually want large corporate providers to move into the PRS because they think this is more 'professional'. The idea that these will create stable communities is laughable. I'm not saying the PRS sector is perfect by any means but this government with its revolving door of housing ministers are quite clearly not capable of developing a fit-for-purpose housing strategy.

Mythoughtextract · 26/07/2023 14:43

Also there is going to need to be a lot of updating to housing to make them fit for climate change so landlords need to be able to afford to update. Also appears to be a lot of shoddy new builds which will need work

Mythoughtextract · 26/07/2023 14:41

Stratocumulus · 26/07/2023 10:30

I’m a mortgage free landlord & getting to the stage where actually, it’s not worth the hassle. I’m thinking of selling. Lovely 3 bed, sought after rural village on city edge.

I have tedious tenants (7 years same family ) and am very proactive but this government is hell bent on not giving an inch to help the private rental market and reward good landlords.

I accept all the good legislation and have no compliance issues but there are some dreadful tenants out there who in real life should be charged with criminal damage when they depart and chased for all other costs attributed to their irresponsible & questionable “lifestyle.”

The government(s) don’t want small private landlords, they just want housing associations/charity projects etc. It’s a joke which is why so many of us are pulling out.

If in doubt, don’t be a landlord. It’s not worth the hassle.

They want stable communities which housing associations and charities provide but fewer private landlords can as they might want their house back or to sell it. House price rises are pricing and hoc landlords as well as potential owner occupiers out

2bazookas · 26/07/2023 14:35

@Cecilia When you say 'only just break even' what you mean is that someone else is covering all of your costs and you will still profit at the end

But nobody else IS covering all a LL's costs.

If a property is damaged/needs repaired/rewired. redecorated, new carpets, the perosn whom pays for that is the LL,

If there's a gap between tenants, the loss of rent affects the LL.

Whenever property is vacant, undergoing work, despite there being no income the LL still has to insure it, pay the council tax, stop it freezing,pay the contractors, pay the fuel bills so the contractors working in it have access to power and water to do their work. Maintain the roof and security, pay charges for communal areas etc.

Bananasandcorn · 26/07/2023 14:29

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 14:20

There is already a lot of regulation. In London its limited to 90 days to the year unless you have a license.

A lot of people use Air bnb to essentially take on lodgers to keep up with mortgage increases- not sure how that's an issue?

Its an issue because, like your doing and quite a few others, is using AirBnB short term holiday style rentals instead of long term renting to working people.

Don't blame people for doing this but it doesn't help those who cannot afford to buy.

Govt policies are fucking useless.

2bazookas · 26/07/2023 14:21

RudsyFarmer · 26/07/2023 12:02

Mumsnet absolutely loathes landlords. So I’m guessing there are lots and lots of delighted people on here.

My I correct you?
Some people on MN who have no clue about private letting law, regulations or tenancy agreements, have a very uninformed view of how they affect landlords.
Some of them are uninformed because, apparently, they didn't read the tanancy agreement they signed.
Other people on MN are experienced LLs who are demonstrable well aware of every legal requirement AND the terms of tenancy agreements, and long experienced in both good and bad tenants.

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 14:20

LlynTegid · 26/07/2023 14:11

I think air BnB and other holiday lets are a bigger issue to be honest, especially in coastal areas. I think there should be proper regulation and even in some areas a ban on them.

Second homes also contribute to the issue.

There is already a lot of regulation. In London its limited to 90 days to the year unless you have a license.

A lot of people use Air bnb to essentially take on lodgers to keep up with mortgage increases- not sure how that's an issue?

OP posts:
YouHaveAnArse · 26/07/2023 14:16

DriftingDora · 26/07/2023 13:41

YouHaveAnArse · Today 11:59

What is this "irresponsible & questionable "lifestyle"? They can't all be turning your homes into cannabis farms, surely?

Use your imagination, it's not too difficult...

there's always one...🙄

I'm using it, usually when I see the word in inverted commas it normally means something homophobic, which is why I'm confused.

TeenagersAngst · 26/07/2023 14:15

There's a common refrain during these debates that a LL leaving the PRS doesn't mean the house ceases to exist, implying that there isn't really a problem, just a greedy LL not liking the status quo. Which I think is what @mumda was getting at.

There's also an assumption that renters can afford to buy - well, obviously some can, but many many more can't - or they wouldn't be renting in the first place. The facts of the matter are that there is a rental crisis in the UK - too much demand, not enough supply (meaning either rental stock is decreasing or the number of renters is growing). Since this problem has only really escalated since 2016 with the introduction of S24, it's likely that it's the former (LLs leaving the market) rather than the latter.

2bazookas · 26/07/2023 14:13

mumda · 26/07/2023 10:52

If 28000 landlords leave each month, who then lives in those houses?
Are they left empty?

LL's don't "leave".

Either the tenants leave and it's not re-let. Or the LL sells the property and who knows if the new owner intends/ continues to let it.

That's not the seller's business.

buckingmad · 26/07/2023 14:11

FYI you can deduct your mortgage interest but the way it’s calculated has changed and is limited to 20% relief rather than at your marginal rate.

LlynTegid · 26/07/2023 14:11

I think air BnB and other holiday lets are a bigger issue to be honest, especially in coastal areas. I think there should be proper regulation and even in some areas a ban on them.

Second homes also contribute to the issue.

Mirandathepandaisontheverandah · 26/07/2023 14:08

mumda · 26/07/2023 10:52

If 28000 landlords leave each month, who then lives in those houses?
Are they left empty?

Some will be left empty as a result. Some will become short term lets / air bnbs.

Rental properties also have higher occupancy on average compared to owner occupied properties.

Fewer rentals adds up to less capacity in UK housing stock.

Swipe left for the next trending thread