Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think rental policy is stifling the market

142 replies

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 09:38

I'm wondering if all this rental regulation is actually doing more harm than good to the supply of rental homes. I say this as someone who rented for years before buying and definitely suffered at the hands of bad landlords, but now I think that there is maybe too much regulation and it could be putting potential landlords off. In London where I live, demand is outstripping supply and pushing up prices.

For personal reasons I'm having to move out my home which I own and I was considering putting it on the rental market to cover my mortgage. I got quotes from estate agents which sounded insanely high, but when I tabled the rough costs:
40% tax on total rent minus the below costs:
Estate agency management fees
Electricity & gas safety certificates
EICR
Inventory & Check In
Tenancy agreement cost

I was only just going to break-even (n.b. you cannot offset your mortgage anymore).

While I was weighing up this and working out, my area has introduced new licencing for landlords which costs £900 and could be denied! Now at this point I felt like it wasn't worth the headache.

There's also the consideration that other new regulation makes it hard to give tenants notice, so if I need to move back into my property or sell it then I might not be able to easily. And that's if you don't encounter problematic tenants.

I can totally see why landlords are being put off and this probably isn't helping supply.

I'm not sure if the purpose is to force landlords to sell, but for instance I can't sell as I'm in the middle of a 5 year mortgage term and I'm not ready to buy another place yet.

Instead I'm looking at doing Air bnb or something like that which I've done before and found it easy and profitable.

I rented out a flat before and think I'm a good landlord - I make sure everything is taken care of super quick and look after my tenants. My house would have made a lovely long term rental and I know there is demand, but I just don't think I can afford to do it and I'm worried about the hassle as well.

OP posts:
Cheesusisgrate · 27/07/2023 11:00

Don't forget that the property also attracts tax when selling. If I check mine, rented for a year at market rate after all tax, I would be in loss most likely

ProseccoOnTap · 27/07/2023 10:54

@Tatzelwyrm - no LL I their right mind will keep on a property if they are running at an annual loss in their tax return.

Even in the days of a rising market.

And especially not now where the market is perhaps falling or unpredictable at best.

More so with rent/eviction freezes as there is here in Scotland.

Tatzelwyrm · 27/07/2023 10:46

2bazookas · 26/07/2023 14:35

@Cecilia When you say 'only just break even' what you mean is that someone else is covering all of your costs and you will still profit at the end

But nobody else IS covering all a LL's costs.

If a property is damaged/needs repaired/rewired. redecorated, new carpets, the perosn whom pays for that is the LL,

If there's a gap between tenants, the loss of rent affects the LL.

Whenever property is vacant, undergoing work, despite there being no income the LL still has to insure it, pay the council tax, stop it freezing,pay the contractors, pay the fuel bills so the contractors working in it have access to power and water to do their work. Maintain the roof and security, pay charges for communal areas etc.

You do know what " break even" means?

It means that the LL has an asset which is probably increasing in value, and they are not losing money on it

SpaceRaiders · 27/07/2023 10:45

The NLA have been highlighting this for months. I know quite a number of landlords who would rather their property sat empty for weeks in the winter months to capitalise on easter and summer short term holiday bookings. They make triple what they’d get on an AST without all the compliance and the risk of a non paying tenant.

ProseccoOnTap · 27/07/2023 10:36

I rented for 5 years when DP lost his job & became self-employed so could t get a mortgage.

As PP said, there are plenty of us who want decent private accommodation temporarily.

GenieGenealogy · 27/07/2023 10:08

There is also a large group of renters who don't WANT a long term rental property, especially in cities. Students are the obvious group, but also people who are in their first job and finding their feet before thinking about buying, people who are on secondments and don't want to be in a hotel for 6 months, visiting academics etc etc etc. Those groups don't want/need social housing. They don't want a tenancy which will be theirs for years and years. They want to be able to access private rental accommodation for 6 months to a year, and then leave. That is becoming increasingly difficult for them to find.

DD is starting university in a couple of months in a Scottish city. She has university accommodation for the first year but this is not guaranteed in subsequent years. It's a real worry.

ProseccoOnTap · 27/07/2023 10:04

And where is all this private/social housing being built????

It's one thing to introduce all this legislation, if there's already something in place.

But there's not.

And there's plenty of people who need to rent, don't want to buy.

I despair of our politicians, especially in Scotland

electriclight · 27/07/2023 09:41

Landlords and letting agents have been warning about the impact of legislation for a long time.

They were told that good quality landlords would be delighted with all the changes, designed to protect tenants and improve quality of rental stock, and that it would be great news if landlords started selling up - more starter homes on the market for buyers.

Looks like they got what they wished for to me, but with the unintended consequences that everyone else could see coming.

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 09:21

Justdontask · 27/07/2023 09:05

The focus is wrong. The response to the housing crisis shouldn't be deregulation or not introducing reforms, but instead a more holistic approach to housing. The number one priority should be a huge amount of house building for social housing. This would free up private rentals to those who can afford it, and mean that the most vulnerable in society are not always at the bottom in bidding wars for properties.

Agree with more social housing - this makes sense on lots of levels. Still think there is too much regulation on private rentals though and like I said, not sure who it benefits.

OP posts:
Justdontask · 27/07/2023 09:05

The focus is wrong. The response to the housing crisis shouldn't be deregulation or not introducing reforms, but instead a more holistic approach to housing. The number one priority should be a huge amount of house building for social housing. This would free up private rentals to those who can afford it, and mean that the most vulnerable in society are not always at the bottom in bidding wars for properties.

Tracker1234 · 27/07/2023 08:54

I am on the fringes of rentals and manage some rentals with the support of a letting agent. Its part of my job role. I agree that the rules and policies have gone far too far. Now our council is introducing Selective Licenses. Another money spinner for god knows who. We are slowly running down our rentals because of the huge amount of work it takes and also a sizeable minority of tenants just wreck the places, or just dont pay the rent. We can serve them with various Section notices but it takes months and months to remove them.

As a PP said. Some people live completely irresponsible lives. 40% of our apartments need significant repairs after a tenant has moved out (cira £3k plus), two were sub let and one was used as a party apartment for friends to wreck and use. Tenant lost his deposit because he hadnt paid for months but the rest of it is long gone. The little scrot then moved to USA!

GenieGenealogy · 27/07/2023 08:42

YANBU. There is a student housing crisis now in Scotland because of these policies. Students NEED to rent private accommodation in their uni towns and have for years, on a yearly basis or September - end of June. The restrictions on tenancies and increased burden on landlords mean that they are just not interested in this market any more. Huge competition for what accommodation there is. Masters students in Glasgow having to live with relatives in Edinburgh and commute because they can't get a flat.

Tiredmummaoftwo · 27/07/2023 08:39

Yep. It's way more ag than it's worth.

JudgeAnderson · 27/07/2023 08:38

@clarebear111 The property was in poor condition but not deliberately vandalised apart from them spreading rubbish all over the floors of each room. It had been a pristine 3 year old new build. We needed to replace all carpets, replace the kitchen and repaint the whole house. Some replastering.
They'd also left a huge amount of junk behind (but managed to steal our lawnmower!).

We did manage to keep the deposit through the deposit protection scheme and claim for the new carpets on our insurance.

I can PM you pictures if you like.

Readthebooks · 27/07/2023 07:33

It has already resulted in very few properties. Landlords round here are all selling up, including my own after 14 years. There is literally nowhere to rent. I've no choice but to stay put until something comes up, however rents have increased 50% here since January are are now unaffordable to single income households like myself. I haven't slept since I found out and have never been so stressed in my life. There is a huge housing crisis and it's being completely ignored by the media. I've paid over 100k in rent on this property but they remortgaged to the hilt and are now in financial difficulty. If they'd sold last year it wouldn't be such a problem. Fortunately for me they haven't followed the correct processes so likely I can stay a good while if I need to but I really just want to find somewhere suitable and move on instead of living in limbo like this.

clarebear111 · 27/07/2023 07:11

whirlyhead · 27/07/2023 06:57

I sold a BTL a few years ago that I’d owned for over 12 years and never made a profit from. I sold it for £1k more than I paid for it so whoever said you’d always make a profit on sale isn’t correct.

bad tenants are horrendous. My friend just managed to evict one who hadn’t paid rent for over 2 years and indeed they have turned the loft into a cannabis farm and trashed the house. Over £10k worth of damage plus all the lost rent.

someone else I know has been trying to evict a non paying tenant for getting on for 4 years now.

i am all for ensuring landlords are held accountable and behave well, and they shouldn’t be allowed to push rents up to ridiculous levels but I’m currently cursing the Scottish situation. I have a Glasgow tenant paying 30% below market value and I can’t put the rent up more than 3%. The mortgage is now more than the rent but there’s nothing I can do. The property is worth less than I paid for it due to issues with the development it’s in so I can’t sell it at present.

being a landlord sucks.

@whirlyhead I’m so sorry to hear this, and the experiences of your friends sound horrendous and not dissimilar to what I am going through. The system seems to be completely ineffective against nightmare tenants.

I think this will all result in very few rental properties being available, and those that are being run by a few, very ruthless large scale landlords. There’s no guarantee those landlords will look after their properties either - just look at the issues with clarion and similar companies.

clarebear111 · 27/07/2023 06:59

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 22:33

That sounds awful and exactly the sort of situation I want to avoid! Hope everything thing turns out OK in the end for you.

Thanks OP, at least I can help others by warning them of the realities of our system.

If you want the security of knowing you can move back into your property on a certain date, you simply cannot let it out I’m afraid. The s21 notice you serve will simply be asking them to leave. To force them to leave, you will need a possession order and then a warrant of eviction and then for the bailiffs to go in. There are so many rules about things like deposit protection and gas safety certificates that it’s actually easy not to have every i dotted and t crossed, even if you use an agent, and it will mean your s21 notice is invalid.

If they owe you rent, and you serve a s8 notice, all they have to do at any time before the date of the court hearing is pay enough rent so that there is less than 2 months’ worth of arrears. If they do that, you won’t even get your possession order, you’ll be out of pocket with court and legal fees and the whole thing starts again.

The delays in the courts post covid don’t help, nor does the expense and stress of having to go to court twice (once for the possession order, and once again for the warrant of eviction).

I don’t think the system is working for anyone, and I can’t blame landlords for not wanting to let out their properties under the current framework. One set of bad tenants is enough to put you off for life.

Coping with the effects on your mental health is also challenging, particularly if this is your family home and the tenants have given you verbal and written assurances they are leaving, but these are completely useless and don’t mean anything legally. People can lie and can be extremely unpleasant, but when they are living in your family home and refusing to leave, it takes on a different complexion.

Sorry for the long, ranty post. In short, I think your instincts are spot on and Airbnb lets will be the answer in this situation.

whirlyhead · 27/07/2023 06:57

I sold a BTL a few years ago that I’d owned for over 12 years and never made a profit from. I sold it for £1k more than I paid for it so whoever said you’d always make a profit on sale isn’t correct.

bad tenants are horrendous. My friend just managed to evict one who hadn’t paid rent for over 2 years and indeed they have turned the loft into a cannabis farm and trashed the house. Over £10k worth of damage plus all the lost rent.

someone else I know has been trying to evict a non paying tenant for getting on for 4 years now.

i am all for ensuring landlords are held accountable and behave well, and they shouldn’t be allowed to push rents up to ridiculous levels but I’m currently cursing the Scottish situation. I have a Glasgow tenant paying 30% below market value and I can’t put the rent up more than 3%. The mortgage is now more than the rent but there’s nothing I can do. The property is worth less than I paid for it due to issues with the development it’s in so I can’t sell it at present.

being a landlord sucks.

clarebear111 · 27/07/2023 06:45

@JudgeAnderson sorry to hear you’ve experienced similar. It’s been incredibly stressful and an eye opener for me in terms of how the system operates.

Can I ask, what condition was your property in when you got it back? I’m expecting them to have trashed it because that just seems to be the sort of people they are. If your property wasn’t in a good condition, what were you able to do (if anything)?

Cheesusisgrate · 27/07/2023 06:43

Yeah everyone always mentions rights in Europe (big place, different rulea tho so...) , but have usually no idea about responsibilities in individual countries.
I can totally imagine how even small things like daily airing or monthly drain cleaning in contract would go down here... I had people 😱 at me here because I air daily even in winter (especially in winter). My native country, small repairs are usually done by tenant, eg wobbly door handle, kitchen cupboard door etc. No one bothers landlords with small stufg. Yes, the security is often better, but it also comes with more responsibilities. Not paying? Unless rules changed, I would not want to deal with bailiffs there after court eviction. They will take everything fom you.

Re difficult mortgage, we have 5% deposits here. Many can dream about it and 25% is standard.

clarebear111 · 27/07/2023 06:41

We are intending to do this but it’s a complicated process. The priority is to get the property back. All a CCJ will do is encourage them to clear the arrears which, whilst welcome, won’t get us our family home back.

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 00:06

SpringViolet · 26/07/2023 23:11

I thought that renting in other European countries was more regulated than in the UK and more secure for tenants?

Why is that such a problem for the UK?

It seems to the same with lots of things in the UK - people complaining about having a welfare state but European countries have more generous benefits (do European countries have government propaganda about benefit ‘scoungers’?), the strain on the NHS but European countries have a much better standard of medical care, free nursery places but again European countries have DC in full time nursery earlier and it’s much cheaper.

How come they can do all that but not us?

Different mentality perhaps? The ‘I don’t want to share, I’m alright Jack’ classist society we still have here?

I've rented in Europe myself in several countries and it's not all roses either. E.g. In Spain the tenant until very recently was responsible for paying huge upfront, and quite unjustified costs (much bigger than we've ever had in the UK) and they also have an issue with spiralling rental costs, although the good part is that you get longer tenancy terms which are more secure.

Even in Germany, which is often hailed as the gold standard, there are cities like Munich which are pretty unaffordable for most.

One thing that is difficult in the UK to most other countries is our mortgage system- in most countries the interest rate is set for the whole mortgage term and also rent increases are in turn controlled more. In the UK, neither are controlled leading to market fluctuation for buying and renting.

Aside from all of this, my post is about how current rental regulation in the UK isn't helping anyone - but especially the average person buying or renting.

OP posts:
SpringViolet · 26/07/2023 23:11

I thought that renting in other European countries was more regulated than in the UK and more secure for tenants?

Why is that such a problem for the UK?

It seems to the same with lots of things in the UK - people complaining about having a welfare state but European countries have more generous benefits (do European countries have government propaganda about benefit ‘scoungers’?), the strain on the NHS but European countries have a much better standard of medical care, free nursery places but again European countries have DC in full time nursery earlier and it’s much cheaper.

How come they can do all that but not us?

Different mentality perhaps? The ‘I don’t want to share, I’m alright Jack’ classist society we still have here?

JudgeAnderson · 26/07/2023 23:08

@clarebear111 We went through similar a few years ago and it was one of the most stressful times of my life.

You will get there eventually and the nightmare will be over, but I will never ever let a tenant step a foot across my threshold ever again regardless of circumstances.

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 22:56

Wattiss · 26/07/2023 22:43

Obviously it's a hassle for people such as you. But ultimately the market doesn't need people such as you. It will be better for everyone all round, tenants included, if we can get rid of hobbyist landlords. Maybe there will still be a place for you all on Airbnb.

I think saying we are 'hobbyist' landlords is condescending and negates what I said about many individual landlords often being better to deal with. I disagree with your POV on this also from my experience as a renter. Legislation seems to suggest the government wants no rental properties at all, "hobbyist" or otherwise anyway.

Also not sure what are people supposed to do when they need to rent out their property temporarily for various reasons (relocation, change of circumstance).

OP posts: