Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think rental policy is stifling the market

142 replies

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 09:38

I'm wondering if all this rental regulation is actually doing more harm than good to the supply of rental homes. I say this as someone who rented for years before buying and definitely suffered at the hands of bad landlords, but now I think that there is maybe too much regulation and it could be putting potential landlords off. In London where I live, demand is outstripping supply and pushing up prices.

For personal reasons I'm having to move out my home which I own and I was considering putting it on the rental market to cover my mortgage. I got quotes from estate agents which sounded insanely high, but when I tabled the rough costs:
40% tax on total rent minus the below costs:
Estate agency management fees
Electricity & gas safety certificates
EICR
Inventory & Check In
Tenancy agreement cost

I was only just going to break-even (n.b. you cannot offset your mortgage anymore).

While I was weighing up this and working out, my area has introduced new licencing for landlords which costs £900 and could be denied! Now at this point I felt like it wasn't worth the headache.

There's also the consideration that other new regulation makes it hard to give tenants notice, so if I need to move back into my property or sell it then I might not be able to easily. And that's if you don't encounter problematic tenants.

I can totally see why landlords are being put off and this probably isn't helping supply.

I'm not sure if the purpose is to force landlords to sell, but for instance I can't sell as I'm in the middle of a 5 year mortgage term and I'm not ready to buy another place yet.

Instead I'm looking at doing Air bnb or something like that which I've done before and found it easy and profitable.

I rented out a flat before and think I'm a good landlord - I make sure everything is taken care of super quick and look after my tenants. My house would have made a lovely long term rental and I know there is demand, but I just don't think I can afford to do it and I'm worried about the hassle as well.

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 27/07/2023 13:50

I literally have no issue with small or large landlord making a profit out of renting out property. It is a business after all.

I have an issue if they are shit and sadly too many small time landlords are just shit. Often they don't mean to be but because they are under capitalised or don't see it as a business but a pension etc..

nobodysdaughternow · 27/07/2023 13:48

When the Conservatives got into power, they very quickly started rewarding homeowners and ripping apart the social housing and private rental infrastructure.

I was working in social housing at the time and it was horrific to see social cleansing being rolled out in front of their greedy eyes.

There are children growing up in a single room with a bathroom they share with other families and others whose parents have been forced into private rented where there is mould and damp and their tenancy could end any moment when the landlord has to sell up due to new restrictions.

Breaking even for a landlord is not ok - they need a way to fund repairs. Breaking even means no repairs.

Families who will never get social housing will now struggle to find private rental.

Little children's lives blighted by greedy people.

Makes me really fucking angry.

3BSHKATS · 27/07/2023 13:43

JudgeAnderson · 27/07/2023 13:40

I find the argument so strange. Utilities companies - profit. Supermarkets - profit. The plumber that fixes your bog - profit. These are all essentials too.

I don't disagree that there should be way more social housing stock btw. Just that there should also be favourable conditions to allow a decent supply of private rentals so that the choice is there for everyone to find something that suits their individual circumstances.

Well, let’s be honest, deepdown people probably don’t even like that either. But again they won’t pay 10p, extra to go to the local butcher.

Cheesusisgrate · 27/07/2023 13:42

HorseyMel · 27/07/2023 13:30

Once private equity companies and the like have a stranglehold on the rental sector, you'll all be begging for the "small time landlords" to come back.

Can't disagree!

This is the same with other sectlrs. Monopoly of giants are not always the best thing

JudgeAnderson · 27/07/2023 13:40

I find the argument so strange. Utilities companies - profit. Supermarkets - profit. The plumber that fixes your bog - profit. These are all essentials too.

I don't disagree that there should be way more social housing stock btw. Just that there should also be favourable conditions to allow a decent supply of private rentals so that the choice is there for everyone to find something that suits their individual circumstances.

WTFAreYouForReal · 27/07/2023 13:39

HorseyMel · 27/07/2023 13:30

Once private equity companies and the like have a stranglehold on the rental sector, you'll all be begging for the "small time landlords" to come back.

Exactly.

Some people are just fucking dumb.

HorseyMel · 27/07/2023 13:30

Once private equity companies and the like have a stranglehold on the rental sector, you'll all be begging for the "small time landlords" to come back.

3BSHKATS · 27/07/2023 13:30

And don’t forget the maintenance company and the block management company will both charge VAT on top of that which year Plumber down the road probably didn’t. Outright theft.

3BSHKATS · 27/07/2023 13:28

MichelleScarn · 27/07/2023 13:20

Are people OK with corporate landlords making a profit or 'breaking even', do some people honestly believe that the 'hobbyist' landlords should let out their property with no return other than they may make a profit when they sell?

This is what literally makes me laugh out loud. It’s like Beyoncé brings out a candle and everybody falls over themselves to pay 10 quid for that. Your best mate you’ve known for 40 years who lives down the road from you your kids go to the same school as Theres . They start making candles and sell them for 11 quid and everybody’s being ripped off. It’s disgraceful have they got a license etc.
I’m an absolute loss to understand why people I’ve got such an issue with mum and dad owning a couple of rental properties and doing their best to keep up with repairs etc versus the big corporate faceless entity. Who if any of you have any experience of block management I can tell you the residents are taking these people to court almost weekly over repairs. And they won’t win because the block as an individual entity doesn’t have any money to carry out repairs even if the organisation as a whole does.

I also have personal experience of the block management companies calling up their mate who owns the maintenance company who then calls up the plumber who charges 100 quid to fix the leak. The maintenance company then adds their charge which will be another hundred. And the block management company add to their 20% service charge so overall we get to £240 for £100 job.

But you’re all fine with that as long as Joeann and Trevor down the road aren’t making any money out of you.

This country is gonna get exactly what it deserves.

JudgeAnderson · 27/07/2023 13:24

Corporate landlords will certainly expect to run at a profit for providing housing - is that okay then?

MichelleScarn · 27/07/2023 13:20

Are people OK with corporate landlords making a profit or 'breaking even', do some people honestly believe that the 'hobbyist' landlords should let out their property with no return other than they may make a profit when they sell?

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 13:17

Ginmonkeyagain · 27/07/2023 13:09

There will be landlords. The problem we have at the moment is too many small time landlords, not too few. Their business models are often laughable and under capitalised, they can be woefully ignorant of their obligations and whine when they come unstuck.

We need to move to:

1 more affordbale homes to buy for young people.

  1. More.spcially rented housing
  1. A return to work provided accomodation for some key worker professions
  1. More long term corporate landlords in the PRS.

Deregulating the sector with ASTs and BTL mortgages in the late eighties certainly flooded the market with rental properties but it also resulted in a lot of very poor qualoty landlords and inflated prices at the lower end as first time buyers found themselves competing with investors for the same properties.

Landlords are providing a life essential service to people so SHOULD be well run, well regulated businesses not someone with a half arsed plan to invest in a second property as a pension.

Why do corportate landlords work better? Surely they're even more set on maximising profit and if they have a larger market share will just crank up rents further?

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 27/07/2023 13:09

There will be landlords. The problem we have at the moment is too many small time landlords, not too few. Their business models are often laughable and under capitalised, they can be woefully ignorant of their obligations and whine when they come unstuck.

We need to move to:

1 more affordbale homes to buy for young people.

  1. More.spcially rented housing
  1. A return to work provided accomodation for some key worker professions
  1. More long term corporate landlords in the PRS.

Deregulating the sector with ASTs and BTL mortgages in the late eighties certainly flooded the market with rental properties but it also resulted in a lot of very poor qualoty landlords and inflated prices at the lower end as first time buyers found themselves competing with investors for the same properties.

Landlords are providing a life essential service to people so SHOULD be well run, well regulated businesses not someone with a half arsed plan to invest in a second property as a pension.

Blinkingbonkers · 27/07/2023 13:07

Just renting out a non mortgaged property which has been sitting empty for a few years. We’ll have to reevaluate when the new EPC rules come in - there’s no actual way for any further work to the Victorian building to increase/better the grading. It’s another of the government’s green policies that will most likely have to be shelved or there’ll be no rentals left🙈. It’ll only decrease supply and increase rents further. Numbskulls🙄.

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 13:01

Ginmonkeyagain · 27/07/2023 12:55

Thing is - being a landlord IS a business and should be treated as such.

Tenants are customers you are providing an essential service to not a convenient way to pay your mortgage.

If you cannot afford your mortgage, you cannot afford to be a landlord - what will you do if your tenant defaults? Or you end up with an urgent expensive repair.

Current legislation has made it an unaffordable business for most LLs - that is the point of the post. What if there are no LLs? Or only large corporations as LLs whose only objective is to make as much money as possible?

OP posts:
Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 12:57

AnoyDad2023 · 27/07/2023 12:20

You know... after reading all of these responses... its amazing how many property owners are so out of touch with reality.

You can't possibly expect people to be happy with landlords "profiting" off a nessecity. People aren't going to roll over and kiss your behind when you're taking half of their wages, while you profit. Even if you don't profit cash, you have an asset that will one day be paid off at somebody else's expense. You have still profited.

You can talk about nightmare tenants all you want. I'm sure there are plenty. Most people are model tenants. They look after the place they live.

And yes. People want secruity. Renting is considered someone's permanent home. Yet you can throw them out with 8 weeks notice without so much as a thank you.

Don't pretend you are hard done too. You aren't the victim in this transaction.

To the landlords that are genuine, caring people.. I salute you. There isn't enough of you.

Let the rental market go mad. House prices are dropping and I might actually be able to afford to buy my own....

Treat housing like a business and you deserve everything that comes your way.

@AnoyDad2023 You sound very bitter. But the point is the current legislation isn't going to help you. My post was about it being both disadvantageous to both potential landlords and renters the current situation.

Also there are plenty of potential landlords like me who are just trying to cover costs due to changes of circumstances. Sometimes ordinary people who let out their homes (because they have to) do get screwed over.

I've been on both sides of renting for years and also really hoped I'd be able to afford to have my own place one day. Eventually I did after much hard work and sacrifice and bought only with intention of security, but due to unfortunate life experiences I need to let out my place (rendundancy, partner leaving me while pregnant) - do you think I deserve to be screwed over?

OP posts:
Ginmonkeyagain · 27/07/2023 12:55

Thing is - being a landlord IS a business and should be treated as such.

Tenants are customers you are providing an essential service to not a convenient way to pay your mortgage.

If you cannot afford your mortgage, you cannot afford to be a landlord - what will you do if your tenant defaults? Or you end up with an urgent expensive repair.

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 12:39

Tatzelwyrm · 27/07/2023 10:46

You do know what " break even" means?

It means that the LL has an asset which is probably increasing in value, and they are not losing money on it

@Tatzelwyrm but I'm not really 'breaking even'. As mentioend houses are depreciating in London and on top of that the LL is landed with the cost of:

-Stamp duty when buying
-Legal fees to buy and sell
-Capital gains tax
-Estate agent's fees
-Maintenance

All of this cost me last time around £30,000. If It was a LL buying a 2nd home it would be closer to £50,000. All considered if I'm only just breaking even, as in to cover my mortgage and service charges, I'm actually making a loss.

Another huge consideration is the deposit an owner puts down. I put in ALL my money as a deposit and it remains tied up there. That is money that I cannot access to either invest or support myself and my baby until I sell and it's also money I have risked in the property game. I run the risk of losing this money if the market crashes and that would essentially be my life savings.

Renters have none of the risk, time or stress of maintaining, buying or selling a property. And yes, appreciation is not guaranteed so you are always taking on a massive risk - people can and do lose tens of thousands of pounds in the property market, and sometimes much more.

As several PPs have mentioned, there is a need for shorter term lets and many tenants would actually appreicate greater flexibility & reduced cost, but current legislation is stifling this/making it impossible for both LLs and renters.

OP posts:
ProseccoOnTap · 27/07/2023 12:30

If only the anger about "profiteering" from a business was directed at supermarkets, energy companies etc. as well.

Apart from they are "allowed" to make huge profits for bare essentials too, like heat & food.

But god forbid if a LL views their property as a business.

AnoyDad2023 · 27/07/2023 12:20

You know... after reading all of these responses... its amazing how many property owners are so out of touch with reality.

You can't possibly expect people to be happy with landlords "profiting" off a nessecity. People aren't going to roll over and kiss your behind when you're taking half of their wages, while you profit. Even if you don't profit cash, you have an asset that will one day be paid off at somebody else's expense. You have still profited.

You can talk about nightmare tenants all you want. I'm sure there are plenty. Most people are model tenants. They look after the place they live.

And yes. People want secruity. Renting is considered someone's permanent home. Yet you can throw them out with 8 weeks notice without so much as a thank you.

Don't pretend you are hard done too. You aren't the victim in this transaction.

To the landlords that are genuine, caring people.. I salute you. There isn't enough of you.

Let the rental market go mad. House prices are dropping and I might actually be able to afford to buy my own....

Treat housing like a business and you deserve everything that comes your way.

Poochypaws · 27/07/2023 12:07

I've rented out flats twice for short periods in Edinburgh. The first time I rented out my home and when I needed it back the tenants did move out with no trouble. The problem is when I moved back in it turned out the boiler had stopped working at some point and they had stuffed up the air vents on the windows presumably as they were freezing. The flat hadn't been vandalised or anything but I moved back into a broken boiler, windows that had aged more rapidily that I would have expected (don't really know why), broken toilet button and just lots of other irritating small items. I was mad as hell as to why they hadn't just contacted me and told me things were breaking so I could resolve it but it turned out they had 3 people living in a tiny flat (really only suitable for one person) so I suspect that was why.

The second time I rented out a different flat the first tenant was fine. No issues. The second tenant was a lovely polite american young man who seemed ideal. He was...if you ignored the fact he kept all the curtains and windows shut 24/7. I got so worried about the place I asked him to leave so I could sell it (I was done being a landlord by this time). When I got flat back all the floorboards had swollen up with the lack of ventilation and when I opened all the windows etc and they went back to their normal size there was gaps between all the floorboards. This was an absolutely immaculate flat furnished to a really high standard that came with absolutely everything the tenant could need. I even bought them a coffee machine and provided sheets /duvets etc. I gave them lovely dishes and a expensive sofa. I wanted them to enjoy living there and was happy to provide a really lovely flat in return for good tenants. It just didn't work out. I sold it at closing date with 7 offers within a week of it going on the market as it was a lovely flat.

I know my tales are minor and in landlord terms these are probably not really awful stories but the point is even the 'nice' people who I interviewed and seemed suitable and took references up etc just didn't look after the place.

I would never, ever be a landlord again. It was stressful and very time consuming and everything seemed stacked against the landlord.

JudgeAnderson · 27/07/2023 11:41

@GenieGenealogy exactly. That choice and flexibility is gone.

YouHaveAnArse · 27/07/2023 11:33

Not all landlords, obv. And nobody expects a landlord to be a charitable concer. But if you've ever rented you know exactly the kind of people I mean.

YouHaveAnArse · 27/07/2023 11:32

The problem is that the dodgy flats aren't cheap anymore. If you're paying 50% of your income on your housing, or more, and you have something with mice/mould/water dripping through the ceiling AND the possibility of having to move within two months and/or face a rent hike, then standards are great.

There are a lot of landlords who have taken advantage of cheap interest rates and what's effectively a captive market to increase their wealth/investments, but not realised or acknowledged that they are also providing a service and need to take on the responsibilites that involves. These types of landlords treat tenants as a terrible inconvenience and not as clients or customers, which we all somehow accept despite this being something that would fail quickly in any other business. Imagine a restaurant where they never cleaned the dishes or refrigerated the food properly and if you were to complain the response would be 'well, you still get to eat, right? We're actually taking a risk in letting you sit in three inches of water during the meal and people don't acknowledge that. Oh, and when you come tomorrow it's going to cost you twice as much.'

onefinemess · 27/07/2023 11:07

The reason for all this regulation is to inflate house prices. No rentals means no choice but to buy.

I am struggling to understand why people wanted controls on rented homes and landlords, could they not see it would make things worse, not better?

When I was in Uni 20 years ago, I could literally open the back of the student rag, phone a number, and move in THAT day. Yes, it may well have been a converted garage, with questionable plumbing, but it would be cheap! And would be a mine.

Can't do that anymore.

What's the point of having all these standards around insulation and shit, when nobody can afford the rent?

Fucking self-defeating, or what!

I'd rather have a dodgy, cheap flat than be homeless of living with parents.

Swipe left for the next trending thread