Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think rental policy is stifling the market

142 replies

Bunny44 · 26/07/2023 09:38

I'm wondering if all this rental regulation is actually doing more harm than good to the supply of rental homes. I say this as someone who rented for years before buying and definitely suffered at the hands of bad landlords, but now I think that there is maybe too much regulation and it could be putting potential landlords off. In London where I live, demand is outstripping supply and pushing up prices.

For personal reasons I'm having to move out my home which I own and I was considering putting it on the rental market to cover my mortgage. I got quotes from estate agents which sounded insanely high, but when I tabled the rough costs:
40% tax on total rent minus the below costs:
Estate agency management fees
Electricity & gas safety certificates
EICR
Inventory & Check In
Tenancy agreement cost

I was only just going to break-even (n.b. you cannot offset your mortgage anymore).

While I was weighing up this and working out, my area has introduced new licencing for landlords which costs £900 and could be denied! Now at this point I felt like it wasn't worth the headache.

There's also the consideration that other new regulation makes it hard to give tenants notice, so if I need to move back into my property or sell it then I might not be able to easily. And that's if you don't encounter problematic tenants.

I can totally see why landlords are being put off and this probably isn't helping supply.

I'm not sure if the purpose is to force landlords to sell, but for instance I can't sell as I'm in the middle of a 5 year mortgage term and I'm not ready to buy another place yet.

Instead I'm looking at doing Air bnb or something like that which I've done before and found it easy and profitable.

I rented out a flat before and think I'm a good landlord - I make sure everything is taken care of super quick and look after my tenants. My house would have made a lovely long term rental and I know there is demand, but I just don't think I can afford to do it and I'm worried about the hassle as well.

OP posts:
Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 17:34

motherofbantams · 27/07/2023 16:50

For us, as well as the break even, it was now being forced to allow pets. We had one tenant whose dogs chewed the place up. The max deposit did not even touch the damage. So yes, another property off the rental market.

Didn't know you can be forced to allow pets? What legislation does that come under?

OP posts:
Labtastic · 27/07/2023 17:33

Got it - thanks for explaining, was confused by that!

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 17:31

Labtastic · 27/07/2023 16:33

Sorry if I've missed it, but if you've been made redundant and can't afford to pay your mortgage so have to move out, why would you be paying 40% tax on the rent? Surely you can't be a higher earner in the circumstances you've described above?

Because I am still earning the rest of the year, first 6 weeks mat leave @ 90% + the gross rental income is very high (but so are the costs as I live in Zone 1 of London). I will have around 4 months where I'll be taking home £400 after tax (yes you still get taxed on statutary maternity pay), whereas my mortgage + bills is around £2000 and this is why I need to rent out my place.

OP posts:
Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 17:25

Elphame · 27/07/2023 16:16

Nothing is private nowadays. Your lender details are obtainable from Land Registry.

I'm going to take the risk knowing my neighbours, but thank you :-)

OP posts:
motherofbantams · 27/07/2023 16:50

For us, as well as the break even, it was now being forced to allow pets. We had one tenant whose dogs chewed the place up. The max deposit did not even touch the damage. So yes, another property off the rental market.

MarySmit · 27/07/2023 16:48

What a lot of people fail to realise is that waging war on landlords, results in waging war on tenants. Without landlords, there are no properties to rent. I know lots of people struggling to find anywhere to live. They are bidding on rentals but they are going within a day of going on the market, as there are dozens of potential tenants for each property. It's resulting in homelessness, as people evicted from rentals due to landlords selling cannot find anywhere else to live. The current rules benefit no one.

FrippEnos · 27/07/2023 16:38

The problem as I see it isn't that its regulated, it needs to be for the benefit of both the landlord and tennet.

Its that far to many people are trying to take money out of a limited financial pool.

I do find it telling that some posters are complaining about gas and electric certificates, as all properties that are renting should be safe and habitable.

Labtastic · 27/07/2023 16:33

Sorry if I've missed it, but if you've been made redundant and can't afford to pay your mortgage so have to move out, why would you be paying 40% tax on the rent? Surely you can't be a higher earner in the circumstances you've described above?

Elphame · 27/07/2023 16:16

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 14:54

I'm good friends with my neighbours and they're very nice people so they'd just message me if there was an issue. Also they don't even know who my mortgage provider is.

Nothing is private nowadays. Your lender details are obtainable from Land Registry.

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 15:52

@Tracker1234 so it looks like even professional landlords are being put off!!

OP posts:
Tracker1234 · 27/07/2023 15:38

I would never never be a landlord myself. Its just too much hassle and upset. The colleague I used to work with was a BTL landord with one 2 bed house and again she said never again!

Lottaflowers · 27/07/2023 15:35

We rented our house out as a long term let when we moved far away and had to rent there in the first instance. Setting up our house to rent out was a complete nightmare, so many things to put in place and hoops to jump through (some sensible, some ridiculous. Next they'll be asking that landlords pad the walls and remove any hard surfaces so the tenants aren't in danger of stubbing their toes or other such minor injuries!).
We weren't professional landlords with a huge portfolio, and we didn't own more than one house at any time. Luckily we ended up with lovely tenants and everything went smoothly, but I counted down the days until we could stop being landlords and just get back to normal - living in the one house that we owned. Our tenants ended up buying our house off us so we didn't have to evict them, thank goodness as they were so nice I would have felt awful doing it.
I never ever want to be a landlord again, it's just not worth the hassle.

Tracker1234 · 27/07/2023 15:33

Thinking of the 40 plus apartment rentals we have offered where I have worked over the last 4 years at least 80% of them are either:

  1. Trashed and various items left in situ. Dirty scummy duvets, food left in oven, fridge disgusting and manky marks on the beds
  2. Complete pig sty when tenant moves out having never been cleaned
  3. Damaged items with scrape marks all over the walls, or hair curlers left on resulting in burned carpet. One particular unit was inspected half way through tenancy and you couldnt get into the second bedroom it was so full of dirty underwear, clothes piled up in corners and the bed a complete disgrace. She was reminded to keep the place tidy and she said it was....
  4. Stolen items and on one particular occasion the tenant had used the curtain as toilet paper. He then found a old towel of his and used that too leaving it for the letting agent to find
  5. Yes, there is a damage deposit but that very very rarely covers the damage
Most important of all if the tenant finds they cannot afford the apartment they are told to stay where they are until evitcted which is months and months.

We are developers and we have decided not to do any more rentals. The law is just too much on the side of the tenant whether they pay their rent or not

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 15:33

Zipps · 27/07/2023 15:17

Shelter and the like have pushed for this, problem is they don't provide any accomodation and only see the tenants point of view.
Rogue landlords and accidental landlords are the issue but all landlords are being lumped together. We've just sold one of ours to our tenants because that was our plan once we retired. Once that money has run out we're selling the next one and those tenants already know that they will get first offer so they are saving up the deposit now.
It's been worth it for capital appreciation and rental income and if you understand the business and are young enough it is still viable. Human nature means that people jump on the bandwagon in droves but when one jumps off lots of others do because they don't have their own plan and so panic. It's going to be terrible for renters, not enough properties to go round as it stands now. We have new tenants in one of ours and they were so grateful because they have a dog and we're given two months notice because their landlords decided to sell and we had 11 people wanting it.

I don't think it's about people jumping on or off the bandwagon - it's about the fact it's not really a viable anymore.

Also those saying it's private landlords that are the issue. I'm still yet to come across these 'corporate' landlords referenced - any examples of companies which do this? The other 3 houses near me are all rented out via individual landlords and the tenants are very happy - they said they fix issues quickly and keep the rent pretty low as they prefer to have long term decent tenants rather than impose high rental increases.

Also nobody has spoken about the properties being bought up by foreign investors who often aren't subject to the same rules and are happy to leave them empty.

According to stats in London alone there are 30,000 empty homes.

OP posts:
Zipps · 27/07/2023 15:17

Shelter and the like have pushed for this, problem is they don't provide any accomodation and only see the tenants point of view.
Rogue landlords and accidental landlords are the issue but all landlords are being lumped together. We've just sold one of ours to our tenants because that was our plan once we retired. Once that money has run out we're selling the next one and those tenants already know that they will get first offer so they are saving up the deposit now.
It's been worth it for capital appreciation and rental income and if you understand the business and are young enough it is still viable. Human nature means that people jump on the bandwagon in droves but when one jumps off lots of others do because they don't have their own plan and so panic. It's going to be terrible for renters, not enough properties to go round as it stands now. We have new tenants in one of ours and they were so grateful because they have a dog and we're given two months notice because their landlords decided to sell and we had 11 people wanting it.

Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 14:59

bingoitsadingo · 27/07/2023 14:30

When you say "break even", presumably you mean in terms of covering your mortgage payment. That's not "breaking even" - you're still building equity, and that equity is your profit.

I don't actually have a problem with small-scale landlords, I've rented from several and they've been great, but they all took a long-term view of the finances, not a short term one.

Refer back to my previous post regarding other costs a LL takes on.

OP posts:
Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 14:58

Ginmonkeyagain · 27/07/2023 13:50

I literally have no issue with small or large landlord making a profit out of renting out property. It is a business after all.

I have an issue if they are shit and sadly too many small time landlords are just shit. Often they don't mean to be but because they are under capitalised or don't see it as a business but a pension etc..

Tbh I don't even know any properties not run by private landlords? What is a corporate landlord?

You seem quite fixated on this - what's your expertise in this area?

OP posts:
Bunny44 · 27/07/2023 14:54

Elphame · 27/07/2023 14:19

I've requested a consent to let which my mortgage provider allows. Doesn't allow Air bnb but to be honest I'm not sure how they'd find out. Sure their priority is me not defaulting on my mortgage anyway.

Disgruntled neighbour hating the noise and disruption?

And if they do find out they could require immediate repayment of your mortgage.

Apparently also breaching your mortgage conditions will also invalidate your insurance (https://uk.virginmoney.com/brighter-money/does-airbnb-break-your-mortgage-rules/ )

I'm good friends with my neighbours and they're very nice people so they'd just message me if there was an issue. Also they don't even know who my mortgage provider is.

OP posts:
Franga41 · 27/07/2023 14:44

Regardless of whether you think that’s fair @bingoitsadingo , small scale landlords do actually have to live still! If they’re making a massive loss on a monthly basis, long term equity is kind of irrelevant as to whether they can continue to do it. You’re assuming they are well off day to day in their own right and can take the hit short term. If they can’t, they’ll just have to stop and take any equity they have now (and that’s not a given at all these days, especially where Capital Gains Tax doesn’t actually recognise a lot in terms of the money you may have put into a property).

You may think that morally that is right, and that’s a matter for debate, but the reality is they are leaving the market and supply is on its knees. Maybe small time/accidental landlords should be pushed out and the whole system should be transformed top to bottom, but nobody is doing that, so doing the former without the latter is just going to make matters worse for renters - and it is, we can all see that.

The EPC requirements are going to have a crazy impact, while an admirable goal most of our housing stock does not meet a C standard, my owned house does not, nothing I saw when looking for my home did. If it’s going to cost 20,000 or so to upgrade, where is that money going to come from, particularly if landlords are making a loss day to day?

JudgeAnderson · 27/07/2023 14:36

When you say "break even", presumably you mean in terms of covering your mortgage payment. That's not "breaking even" - you're still building equity, and that equity is your profit.

There's still their time though - people in any other industry rightfully expect to get paid for or making a profit on that.

bingoitsadingo · 27/07/2023 14:30

When you say "break even", presumably you mean in terms of covering your mortgage payment. That's not "breaking even" - you're still building equity, and that equity is your profit.

I don't actually have a problem with small-scale landlords, I've rented from several and they've been great, but they all took a long-term view of the finances, not a short term one.

Franga41 · 27/07/2023 14:19

@CeciliaMars I think it's completely right that you can't offset your mortgage against tax

you never could. You could offset the interest - so you were always paying the capital off yourself, it was the cost of servicing the loan that you could claim.

regardless of what you think about this, a large proportion of landlords in this country are private owners renting out their own home, not a second home, and do actually need to cover their costs if they are to do so. You have to pay your mortgage, so if the interest cannot be offset, you often end up paying money to HMRC that you have never actually received. If you need to rent elsewhere as I did, you come out way worse off than if you’d stayed in their mortgaged home.

If it’s a buy to let that’s just an investment and you are a limited company then that’s slightly different - but the irony is that those people actually can still get the interest offset!

I know many people who have needed to rent out their homes for a period recently - divorce, care for parents, need to move location, can’t sell right now etc - and none of them are doing it because of all the costs and barriers.

Elphame · 27/07/2023 14:19

I've requested a consent to let which my mortgage provider allows. Doesn't allow Air bnb but to be honest I'm not sure how they'd find out. Sure their priority is me not defaulting on my mortgage anyway.

Disgruntled neighbour hating the noise and disruption?

And if they do find out they could require immediate repayment of your mortgage.

Apparently also breaching your mortgage conditions will also invalidate your insurance (https://uk.virginmoney.com/brighter-money/does-airbnb-break-your-mortgage-rules/ )

https://www.virginmoney.com/img/img-bm--does-airbnb-break-your-mortgage-rules--1x1_tcm142-112189.jpg

Does Airbnb break your mortgage rules? | Brighter Money | Virgin Money UK

Extra cash for letting out rooms is great, but becoming an Airbnb “hotelier” isn’t always as straightforward as it seems

https://uk.virginmoney.com/brighter-money/does-airbnb-break-your-mortgage-rules

Franga41 · 27/07/2023 14:08

You’re completely right, even though that’s a very unpopular opinion these days. It doesn’t make sense to do it anymore - and of course you become somewhat of a hate figure too! I’ve rented my place out a couple of times while working abroad and I would never do it again. On top of everything you mention you need to factor in a large capital gains tax bill when you come to sell because rental relief has been taken away (retrospectively too) so I as a not high earning single mum was landed with a bill for thousands because of rental periods that at the time were exempted.

of course there are terrible landlords and perhaps the entire sector needs a complete reform so that it something that people invest into but run by say a social entity. I don’t know. But if you take the existing system and just make it much more difficult and costly for landlords, of course it is going to strangle supply - and that is exactly what we are seeing right now. Unintended consequences etc…