Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

stuck between daughter and husband

211 replies

mrspointi · 26/07/2023 07:53

My daughter is due to give birth in 4 ish weeks. Her fiancé is currently away and is returning days before the due date. Our daughter has asked us to be on call for her while he is away. This weekend dh wants to go to a cinema showing 45 minutes away on Saturday night. My daughter is very upset about this and says the cinema he’s chosen (old style one) is in the opposite direction to the hospital which is already 40 minutes away from her home, and so if she needed us it would be an hour and a half at least before she got to the hospital. I have tried to reassure her that even if she went into labour she probably wouldn’t need to go in straight away especially as it’s her first baby. I’ve also told her she’s more likely to go over the due date than have the baby early. DH has lost his cool with her and thinks she’s not a teenager and in her thirties she could call an ambulance if things were desperate. I’ve suggested to DH we go to the cinema after the birth but then the film he wants to see won’t be on. I know our daughter is being very over the top but I also understand the stress she is under and wonder if we should just accept it for now given how close it is to the birth. If I say that though, DH just despairs and will think we are giving in to silly demands. Would you just stick to the plans and go out as it’s only a few hours?

OP posts:
Iwanderedlonelyasagoat · 26/07/2023 17:16

I'm 40 weeks pregnant and my mum will be looking after my toddler during childbirth. She went to a wedding last weekend which was fine - I just had neighbours that I'm friends with on standby - does she have anything like this, or close friends near? I really wouldn't have said anything about my mum's plan unless she, e.g. told me right at the last minute she was going on holiday or something.

lovenotwar149 · 26/07/2023 17:03

Is your DH your daughters father?

Brightandshining · 26/07/2023 17:01

Your daughter is being ridiculous but I've put YANBU just because she's probably very scared if this is her first baby... so of course as her mother you want to help her be calm by guaranteeing you will be available for her. I think your husbands reaction is also ridiculous tbh. He's right that she is basically worrying about nothing but to get angry with your frightened pregnant daughter is pretty shit. Doesnt matter if she's 30 she's never given birth before and is very anxious.
Why does your husband absolutely need your company to go see this film? Can he not go by himself so you can be on call to reassure your daughter? Of course you won't really need to drive her to the hospital as you are right she's much more likely to be overdue... but it would be kind of you to placate her. I dont agree with other posters that her anxiety will magically dissappear if you ignore it. She clearly needs your support and to feel like someone is there for her. She probably needs that more than your husband needs company to see this film in the cinema.

lovenotwar149 · 26/07/2023 17:00

Don't tell her you're going

Someone else suggested not telling her. I think this isn't the way to build trust in a relationship. Make your decision and stay frank about it I say

Loverofoxbowlakes · 26/07/2023 16:57

Fuck me op, it's weeks away and she's very likely to go past her due date.

Unless there have been complications in pregnancy, and she has been told that her birth is likely to be an emergency then 90 minutes is plenty of time to get to hospital for a first baby.

What would she do if you were at work or at the doctors or supermarket? Has she got you on house arrest?

Go to the cinema. Don't tell her you're going, and switch your phone to mute. You're going to have your hands full in the next few weeks/nonths/years....

Cornishclio · 26/07/2023 16:56

Cinema is hardly critical and given she is only 2 weeks away and presumably has no one else I would find a closer cinema. It is a bit precious to insist on a particular cinema so I think your husband is being a bit of a pain.

Amberjane41 · 26/07/2023 16:54

Taking your partner out of the equation. If this same scenario were you going with a friend and your daughter asked you not to. Would you still go?
I think your daughter is being unreasonable but she is pregnant and scared and I really wouldn’t choose a film over her if it was me. As that’s how she will be viewing it right now. I’d stay home but I would also tell her she’s being a tad dramatic and try and have a laugh about it! Let us know what you decide!

TimeToMoveIt · 26/07/2023 16:54

Bloody hell, some people's partners work further away than that . It's unlikely to happen when you are at the cinema. It's even more unlikely that you won't have time to get to her long before she needs the hospital

saoirse31 · 26/07/2023 16:54

Worst case scenario she can get a taxi surely. But tbf also, sometimes first babies can arrive both early and quickly!!

tattygrl · 26/07/2023 16:54

The more snarky part of me also wants to say that your husband isn't a teenager any more, and that surely the days of prioritising a movie at the cinema over a request from his daughter are behind him...

lovenotwar149 · 26/07/2023 16:54

First I don't have a daughter who is almost due. Lucky u!

DH has lost his cool with her and thinks she’s not a teenager

Ideally your DH wouldn't lose his cool with her. Rather calmly explain what his perspective is on this situation.She is a grown up about to give birth to her first child.
This in my opinion is about your relationship with her and how u show up for her. if she is used to making requests (demands?) like this then she's just behaving how she usually does I assume.
It seems perfectly safe for you to go to the cinema under the circumstances (I am a mother of 3) but if she is anxious , she may not think so.
Perhaps if u do decide to go to the cinema, she has a friend who is nearby that she feels she could call incase anything happens? That might leave her with a safer feeling?

tattygrl · 26/07/2023 16:53

To me, it comes down to the fact that you agreed to be on call. If you think it's ridiculous to need to be on call, nearby and available at this time, why did you agree to it? I also think your husband is being needlessly callous. It's understandable that you both feel your daughter is being over-anxious, but saying "she's not a teenager any more, she can get an ambulance if she needs to" is a little bit eyebrow-raising to me. I think a bit of extra love and care wouldn't go amiss here.

NumberTheory · 26/07/2023 16:50

Is she really expecting you to be less than 45 minutes away for the next 4 - 6 weeks? How close does she think you should be?

My DH was an hour away every weekday until I gave birth. It didn’t occur to me that it would be a problem. I assumed there’d be time and in the unlikely case there wasn’t, I’d call emergency services.

I think you should go to the cinema, but also, since she’s anxious about the pregnancy, maybe try and spend a bit more time with her providing a calm, reasonable voice to counter her fears when she gets anxious.

Ponoka7 · 26/07/2023 16:40

Fwiw, my DD had her first within three hours, it was a home birth and needed pain relief and a MW within an hour of me arriving. I was just talking about the lack of care and thought towards women the other day. Previous generations had friends and family (who were neighbours) around them. The more care a woman gets, the better her and the baby's health is.

Beachwalker66 · 26/07/2023 16:36

I wouldn’t go. I would convince myself something would happen with DD and I wouldn’t be able to enjoy the film anyway.

Just get DH to go on his own, it’s no big deal surely? Is DH the father of your DD?

Ponoka7 · 26/07/2023 16:35

I was my DD'S birth partner, as well as her DP. In the last two weeks I wasn't more than about 40 minutes away. I wouldn't tell a relative to get a taxi, alone, for any other medical procedure that is as difficult as birth, so why would I tell my DD that? I remember going in by myself, to just get my tonsils out and I was the only one alone. Births can be two weeks either way, so she's entered the time that birth is likely. You need to clarify if there was another cinema closer, or if your DH is generally dismissive when it's something women go through. Isolation increases anxiety and increases the likelihood of PND, I wouldn't be subjecting my DD to those risks. Is it your DH who has put in your head that she has a month to go? Now you've worked out it's two weeks, are you rethinking things?

ChildrenOfRuin · 26/07/2023 16:29

Logically the odds are that you’d be fine going to the cinema without there being a problem. Even though she must be 38 weeks along now, if the baby’s due in the second week of August.

But it’s her first baby, she’s clearly anxious, so under the circumstances I’d personally either cancel the cinema trip, or rearrange it for a cinema nearer her home.

FWIW, while I started having contractions about 20 hours before I gave birth to DC1, it took me about 16 hours to work out that the pains I was feeling might be related to being in labour.
DC1 was back to back, so the contractions just felt like a weird intermittent backache until things were quite well advanced.

shakeitoffsis · 26/07/2023 16:13

your daughter is being totally unreasonable. Enjoy the film.

Hankunamatata · 26/07/2023 16:13

I wouldn't have told her you were going to the cinema. She doesn't need to know your exact location for the next month

Hankunamatata · 26/07/2023 16:12

She's stressed and worried but being unreasonable. My dh worked away until a week before my due date. If I'd gone into labour I was getting an taxi to hospital.

gloriawasright · 26/07/2023 16:08

She is 38 weeks now ?
My dd gave birth at 38weeks,labour was 1.5 hours .
You can see a movie any time,give your dd peace of mind and bin the movie.
Hormones are all over the place at this stage,cut her some slack and let her have a stress free weekend .

Sigmama · 26/07/2023 15:15

Next time don't tell her, she is ott

Bansheed · 26/07/2023 15:15

This has depressed the hell put of me. It is pretty much 'women gave birth in rice fields and carried on to work a full day with no bother'..

This is one of the most alienating times in human history to be pregnant. I have had three, worked, had nannies and am definitely one of life's serious copers.

However, I wouldn't even think twice to be around a 1st time pregnant mother at 37 weeks, as her support and alter plans accordingly.

And I think your DH is being a dick to think otherwise.

FTR, with out medically intervention, 1 out of 10 women died and 3 out of 10 were permanently injured. ( remember these stats from a study in Yemen about 20 years ago).

Birth is a common process, many sail through, but not humdrum, nor without risk (1 brain injury and 1 lung injury and 1 text book healthy, out of my births in leading, teaching hospitals)

Cas112 · 26/07/2023 14:37

Your daughter is being highly unreasonable

Bouledeneige · 26/07/2023 13:49

Your DD is being ridiculous. Is she expecting you not to go out at all? What's stopping her getting a taxi in the unlikely event she has to rush at the precise moment you or your DH are in the cinema?

Sounds like quite a precious, I mean anxious, first time Mother.