Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask them to pay to replace my phone screen?

357 replies

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 01:08

Today at work while walking the dogs, one of them knocked it out of my hand. The screen is totally smashed and my phone is unusable. (I don't normally have it out but was trying to answer a call from my GP). I'm a private Housekeeper and walking the dogs is part of my job.

It's not insured - I've never had a phone damaged and tbh since my partner passed, money has been so tight it was an expense I couldn't afford. It's going to be at least £140 to replace the screen. (Google Pixel 6) It had a good case and screen protector but landed on a brick path.

Wibu to ask the family to either pay or claim off their house insurance? I'm using an old one at the moment but it's 3g so can't make calls!

OP posts:
rookiemere · 26/07/2023 09:33

You could ask for an advance from your salary.
But my guess is if they are moneyed people they'll just tut tut at you having an expensive phone without knowing it wasn't bought by you.

As a by the by shocked by how much it costs to get a google pixel screen replacement. I got my cracked iPhone 11 repaired for £65.

Quveas · 26/07/2023 09:33

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 08:53

Such hyperbole!

The was no one around to attack. I was on the estate where the house is, next to one of the lawns. Dog jumped at me as I got my phone out to answer and it dropped straight down onto the brick path. They're gundogs and I'm not tall!

My slot was for between 9-12. Not taking them out unfortunately isn't an option - my employer is fine with me taking calls while out with them (and I'd say there's an expectation that I'd answer the phone while out because I can be 10-20mins away from the house while walking the dogs!) And unfortunately I've lost that appointment now and will have to go through the process again - you only get one chance to answer!

If I'm getting grumpy it's because I'm sick of people inventing stories! It's not being told I'm unreasonable, it's people making stuff up then telling me I'm wrong.

It doesn't matter where you are - it is your responsibility to control the dogs, and if you are unable to do so then you should be telling your employers that - not whining about how it isn't your fault that you dropped the phone that you didn't insure on a path when walking dogs that you don't have under control. I am fairly positive that other people will be on the estate - you know, like others workers, mailworkers, delivery drivers etc. When responsible for dogs it does not matter where you are - you are responsible for their behaviour. And if you cannot do that then you should be explaining to your employer why you are unable to do as they ask. I repeat, if the dogs attacked someone - or even jumped up and caused injury - whilst under your control, then you are responsible for that. your attention should be on the dogs and not your phone. People on private property are still responsible for what their dogs do to others.

Also, if they are actual gundogs, then they definitely shouldn't be jumping up at anyone.

You are being grumpy because the vast majority of people can see that you are being unreasonable and are telling you so - you have argued with everyone why it wasn't your fault. It was.

Summerishere123 · 26/07/2023 09:30

I think if the dogs chewed your phone or similar then you could ask. But dropping it because they "bumped" you isn't going to fly.

Orangey25 · 26/07/2023 09:30

God, why are you being so rude to people who reply to you.
Face it, it was your fault.

SheRaaaaa · 26/07/2023 09:27

I think they should pay, or at least contribute a large chunk of the cost.

It happened at work on their time, walking thier dogs.

Its not unreasonable to take a call at work, at all.

Gatehouse77 · 26/07/2023 09:12

I’d ask but with no expectation that they would agree. Not because it’s unreasonable given it was a work place accident and you weren’t doing anything that hadn’t been agreed previously. But because they simply don’t agree, can’t be bothered with the admin or don’t care.

Also, how they react (not necessarily the outcome) will give you a sense of what working for them means long term.

Having worked as a nanny it’s ridiculously reductive of people to say you shouldn’t have been on your phone to make a medical appointment when it’s only possible to do during your working hours!

However, whilst I can see, from your perspective, it’s the dog that caused the problem, equally, from their perspective, it’s because you didn’t pick a moment when the dogs weren’t nearby. It’s not necessarily as clear cut as you want it to be.

Howmanyweekz · 26/07/2023 09:12

Sorry OP - I think you would be unreasonable to ask them to pay for your phone

it maybe be cheaper to look for a refurbished phone instead ?

Anewuser · 26/07/2023 09:01

You know you’re unreasonable.

You have every excuse under the sun: important call, GP, unruly dogs, allowed personal calls, poor quality screen protector and cover.

Why ask if you don’t accept the responses.

Ask your employer then, they can only say no.

The dogs are probably excited to be going on a walk, rather than unruly. Consider carrying your phone in a bag across your body and using earbuds, in future. Then you can answer your calls without dropping your phone and your hands are free to hold the dogs leads. Consider getting a gorilla case for your phone, they are military grade so will protect your phone.

FatAgainItsLettuceTime · 26/07/2023 09:01

No you can't ask them to pay, dogs pull and jump and run, you had your phone in your hand and weren't holding it tight enough so an accident happened and it fell and by bad luck the screen broke.

By your logic the GP could be given responsibility for it because they called when you weee walking dogs.

The only one who had any ability to prevent the accident was you, the dogs don't know how phones work or that they're breakable so could control their actions, the owners didn't know you'd be on the phone and the GP didn't know you were walking dogs.

neveradullmoment99 · 26/07/2023 08:59

It was an accident, unfortunately. To ask them to pay for the damage is really cheeky. It will damage your relationship. You just need to pay for it yourself.

EarringsandLipstick · 26/07/2023 08:58

No, you can't ask them to pay. The same as if you worked in an office and dropped your phone while doing a work task.

I don't think you did anything wrong by taking the call, but it's not your employer's responsibility to pay for your damaged phone.

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 08:56

GrumpyPanda · 26/07/2023 08:35

Agree with asking if they'd cover it as a courtesy and/or check into insurance coverage.

That aside, longer term it sounds like you're spending way more on your phone than you have to or can afford to. I take it you had the Google Pixel as part of a subscription? Once it expires, much more sensible to hang on to your existing phone/buy an entry level phone outright and go to a basic calling plan/prepaid phone card that doesn't include a handset. There are perfectly decent phones on the market that cost between 100 to 200. I've been on a Galaxy A20 for 3 years now, won't replace until I run into memory or app update issues, and my monthly bills are negligible.

I spend £7 a month on my sim. The physical phone was a gift from a friend when she upgraded her contract.

OP posts:
Thelonelygiraffe · 26/07/2023 08:55

I think people are being really harsh here. I don't think OP was being U to be answering a call from her GP when she was walking the dogs. It wasn't doing any harm.

Op, I'd talk to your employer, see what they say. Maybe suggest you go half's on repairing your phone?

PinkIcedCream · 26/07/2023 08:53

Yes, I think you should ask them to pay.

Replace badly trained dog with “their Toddler who was being especially boisterous knocked your phone out of your hand”.

Surely in that situation, you’d reasonably expect the employer to pay. Their unruly dog caused the accident and as they know their dogs are not particularly well behaved, they must expect to pay for any damage the dogs cause?

ImNotReallySpartacus · 26/07/2023 08:53

That was unfortunate, but whilst it's your employer's dog, you were in control of it at the time. Boisterous animals and expensive equipment don't mix well.

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 08:53

Quveas · 26/07/2023 08:10

Sorry, but the OP was not "walking the dogs". They were at work. And therefore should not have taken a personal call unless it was safe and sensible to do so. Supervising dogs is not a time when it is safe or sensible to do so. And I am not one of the "MN dog-hating brigade". But I am fed up to the back teeth of people who are "walking their dogs" completely unsupervised whilst they are on the phone. If the owners dogs had attacked someone whilst she was on the phone, most people here would be screaming blue murder about not properly controlling the dogs. The fact that they jumped up at her (i.e. not under control) and she dropped her phone was a direct consequence of her not giving her attention to her job. Her fault.

Such hyperbole!

The was no one around to attack. I was on the estate where the house is, next to one of the lawns. Dog jumped at me as I got my phone out to answer and it dropped straight down onto the brick path. They're gundogs and I'm not tall!

My slot was for between 9-12. Not taking them out unfortunately isn't an option - my employer is fine with me taking calls while out with them (and I'd say there's an expectation that I'd answer the phone while out because I can be 10-20mins away from the house while walking the dogs!) And unfortunately I've lost that appointment now and will have to go through the process again - you only get one chance to answer!

If I'm getting grumpy it's because I'm sick of people inventing stories! It's not being told I'm unreasonable, it's people making stuff up then telling me I'm wrong.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 26/07/2023 08:50

Perhaps the wider question is are you getting paid fairly for your job.

I'd expect a fair bit above minimum wage if dog walking large unruly dogs was part of my core job description. I'd also worry about the insurance implications if they hurt someone in your care.

There may be other more suitable jobs, as others have said are there additional benefits you are entitled to. Could you rent out a room or a garage/driveway or increase your income in amy other way ?

Sonyrec · 26/07/2023 08:45

Of course it's your fault and your responsibility to pay for repairs. However as you're tight on funds, you can get really great deals on up to date refurbished phones on GiffGaff. I've got a high spec Oppo phone for £8 per month over 24 months. Maybe worth thinking about options before you pay to repair?

Acourtof · 26/07/2023 08:43

Totally understand needing to take a GP call at work. I did the same yesterday.

I think you’re responsible for your own phone too. I wouldn’t be impressed if an employee asked me to replace their phone screen in these circumstances. Even if I said yes, it would impact the relationship going forward.

Moveoverdarlin · 26/07/2023 08:42

There is no way you can ask your employers to cover the cost of your broken phone in this instance. It will make you appear completely unprofessional and on the take. For all they know you dropped it at home that morning.

It’s like breaking the heel off your shoe when getting off a train for a work meeting and asking work to buy new shoes or pay for heel repairs. It’s just life, shit happens, things break.

If you like the job, don’t do this.

Screwballs · 26/07/2023 08:41

Ilovelurchers · 26/07/2023 05:45

OP, I think you are getting some quire harsh answers on here, possibly in part because the site tends to have quite a right wing bias and not a huge amount of sympathy with the rights of workers. (Not saying this is why everybody is being harsh by the way - maybe some of the people being harsh are committed socialists - I cannot know....)

Anyway, it's totally irrelevant what all these people on here think - what really matters is what your employers think. Because I doubt they are legally obliged to pay you, but they are presumably wealthy (affording large dogs and a housekeeper). If I was in their position, and I knew my employee was struggling financially, and she broke her phone due to the behaviour of my dogs, I wouldn't hesitate to pay for it, yes.

Not because I was obliged to. But I would believe it was the kind, and therefore right, thing to do.

You may as well ask them. They may feel the same. Unless they are likely to take against you due to the request. Only you can judge that really - we don't know them.

LOL @ everyone is being mean cause politics.

People are being harsh because she sounds bloody entitled. Her responses are rude.

Soothingaftersun · 26/07/2023 08:41

I would tell them what happened and that the phone is broken and see what they say. If they are a wealthy family and value you as an employee they may offer to pay as a good will gesture.

Mumofsend · 26/07/2023 08:38

You can't ask them to replace it because you were using it whilst walking dogs and happened to drop it.

Rubytoos · 26/07/2023 08:37

I think this probably opens up a bigger question around what your normal duties are and whether you are properly employed. Does your family have insurance for you, say if you have an accident at theirs and have to have time off work?

Swipe left for the next trending thread