Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask them to pay to replace my phone screen?

357 replies

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 01:08

Today at work while walking the dogs, one of them knocked it out of my hand. The screen is totally smashed and my phone is unusable. (I don't normally have it out but was trying to answer a call from my GP). I'm a private Housekeeper and walking the dogs is part of my job.

It's not insured - I've never had a phone damaged and tbh since my partner passed, money has been so tight it was an expense I couldn't afford. It's going to be at least £140 to replace the screen. (Google Pixel 6) It had a good case and screen protector but landed on a brick path.

Wibu to ask the family to either pay or claim off their house insurance? I'm using an old one at the moment but it's 3g so can't make calls!

OP posts:
Misty84 · 26/07/2023 10:06

Of course you can’t charge the family!! 🤦‍♀️

KingOfThieves · 26/07/2023 10:04

You chose to have your personal phone out at work - this is on you. As much as I understand why you needed it, it is still on you.

JennyJenny8675309 · 26/07/2023 10:02

I’m sorry it will be a financial strain to pay for the repair. I do think it’s your own responsibility though. I know it’s not what you want to hear, but you asked for opinions and now you have them.

Loulaa1977 · 26/07/2023 10:01

I wouldn't ask my employers to pay. It was an accident. I might mention that it happened it in conversation and you never know what they may offer, but asking outright will possibly end the working relationship.

I recently paid £60 for my son's iPhone x screen to be replaced so I definitely wouldn't be paying over the odds and would shop about.

Finally, I wouldn't ask an AIBU question on here and be rude to multiple responses 🤷‍♀️

Takoneko · 26/07/2023 10:01

I don’t think it’s reasonable to ask them to pay.

It’s a risk you take if you choose to use your personal phone for a personal call during the work day. I work in a school, if a child knocked my phone out of my hand on a busy corridor or in the lunch queue and it broke it would be annoying but I wouldn’t dream of asking my employer to pay for it. And if I did ask, I would expect to be told that I have my personal property on site at my own risk.

Dita73 · 26/07/2023 09:59

You must ask them to pay for it and then come back and tell us what they say. I could do with a laugh!

TheCrystalPalace · 26/07/2023 09:58

Wow, you've been given a right pasting on here by some. Unpleasant reading.
I think your best bet is to try to get a cheap repair/new screen until someone you know upgrades and can pass on another older model to you. I do agree that your employers aren't really liable for this one. It was an unfortunate accident.

And to those piling in about not taking calls when working, it's not like she's a teacher or conducting brain surgery. Not all jobs are the same and surely the OP knows if it was acceptable/allowable to take a GP's call at the time she did.

Hate MN for threads like this one. Full of people piling in to put the boot in for the sake of it.

RedHelenB · 26/07/2023 09:57

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 01:54

I'm so sorry, i didn't realise you worked in the same house as me!

The family are fine with me taking calls and unfortunately I don't get to decide when my GP rings!

You are paid to look after the dogs. If your full attention had been on them then the phone wouldn't have got damaged. 100% your fault I'm afraid.

BashfulClam · 26/07/2023 09:56

schnauzerbeard · 26/07/2023 06:06

You should have had a protective case

She did, did you read the OP?

Luxell934 · 26/07/2023 09:55

Sorry for your loss OP

I can understand why you would be annoyed that the dog knocked your phone out of your hands. But ultimately I don’t really think you could ask your employers to pay for the phone. You must have a general idea about what they are like so you probably know better than anyone how it might go down if you asked them. One option could be telling them that you are no longer able to walk the dogs as they are too unruly for you and explain what happened to your phone. They just might offer to help replace it, or they won’t. £140 is ridiculous for a phone screen, have you looked around in different shops?

I also understand about the GP call, I’ll often have to tell my boss I’m waiting for the doctor to call in work time. It’s either let me go for 5 mins to take a quick call or be off for the whole morning. I think most employers would rather you just take a quick call rather than be off all morning!

Grapewrath · 26/07/2023 09:54

Of course you’re unreasonable- you are walking two large dogs and answer a personal call. The dogs might be badly behaved but you didn’t have them under control while trying to answer your phone. You also agreed to walk the dogs knowing they are bouncy

If I was your employer I’d tell you to be more careful and make sure you have your own insurance

pontipinemum · 26/07/2023 09:53

It isn't really your employers fault or responsibility. It is very very annoying and unfortunate. And it being a personal call, you've said they don't mind. My employers don't mind either, and I have broken a phone at work before.

I wouldn't pay £140 to replace a screen though. How 'into' the phone are you? If not very I would go to the CEX shop and get a sim free phone. I've had a few phones from there they are very good and the warranty is usually 2 years (wouldn't have covered this though). Or go to an electrical shop and buy a new sim free phone

YarisKaris · 26/07/2023 09:52

Sympathise with the gp thing. Ours can ring anytime after the e consult to 6.30 the next day. It's a nightmare and then you get lectured if you were unable to pick up. I don't think you can ask your employers to pay though.

JenWillsiam · 26/07/2023 09:52

Of course YABU. You were at work. It was gracious of them to allow you to make personal calls but it doesn’t make them in anyway responsible for your phone.

almostoverthehill · 26/07/2023 09:49

You are being totally ridiculous

Catspyjamas17 · 26/07/2023 09:49

Sorry OP, while it's frustrating I think it's your fault for having it in your hand while you were wrangling dogs.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 26/07/2023 09:47

I do not think they are liable for the phone. But if repairing it leaves you in real hardship and you have a good relationship with your employers I’d ask them if they were in a position to replace it for you (or alternatively whether you could have an advance on your wages and pay them back in instalments). Only you know really whether your relationship would support such a request.

Ignore all the silly comments saying you should not have been using your phone at work. This was just an unfortunate accident. I don’t think anyone is to blame as such. If your employers are kind and value you they may well want to help. It sounds as though doing so would not be a financial burden on them.

DrSbaitso · 26/07/2023 09:47

It was an accident and it's not their responsibility. It's your phone and your personal call. Nothing wrong with you taking the call, but it isn't your employer's responsibility.

Check with your current account provider. They might offer phone insurance.

Catlady1978 · 26/07/2023 09:46

@Housekeeperbatcocoa if you were working then you aren’t being paid to take phone calls. I work and have to schedule these things around it, GP calls included. They are dogs and no doubt excitable. Take this one on the chin and insure your phone in future! Accidents happen and they aren’t always someone else’s fault!

vickylou78 · 26/07/2023 09:43

Yabu it's your personal phone and I assume you decided to try and do two things at the same time (dog walking and making a phone call). Your fault I'm afraid. See if you can get a refurbished mobile phone as a replacement.

Quveas · 26/07/2023 09:42

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 09:40

You're still making stuff up! It's a big farm in the middle of nowhere - I was the only person about!

Gosh - they have lawns (because you said that you were next to a lawn) in the middle of nowhere???? I have made nothing up. Because you do not see a person around (especially when you are looking at your phone and not what is around you) there can be people or animals or anything - you are not paying attention to the dogs and they are therefore not under control. Changing your story to fit your facts doesn't change any of that.

Quveas · 26/07/2023 09:40

PS - I have just googled your replacement screen for Pixel 6. DIY kit to do the job is 12.99 on eBay. I found a couple of places offering repairs for £37. If you shop around at smaller outlets they will often do the job for a fraction of the cost that the "official outlets" charge. My friends husband has one such shop and I just texted him the question - he says about £50 would be the going rate.

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 09:40

Quveas · 26/07/2023 09:33

It doesn't matter where you are - it is your responsibility to control the dogs, and if you are unable to do so then you should be telling your employers that - not whining about how it isn't your fault that you dropped the phone that you didn't insure on a path when walking dogs that you don't have under control. I am fairly positive that other people will be on the estate - you know, like others workers, mailworkers, delivery drivers etc. When responsible for dogs it does not matter where you are - you are responsible for their behaviour. And if you cannot do that then you should be explaining to your employer why you are unable to do as they ask. I repeat, if the dogs attacked someone - or even jumped up and caused injury - whilst under your control, then you are responsible for that. your attention should be on the dogs and not your phone. People on private property are still responsible for what their dogs do to others.

Also, if they are actual gundogs, then they definitely shouldn't be jumping up at anyone.

You are being grumpy because the vast majority of people can see that you are being unreasonable and are telling you so - you have argued with everyone why it wasn't your fault. It was.

You're still making stuff up! It's a big farm in the middle of nowhere - I was the only person about!

OP posts:
Enko · 26/07/2023 09:38

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 08:56

I spend £7 a month on my sim. The physical phone was a gift from a friend when she upgraded her contract.

Op could you ask them if their insurance may cover it as it was their dog. Softens the asking as you are not directly asking them to pay. May make them say ohh we will pay don't worry.

Beautiful3 · 26/07/2023 09:34

You could mention that it happened and see what they say.