Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask them to pay to replace my phone screen?

357 replies

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 26/07/2023 01:08

Today at work while walking the dogs, one of them knocked it out of my hand. The screen is totally smashed and my phone is unusable. (I don't normally have it out but was trying to answer a call from my GP). I'm a private Housekeeper and walking the dogs is part of my job.

It's not insured - I've never had a phone damaged and tbh since my partner passed, money has been so tight it was an expense I couldn't afford. It's going to be at least £140 to replace the screen. (Google Pixel 6) It had a good case and screen protector but landed on a brick path.

Wibu to ask the family to either pay or claim off their house insurance? I'm using an old one at the moment but it's 3g so can't make calls!

OP posts:
SunRainStorm · 28/07/2023 02:16

@Housekeeperbatcocoa I think we've got a bit hung up on whose fault it was.

It wasn't really anyone's fault. It was an accident. A variety of events (out for a walk, doctors call, unruly dogs, your hand/phone in the wrong place at the wrong time) occurred and it's really unlucky that your phone went flying and broke.

That's life, sometimes bad things happen that aren't our fault, and we have to pay to fix them anyway.

I wouldn't ask your employer, it's not their fault or responsibility.

Housekeeperbatcocoa · 27/07/2023 22:11

It's not that I can't control the dogs - they're totally untrained - they won't even listen to their owner! They get taken out to the big lawn a few times a day and let loose to run about.

I'm not inexperienced with dogs - my own dog is gold level Canine Good Citizen and we (used to) regularly get good results in obedience and agility classes.

But with the dogs at work, they're just left to run wild and because I'm only in for a few hours a week with other stuff to do, trying to do any training is just like pissing in the wind.

I am not confident in getting the screen replaced by the local phone place. It's still under warranty and the local place doesn't have a good reputation at all.

OP posts:
Winterscomingagain · 27/07/2023 16:18

I had a similar incident with a Google phone and they have two layers of glass, both of which were smashed on mine.
In my case I just had to replace it which I couldn't really afford.

Kteeb1 · 27/07/2023 16:14

Also everyone saying how cheap it is to replace a screen. Depends on the damage and the phone. I smashed my phone and it was over £200 to repair. Still under the threshold to bother with insurance but a healthy wack. I got a new phone instead but that's not an option for OP due to cost.

NamelessNancy · 27/07/2023 09:24

Sorry to hear you've been having a hard time OP. Totally understandable that you needed to take the doctor's call during work hours but as others have said it was your responsibility to control the dogs at the time.

Rather than asking them to pay for the phone it might be worth looking at the bigger picture here re the dogs. If you can't control them maybe the family should be getting someone better able to handle them to do that part of the work or alternatively paying for a few sessions with a dog trainer so you can.

BlairWaldorfOG · 27/07/2023 08:45

Maybe mention it to your employers and see if they offer to contribute? I'd echo what another user said and take it to a phone shop/ even a market stall that repairs them and get it replaced. Sounds like unfortunate timing that the GP happened to ring at that time, I hope you get your medical issue sorted too x

ultraviolet4753 · 27/07/2023 01:46

I'm fine with my support worker using her phone during work, as long as it doesn't get in the way of things, never been an issue.
We don't have dogs, but if it was their bad behaviour, I'd probably offer to pay half, or help her find somewhere cheaper to repair it, as don't want to lose a good worker over it.

IntheJingelyJangelyJungle · 27/07/2023 00:09

I’d suggest people now stop jumping in with the CF comments. They aren’t helpful for her or anyone at this point..

OP has had a tough time, is bereaved, in financial very tight times (or so I assume from reading posts) and those people leaping in to stick the boot in are just here to be cruel.

Katey83 · 26/07/2023 23:58

I agree with everyone else, if your phone is knocked out of your hand by a dog you are supervising then this is a you problem.

PollyPut · 26/07/2023 22:13

@Housekeeperbatcocoa some people have their phones on lanyards around their necks (like people used to put cameras on in the past). It sounds like that is what you need here (when it is finally fixed).

I wouldn't ask them to replace the screen, no.

Pugdogmom · 26/07/2023 22:09

Snugglemonkey · 26/07/2023 21:59

This is mad. The phone is the op's responsibility.

Absolutely this. If I drop my phone, it's my responsibility.

Snugglemonkey · 26/07/2023 21:59

NailTapBucket · 26/07/2023 01:21

I disagree with everyone else - sounds like they should be paying because their dogs should be better behaved - you did what you could to "look after 🙄" your phone!

This is mad. The phone is the op's responsibility.

Tinktravels · 26/07/2023 21:38

You are being a CF. Doesn't matter that you claim people are making stuff up. You broke your phone, you pay.

Lostthewilltolive1970 · 26/07/2023 21:32

You've asked the question and been given many answers, most of which say yes YABU. You clearly don't like this answer, so why ask the question?

xyz111 · 26/07/2023 21:29

Unfortunately, it's just one of those unfortunate accidents. You can't ask them to pay for it as it fell out of your hand. There's very sturdy cases and screen protectors you can get to stop it smashing.

Echio · 26/07/2023 21:04

@IntheJingelyJangelyJungle A really helpful perspective!

IntheJingelyJangelyJungle · 26/07/2023 21:00

We have a nanny 3 days a week because we work 12 hour days in healthcare. We aren’t wealthy as in landed wealthy but we are comfortable as long as we manage our budget carefully.

Our nanny walks our dog around school run time.

If she mentioned that my dog had bumped her so she dropped her phone and broke it I’d instantly offer to pay or at least 50%… because I value her day to day so much and it would be a way to show her this.

If she came to me and said ‘your dog broke my phone, you have to pay for it’ (which she would never do because, actually, I don’t have to pay for it and most people would appear to agree on this thread) I might feel different.

If you proceed with this think carefully about how you approach it.

Blossomkitty40 · 26/07/2023 20:57

Not that this is going to be much help now, but maybe it would have been better to say to your employers "I'm sorry but I'm not going to be able to take the dogs out this morning as I'm waiting for an important phone call today." I'm with whoever it was that said 'mention it to them and see if they offer to help out with the cost of it'. But really don't think they should be held accountable for it. YOU were in charge of the dogs at the time, the dog bumped your hand and YOU dropped your phone. Sorry, definitely think YABU.

londonrach · 26/07/2023 20:41

Yabu. If at work phone away...your choice to have it out on a dog walk

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 26/07/2023 20:39

I work with dogs and by law, the person in charge of the dogs at the time of an incident is the person responsible for any damage or injury - even on private land.

If you were walking with the owners at the time, it would be different but as you were the sole adult in charge, it's up to you to have control of the dogs.

CaroleSinger · 26/07/2023 20:34

This is a real stretch. Asking them to pay to replace the screen? You can get a generic replacement screen for well under £100. One thing I never do is take calls while I'm trying to hold onto the dog. It's guaranteed to end badly.

Echio · 26/07/2023 20:33

People have been quite mean to you here OP.

In the circumstances you've described where you were at work, at part of your job is taking the dogs out, and you have agreed personal / medical calls on a walk are fine, you wouldn't be unreasonable to ask your employer, saying the dog jumped up and caused the breakage.

You'd need to do this promptly as there would be trust involved about the cause in the absence of them witnessing it directly- the longer you leave it the less they'll readily believe that was the cause.

They almost certainly wouldn't want to claim on their insurance as the cost of the repair is way lower than the no-claims bonus they would otherwise benefit from, and in any case there's likely an excess that would be over the cost of repair too. So there would almost certainly be a real cost to them that they can't just 'claim' for, and because of this I think your chances of success are slim.

I realise it's probably not relevant but most conventional employment contracts include things about personal property being at your own risk etc - so if I had my phone stolen from the office for example, they have no obligation to replace it. Assuming your contract is just verbal, there would be an implied 'conventional' approach to matters like this and the most normal is personal property is not covered by the employer.

But, you can ask, and they might meet you half way or something. It's just it may sour the relationship going forward so I'd be weighing that up as a 'cost'.

It's rotten luck but it might be more prudent just to put it down to 'one of those things'.

Bangolads · 26/07/2023 20:31

If they give you permission to be on your phone that doesn’t then make them liable for your phone. You are still liable for the risk whether it’s their dogs or something else on their premises. No you shouldn’t ask them to contribute. We all have to field Doctor’s stuff around work. That’s life not an excuse. I’m sorry you’re having a hard time.

Kteeb1 · 26/07/2023 20:29

I really feel for you. To be without a phone and not be able to replace it is awful. You will be able to pick up a cheaper refurbished one or maybe even one of your friends has an old phone you could use? Your employer isn't liable though. As some has suggested your best bet it to mention it and see if they offer. I would stop short of requesting as its really not that reasonable and you may find relations with your employer sour and you don't need that.

cabbageking · 26/07/2023 20:13

I would ask the person who had or did not have control of the dogs when the accident happened. I think that was you.