Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Charity shops aren't doing themselves any favours

420 replies

Downatthefarm · 25/07/2023 22:07

I can afford to buy new but prefer to buy second hand. I enjoy the experience of sifting through the varied clothes in the charity shops and finding things I wouldn't otherwise see on the high street at that time, and of course I like other thrifters love a good bargain.

Over the last 5 years charity shops have really gone downhill where I am. They price second / third hand clothes similarly to the original RRP, sometimes even more expensive.

They are stocking more and more brand new items, like Frenchic furniture paint, priced higher than it costs at places like Wilko's and B&Q.

I already know somebody will say "the shops purpose is to raise as much money for their charity as they can, not to cater to people who don't have much money" but hasn't being accessible to people with low incomes and being good value for money always been one of the most appealing aspects of them?

I still donate but do the vast majority of my own second hand buying on vinted now and I know lots of others are doing the same.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Tiredalwaystired · 26/07/2023 07:50

Wintercomesoon · 25/07/2023 23:40

Is it not possible that head office may be out of touch because they do not buy their own clothes from Primark/H&M/Zara etc

So you don’t think that head office might employ retail professionals at that level?

That’s like saying it’s not possible to work in a Nissan car sales room if you own a Ford. Of course they understand the market. It’s their job.

GenieGenealogy · 26/07/2023 07:49

Here's the job board of charity retail vacancies for all the people who know better than the people doing it for a living.

https://www.charityjob.co.uk/retail-manager-jobs

On the Goodwill thing - impressive organisation, entirely different beast. It's a not for profit for a start, not a charity. They have mahoosive out of town outlets which are supermarket sized rather than front-room sized. Their staff are paid, not volunteers. That business model works for them, but it's not a "charity shop" in the way we understand charity shops in the UK/Ireland.

FrivolousTreeDuck · 26/07/2023 07:46

LadyBird1973 · 25/07/2023 22:15

Charity shops had a dual function imo - to raise funds for the charity whilst also enabling people to find bargains. It's not cheeky fuckery to think that if you are buying second hand, it shouldn't be priced at more than a brand new item.

I've had a couple of good bargains recently but it's true there's a lot of dross to sift through.

A third function is to enable people to shop sustainably and ethically - an (in theory) affordable alternative to fast fashion.

FrivolousTreeDuck · 26/07/2023 07:43

Yes - too many 'unbranded' items are overpriced. I'm happy to pay £20 for a Monsoon dress that would've cost £60, but not to pay £12 for a George dress that would've cost £14.

Tiredalwaystired · 26/07/2023 07:36

earsup · 25/07/2023 22:54

I dont bother much these days, most shops have an outlet store on ebay, items are very cheap, i got river island tracksuits for £7 each....brand new and free post.
I donated boxes of stuff when aunt died to local BHF shop.....months later all sitting on shelf with ridiculous prices, i did point this out to staff but no interest at all....maybe a few closures will open their eyes.....a few are still ok but not the great shops years ago....

In which case the shop aren’t following protocol. All items should be dated on the day they are put out and taken off the floor after a few weeks if I sold, then either moved to another shop or sent for rag.

Sounds like a poorly managed shop over all.

Boymum2104 · 26/07/2023 04:01

100% agree with this OP! Most charity shops near me are also trying to sell ‘good stuff’ online. I think they would maximise profits by taking a leaf out of Vinted’s book with their pricing strategy in the shops.

Danikm151 · 26/07/2023 03:29

Some really are pushing it. My favourite ones are the items are either £1,2,3

price low sell high works! Our local ymca used to be great but now they want £20 for a pair of trainers that I donated and paid £5 for! Dresses £15 when they are £10 brand new.

slashlover · 26/07/2023 02:50

IWasFunBeforeMum · 25/07/2023 22:18

Heard a woman in my local Barnardo's saying "that box is for eBay" so I've given up thinking any amazing brands left in the shops themselves anymore, all goes online. Sigh.

I work for them and we have a budget for eBay and any item must sell for a minimum of £30. We know what does and does not sell in our individual shops. For example in my last box I sent a medical scale which sells for £90, an ornament which sells for £60 (and we had out for sale on the shop floor for 3 weeks for £40), an old fashioned board game which sells for £35 etc.

There's a mixture of items we know won't sell and items we have put on the shop floor and which haven't sold. We put out a load of BNWT Coast dresses for £20 (tags said £160-£180) which didn't sell? Do you suggest we try them on eBay and get £30 each or sell them instore for £5?

Seddon · 26/07/2023 02:09

Nat6999 · 26/07/2023 01:24

I've fallen out with charity shops after we tried to donate my dad's clothes after he died. Our local hospice shop turned their noses up at what we wanted to donate. There were several made to measure suits, brand new shirts still in their wrappers, beautiful Gabicci jumpers, a couple of dinner suits, plus some M & S Italian collection trousers, apparently they weren't of sufficient quality for the shop. We ended up filling those charity bags that come through the door.

Ouch, that must've hurt.

I've never known a charity shop to gatekeep the clothes I'm trying to donate - I drop things in bags or boxes which are gratefully accepted and (I assume) sifted through later.

Nat6999 · 26/07/2023 01:24

I've fallen out with charity shops after we tried to donate my dad's clothes after he died. Our local hospice shop turned their noses up at what we wanted to donate. There were several made to measure suits, brand new shirts still in their wrappers, beautiful Gabicci jumpers, a couple of dinner suits, plus some M & S Italian collection trousers, apparently they weren't of sufficient quality for the shop. We ended up filling those charity bags that come through the door.

Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 00:47

Oh! Also, I got a big bundle of Spanish toddler clothes for my youngest on vinted last week. I paid £26. They would have cost hundreds brand new. I've never been lucky enough to spot that style of kids clothes in any of my locals yet.

OP posts:
Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 00:45

Vinted is great for dressed from Nobody's Child! I also got a lovely Joanie dress on there a few months ago for something like £8 and it's in perfect condition. I'm hooked.

OP posts:
Puffalicious · 26/07/2023 00:37

RubyWedding · 25/07/2023 23:59

I do the vast majority of my own second hand buying on vinted now and I know lots of others are doing the same.

if all the good stuff is going straight onto vinted, either by its original owner or a professional reseller who buys charity shop bargains as soon as they're put out, then is it any surprise that there isn't much good stuff left in charity shops? The whole nature of the secondhand clothes market has changed beyond recognition in the last five years..

I don't reckon so. I just got a lovely Nobody 's Child dress delivered for £21 from Vinted. I wouldn't pick that up in a charity shop - have never seen that brand for much cheaper than that. So if someone did pick it up in a charity shop they're not making much profit.

I searched by size/ colour/ brand - so convenient- and it arrived promptly, packaged beautifully and freshly laundered. It is a no brainer for me.

Coyoacan · 26/07/2023 00:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You're nuts. Second goods should not be priced as new. And yes charity shops have a dual purpose

Puffalicious · 26/07/2023 00:32

mathanxiety · 25/07/2023 22:16

Agree with @NuffSaidSam .
I'm in the US where there is a big nationwide chain, Goodwill, which does uniform pricing, and you know if you see something you like you'd better buy it because it won't be there the next day.

My son is in the US right now and called raving about Goodwill! He said the donations were in big tubs categorised in size and it was priced per kilo. As a typical student he was delighted to get a couple of retro tshirts and a thick fleece (which he needed as it's cooler in the evenings than he thought it would be) for $3! He's lucky as at 18 he can wear a binbag and look cool!

Seddon · 26/07/2023 00:24

and you probably have no friends

Oh look out, looks like my teenagers have arrived on the thread! Grin

Icepinkeskimo · 26/07/2023 00:21

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Cherry aka my dogs bigger than yours go rattle your pearls of non wisdom elsewhere, your antagonist and you probably have no friends, and if so you are the cf among them.
New flash…people have always shopped at charity shops when times are hard…

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 26/07/2023 00:00

We're in a very depressed area. We have one shop where all adult clothes other than brand new are £1.00. Children's books are10 for £1.00. I bought curtains for my large living room window - Sandersons fabric, lined - for a fiver and a Jacques Vert hat for £ 1.00. The manager sees the shop as having a dual role to raise money for the charity and to provide low cost clothes and goods to the community. Directly opposite is another charity shop where the prices are through the roof. One is always busy, the other has more staff than customers.

RubyWedding · 25/07/2023 23:59

I do the vast majority of my own second hand buying on vinted now and I know lots of others are doing the same.

if all the good stuff is going straight onto vinted, either by its original owner or a professional reseller who buys charity shop bargains as soon as they're put out, then is it any surprise that there isn't much good stuff left in charity shops? The whole nature of the secondhand clothes market has changed beyond recognition in the last five years..

ShanghaiDiva · 25/07/2023 23:57

@Downatthefarm
i have volunteered with BHF and we don’t intentionally sell items for more than rrp. All of our prices have gone up as has our rent and utility costs. The shop is next door to a charity shop clearance shop (items that have not sold in shops in the local area are sent there) and their prices are cheaper. Imo there is a demand for both types of shop.

Tillypet · 25/07/2023 23:56

I've given up on charity shops because (at least in my area) the quality of the clothes is just shit.

I can't help thinking that this is a knock-on effect from the generally worsening quality of new clothes on sale. I'm in my 50s now and the rise of disposable fashion over the last 30 years or so has really screwed second hand shopping. So many pieces now were never very good in the first place, so by the time they hit the charity shop they're just not worth having.

Of course the rise of Ebay and Vinted etc doesn't help; people can sell their good quality stuff themselves now for extra cash (and who can blame them). Plus I live in an area where a lot of people are doing most of their shopping in Primark or similar.

One way or another, the charity shops round here are full of manky polyester tat, sadly.

GenieGenealogy · 25/07/2023 23:49

Oxfam got Zara too. They also have a long-standing relationship with M&S. And in the past got corporate donations from Ted Baker and Speedo. I was in a Shelter shop today too and they had lots of accessories like belts and purses from M&S.

I have said it before on these threads but you would not believe the quantity of information that a charity shop manager or volunteer team gets about sales. Broken down in every way possible - per square foot, by department, against last week/month/quarter/year, against other stores in the area, price per transaction etc etc etc. You do not have to be a spreadsheet genius to spot where you are making money and where you are not.

Also these threads are always people moaning about clothing. That is only part of what charity shop sells. Where I used to volunteer we made more on books, or bric-a-brac than we did on women's clothing.

ShanghaiDiva · 25/07/2023 23:44

Red Cross has Zara. At BHF we have a lot of ex top shop, principles, Debenhams.

AliceMcK · 25/07/2023 23:42

Siameasy · 25/07/2023 22:17

I don’t even bother going in Oxfam or BHF half the time as they’re full of last season Zara…boring

Ahhh dose this include Red Cross? Our local one seems full of Zara stuff, all new.

Downatthefarm · 25/07/2023 23:42

GenieGenealogy · 25/07/2023 23:38

I was under the impression that the store managers are given price guides from higher up, are they not?

And - if you think this is the case, do you really really think that the people in the head office of a charity have a deliberate strategy to try to make money by selling items at more than they would cost new?

As we're always reminded on here the charities sole objective is to get as much for an item as they can.

I'm not saying it's a conspiracy, but it happens, many have seen it. You'll know more about that than me though, given that you work for one.

I'm merely a customer observing my locals.

OP posts: