Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Charity shops aren't doing themselves any favours

420 replies

Downatthefarm · 25/07/2023 22:07

I can afford to buy new but prefer to buy second hand. I enjoy the experience of sifting through the varied clothes in the charity shops and finding things I wouldn't otherwise see on the high street at that time, and of course I like other thrifters love a good bargain.

Over the last 5 years charity shops have really gone downhill where I am. They price second / third hand clothes similarly to the original RRP, sometimes even more expensive.

They are stocking more and more brand new items, like Frenchic furniture paint, priced higher than it costs at places like Wilko's and B&Q.

I already know somebody will say "the shops purpose is to raise as much money for their charity as they can, not to cater to people who don't have much money" but hasn't being accessible to people with low incomes and being good value for money always been one of the most appealing aspects of them?

I still donate but do the vast majority of my own second hand buying on vinted now and I know lots of others are doing the same.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
AvengedQuince · 26/07/2023 12:48

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 26/07/2023 12:40

Not really sure what your point is. Your £1.50 tops become £2.28 with the buyer's protection fee added on, plus £2.29 or £2.80 minimum postage, that's £4.50 or £5.00. Charity shops near me have items of clothing for less than this.

And many more items on Vinted are well above £1.50.

Your suggestion that Vinted is an alternative to charity shop prices isn't really sound.

There are often costs, and significant time involved shopping in person. Possible travel costs, parking, then the time to look through rails of clothing in multiple shops for what you need. Vinted is much quicker as you can search and filter, so savings there.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 26/07/2023 12:40

Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 11:16

I've got tops for as little as £1.50 on my shop, perfect condition. IME people don't want to pay alot on vinted partly to do with the buyer protection fee and shipping often costing as much if not more as the item itself.

I've also bought great condition designer polo tshirts for my son for as little as £3.

I have stuff in my favourites list that has been on there for months because the seller has priced high. Vinted is a buyers market.

Not really sure what your point is. Your £1.50 tops become £2.28 with the buyer's protection fee added on, plus £2.29 or £2.80 minimum postage, that's £4.50 or £5.00. Charity shops near me have items of clothing for less than this.

And many more items on Vinted are well above £1.50.

Your suggestion that Vinted is an alternative to charity shop prices isn't really sound.

FrivolousTreeDuck · 26/07/2023 12:13

Charlize43 · 26/07/2023 10:38

I love cinema and it's a shame that more and more charity shops are now getting rid of their DVD sections.

I've always got a tremendous kick of watching a movie that may have cost millions to make (Gladiator or Avatar, for example) for 50p! Mind blowing!

I am hopeful DVDs will see a revival when people realise that by relying on streaming services their choice of viewing is at the mercy of trends, random rights issues and people not being 'cancelled'.

OhBanana · 26/07/2023 12:13

Tiredalwaystired · 26/07/2023 10:07

I really don’t have any problem with this.

As long as the volunteer pays the exact same price it would go in the shop floor for it’s a small way to recognise their support.

They’re not ripping anyone off and they’re not getting paid. If it bothers you - volunteer!

I have previously volunteered - and have 10+ years retail experience. It wasn’t the done thing years ago when I volunteered and I’ve never been allowed to buy stock in normal retail outlets before customers either.

At a minimum they should be paying the same but I also think they are struggling to get people in the door. Siphoning off the best stuff for eBay or for themselves to purchase isn’t the best strategy for this. I remember when my local shops had a reputation for having really good stuff and which ones in particular- you don’t get that anymore sadly. And is an affluent area so I doubt that the type of thing being donated has changed that drastically (I know my customers at my retail job have, thank goodness, continued to spend the same on what we sell so many are weathering the col crisis quite well here, although some may be going to Vinted too I suppose!).

Puffalicious · 26/07/2023 11:54

GenieGenealogy · 26/07/2023 07:49

Here's the job board of charity retail vacancies for all the people who know better than the people doing it for a living.

https://www.charityjob.co.uk/retail-manager-jobs

On the Goodwill thing - impressive organisation, entirely different beast. It's a not for profit for a start, not a charity. They have mahoosive out of town outlets which are supermarket sized rather than front-room sized. Their staff are paid, not volunteers. That business model works for them, but it's not a "charity shop" in the way we understand charity shops in the UK/Ireland.

That's interesting about Goodwill. I didn't know this. Makes sense and is surely a great service for everyone, particularly the low-waged.

ShanghaiDiva · 26/07/2023 11:53

@MsRead
several posters have explained on this thread why they are full and cannot take donations.

MsRead · 26/07/2023 11:51

It’s happening in other countries as well, I was looking for some old plates to pop underneath pot plants to conserve water. The charity shop had second hand plates for sale that were more expensive than brand new ones from our equivalent of Home Bargain type shop.
Similarly, I make jams, pickles and chutneys and the charity shop price for badly washed out, second hand jars with labels ( that you spend a while removing) was extortionate compared with new. Our charity shops often say they are full as well, doesn’t make any sense to me.

CruCru · 26/07/2023 11:48

roses2 · 26/07/2023 10:34

So they give it to a charity shop, for the volunteers to put it in the rag bin.

Don't the shops get paid by weight for rags? If I have rags I donate to my local shop and put them in a bag marked "rags" so they know.

They do and, if they have room in the rag bin, that is fine. It’s a heart sink moment for the volunteers when someone hands in a bag of “good” stuff and they realise that most of it (but not all) is rags.

Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 11:27

ShanghaiDiva · 26/07/2023 11:24

I am not tripping you up, but surely you see the hypocrisy in complaining that prices are too expensive then gleeful asking where you get a Prada coat for a discounted price.

Lol thats the opposite of hypocrisy. If I'm complaining about high prices then of course I'm going to be happy about potentially getting a bargain.

Hypocrisy would be complaining about the prices in charity shops and then sticking one of those famous bobbled primark jumpers on my vinted store for £20.

OP posts:
ShanghaiDiva · 26/07/2023 11:24

Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 11:19

You seem to be waiting for opportunities to trip me up, you've done this continuously throughout the thread. Don't take everything so personally. Nobody is attacking you or your charity shop. This is a discussion about charity shops in general. If your shop is reasonable then great. I don't see why you're so offended.

I am not tripping you up, but surely you see the hypocrisy in complaining that prices are too expensive then gleeful asking where you get a Prada coat for a discounted price.

Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 11:19

ShanghaiDiva · 26/07/2023 10:43

@Downatthefarm
so it’s okay for items to be priced inaccurately as long as it’s in the customer’s favour..

You seem to be waiting for opportunities to trip me up, you've done this continuously throughout the thread. Don't take everything so personally. Nobody is attacking you or your charity shop. This is a discussion about charity shops in general. If your shop is reasonable then great. I don't see why you're so offended.

OP posts:
Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 11:16

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 26/07/2023 10:27

Seasalt and White Stuff prices on Vinted are HIGH.

That's before you add in the buyer's protection and courier fees.

Given this, I don't see how the OP can think Vinted is a viable alternative to chazzas.

Vinted has an additional hassle of potentially not being as good in the flesh, whereas you are able to see the item before you buy in the shop.

A single small top is easily £6+ on Vinted, and that is after the seller deigns to take it to the courier and it gets delivered.

I've got tops for as little as £1.50 on my shop, perfect condition. IME people don't want to pay alot on vinted partly to do with the buyer protection fee and shipping often costing as much if not more as the item itself.

I've also bought great condition designer polo tshirts for my son for as little as £3.

I have stuff in my favourites list that has been on there for months because the seller has priced high. Vinted is a buyers market.

OP posts:
LuluGuinea · 26/07/2023 11:12

OhBanana · 26/07/2023 08:06

With regards to staff taking the best stuff, just this week I witnessed a charity shop worker say she was going to take home and test a bass guitar in great condition as shop was selling for £30… the public never had a look in! This is in SW London, where sadly I can’t afford most charity shop pricing now and stick to Vinted!

But she didn't take it to keep, she took it for testing. Not the same thing, surely ?

LuluGuinea · 26/07/2023 11:10

ShanghaiDiva · 26/07/2023 08:34

@Elvis1956
i volunteer with BHF and ime a good shop manager will encourage volunteers to play to their strengths. I am an avid reader and price all the books. We are located opposite WHSmith so I know what’s on offer in there and promote our books accordingly.

I had that job when I volunteered at the charity shop. I loved it because I love to read.

slashlover · 26/07/2023 11:07

OhBanana · 26/07/2023 08:06

With regards to staff taking the best stuff, just this week I witnessed a charity shop worker say she was going to take home and test a bass guitar in great condition as shop was selling for £30… the public never had a look in! This is in SW London, where sadly I can’t afford most charity shop pricing now and stick to Vinted!

So you'd rather items were sold untested and possibly not working? They probably won't have had a working amp in store and the staff member may have had one at home.

The PAT tester comes in and tests items for safety and not for function. Would you rather we take a guitar home overnight, check it's fully functioning and sell it to you, or sell it to you and then you have to return it?

GenieGenealogy · 26/07/2023 11:03

Charlize43 · 26/07/2023 10:38

I love cinema and it's a shame that more and more charity shops are now getting rid of their DVD sections.

I've always got a tremendous kick of watching a movie that may have cost millions to make (Gladiator or Avatar, for example) for 50p! Mind blowing!

This is one thing I have really noticed a difference in during the time I have been volunteering. When I started first about 8 or 9 years ago, DVDs sold well. Then along came Netflix and Amazon Prime and Disney Plus and smart TVs. DVD sales have decreased rapidly and even at 3 for £1 we can't shift the stock. Some get sent to Music Magpie or Ziffit but you have to weight the selling price of just a couple of pennies for popular DVDs against the time it takes for someone to scan the barcodes and box them all up. CDs are rapidly going the same way, people stream their music on Spotify or similar, new cars don't have CD players any more.

Yes we can rag stuff but it's again very little per kilo and it only takes a dozen black bags of rags and stuff which isn't fit for selling before your back sorting area is full and the recycling isn't collected for another week...

ShanghaiDiva · 26/07/2023 10:43

@Downatthefarm
so it’s okay for items to be priced inaccurately as long as it’s in the customer’s favour..

Charlize43 · 26/07/2023 10:38

I love cinema and it's a shame that more and more charity shops are now getting rid of their DVD sections.

I've always got a tremendous kick of watching a movie that may have cost millions to make (Gladiator or Avatar, for example) for 50p! Mind blowing!

roses2 · 26/07/2023 10:34

So they give it to a charity shop, for the volunteers to put it in the rag bin.

Don't the shops get paid by weight for rags? If I have rags I donate to my local shop and put them in a bag marked "rags" so they know.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 26/07/2023 10:27

HarrietSchulenberg · 25/07/2023 23:07

I'm really lucky as people near me donate clothes that I like and the 5 charity shops price them decently. I have recently bought Seasalt, Fatface, White Stuff and Mantaray clothing (which I like and suit me) for waaaay less than they go for on Vinted. As new Seasalt tops and dresses for about £7-8, Fatface cardigan for £4, and my absolute favourite was a button through dress for £8, really unusual American brand that I wouldn't be surprised is the only one in the UK (BNWT with the price tag in US dollars).

Seasalt and White Stuff prices on Vinted are HIGH.

That's before you add in the buyer's protection and courier fees.

Given this, I don't see how the OP can think Vinted is a viable alternative to chazzas.

Vinted has an additional hassle of potentially not being as good in the flesh, whereas you are able to see the item before you buy in the shop.

A single small top is easily £6+ on Vinted, and that is after the seller deigns to take it to the courier and it gets delivered.

thebellagio · 26/07/2023 10:26

But isn't it because most people are now buying fast fashion and buying clothes from the supermarkets/primark, so it makes sense that the bulk of donations will then be the same thing.

Its because thats where the volume is from - its like CDs back in the early-mid 00s, charity shops would have been packed full of albums by Steps/S Club etc, purely because of the sheer volume of CDs that were sold by those bands

But I agree, there is an issue when the clothes are being resold second-hand for more than or close to the original retail value. And when the supermarket/primark are so cheap, it potentially makes more sense to buy new because you've then got the option to benefit from returns policy/collect loyalty points etc

In my village we have an absolute thriving freecycle page and most of my old clothes/kids old clothes I give away for free on there. Its the same with books, furniture, hangers etc. Where I live, the nearest charity shop is about a 15-20 min drive away, so everyone just shares stuff and regifts in the village - particularly school uniforms.

whatsappdoc · 26/07/2023 10:23

I'd be interested to see a photo of a 'bobbled Primark cardigan' for sale in a charity shop. Anything bobbled would be put in a rag bag and not put out in the shop unless they were REALLY desperate.

3isthemagicnumberrr · 26/07/2023 10:17

Totally agree.

Charlize43 · 26/07/2023 10:17

Downatthefarm · 26/07/2023 10:00

I don't suppose you're willing to let me know which charity shop is this are you? Area wise 😇

I'd be a fool to tell you!

But London has many areas where big monied people live side by side with those less fortunate (of which I am one).

I've had good scoops in charity shops in Marylebone, Highgate, Blackheath, Camden, Greenwich, Victoria and Golders Green.

Chelsea, Kensington & Notting Hill areas are a good example where the charity shops mark up accordingly to brand, so much harder to get a real bargain.

CruCru · 26/07/2023 10:14

Part of the problem is that so many people donate piles of absolute tat. I remember someone describing it as “wishcycling”. They paid good money for that thing and, even though it’s stained and holey, they can’t bear to put it in the clothes recycling bag / bin. So they give it to a charity shop, for the volunteers to put it in the rag bin.

It’s part of the reason none of the charity shops near me will take children’s clothes. Too much tomato stained junk to make it worth their time to sort.