Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that some people don't want to be grandparents

109 replies

SilIssuesAgain · 25/07/2023 16:17

My parents were over the moon when I told them I was pregnant. They love spending time with our 2 dc. They visit lots and interact with them and they are happy to help out.

My inlaws are the exact opposite. Mil especially does not seem interested in being a grandmother and I get the impression she thinks they are a burden almost. When dh told her I was pregnant she was on the phone almost in tears asking how we would cope (married, early 30s, have mortgage and some savings - not that that matters. We have also never asked her for any help). She rarely sees my dc and when she visits she is just interested in talking to dh. I honestly wonder if she even likes our dc.

Are your parents or inlaws interested in your dc?

OP posts:
GulfCoastBeachGirl · 25/07/2023 18:12

My adult child doesn't seem at all interested in having children and that suits me just fine. I loved being a mother but have no desire to try to recreate that feeling 3 decades on!

But things change, and if I ever get "the call" I'll be congratulatory and supportive (but inside won't be bubbling with excitement). I'm sure I'd love any potential grandchild but honestly don't think I'd be involved in the day-to-day.

AnxiousFairyQueen · 25/07/2023 18:10

Random789 · 25/07/2023 16:42

Of course some people don't want to be grandparents. Why would people all be the same in that respect when they differ in every other?

My gut feeling is that for some people the worries of being a parent, the life sentence of fretting about your children's happiness, just make the prospect of extending the same level of loving concern to grandchildren too frightening to be welome.

And also ,it is very easy to start worrying that your existing children may become unhappy/worried in various ways as a result becoming parents themselves, giving you another reason to feel unsure about the prospect of grandchildren.

I don’t think it works like that. I just can’t see someone who’s that concerned about their children’s welfare just switch off their emotions with grandchildren. I’d want to of course, because worrying about my children has ruined my life but I’d feel responsible.

cyclamenqueen · 25/07/2023 18:09

I have no urge to be a grandparent, of course if they come along I will love them to bits just as I do my dc but I feel utterly and completely rung out both emotionally and physically by parenting . There is just nothing left at the moment and what is left is taken up by caring for elderly parents and grandparents (106 and still going) . The thought of anyone else needing me is just pretty horrifying.

Framilode · 25/07/2023 18:09

I love my two daughters but found parenting difficult. I did a good job but I did it conciously not instinctively. Babies don't interest me,
or toddlers, but as my grandchildren became older I enjoyed my time with them more and more. Now as young adults, I find them fascinating and fun. I'm not a traditional grandma but I love them dearly.

McaRoonie · 25/07/2023 18:09

Unless your parents/ in laws put huge pressure on you to have children and promised you the world once they came along, then I don’t think you have any comeback whatsoever.
YOU are the adult who decided to have children- why do you expect others to fawn around them and look after them?
I’m in a lucky position that I do have grandparents who care- but it was never an expectation . It was our decision to have children, our responsibility to get them looked after when needed and nothing to do with how our parents felt.
I have always said- it’s my time- they have done their time.
I understand why/ how it can be disappointing but nothing more than that. It’s disappointing like the friends who dumped me when I had a child (who I thought were good friends but because they didn't have kids) but we are all in different situations. So we can’t expect anyone else to “enjoy” or look after our children -just because they are family-when they weren’t the ones who reproduced/ didn’t want them and now have their own lives!

sanityisamyth · 25/07/2023 18:02

My mother told me when I was 13 that she didn't want to be a grandmother. When DS started a hobby she was interested in (she's 7) she became a lot more interested in him. He's taking a break from the hobby and she hasn't spoken to him since.

Hbh17 · 25/07/2023 18:01

It's absolutely fine if people aren't keen on being grandparents - each to their own. But whilst we have a choice about being parents, anyone with a child can then have grandparenthood forced upon them - effectively, it's out of their control and they don't get a say!

littleripper · 25/07/2023 18:01

My Gma has made us all so desperate to be grandmas. She has 17 of us and every single one of us visits and loves her so much. She is 98 and like a Queen for us, we can just enjoy her so much. I cannot wait for that pure love, with no obligations and all those baby kisses.

SlideandPolka · 25/07/2023 18:00

Random789 · 25/07/2023 16:42

Of course some people don't want to be grandparents. Why would people all be the same in that respect when they differ in every other?

My gut feeling is that for some people the worries of being a parent, the life sentence of fretting about your children's happiness, just make the prospect of extending the same level of loving concern to grandchildren too frightening to be welome.

And also ,it is very easy to start worrying that your existing children may become unhappy/worried in various ways as a result becoming parents themselves, giving you another reason to feel unsure about the prospect of grandchildren.

I think that’s perfectly reasonable. It’s at least as reasonable as the demented people dropping heavy handed hints about longing for grandbabies from the moment their child gets their first girl/boyfriend.

Dontcallmescarface · 25/07/2023 17:59

My own GP's ( only had one set growing up), were shit but my parents were amazing. DD and her DP don't want children ever, so being a GM myself is not something that will figure in my life and I'm not at all bothered if I'm honest. I don't think I would be cut out to be the sort of GP's my parents were although I'll sure as Hell be better than mine ever were...i.e I won't have gotten pissed and battered my GC with my walking stick.

YukoandHiro · 25/07/2023 17:59

CurlewKate · 25/07/2023 17:06

People are allowed not to want to be grandparents! I'm not sure whether I want to be and my children are of an age where it could happen soon.

I totally get what you're saying but it's not something that you choose or is ever in your control - the part you can control is how involved you choose to be.
To say you don't want to be a GP could be like saying "I don't want my child to do something that may be very important to them personally and emotionally because it doesn't suit me"

HorseyMel · 25/07/2023 17:59

There is also a difference between being a grandparent who sees the kids for a bit every so often and being expected to provide a day of care several days per week for several years - and to act like you enjoy it.

I can see one end of the spectrum being good and the other one being not so good.

Mayhem3 · 25/07/2023 17:58

I had my kids going and am in my early 40s. I will be likely to be working if they have kids. There’s not much chance I will be hands on.

I wonder if this is part of the problem.

Most women work now and do not have the time to be hands on grandparents.
Whereas my grandparents were much more hands on and that’s probably because my grandmothers especially didn’t work and their only identity was a mother and so they wanted to carry it on.

YukoandHiro · 25/07/2023 17:57

Polik · 25/07/2023 16:57

I don't want to be an involved grandparent. Do you want to AMA to understand?

The essentials are - I love kids. We have four (aged nearly 9-19). I also work with kids all day. I look forward to "retiring" to a time when I don't have responsibility for any children.

I'll ask:

  1. Are you worried that you'll be expected to be heavily involved because you chose to have a lot of kids and also work with them? And are you worried that not being involved will damage your relationship with your children?
  2. have you pre-empted all this with a chat about how you're not able to give up that time to eg do childcare or be highly involved?
  3. do you think your attitude will change when/if DGCS arrive?
Mayhem3 · 25/07/2023 17:55

My DDs 15 and perhaps I’d feel differently in a few years but tbh I’m dreading it and I hope she doesn’t get pregnant young.

I got pregnant as a teen and I’ve never not had any responsibility as an adult and selfishly I can’t wait for the day I can do whatever I want and perhaps work in other countries etc without having to think of someone else.

If my DD has kids then I want to be fully involved because I don’t want her throwing her life away and being restricted in getting her career or going out with her friends etc like I did as it so difficult not having that support but I also want to live my own life.

Wheretostartstitching · 25/07/2023 17:55

I have 2 kids own and adult and one almost an adult. My mum always looked forward to grandkids. I feel a bit ‘meh’ about it. Either my kids have kids or they don’t.

I had my kids going and am in my early 40s. I will be likely to be working if they have kids. There’s not much chance I will be hands on. I don’t think I would choose to even if I didn’t need to work. I would babysit from time to time and spend time with them. But wouldn’t be providing regular childcare.

I enjoy being a parent but don’t want to do it again. As I get older I look forward to having less responsibility. Not ramping it up again.

BarelyLiterate · 25/07/2023 17:54

I know people who are not super-involved grandparents, and to me it seems like a generational thing. They are in their early 60s & have retired but certainly don’t consider themselves to be old in any sense of the term. They are very different to my own grandparents’ generation, being fit & active and are busy travelling and doing their sports & hobbies. They just don’t see themselves as ‘grandma & grandpa’ at all and prefer the grandkids to call them ‘Tom & Kate’.

UrsulaIsMyQueen · 25/07/2023 17:54

Well no, not everyone wants the same thing. I’m sure there are many people who aren’t massively bothered about being grandparents.

Parentalalienation · 25/07/2023 17:53

I couldn't have my own children for medical reasons. I gained lovely step-children via marriage but my parents wanted nothing to do with them. Even down to refusing to let the children call them 'grandparent' names. Their only opportunity to be grandparents and they didn't want to know because they weren't 'real blood grandchildren'. I don't understand their reasoning.

kraftyKitten · 25/07/2023 17:53

I think if the grand children are from a daughter they are more involved as there are fewer boundaries. Also I find Great Grandparents are not into GreatGrand Children as they are too old . I enjoy my Grandchildren, I love them but I'm glad to hand them back . We get the good bits .

TellySavalashairbrush · 25/07/2023 17:52

Random789 · 25/07/2023 16:42

Of course some people don't want to be grandparents. Why would people all be the same in that respect when they differ in every other?

My gut feeling is that for some people the worries of being a parent, the life sentence of fretting about your children's happiness, just make the prospect of extending the same level of loving concern to grandchildren too frightening to be welome.

And also ,it is very easy to start worrying that your existing children may become unhappy/worried in various ways as a result becoming parents themselves, giving you another reason to feel unsure about the prospect of grandchildren.

I can identify with this 100%

Ultraviolet85 · 25/07/2023 17:52

“You lot” who are you talking to exactly?

readbooksdrinktea · 25/07/2023 17:49

Isn't the point that some grandparents don’t enjoy it, know they won't, and therefore don’t become involved? They're probably not feeling they are missing out, as hurtful and incomprehensible as that is to parents.

gogomoto · 25/07/2023 17:48

My ex mil told me she didn't want to be a grandma and I wasn't to buy cards etc with it on. She mellowed years later for my kids cousins (big age gap, half sibling situation) but ruined any chance of a close relationship with my dc, she moans they don't keep in touch and my exh doesn't make them (they are adults!) I'm on pleasantries terms with her, but make no effort to see her except at inevitable moments like funerals

heatdeath · 25/07/2023 17:48

I have no overwhelming desire to be a grandparent. I have four children, I work with children, and I enjoy children generally. If any of my children chose to have children of their own then I'm sure it would be great but it'll be equally good if they chose not to!

My parents are fairly involved with our children - on their own terms (as my grandparents were) & they have strong relationships with their adult grandchildren. I would never have considered asking them for childcare - they worked & now they are enjoying their retirement! I imagine I'd be quite similar if/when the opportunity arises.