Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that some people don't want to be grandparents

109 replies

SilIssuesAgain · 25/07/2023 16:17

My parents were over the moon when I told them I was pregnant. They love spending time with our 2 dc. They visit lots and interact with them and they are happy to help out.

My inlaws are the exact opposite. Mil especially does not seem interested in being a grandmother and I get the impression she thinks they are a burden almost. When dh told her I was pregnant she was on the phone almost in tears asking how we would cope (married, early 30s, have mortgage and some savings - not that that matters. We have also never asked her for any help). She rarely sees my dc and when she visits she is just interested in talking to dh. I honestly wonder if she even likes our dc.

Are your parents or inlaws interested in your dc?

OP posts:
yesterdayisgone · 25/07/2023 19:05

I’ve done 28 years of parenting and there’s light at the end of the tunnel now . I’m not going to provide free childcare and raise grandkids . So yeah I’m certainly not arsed about potential grandkids

cptartapp · 25/07/2023 19:02

My DM never offered to babysit for us, always had to be asked. Never a sleepover in 17 years. I kind of get it. She'd rather be on holiday or going shopping, and although she loved her GC just didn't enjoy the company of young DC.
The difference was she wasn't afraid to say no to anything but occasional ad hoc care. I used to watch the same beleaguered bored looking GP pushing swings in the park and trudging round with prams and wonder why they didn't just say no too.
Makes me thankful to have boys tbh. Far less likely to be first port of call.

heatdeath · 25/07/2023 18:54

@Polik you sound very similar to me - including the 10 (well 11 in my case) year spread of children. My eldest is in her mid 20s, I'm still very much actively parenting my younger children. I do suspect that there is is an expectation within our extended family that I will be desperate to jump in as a hands-on-grandma. I don't want to be essential to anyone's parenting plans!

I'm utterly gobsmacked by many of the demands that are placed upon grandparents - it's way beyond anything I, or my parents, would have thought reasonable.

Hollyppp · 25/07/2023 18:53

Duckduckie · 25/07/2023 16:45

I think that generation is also when some women didn’t want to be mothers. birth control was coming in however society hadn’t changed yet and there was a lot of pressure.

My parents aren’t that interested but I also think my mum wasn’t that interested in me.

This. I don’t think Dh parents truly wanted children but did as it was the norm

saraclara · 25/07/2023 18:50

When we told my parents I was pregnant, my mum went absolutely silent and loked horrified. My dad quickly stepped in and congratulated us with real pleasure. It honestly wasn't the reaction from my mum that I was expecting. But it was real and has set the tone right up to now when her DGCs are in their 30s.

We left my parents' that day to drive on to tell my PILs. Whoe were absolutely ecstatic, not only at becoming GPs, but with joy for us. And that equally predicted what sort of GPs they became.

I'm going to sound awful now, but sometimes I'm really angry that my mum is still around, and my PILs never got the joy of being GGPs. They'd have loved my DGDs SO much.

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 25/07/2023 18:50

I love my kids, but the idea of being a grandparent fills me with dread.

I want to retire and not have any responsibility to children. I'm sure if my kids have children I will love them. But it will very much be a case of handing them back with much delight!

thatsnotmylifeitstoocrazy · 25/07/2023 18:49

Mil likes to tell people all about her gc, does nothing to help out and nothing with them unless its something she enjoys like shopping. Asked for help when we were struggling with teen daughter, she said no. Fil actually does things with gc but doesnt help out. When dh visits quite often he does things with dcs on his own. 🤦🏼‍♀️

continentallentil · 25/07/2023 18:48

peachypudding · 25/07/2023 18:41

I remember feeling a bit hurt that my parents didn't seem that bothered about my children. They loved them but weren't exactly desperate to look after them.

Now I'm a grandmother I get it completely. I love my grandchild but have no desire to provide childcare (though I have agreed to).

@peachypudding

If you don’t mind me asking, why have you agreed then?

Polik · 25/07/2023 18:46

YukoandHiro · 25/07/2023 17:57

I'll ask:

  1. Are you worried that you'll be expected to be heavily involved because you chose to have a lot of kids and also work with them? And are you worried that not being involved will damage your relationship with your children?
  2. have you pre-empted all this with a chat about how you're not able to give up that time to eg do childcare or be highly involved?
  3. do you think your attitude will change when/if DGCS arrive?
  1. It's likely to be an expectation. DH is very child-focused as well as me (part of the reason we have 4 children). I'm not worried about that expectation, I'm good at saying no when needed. I don't think an adult child - parent relationship needs lots of "involvement" to be close and stable.
  1. Yes, certainly with our older teens. They haven't even gone to uni yet tho, so babies are a while away. The kids already know our retirement plan is a tiny house somewhere remote. The tiny house means no room for grandchildren sleepovers. Somewhere remote means moving away. DH and I are both natural introverts. We love our children with all our hearts, but look forward to the empty nest. Ìt feels taboo to state that.
  1. Possibly. I accept it might. I really want some "just me and DH time" without any responsibility for others. Because we have 10y between our eldest and youngest child, we may still be active parenting when we become grandparents. I don't face that thought with any glee.
changeyerheadworzel · 25/07/2023 18:46

peachypudding · 25/07/2023 18:41

I remember feeling a bit hurt that my parents didn't seem that bothered about my children. They loved them but weren't exactly desperate to look after them.

Now I'm a grandmother I get it completely. I love my grandchild but have no desire to provide childcare (though I have agreed to).

Why did you agree to it?

continentallentil · 25/07/2023 18:46

TomatoSandwiches · 25/07/2023 16:56

Whenever I've suggested that perhaps a poster parents didn't enjoy parenting them or dealing with the worries of having a child I get shot down but I still stand by it.
Lots of people would not have children if they had their time again, they can't turn back time but it is quite clear they have issues about it when they aren't doting grandparents.

Well sometimes, but sometimes less than enthusiastic grandparents have just had their fill of children by being parents.

They do have fond feelings for their grandchildren, but they want to do other things with their lives than centre life around kids, again.

We expect too much of grandparents these days. It’s lovely when they want to be hands on, but it can’t be expected.

CurlewKate · 25/07/2023 18:45

I'm pretty sure she won't-I think we have a equal, respectful relationship and we like each other. And of course I might suddenly turn into a doting devoted granny. But in my dark moments at 2 in the morning, I do worry that when/if my dd has children, I'll end up with a relationship with my dd that is dependent on her children.

peachypudding · 25/07/2023 18:41

I remember feeling a bit hurt that my parents didn't seem that bothered about my children. They loved them but weren't exactly desperate to look after them.

Now I'm a grandmother I get it completely. I love my grandchild but have no desire to provide childcare (though I have agreed to).

JudgeRudy · 25/07/2023 18:40

I think plenty of people don't particularly want to be grandparents but I don't think most resent/disapprove when their children do become parents.
I think the truth is many (older) woman have never really viewed being child free as an option. I've heard many older people say they married and had kids (pretty soon) because 'that's what people did '. I dare say there are reluctant grandparents who, if they had their time again today would probably not even be parents!
Living away from each other makes it easier to 'ignore' grandchildren because you don't really bond with them. When I visit my daughter I enjoy spending time with her the most. She has 2 teens who l have a 'good' relationship, but I'd much rather spend time in daughter's company. My sons due a baby (maybe today!) and ill visit, but it's him I want to see. If he emigrated I'd miss him a lot. I wouldn't miss the baby at all.

saraclara · 25/07/2023 18:38

You have the choice (usually) whether to be a mother. You don't get any choice about whether you want to be a grandparent.

I adore my grandkids, who are at really cute ages when they love my company too. But who knows whether I always will, when they get to the stage when a visit to grandma's means they just sit on their phones and ignore me because they're only here on sufferance (my friends are enduring that stage at the moment!).

My inlaws adored being grandparents, and would have been beside themselves had they lived to see their DGGDs. My mum couldn't be less interested in her grandkids, and hasn't shown the slightest interest in metting her GGDs.

AcrossthePond55 · 25/07/2023 18:37

SilIssuesAgain · 25/07/2023 17:30

I do find the Mumsnet expectation that grandparents should be prepared to drop everything ans do childcare a bit odd never asked or expected childcare from mil. But I think she does not even like our dc let alone love them. It's one thing not wanting to take active roll in being a grandparent and being almost in tears at the prospect of being one and showing zero interest in the few times you see them. I think she resents our dc as it changes the relationship she has with dh.

It's one thing not wanting to take active roll in being a grandparent and being almost in tears at the prospect of being one and showing zero interest in the few times you see them.

But if she didn't want to be a grandparent, why wouldn't she be upset knowing that our society's (and likely her children's) 'expectations' of her were going to be that she would be thrilled to be 'lovely helpful granny' and she would be 'odd' if she isn't. And the fact that you mention that she has 'zero interest' shows that you do have some expectations of what her behaviour 'should be'.

This is no different than a woman who doesn't want children being upset at unexpectedly falling pregnant. People will insist 'you will love it when it gets here' and are aghast at 'you don't want your baby?'. The difference is that the woman can make her own decision about what to do, but an 'unwilling' prospective grandparent (rightly) has no say as to the coming grandchild. All they can do is carry on with their lives and have as little or as much involvement as they choose to have, regardless of the wishes of their child. That doesn't make them a 'bad person' nor should they have to 'sacrifice' (for lack of a better word) the life they want to live.

My situation is 'opposite' as my eldest & spouse have decided they don't want children and I would love to be a grandma. But I have no more right to 'force' them to provide me with a grandchild than they would have to 'force' me to be a 'granny' if I didn't want the 'role' or responsibilities.

maddiemookins16mum · 25/07/2023 18:33

My mum died when DD was 8 (now 18) they adored each other. Thankfully my DMIL is still with us (at 94 and living in our annexe). They too have an incredible relationship built on a mutual respect, lots of ‘in jokes’ and a love of Australian Masterchef and Bake Off.
It’s a joy to watch them together, they are both very lucky.
DD joined the Navy in May, I know DMIL misses her terribly, she writes her proper letters every week.

Hardbackwriter · 25/07/2023 18:32

I think there's an assumption throughout this thread that you'll know exactly how you'll feel about grandparenthood before having any grandchildren - but I think that, as with becoming a parent, it isn't always that predictable. My ILs were very clear before we had DC1 that they wouldn't want to be much involved - had far too much going on, not baby people, etc. He was born and they fell head over heels for him and it's hard to prise them away from him and his brother and I know for a fact that they bore on about their brilliance to all they encounter! On the other hand just like parenthood a lot of people have romanticised ideals that don't come true - hence the common occurrence of childcare arrangements being arranged in pregnancy/early infancy and then reneged on as reality looms...

HideousKinky · 25/07/2023 18:29

I thought I wasn't that bothered about being a grandmother but when my DD's baby was born I was instantly smitten 😄

BadNomad · 25/07/2023 18:28

There are no rules. Everyone is different. Some people just aren't close to their children, or maybe they didn't particularly enjoy raising children, so grandchildren aren't necessarily a positive or exciting addition to their lives. And some might feel closer to their daughter's children than to their son's. Everyone is different.

GulfCoastBeachGirl · 25/07/2023 18:20

Babies don't interest me,
or toddlers, but as my grandchildren became older I enjoyed my time with them more and more

I can see myself (potentially) being the same way. The only baby or toddler I ever had any interest in was my own. Just was never one of those women that was besotted by babies or found toddlers "adorable". Too old to change my ways now😂

Loverofoxbowlakes · 25/07/2023 18:19

My ex mil lived very locally and already had 6 dgc before mine came along so I hoped we were on a winner (albeit more of a glamorous gran than hands-on) as my parents lived hundreds of miles away.

In their first 6 years of life my dc saw more of my parents than of mil and fil, it really did break my heart (and contributed significantly to my pnd). Since I left dh they've seen the dc less than 5 times in 10 years.

WickedSerious · 25/07/2023 18:16

TomatoSandwiches · 25/07/2023 16:56

Whenever I've suggested that perhaps a poster parents didn't enjoy parenting them or dealing with the worries of having a child I get shot down but I still stand by it.
Lots of people would not have children if they had their time again, they can't turn back time but it is quite clear they have issues about it when they aren't doting grandparents.

I'm one of those people and knowing I'll never have grandchildren has come as a huge relief.

changeyerheadworzel · 25/07/2023 18:16

I used to think I would be so sad if I wasn't a grandparent, I am not so sure now. I think I would be ok with it if none of mine had any children. Funny thing is, I adore children but the intrinsic want that I used to have to have about being a grandmother has waned. On the other hand if I do get grandchildren, I will dote on the them, visit lots, have them visit me and do the odd night of babysitting but I will not do any kind of regular childcare, not a chance, not a hope. I am only now beginning to relax and enjoy the freedom that having young adults and teenagers brings and there is not a chance in hell I would give that up to be saddled with minding grandchildren all day every day. Some people on here especially take the absolute PISS out of their parents and wear them in to the ground with free childminding. I won't be one of those grandparents. I will be living my life and enjoying my retirement. I will also enjoy my grandkids if I do get any but not to my own detriment.

Lwrenagain · 25/07/2023 18:12

I really should change my name to lwrenconfusedagain, because this topic makes me swing between thoughts like a hypnotists watch 🙈

When DC1 was newborn a lady in the asda burst into tears because her DC had both chosen to remain childfree. She really seemed to grieve this, she explained when they were little they didn't have much and she was not in a much nicer home etc, she'd just imagined being a hands on nana etc.

I love children of all ages and we're the family the neighbours kids or their friends are hanging out in our house, so I'd love on one hand the idea we always have a nice full house, but equally, it's not a nice world anymore.
It's a clusterfuck on many levels, so I'd possibly feel relieved that my DC weren't going to feel the endless pressures of modern life with DC.
I think back to the grieving lady in the shop and think, if my life needed more children to care for, I'd return to fostering or care home work for older kids.

My eldest has always wanted to be a dad, but he may change his mind, I'll encourage him to do what makes him happy always.

I have 3 NT kids, the 2 youngest I would be surprised if children are a choice the more able one would make and my youngest is sadly not, if I'm honest, likely to ever have the capacity for an adult relationship 💔

I'm due my first and only DD soon and I hope she never ever feels she has to justify her choices to have children or remain child free or to have a large brood to me.
I hope I can raise her to be confident to do what she feels is her path.

My DS has friends who are parents at 16 and I honestly felt so capable and ready to start spitting out kids that age, (I never, waited until 19, so I was SUPER mature!) But i look at these kids now and realise how young they are, I'd definitely be as helpful as I could in this scenario, but I'd be secretly upset for all the experiences my DC would miss out on.
But equally, nothing has ever bought me as much joy as sitting on the beach with my little fella in his straw hat, face covered in ice cream and sand and just being truly, 100% completely happy in the moments I had with him when it was just us, but I do hope my kids never feel their lives are so lacking they need someone to love such as a baby.

So with my twattish thoughts compressed, whilst I would always love more DC in our lives, more people even, to love, I'd just much rather my actual DC as opposed to imaginary DGC are happy. Whatever they choose, they have my support. (Unless they choose to be dicks, not having that)