Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that some people don't want to be grandparents

109 replies

SilIssuesAgain · 25/07/2023 16:17

My parents were over the moon when I told them I was pregnant. They love spending time with our 2 dc. They visit lots and interact with them and they are happy to help out.

My inlaws are the exact opposite. Mil especially does not seem interested in being a grandmother and I get the impression she thinks they are a burden almost. When dh told her I was pregnant she was on the phone almost in tears asking how we would cope (married, early 30s, have mortgage and some savings - not that that matters. We have also never asked her for any help). She rarely sees my dc and when she visits she is just interested in talking to dh. I honestly wonder if she even likes our dc.

Are your parents or inlaws interested in your dc?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
UrsulaIsMyQueen · 26/07/2023 21:03

My own mother said she'd meet from infant/junior school 3pm-5, 2-3 days a week for me, would absolutely be there in an emergency; but would not provide 'childcare' as my kids were my responsibility

What’s that if not childcare? Genuine question. My parents work full time and in laws live abroad so we don’t get that luxury! We pay for after school club every day.

Fordian · 26/07/2023 20:58

I should add, my DSs are 22/24. So no grandchildren in the immediate offing. And any that might appear now would be 'accidents' which is hardly ideal for anyone.

I couldn't care less. I don't need the hassle!

Fordian · 26/07/2023 20:56

I'm 60. I have two very close same age friends who are grandmothers. One is also dealing with 90+ parents.

It sounds exhausting.

The one with the very elderly, rich, demanding parents ('oh no, darling, we wouldn't want strangers in the house when you can help!'- etc) works 3 days a week, but also drives an hour plus each way, one day a week for an 8-6 looking after her 3/5 yr old grandkids. (Their mother is a partner in a London law firm...).

The other does 7-6 two days a week as her DD can't afford childcare....

Screw that.

My own mother said she'd meet from infant/junior school 3pm-5, 2-3 days a week for me, would absolutely be there in an emergency; but would not provide 'childcare' as my kids were my responsibility.

I concur.

Some ppl's (women's) reason for existing is caring for others. It defines their worth. Others, not.

kraftyKitten · 26/07/2023 07:31

Take my cousin . Resented being at home with her DC s went back to work asap . Said being at home with babies was boring. Now she is a Grandma she does childcare and can't get enough of them .

PyongyangKipperbang · 26/07/2023 00:16

I am grandparent age. Eldest in his thirties and will almost certainly never have kids. DD is mid twenties and says she doesnt want them but that could change. Others are younger so I cant imagine it becoming an issue for a good while, although they are all older enough to have them but I cant see it happening for some years yet.

I have no interest in becoming a grandmother. Not that I would actively discourage them, they must like their own lives as I have lived mine, but I am not one of those women who get to the empty nest stage and then focus on having grandkids to fill the void.

I suspect that there are two reasons for this. One is that DS was born when I was 17 so had no fun young years like most people do. Then I had 5 more, all wanted and planned for (well apart from DS2 who was a bit of a surprise but no less wanted for that!) over the next 21 years so until recently I have always had young children. Youngest is now 12 and I am entering a period of my life that I can live solely for me. Of course she is the priority but I can go away for the weekend and not have that horrible worry about leaving her as I did when she, and the others, were little. She is living her own life now with her friends with sleepovers etc, and I can do that same.

So I dont feel any empty nest worries about the kids gradually leaving because I am looking forward to finally having some years just for me. I would never be a child care grandparent, I would do much as my parents did/do which is babysit occasionally, step up in an emergency (of couse I would without a thought) and spend time with them as a family. I would never be the "I want the baby to myself overnight once a week to pretend to be a newborn mummy again" grandparent either, friends have had this and it was suffocating for them.

I know I sound horrible but if the kids dont have their own kids it wouldnt bother me in the slightest.

saraclara · 25/07/2023 22:48

dogsweetdog · 25/07/2023 21:58

My gut feeling is that for some people the worries of being a parent, the life sentence of fretting about your children's happiness, just make the prospect of extending the same level of loving concern to grandchildren too frightening to be welome.

Nailed it.

There is that. Though it didn't hit me until I became a grandparent.

I can worry for Britain regarding my grandchildren. All the more, I think, because I don't have any control. My own kids were my responsibility and I could be proactive about things. Make the decisions. But as a GM I can only watch. MN is a constant reminder that they're not my children and I don't get to give their mother* advice.

*she is a wonderful mother by the way. But there's still that stress and worry and the helplessness I feel about these small people that I love.

hiredandsqueak · 25/07/2023 22:01

Well I'm a Granny, love my dgs and even provide childcare (only in school holidays now thank God) but, no, I was never bothered about being a grandparent, didn't actually expect I ever would be and had circumstances been different I most definitely would never have agreed to providing childcare. Yes dgs is lovely and a joy but I can't say that I would have felt in any way deprived should I never have had a grandchild.

Fifthtimelucky · 25/07/2023 21:59

My parents and parents in law were all loving and interested grandparents to my children - though not involved on a day to day basis because of distance.

I hope to be a grandparent one day. I'm in my 60s and would like them while I'm still young enough to do active things with them, but if my children wait as long to have children as I did, I shall be well into my 70s.

dogsweetdog · 25/07/2023 21:58

My gut feeling is that for some people the worries of being a parent, the life sentence of fretting about your children's happiness, just make the prospect of extending the same level of loving concern to grandchildren too frightening to be welome.

Nailed it.

LeilaDarling · 25/07/2023 21:52

Being really honest I’m not overly fussed about the prospect at all. Love my sons to bits but if they don’t have their own children that’s ok - a dog or cat Nan is fine for me!

Purplepeaches123 · 25/07/2023 21:49

My parents live all their grandchildren. I have adult children, eldest in her thirties. I have no desire for grandchildren but of course if they did come along I’d love them and want to spend time with them.

LuckyPeonies · 25/07/2023 21:46

Dontcallmescarface · 25/07/2023 19:19

My mum was the complete opposite.
Whilst I've no doubt she loved all 3 of her DC's in her own way she didn't really enjoy being a mother. She was never abusive or nasty but there were many times, looking back, that she was just "going through the motions" of being a mother, for want of a better way to describe it. When the GC came along all that changed. She absolutely adored all 5 of them and when the GGC arrived (there were 6 by the time she died), she positively glowed with happiness. I think DD misses her GM far more than I miss my mum 3 years on from mum's death. Of all the people I thought would be ambivalent about being a GP I would have put mum on the top of the list...I got that so, so wrong.

That’s lovely to read! Perhaps, in retrospect, she felt badly about her lack of enthusiasm as a mother, and considered her grandchildren a second chance?

Ultraviolet85 · 25/07/2023 20:50

I’m a long way off being a grandparent but I could never imagine shunning my babies babies! I will definitely be an involved grandparent if/ when that day comes, I can say that with certainty!

mewkins · 25/07/2023 20:41

This thread is quite an eye opener and I think things have changed an enormous amount over the generations. All of my friends my age had really involved grandparents who were very much part of the family (whether they lived with them or not). I can't remember any grandparents 'opting out' and I'm not talking about childcare - just being present at birthday parties, BBQs, holidays etc.

I'm really lucky in that my parents absolutely embraced being grandparents and during the last year or so of my dad's life when he was in a lot of pain, they were his focus.

Now that my mum is on her own to be involved in her grandchildren's lives keeps her going and keeps her young. She loves spending time with them and their friends.

Also plenty of studies have shown the positive effects for both grandparents and grandchildren in a good relationship and being actively involved in each others lives.

Bluebellbike · 25/07/2023 20:12

HelpMeGetThrough · 25/07/2023 17:36

If I become one, that's fine. If there is an expectation to provide childcare or be available at the drop of a hat, I won't be up for that.

Exactly how I feel. However it is unlikely I will ever be a biological grandparent. My DD has always been clear she would only adopt. My DS is unable to have DC. I worked in childcare and education for 27 years and feel like I wouldn't be interested in being a grandparent; particularly if they had no biological connection.

unicornhair · 25/07/2023 20:12

I think it’s obvious disinterested parents become disinterested GPs.
MIL was obsessed when first GC was born and talked about little else, but she lived a distance away. When they moved closer I think it became clear she wasn’t actually interested in small children at all. When the second GC was born she was totally over it. She did do babysitting for them, but very minimal interaction with them.
Of course wasn’t interested when DD was born. She particularly wanted DH to stay child free (and single) to be totally available to her.
If you went in her house it was full of photos of her GC so you would think she was devoted. DH still persists in talking as if she was. She would do anything not to actually spend any actual time with them though or be in the room with them.
She was minimally interested in her own children particularly when they were children though.

Wintercomesoon · 25/07/2023 19:50

These potential grandparents are also actual adults with their own hopes, dreams and goals. Being a grandparent is not a goal of mine because I have a rich, fulfilling life and i don't feel like I need grandchildren to define myself. If I do eventually have grandchildren I will love them but I plan to spend my later years being me and rediscovering my passions that fr the most part, I had to sacrifice while being a parent.

SydneyJKL · 25/07/2023 19:43

My parents have always been disinterested. They moved abroad when mine were tiny and the relationship now the DC’s are young adults hasn't - I was going to say recovered - but actually has never really established. A three week visit once a year hasn't been enough.

On the other hand I would love to be actively involved as a GP. My ex step DIL made contact very difficult when she was married to DSS. She has refused any contact since they divorced and we have lost our GDC’s. ☹️

willWillSmithsmith · 25/07/2023 19:41

Parentalalienation · 25/07/2023 17:53

I couldn't have my own children for medical reasons. I gained lovely step-children via marriage but my parents wanted nothing to do with them. Even down to refusing to let the children call them 'grandparent' names. Their only opportunity to be grandparents and they didn't want to know because they weren't 'real blood grandchildren'. I don't understand their reasoning.

That’s horrible. Although I’m not at all eager to be a GP I couldn’t imagine being so cold.

leli · 25/07/2023 19:35

GillianMcQueef · 25/07/2023 17:11

DH adopted my DD from a previous relationship when she was 4. His parents refused to acknowledge her even though we asked her if they would (she has no other grandparents). When we talked about having a baby they said they were too young (although they were in their 60s) and they wouldn't want any child of ours to call them grandma/grandad, and we'd better be aware that they wouldn't want to babysit or be involved in the child's life at all. As it happened we didn't have more DC, it just didn't happen for us.

DH went NC a couple of years later for many reasons, but their attitude to DD was a main contributing factor to his decision.

How totally awful. So sad for you and your partner.

TortolaParadise · 25/07/2023 19:23

I guess some people don't want to be grandparents any more than you or I chose to be born. It's a decision out of their hands. Sad but true.

Dontcallmescarface · 25/07/2023 19:19

LuckyPeonies · 25/07/2023 17:36

From personal experience, people who enjoyed parenting and, given the choice, would do it over again, generally make for involved grandparents. Those who were ambivalent (or forced into it via abortion denial or family pressure) and would not do it again, generally don’t. I also think people who were reluctant parents generally don’t have great relationships with their kids, so that would also affect the relationship with the grandkids.

My mum was the complete opposite.
Whilst I've no doubt she loved all 3 of her DC's in her own way she didn't really enjoy being a mother. She was never abusive or nasty but there were many times, looking back, that she was just "going through the motions" of being a mother, for want of a better way to describe it. When the GC came along all that changed. She absolutely adored all 5 of them and when the GGC arrived (there were 6 by the time she died), she positively glowed with happiness. I think DD misses her GM far more than I miss my mum 3 years on from mum's death. Of all the people I thought would be ambivalent about being a GP I would have put mum on the top of the list...I got that so, so wrong.

everetting · 25/07/2023 19:16

My children are teenagers. I loved it when they were small and loved spending time with them. But now the idea of spending a lot of time with a small child horrified me. Maybe it's menopause?

CurlewKate · 25/07/2023 19:16

To be honest, this thread is mr very encouraging. Everyone seems to be talking about grandparents in terms of childcare. I never actually met my grandmother, but we had a brilliant relationship pre internet by letter. She was wise and kind and I learned enormous amounts from her. My own mother was a very hands on grandma to my dd, but wasn't physically able to look after ds alone. But they read and talked and drew together and he and she had a very special relationship. No childcare at all.

Crimblecrumble1990 · 25/07/2023 19:13

Gosh how much childcare do people think you are expected to do??

My parents are wonderful grandparents - we probably see them once a week, perhaps a visit to a farm or something with my children and my brother's children.

They are more than happy to babysit for the odd meal out or if I need someone to sit in while I give the house a clean or something.

They are genuinely interested to see photos and hear about what we've been up to.

They are not particularly fond of children but love me and my brother and by extension love our children. We are very lucky to have them by the sound of this thread!

Swipe left for the next trending thread