Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage you to fast?

335 replies

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 12:58

If you want to lose weight and keep it off.

I fast from 8pm to 12 pm. Usually have my first something around 1pm

I haven't actually changed what I eat. I make sure I have some nutrient rich food in me but generally my diet is a bit shit Blush

Anyway, I've gone from a size 16 to a size 10. This happened within 3 months. It's been 9 months now and I've kept it all off! Remaining at a size 10

I don't eat breakfast, ever.

When I was in my teens, I almost skipped breakfast because I genuinely forgot to eat. The same happened early twenties but then after I had my son, I started eating breakfast!

Since that time I went from a size 10 to a size 16.

So yeah, for 9 months now, I just haven't eaten breakfast but haven't restricted myself really and still don't have a perfect diet by any means

I am remaining a size 10 and it's working. I suppose I'm an 'all or nothing' person. And I find the fast easy to stick to because I can eat 0! Sticking to 0 is easier than sticking to 3 sensible meals a day, for me Grin

Now I just have lunch, snack a bit tbh, and then dinner, also snack a bit but not loads as find I don't want to

When I ate breakfast, I found I was hungry all the time!

So glad I did this and took the plunge. Just thought I'd share

OP posts:
FarmGirl78 · 25/07/2023 16:17

This would be dangerous for people on certain medications. For you, it may have worked, but for some people it would cause havok and lead to too severe peak/trough with metabolism when levels need to be as steady as poss.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 25/07/2023 16:14

Desperatenow1 · 25/07/2023 16:03

😂hardly VVV unreasonable...

How on earth can eating your daily calories in a condensed timeframe not be safe? It will work if it means you consume less calories a day, as that's the only way to lose weight.

Where does it say the body HAS to have xx amount of food at certain intervals throughout the day? I am intrigued about this not safe/appropriate comment of your post.

Where does it say the body HAS to have xx amount of food at certain intervals throughout the day?

In guidance given to type one diabetics and to migraine sufferers. Too long between meals will cause diabetic coma in the former and trigger a migraine in the latter.

WonderingWanda · 25/07/2023 16:14

Glad it's working for you. It just doesn't work for me, my blood sugar drops too low. Very low carb and no sugar but keeping topped up throughout the day works better for me.

KickingEAP · 25/07/2023 16:12

I wish I could make this work for me. I like to drink wine of an evening at least once a week though, and when I'm working (three days a week) I get up at 5am and work a 12hr shift. I don't think I could do it without sustenance.

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 25/07/2023 16:12

Anotherparkingthread · 25/07/2023 13:07

This is actually a misconception. You only become hungry when your body has had something to eat and your blood sugar starts to fall again. You won't feel hungry at all as long as you stick to just coffee etc without sugar. Your appetite will return to normal when you break fasting period after your first meal.
Size 8 at 5ft 9 and have fasted since my teens. Health benefits are great.

That's utter shite about not being hungry if you don't eat. If I don't eat breakfast, I'm feeling faint by lunch time. The increased incidence of migraines isn't much fun either.

pollykitty · 25/07/2023 16:11

I’m currently trying it, 14 hours seems to be my limit. It’s good to hear a positive result as I’m currently size 16.

sandyhappypeople · 25/07/2023 16:09

pigsDOfly · 25/07/2023 15:13

Not really 'fasting' is it? It's just not eating breakfast, which a great many people have always done, it's nothing new, and it's not some sort of magic weight loss formula.

I enjoy my breakfast. I come from a family that has always eaten breakfast and the whole family has always been very slim. Probably because what they eat for breakfast, and the rest of the time, doesn't include a load of calorie heavy crap.

If you cut out a complete meal every day your calorie intake will be less, especially if breakfast, in the past, has always been a fry up or a sugar laden cereal.

Not difficult to see how it would work for some people really.

It is fasting though..

you only eat within an 8 hour window, then fast the rest of the time, it works for consistent weight loss because unlike just skipping a meal, you aren’t snacking outside of your 8 hour window, and the facts of it are, for some people who do it, something just clicks and your body gets used to that way of eating and you genuinely don’t feel hungry outside of your normal mealtimes.. THAT’S what makes it more effective than just skipping a meal, if it works for you it can be a total game changer.

if you’ve never been overweight, that’s great, but a lot of people are and if they find something that helps them lose weight effectively and keep it off and they want to share it, why feel the need to shit all over it?

Madamecastafiore · 25/07/2023 16:07

God I couldn't think of anything worse. Just eat a sensible, balanced diet and no processed shite and you'll be able to eat regularly and not have to miss meals.

Desperatenow1 · 25/07/2023 16:03

LordEmsworth · 25/07/2023 13:10

YABVVVU.

Great it's worked for you . Doesn't mean it will work, is appropriate, or is safe for everyone.

😂hardly VVV unreasonable...

How on earth can eating your daily calories in a condensed timeframe not be safe? It will work if it means you consume less calories a day, as that's the only way to lose weight.

Where does it say the body HAS to have xx amount of food at certain intervals throughout the day? I am intrigued about this not safe/appropriate comment of your post.

Dentistlakes · 25/07/2023 16:02

Fasting is a great tool for weight management, but as
this thread shows, it’s not for everyone.

For me, building muscle through resistance training has been a game changer. After many years fasting and consuming 1200 calories (whilst running 50+ miles per week), I now eat twice that without having to fast or hammer the hell out of my body with excessive cardio. I would highly recommend it, especially to women as they age and lose muscle mass. I’m in way better shape at over 50 than I was in my 20’s.

WisherWood · 25/07/2023 16:02

I've started doing this fast though and after a couple of days I found I wasn't hungry in the morning. I now struggle to eat early! I do have a cuppa (with milk and a bit of sugar tho)

Once the milk and sugar hit your stomach, your fast has ended. That does still need digesting, even if there isn't much of it.

WisherWood · 25/07/2023 15:57

Anotherparkingthread · 25/07/2023 13:07

This is actually a misconception. You only become hungry when your body has had something to eat and your blood sugar starts to fall again. You won't feel hungry at all as long as you stick to just coffee etc without sugar. Your appetite will return to normal when you break fasting period after your first meal.
Size 8 at 5ft 9 and have fasted since my teens. Health benefits are great.

You might then want to explain to my body, when I wake up at 7:30am, having not eaten for 12 hours, why it is I feel hungry. If I don't have breakfast, I faint. I don't see point of battling through that for anybody. I've been a size 10 (at 5' 7") for many years. I can fit into clothes I had 30 years ago. I eat between 7:30am and 730 pm. It's fine for me.

If fasting works for you, great. But it won't be what works for every body.

lightinthebox · 25/07/2023 15:54

Nah. I weight train and need to eat to keep getting stronger. But then, all women should be skinny and weak right from not eating?

mumlikeaboss · 25/07/2023 15:53

Ooh and echo what @Freetodowhatiwant says about thyroid levels - Hashi's sufferer here 👋🏻

If you ever get thyroid bloods done you REALLY must get the numbers to know where you stand!!

Plennury · 25/07/2023 15:52

Or, you know, just eat a healthy diet made up of a variety of different food groups, in reasonably sized portions. Radical, I know, but unless you have a medical condition as diagnosed by a medical doctor and not by Google, that should be all you need to do to maintain an appropriate weight.

gingerguineapig · 25/07/2023 15:51

I think fasting is a silly idea. People go for "fasted" runs - yuck. I like to have some fuel for exercise! Actually it may not be such a bad idea for men, but isn't advisable for women.

More generally, if you want to lose weight, exercise more and eat less.

You don't need to do silly faddish things.

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/07/2023 15:51

NorthernSpirit · 25/07/2023 15:36

As a qualified food scientist - this fad of fasting makes my skin crawl.

It isn’t teaching healthy eating or moderation.

Because you are depriving your body of food on certain days or between certain hours, your hunger can become more extreme which will also lead to over-eating and a choice of foods that are not so healthy for your body.

Another drawback of fasting is that it can lead to a reduction in your physical activity.

A great quick fix, but not sustainable.

It suits some people though. My dh goes to work and doesn’t eat until he gets home, which can be as late as 7.30pm, sometimes as early as 5.30pm. He then has his second meal at about 10.30pm/11pm. He sometimes eats at Lunch then an earlier dinner if with colleagues or at the weekend.

I otoh couldn’t eat like this. My window starts between 9 and 10 am. I shift it around depending on what I’m doing. I’d rather 10 but can’t always do this. If I’ve misjudged my consumption needs, I eat a bit of fruit and /or a few nuts outside the window. No point stressing about it.

mumlikeaboss · 25/07/2023 15:51

It's not magic, but it does work for lots of people.

I absolutely love it, feel much better physically than if I eat several meals a day. Have done it for 2 1/2 years now and at first I wanted to convert EVERYONE 😂 but with the benefit of experience I now realise that not everyone will get on well with it.

Does irritate me when people make flat statements about it being dangerous for everyone or making people eat badly... I eat way better and more intuitively now than I did 3 years ago.

UserRose · 25/07/2023 15:49

Freetodowhatiwant · 25/07/2023 13:14

I totally agree! I often forget to fast in the winter and life sometimes takes over, but when I want to lose weight and keep it off I do 16:8 and it really works. I too have thyroid disease and take thyroxine. I realise not everything works for everyone but for me it definitely works. Your thyroid does have to be normal and by normal for me that's a TSH of 1. something, nothing over 2 if I can help it. A doctor would tell me anything over 3 is normal and for me that is really not a nice level to be on at all. Anyone with thyroid issues - make sure you check your actual numbers and don't let them tell you it's 'normal' without knowing what works for you.

This 100%

Usernamen · 25/07/2023 15:49

I also do this! I try to eat between 12-6 but it always ends up 12-8 because DP doesn’t like eating dinner so early.

I don’t lose weight, this is just a way to maintain weight (I’m a size 6/8).

KatherineSwynford1403 · 25/07/2023 15:48

JustRingJoeDuffy · 25/07/2023 13:15

Do you think it's the not eating breakfast or the fasting for 16 hours that is key?

I think I could try having breakfast at 8am, having a big lunch at 1pm and maybe a banana around 4pm - but I don't think I'd do well without having any breakfast. I get up just after 6 and bring breakfast with me to have at work, and if ever I forget it I either end up buying a croissant or having a headache by 12 o'clock.
Breakfast isn't huge - oat flakes, some raisins and nuts, yogurt and some frozen berries mixed in a bowl and left overnight in the fridge. But I would miss it a lot if I didn't have it. Whereas I'd be fine with a cup of milk-less tea in the evening - providing I had a big lunch (i.e. soup and main) at lunchtime.

I could do that - the problem I have is that I finish work at 4.30 and go to the gym to a class and am always hungry then and get home too tired to eat anything. Maybe this would work.

Lovesacake · 25/07/2023 15:45

It’s not a magic bullet. I lost 5 stone whilst fasting. Have now regained 4 of those stones whilst still fasting. It’s not the fasting that lost the weight, it was the calorie deficit.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 25/07/2023 15:45

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 25/07/2023 15:40

I'm the same, I feel dizzy and sick if I don't eat. I was told on here that I must be diabetic as it's not possible to feel like that otherwise!

Ha, me too. I've had multiple blood tests and no signs of diabetes.

For me it's because I work an active job (dog walking) so I'm on the go constantly from basically the moment I get up. If I skip breakfast, I'm starving by 10am and feeling unwell by lunchtime. My dad is super active and he's exactly the same - he needs to eat breakfast or he gets unwell.

But at weekends or on days off I can skip breakfast quite happily and I don't get the same feeling of hunger, so I put it down to being so active and needing that food to keep me going.

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/07/2023 15:44

sigfey · 25/07/2023 13:12

I'm the same - I don't think it is personally.

Some people are just more susceptible to feeling rubbish if they get blood glucose at the lower end.

I have recently restarted better eating. It’s tough in the beginning. To overcome this, it is possible to start with a longer eating and reduce down. Eg instead of 16/8 do 14/10 etc. Above all eat healthily and reduce sugar. It’s a great time of year for it as the weather is hot. I am eating lots of salads.

The best way to over come the dizziness and stabilise blood sugar longer term is to eat the vegetables (a large amount) first then the protein then the carb. It is much better for the digestive system. As I am used to eating veg with my protein, I tend to eat half the veg first then eat the rest with the protein.

Rehydration salts as mentioned. I make myself a saturated salt drink called sole to keep myself hydrated.

mumlikeaboss · 25/07/2023 15:42

JustRingJoeDuffy · 25/07/2023 13:15

Do you think it's the not eating breakfast or the fasting for 16 hours that is key?

I think I could try having breakfast at 8am, having a big lunch at 1pm and maybe a banana around 4pm - but I don't think I'd do well without having any breakfast. I get up just after 6 and bring breakfast with me to have at work, and if ever I forget it I either end up buying a croissant or having a headache by 12 o'clock.
Breakfast isn't huge - oat flakes, some raisins and nuts, yogurt and some frozen berries mixed in a bowl and left overnight in the fridge. But I would miss it a lot if I didn't have it. Whereas I'd be fine with a cup of milk-less tea in the evening - providing I had a big lunch (i.e. soup and main) at lunchtime.

It's the 16 hours that matters, it doesn't matter which 8-hour slot you choose to eat in 👍🏻