Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage you to fast?

335 replies

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 12:58

If you want to lose weight and keep it off.

I fast from 8pm to 12 pm. Usually have my first something around 1pm

I haven't actually changed what I eat. I make sure I have some nutrient rich food in me but generally my diet is a bit shit Blush

Anyway, I've gone from a size 16 to a size 10. This happened within 3 months. It's been 9 months now and I've kept it all off! Remaining at a size 10

I don't eat breakfast, ever.

When I was in my teens, I almost skipped breakfast because I genuinely forgot to eat. The same happened early twenties but then after I had my son, I started eating breakfast!

Since that time I went from a size 10 to a size 16.

So yeah, for 9 months now, I just haven't eaten breakfast but haven't restricted myself really and still don't have a perfect diet by any means

I am remaining a size 10 and it's working. I suppose I'm an 'all or nothing' person. And I find the fast easy to stick to because I can eat 0! Sticking to 0 is easier than sticking to 3 sensible meals a day, for me Grin

Now I just have lunch, snack a bit tbh, and then dinner, also snack a bit but not loads as find I don't want to

When I ate breakfast, I found I was hungry all the time!

So glad I did this and took the plunge. Just thought I'd share

OP posts:
LuckyCats · 25/07/2023 21:07

It works for me.
I had an eating disorder in my late teens into my early teens and fasting feels like the healthiest way for me to lose weight.
counting calories or weighting food would be triggering for me, I like that I don’t have to think about food at all only if I can eat or not eat.

sigfey · 25/07/2023 21:03

There has been evidence that migraine sufferers have benefited from fasting, so again not sure why it wouldn't be considered safe, I would have thought at least one would try it for them first to see if it might work.

There genuinely is no good quality to evidence to suggest that individuals with migraine disorder benefit from fasting - in contrast, there is good quality evidence that they benefit from regular small meals - hence the current recommendations from neurologists and migraine specialists.

In terms of being considered safe or not, it's unwise to encourage patients to expose themselves to known triggers, particularly those with chronic migraine disorder (of which there are many complications of the disorder becoming unmanageable).

Interested to see where you're getting the claims from @Desperatenow1

Annaisatwat · 25/07/2023 20:54

Delatron · 25/07/2023 20:52

It will be more the lack of processed foods, no sugar, cooking from scratch. Only drinking water and green tea. Don’t underestimate the huge impact of that and overemphasise the impact of fasting. You’ve changed the way you eat entirely.

Oh yes, of course there is that. It plays a massive part. I’ll never go back to eating out of jars and packets.

But I am also happier fasting with it. I feel great, it just suits me. I don’t find it difficult or a chore at all.

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 20:52

mumlikeaboss · 25/07/2023 15:53

Ooh and echo what @Freetodowhatiwant says about thyroid levels - Hashi's sufferer here 👋🏻

If you ever get thyroid bloods done you REALLY must get the numbers to know where you stand!!

Hashimotos for me too
I've actually just changed GP, the final straw being that a TSH of 2.5 and a T4 of 13 is "fine"
I feel awful

My new GP has upped my levo, and is sending me for T3 bloods

Delatron · 25/07/2023 20:52

Annaisatwat · 25/07/2023 20:37

I do OMAD, or 23/1 fasting. Once a week I’ll may be so two meals.

It’s changed my life. I don’t eat anything processed, I cook from scratch. No sugar at all. I only drink water and green tea.

I feel and look amazing. My blood pressure is now normal (it was high for a period, I didn’t want to take drugs which is why I changed my life), my last bloods showed my inflammation markers which had been high for a while were right down to the lowest they could be.

Of course, I am told that it’s unhealthy and that I am killing myself. Usually by someone who is tucking into a Greggs 😂

It will be more the lack of processed foods, no sugar, cooking from scratch. Only drinking water and green tea. Don’t underestimate the huge impact of that and overemphasise the impact of fasting. You’ve changed the way you eat entirely.

Bloodyleaverspartybollocks · 25/07/2023 20:50

aperolspritzbasicbitch · 25/07/2023 13:12

Yeah, you lost me at no cuppa 🤣

I don't tend to eat until 12/1pm, and I'm normally done eating by 7:30, but I need a cuppa first thing in the morning and just before bed

You can have black coffee. Took me a while to get used to it but I prefer it black now. I can't ditch the 1 sweetener though

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 20:42

HidingUnderARock · 25/07/2023 20:14

Also, YABVU for not including a vote - unless MN is somehow just not showing it.

You can't on the app

OP posts:
Annaisatwat · 25/07/2023 20:37

I do OMAD, or 23/1 fasting. Once a week I’ll may be so two meals.

It’s changed my life. I don’t eat anything processed, I cook from scratch. No sugar at all. I only drink water and green tea.

I feel and look amazing. My blood pressure is now normal (it was high for a period, I didn’t want to take drugs which is why I changed my life), my last bloods showed my inflammation markers which had been high for a while were right down to the lowest they could be.

Of course, I am told that it’s unhealthy and that I am killing myself. Usually by someone who is tucking into a Greggs 😂

HidingUnderARock · 25/07/2023 20:14

Also, YABVU for not including a vote - unless MN is somehow just not showing it.

Desperatenow1 · 25/07/2023 20:02

VitoCorleoneOfMNMafia · 25/07/2023 16:14

Where does it say the body HAS to have xx amount of food at certain intervals throughout the day?

In guidance given to type one diabetics and to migraine sufferers. Too long between meals will cause diabetic coma in the former and trigger a migraine in the latter.

There's plenty of research (up to date research) that advocates fasting for diabetics, as long as it's managed correctly and blood glucose levels are monitored.

This post wasn't aimed at diabetics though, it appears to be aimed at people in general rather than specifically to diabetics.

There has been evidence that migraine sufferers have benefited from fasting, so again not sure why it wouldn't be considered safe, I would have thought at least one would try it for them first to see if it might work.

So I am still a bit lost as to why the OP was VVV unreasonable...

sandyhappypeople · 25/07/2023 19:43

pigsDOfly · 25/07/2023 18:03

I'm not, as you put it, shitting all over it.

Years ago people would have three meals a day, go to bed, wake up and have breakfast.

They didn't feel the need, nor have the opportunity to graze permanently and there wasn't the access to high sugar, processes foods. They tended to do more physical activity because they didn't jump in a car to go everywhere and work tended to be more physical.

They ate at regular times, and to an extent, during a 'restricted window', albeit a window longer than 8 hours. It wasn't something they over analysed and labelled.

I can't see a great deal of difference between that and the idea that once you've had your evening meal, you stop eating for the evening.

But suddenly what people had been doing for generations is being presented as a wonderful new idea that someone just thought up and when you do it it's called 'fasting'.

Given that people tended to be a lot slimmer in those days, yes, it's highly likely to help with weight loss, which is what I said in my pp.

So no not shitting all over it, just pointing out it's not new and it's not magic.

Still sounds like shitting all over it to me 😀

Why can’t you people just be thin!!

Delatron · 25/07/2023 19:24

BlossomCloud · 25/07/2023 19:13

I agree. The habit of constant snacking didn't used to be a thing, so the idea of not eating after the evening meal is not as novel as it sounds.

Yep. I don’t think not eating after your evening meal should be described as fasting. It’s just not snacking after a large meal.

BlossomCloud · 25/07/2023 19:13

pigsDOfly · 25/07/2023 18:03

I'm not, as you put it, shitting all over it.

Years ago people would have three meals a day, go to bed, wake up and have breakfast.

They didn't feel the need, nor have the opportunity to graze permanently and there wasn't the access to high sugar, processes foods. They tended to do more physical activity because they didn't jump in a car to go everywhere and work tended to be more physical.

They ate at regular times, and to an extent, during a 'restricted window', albeit a window longer than 8 hours. It wasn't something they over analysed and labelled.

I can't see a great deal of difference between that and the idea that once you've had your evening meal, you stop eating for the evening.

But suddenly what people had been doing for generations is being presented as a wonderful new idea that someone just thought up and when you do it it's called 'fasting'.

Given that people tended to be a lot slimmer in those days, yes, it's highly likely to help with weight loss, which is what I said in my pp.

So no not shitting all over it, just pointing out it's not new and it's not magic.

I agree. The habit of constant snacking didn't used to be a thing, so the idea of not eating after the evening meal is not as novel as it sounds.

BlossomCloud · 25/07/2023 19:08

Terloz · 25/07/2023 17:38

BlossomCloud · Today 13:47
I've lost a stone in two months on 1400 calories a day spread over 3 meals and sometimes a snack. This feels sustainable. (I gained weight rapidly due to steroids, I had been healthy till I got ill, so I fairness it may be that I find it easier because healthy eating is my normal anyway)

@BlossomCloud the NHS weight loss app recommendation was about 1400 calories for me too. Quite a drop from the 2000 average. I couldn’t sustain it. Any tips on what your meals look like? I need to try it again though perhaps after the all inclusive holiday…

@Terloz

  • breakfast: either yoghurt and seeds and fruit or cereal and seeds and fruit
  • lunch - a salad with chicken/fish
  • dinner - mixture but always a mix of carbs/veg/protein

Fairly simple food as life is chaotic!

I don't find it hard at all but in all honesty I was slim most of my life with a brief period of anorexia. The weight gain came first slowly from appetite increase from anti depressants and then dramatically from serious water retention and appetite increase from heavy steroids.

Before medication, when I was my "normal" self I never really snacked outside of meals and I enjoyed healthy food anyway.

I actually have to make sure I eat enough to stop any risk of swinging back into anorexia. My goal is to not lose the weight too fast

pigsDOfly · 25/07/2023 18:03

sandyhappypeople · 25/07/2023 16:09

It is fasting though..

you only eat within an 8 hour window, then fast the rest of the time, it works for consistent weight loss because unlike just skipping a meal, you aren’t snacking outside of your 8 hour window, and the facts of it are, for some people who do it, something just clicks and your body gets used to that way of eating and you genuinely don’t feel hungry outside of your normal mealtimes.. THAT’S what makes it more effective than just skipping a meal, if it works for you it can be a total game changer.

if you’ve never been overweight, that’s great, but a lot of people are and if they find something that helps them lose weight effectively and keep it off and they want to share it, why feel the need to shit all over it?

I'm not, as you put it, shitting all over it.

Years ago people would have three meals a day, go to bed, wake up and have breakfast.

They didn't feel the need, nor have the opportunity to graze permanently and there wasn't the access to high sugar, processes foods. They tended to do more physical activity because they didn't jump in a car to go everywhere and work tended to be more physical.

They ate at regular times, and to an extent, during a 'restricted window', albeit a window longer than 8 hours. It wasn't something they over analysed and labelled.

I can't see a great deal of difference between that and the idea that once you've had your evening meal, you stop eating for the evening.

But suddenly what people had been doing for generations is being presented as a wonderful new idea that someone just thought up and when you do it it's called 'fasting'.

Given that people tended to be a lot slimmer in those days, yes, it's highly likely to help with weight loss, which is what I said in my pp.

So no not shitting all over it, just pointing out it's not new and it's not magic.

merrymelodies · 25/07/2023 18:01

The only fasting I do is between dinner and breakfast. About 12-13 hours. Does that count?

VeganFromSveden · 25/07/2023 17:54

Not read the whole thread…
just wanted to say that I’m late 60’s, have had an under active thyroid for 20 plus years.
was overweight until nine and a half years ago.
I (fortunately) don’t wake up hungry, and when I do have my first food of the day, which is effectively my “breakfast” (breaking the fast) it feels like it opens up my system to wanting food, but in sensible amounts, not to make up for the hours without.
I also haven’t drunk conventional tea or coffee since 2013, as I don’t want to consume dairy.
My first drink (always have this recipe on an empty tum) of the morning is organic apple cider vinegar with the (six fluid ounces boiling water, two tablespoons of acv, quarter teaspoon bicarbonate, and then add two fluid ounces of cold water before adding a small teaspoon of raw honey, else too hot water will destroy any health benefits of the honey) mother.
I buy it in 5litre bulk, but I think it’s around £2 for a 500ml bottle in Aldi or Lidl.

Further drinks throughout the day are either boiling water to infuse fresh mint or thyme from the garden… just don’t forget to cool the water if you want to add a “good” honey.

In the first few months of doing above, I lost two stone…

My first food of the day can be anytime from 2pm to 6pm, but if it is as late as 6pm, that will be my only meal…. that takes me to the next day.
Basically, I eat when I’m actually hungry.
I’ve found that in the past, I was mistaking hunger for thirst.

I absolutely do realise what I do won’t be ok for all.
It suits me, and my lifestyle.
I’m roughly 5’5”, and just under 9stone.

Note, I also rebound, do stretches, and lift small weights…. none of it is that strict tho’.
I find exercise can be quite addictive, especially as I note what I do, and try to beat my own records.. eg if I achieve 30 squats, I’ll then up it by 5 more, and do that til I want to “up” it again iyswim.

Densol57 · 25/07/2023 17:47

Interesting !
I used to always skip breakfast as never felt hungry, then fell for the diet mantra of “must eat breakfast” etc
I train in the mornings, so tend to eat something. I might try this fasting to shift a few pounds 🤞🏼🤞🏼
cheers 😃

HelpMeGetThrough · 25/07/2023 17:44

I usually go 24 hours between eating, just have an evening meal. Food doesn't interest me, so generally can't be arsed with it. It does seem to keep the weight off though.

I like my tea and coffee though. Usually off my nut on codeine and caffeine by the time I start work.

FuppingEll · 25/07/2023 17:40

I haven't eaten breakfast since I was about 11. I never eat until 1 or 2. I never really thought about it as fasting though, just that I'm never hungry until then. I wouldn't say I was sedentary either. I walk the dogs for an hour first thing every morning, I do a spin class 5 times a week and walk the dogs for another hour in the evening, sometimes I sneak in a 3rd dog walk on my lunch break(work from home).

I just don't feel hungry before lunch time and have never been an evening snacker really, I don't feel weak or anything else either. I've just always eaten this way. I feel like some people are going in hard on people who just don't feel hungry or get hangry or weak or whatever else.

I wouldn't tell everyone to eat like me, I don't care how people eat if I am honest but I don't think there is anything wrong with the way I do.

CoffeeDrinkerLatte · 25/07/2023 17:39

Gosh 10 pages in I’m not sure I can contribute much more, but I find I am the same amount of hungry at around 10.30/11am no matter if I have breakfast or not, and no matter what I have for breakfast if I do.

Terloz · 25/07/2023 17:38

BlossomCloud · Today 13:47
I've lost a stone in two months on 1400 calories a day spread over 3 meals and sometimes a snack. This feels sustainable. (I gained weight rapidly due to steroids, I had been healthy till I got ill, so I fairness it may be that I find it easier because healthy eating is my normal anyway)

@BlossomCloud the NHS weight loss app recommendation was about 1400 calories for me too. Quite a drop from the 2000 average. I couldn’t sustain it. Any tips on what your meals look like? I need to try it again though perhaps after the all inclusive holiday…

Mayhem3 · 25/07/2023 17:31

changeyerheadworzel · 25/07/2023 17:22

I could easily not eat till 12 or 1pm but I enjoy my sly snacking after 9pm which is probably my downfall.

Have a cup of peppermint or camomile tea and go to bed early.

When I stopped smoking the evenings were the most difficult and I’d end up snacking, so I’d have a bath and go to bed early and read a book whilst drinking some sort of low caffeine tea.

It’s not very rock and roll but you feel so much better for it.

Tabitha005 · 25/07/2023 17:29

I've just started fasting from around 7:30pm until at least midday, and incrementally building up to a longer fast from there.

I ALWAYS woke up hungry before I tried fasting and would rush to the kitchen for breakfast. And I'm talking proper, sick-feeling, tummy-rumbling terrible. I was VERY skeptical that not eating anything until at least midday would be absolutely awful but it's been as easy as anything. I have a cup of black coffee without sugar or any other form of sweetener about half an hour after getting up and maybe another around 10/10:30am, and I'm drinking 2-2.5ltrs of water a day and feeling - right now at least - bloody amazing!

SilverGlitterBaubles · 25/07/2023 17:28

Skipping breakfast just sets me up to snack and binge later in the day. If I have breakfast such as porridge I can go quite a long time without eating and I am not tempt to snack. I am also more focused and have less energy dips. Different things work for different people.