Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage you to fast?

335 replies

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 12:58

If you want to lose weight and keep it off.

I fast from 8pm to 12 pm. Usually have my first something around 1pm

I haven't actually changed what I eat. I make sure I have some nutrient rich food in me but generally my diet is a bit shit Blush

Anyway, I've gone from a size 16 to a size 10. This happened within 3 months. It's been 9 months now and I've kept it all off! Remaining at a size 10

I don't eat breakfast, ever.

When I was in my teens, I almost skipped breakfast because I genuinely forgot to eat. The same happened early twenties but then after I had my son, I started eating breakfast!

Since that time I went from a size 10 to a size 16.

So yeah, for 9 months now, I just haven't eaten breakfast but haven't restricted myself really and still don't have a perfect diet by any means

I am remaining a size 10 and it's working. I suppose I'm an 'all or nothing' person. And I find the fast easy to stick to because I can eat 0! Sticking to 0 is easier than sticking to 3 sensible meals a day, for me Grin

Now I just have lunch, snack a bit tbh, and then dinner, also snack a bit but not loads as find I don't want to

When I ate breakfast, I found I was hungry all the time!

So glad I did this and took the plunge. Just thought I'd share

OP posts:
sandyhappypeople · 25/07/2023 22:53

19991234c · 25/07/2023 22:23

I would faint if I did this. I have to eat every 2-3 hours or I get weak and dizzy I’m a size 8 and 5ft 8 but I have breakfast every morning. I thought it was terrible for you to skip breakfast?

Why would you do this though? If you're 5'8 and a size 8, you wouldn't need to fast to lose weight and keep it off?

Delatron · 25/07/2023 22:49

Beneficialchampion2 · 25/07/2023 22:35

Why inadvisable? Your body doesn't give a shit where it's fuel comes from, if it needs energy it'll get it from your fat reserves.

I've not eaten breakfast in 15+ years, I start work at 6AM and don't eat until 12PM.

I said inadvisable if you have an active morning planned. You need to fuel your body for activity. Otherwise that energy won’t come from fat stores - your body will start to breakdown muscle and cortisol levels will increase.

Look we’ve already said everyone is different. You don’t say what your job is but if it’s a desk job then sure not eating until lunch may work for you. I’ve explained why clearly why it doesn’t work for me.

We are all different!

LouLou198 · 25/07/2023 22:46

throwbacko2 · 25/07/2023 13:43

I would be seeing my doctor if I dropped form a size 16 to a 10 in 3 months with very little dietary changes tbh.

I was thinking the same. It is a big weight loss in a short space of time .

Delatron · 25/07/2023 22:36

Beneficialchampion2 · 25/07/2023 22:33

You should probably see a doctor, your symptoms sound indicative of a health condition. Probably related to blood sugar/insulin.

No she doesn’t. Plenty of people feel like this. Especially slim people. Probably low blood sugar. I need to eat reasonably regularly or I feel faint and dizzy. I’m also 5 ft 8 and size 8.

Beneficialchampion2 · 25/07/2023 22:35

Delatron · 25/07/2023 22:26

I said it would be difficult (inadvisable) to skip breakfast if you had an active morning/job and easier if you had a desk job/were sedentary. That’s true.

Why inadvisable? Your body doesn't give a shit where it's fuel comes from, if it needs energy it'll get it from your fat reserves.

I've not eaten breakfast in 15+ years, I start work at 6AM and don't eat until 12PM.

Beneficialchampion2 · 25/07/2023 22:33

19991234c · 25/07/2023 22:23

I would faint if I did this. I have to eat every 2-3 hours or I get weak and dizzy I’m a size 8 and 5ft 8 but I have breakfast every morning. I thought it was terrible for you to skip breakfast?

You should probably see a doctor, your symptoms sound indicative of a health condition. Probably related to blood sugar/insulin.

Delatron · 25/07/2023 22:26

FuppingEll · 25/07/2023 22:08

I'm neither obese/overweight nor sedentary and it works for me. It isn't for everyone no but I don't understand why you keep insisting if you don't need breakfast you are either fat or don't move? Just because you can't move without breakfast it doesn't mean that others are the same.

I said it would be difficult (inadvisable) to skip breakfast if you had an active morning/job and easier if you had a desk job/were sedentary. That’s true.

19991234c · 25/07/2023 22:23

I would faint if I did this. I have to eat every 2-3 hours or I get weak and dizzy I’m a size 8 and 5ft 8 but I have breakfast every morning. I thought it was terrible for you to skip breakfast?

FuppingEll · 25/07/2023 22:08

Delatron · 25/07/2023 21:55

Yes and obese/sedentary people may benefit from fasting. But it’s not for everyone.

I'm neither obese/overweight nor sedentary and it works for me. It isn't for everyone no but I don't understand why you keep insisting if you don't need breakfast you are either fat or don't move? Just because you can't move without breakfast it doesn't mean that others are the same.

Delatron · 25/07/2023 22:05

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 25/07/2023 22:00

I had obesity.

fasting still lead to amenorrhea and I was told / forced (?) to stop.

it is not for everyone. Whether that person is slim, athletic, overweight or obese. I wish people stopped trying to suggest solutions to genuine medical problems on SM…

Ok yes I’m sorry to hear that. I’m not a fan of fasting at all and it is such an individual thing.

I did say ‘may’ in response to another poster. But in general I think it’s such a complex picture for all women in terms of potential hormone disruption and metabolic disruption.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 25/07/2023 22:00

Delatron · 25/07/2023 21:55

Yes and obese/sedentary people may benefit from fasting. But it’s not for everyone.

I had obesity.

fasting still lead to amenorrhea and I was told / forced (?) to stop.

it is not for everyone. Whether that person is slim, athletic, overweight or obese. I wish people stopped trying to suggest solutions to genuine medical problems on SM…

Delatron · 25/07/2023 21:55

LuckyCats · 25/07/2023 21:52

I’m not saying people who don’t want to fast snack eat constantly and drink sugary drinks I’m saying obese people probably do or they wouldn’t be obese.
and it’s not healthy to be feeding your body with fuel constantly that it will never be able to use.

Yes and obese/sedentary people may benefit from fasting. But it’s not for everyone.

LuckyCats · 25/07/2023 21:52

I’m not saying people who don’t want to fast snack eat constantly and drink sugary drinks I’m saying obese people probably do or they wouldn’t be obese.
and it’s not healthy to be feeding your body with fuel constantly that it will never be able to use.

LuckyCats · 25/07/2023 21:49

No I don’t sit at a desk much at all, my job is active but admittedly I don’t go the gym ever.
i used to work in a busy restaurant starting at 9 or 10 am and break my fast with fruit juice at 12 then eat my main meal at 3 or 4.
Ive never been obese, slightly over weight only and I used fasting to get back to how I like to be.
I drink too many sugary drinks myself but I never snack and feel hungry before eating and stop when I’m full.

EarlGreywithLemon · 25/07/2023 21:48

It’s the 16 hours I couldn’t do - I just faint! I also can’t do low carb, it makes my IBS so so much worse.
What I’m trying to say is that our bodies all work differently, and what suits you might not suit others.
I have to eat a balanced amount of protein, carbs, dairy, fruit and vegetables to feel well. But- I don’t snack after dinner, pudding is mostly fruit, bar a couple of times a week, I don’t drink, or eat crisps, or biscuits or chocolate bars. I will have a little bit of very dark chocolate when I feel like it though. I find that’s the best approach for my body and my sanity.

Delatron · 25/07/2023 21:45

MrsJBaptiste · 25/07/2023 21:41

I suppose it depends on the individual.

I much prefer going to the gym without eating first, whether that's at 6am or 11am. Unless I go after work at 6pm, I'll always exercise in a fasted state. I much prefer that to having eaten (even if that within a couple of hours of going to the gym, etc.)

It is up to the individual but everything I’ve read recently (new research coming out) and been advised by a dietician is that exercising in a fasted state for women is not advised (men are fine) it can disrupt hormones and increase cortisol.

I used to run fasted as I’d hate the feeling of something in my stomach when I was running but after reading around the subject I now make sure I eat - even a piece of toast and a banana. You can actually train your stomach and then it feels fine.

mumlikeaboss · 25/07/2023 21:44

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 20:52

Hashimotos for me too
I've actually just changed GP, the final straw being that a TSH of 2.5 and a T4 of 13 is "fine"
I feel awful

My new GP has upped my levo, and is sending me for T3 bloods

It's crazy isn't it... Makes me so frustrated.

These days I request bloods, and when the results come back I basically make my own decisions re meds, based on the numbers, and tell the GP what dose I'm going to be taking 😏😏😏

They seem to be okay with me doing that... They just can't apparently be bothered to do the thinking themselves and give me good advice!!

MrsJBaptiste · 25/07/2023 21:41

I suppose it depends on the individual.

I much prefer going to the gym without eating first, whether that's at 6am or 11am. Unless I go after work at 6pm, I'll always exercise in a fasted state. I much prefer that to having eaten (even if that within a couple of hours of going to the gym, etc.)

Delatron · 25/07/2023 21:34

LuckyCats · 25/07/2023 21:20

All the people saying oh I couldn’t live without breakfast in the morning are missing the point, the fasting window can be whenever you like, if you start eating earlier with a breakfast type food in the morning you would just stop eating earlier in the day also, 8 hours later and not eat until the next day 16 hours later.
Humans really don’t need to be eating at all hours of the day it’s not natural the way we eat now with constant snacks and sugary drinks.
That’s why we’re in an obesity crisis.
Lots of people don’t even know what it feels like to be hungry but it’s not a bad thing although I guess can be scary at first to people who’ve never had the feeling.

I don’t drink sugary drinks or eat crap. I wish people would stop saying those that don’t want to fast don’t eat healthily and snack constantly - it’s all a bit holier than thou. And completely untrue.

Fast if you like - it’s not for everyone and you can be perfectly healthy not ‘fasting’

I will listen to my hunger cues as they’ve served me well over the years..

Delatron · 25/07/2023 21:30

LuckyCats · 25/07/2023 21:20

All the people saying oh I couldn’t live without breakfast in the morning are missing the point, the fasting window can be whenever you like, if you start eating earlier with a breakfast type food in the morning you would just stop eating earlier in the day also, 8 hours later and not eat until the next day 16 hours later.
Humans really don’t need to be eating at all hours of the day it’s not natural the way we eat now with constant snacks and sugary drinks.
That’s why we’re in an obesity crisis.
Lots of people don’t even know what it feels like to be hungry but it’s not a bad thing although I guess can be scary at first to people who’ve never had the feeling.

You can put the 16 hour window wherever you like it still won’t work for me. I wouldn’t eat earlier than say 7 pm (work/clubs) so add. 16 hours to that I’m still not eating until 11am? Well I get up, go for a run (not supposed to do that fasted) Teach an exercise class then walk the dog. Im not doing that on thin air!

It may work for you if you sit at a desk until
lunch but people are repeatedly saying it’s an individual thing - it works for some and not others.

LuckyCats · 25/07/2023 21:20

All the people saying oh I couldn’t live without breakfast in the morning are missing the point, the fasting window can be whenever you like, if you start eating earlier with a breakfast type food in the morning you would just stop eating earlier in the day also, 8 hours later and not eat until the next day 16 hours later.
Humans really don’t need to be eating at all hours of the day it’s not natural the way we eat now with constant snacks and sugary drinks.
That’s why we’re in an obesity crisis.
Lots of people don’t even know what it feels like to be hungry but it’s not a bad thing although I guess can be scary at first to people who’ve never had the feeling.

sandyhappypeople · 25/07/2023 21:20

sigfey · 25/07/2023 21:09

re the claims on diabetes - I'm less of an expert but Diabetes UK seems to disagree with your blanket statement There's plenty of research (up to date research) that advocates fasting for diabetics

They talk much about managing the risks of fasting in unavoidable settings (e.g., religious reasons) and how for for some people it will not be safe to do despite extra monitoring - they're certainly not "advocating" for it! @Desperatenow1

....This can help you to understand how fasting could be a risk to your health, how to reduce this risk or whether the risk to your health is too high.

Fasting clearly works well for some people, but no idea why you're so hell bent on pushing it as a cure all for patient groups for whom it's dangerous!

IF helped me lose a lot of weight, and once I got my head round it it was easy, almost effortless, so I would always recommend it as an option if people ever ask me, but anyone who suffers dizzy spells or can't skip meals without feeling faint I don't think it would be suitable for. I personally suffered migraines before IF, but don't anymore, but again, I wouldn't presume it would work on all migraine sufferers, as everyone has different triggers.

I have heard this a lot too, about the correlation between IF and diabetes, I don't think it's necessarily tied to IF though, it's more to do with losing weight effectively:

Intermittent fasting may reverse type 2 diabetes | Endocrine SocietyIntermittent fasting may reverse type 2 diabetes | Endocrine Society

Intermittent fasting may reverse type 2 diabetes

After an intermittent fasting diet intervention, patients achieved complete diabetes remission, defined as an HbA1c (average blood sugar) level of less than 6.5% at least one year after stopping diabetes medication, according to a new study published i...

https://www.endocrine.org/news-and-advocacy/news-room/2022/intermittent-fasting-may-reverse-type-2-diabetes#:~:text=After%20an%20intermittent%20fasting%20diet,Society%27s%20Journal%20of%20Clinical%20Endocrinology%20%26

OMG12 · 25/07/2023 21:14

Like most food related practices it will be great for some, shit for others. I tend to fast for 14 hours. I’ve lost some weight, I’m sleeping incredibly well, my acid reflux has gone, certain cravings have disappeared, my inflammation markers have reduced plus many other benefits.

onviously it doesn’t suit everyone.

sigfey · 25/07/2023 21:09

re the claims on diabetes - I'm less of an expert but Diabetes UK seems to disagree with your blanket statement There's plenty of research (up to date research) that advocates fasting for diabetics

They talk much about managing the risks of fasting in unavoidable settings (e.g., religious reasons) and how for for some people it will not be safe to do despite extra monitoring - they're certainly not "advocating" for it! @Desperatenow1

....This can help you to understand how fasting could be a risk to your health, how to reduce this risk or whether the risk to your health is too high.

Fasting clearly works well for some people, but no idea why you're so hell bent on pushing it as a cure all for patient groups for whom it's dangerous!

Swipe left for the next trending thread