Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage you to fast?

335 replies

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 12:58

If you want to lose weight and keep it off.

I fast from 8pm to 12 pm. Usually have my first something around 1pm

I haven't actually changed what I eat. I make sure I have some nutrient rich food in me but generally my diet is a bit shit Blush

Anyway, I've gone from a size 16 to a size 10. This happened within 3 months. It's been 9 months now and I've kept it all off! Remaining at a size 10

I don't eat breakfast, ever.

When I was in my teens, I almost skipped breakfast because I genuinely forgot to eat. The same happened early twenties but then after I had my son, I started eating breakfast!

Since that time I went from a size 10 to a size 16.

So yeah, for 9 months now, I just haven't eaten breakfast but haven't restricted myself really and still don't have a perfect diet by any means

I am remaining a size 10 and it's working. I suppose I'm an 'all or nothing' person. And I find the fast easy to stick to because I can eat 0! Sticking to 0 is easier than sticking to 3 sensible meals a day, for me Grin

Now I just have lunch, snack a bit tbh, and then dinner, also snack a bit but not loads as find I don't want to

When I ate breakfast, I found I was hungry all the time!

So glad I did this and took the plunge. Just thought I'd share

OP posts:
OneTC · 26/07/2023 13:40

Dutch1e · 26/07/2023 10:58

I wouldn't advocate for anyone else to fast but I do quite like that the concept is more accepted now.

I'm not hungry in the morning, a little milk in my coffee to avoid sour-belly is ample until whenever I feel ready to eat (somewhere between 11am - 1pm usually, unless it's a hotel buffet then I roll out of bed and dive into the pastries!).

So many years of having people worry if I have an ED just because my appetite hasn't woken up yet was quite stressful.

Now it seems much more normal to listen to your own body and adapt your intake accordingly. So a big healthy breakfast is fine, and fasting through to lunchtime is also fine. Or is that a misperception on my part?

The important part seems to be the spacing rather than the timing. Pick whatever 8 hour window and only eat then. Most people are going to need to skip a meal and breakfast seems the most convenient.

Dutch1e · 26/07/2023 10:58

I wouldn't advocate for anyone else to fast but I do quite like that the concept is more accepted now.

I'm not hungry in the morning, a little milk in my coffee to avoid sour-belly is ample until whenever I feel ready to eat (somewhere between 11am - 1pm usually, unless it's a hotel buffet then I roll out of bed and dive into the pastries!).

So many years of having people worry if I have an ED just because my appetite hasn't woken up yet was quite stressful.

Now it seems much more normal to listen to your own body and adapt your intake accordingly. So a big healthy breakfast is fine, and fasting through to lunchtime is also fine. Or is that a misperception on my part?

ontetwo3 · 26/07/2023 10:40

No! I had an ED and my son has an ED. Whilst I will admit there may be some benefits to fasting occasionally, regularly missing meals, and doing this as a way of controlling weight is not healthy for me, and goes against everything I am trying to encourage my son to do (e.g. eat sensibly, not get too hungry, not see eating nothing as something positive).

Luxell934 · 26/07/2023 10:12

Just wondering how much actual weight you lost in those 3 months going from a size 16 to a 10?

OneTC · 26/07/2023 10:10

Me and my OH have always been about the same dimensions, same height and weight, same size clothes, and we're 3 months different in age. In the last 3 years though she's gone up from her previous XS size clothes to a M/L size and has tried loads of things to lose weight and it has been without success. She's about 20kg heavier than when she's been at her fighting weight.

Anyway about a month ago she started doing a rigid 16:8 and she's the smallest I've seen her in that 3 years. She initially found the fasting periods difficult but was fine after a week or so. She now eats more healthily in the break periods and finds that she doesn't feel so drawn to snacking. Her calorific intake is definitely down. She isn't deliberately targeting any specific food groups but is tending towards higher protein and lower carbs. She's also gone to more 18:6 and is going to experiment with a randomised pattern of fasting, where sometimes it's shorter and sometimes it's longer

I do intermittent fasting as a default form of eating and pretty much always have since I was a teen. One thing I always find interesting about these threads is different people's attitudes to being hungry, some people talk about it like it's going to do them actual harm to be hungry here and there.

Annaisatwat · 26/07/2023 10:01

Fizbosshoes · 26/07/2023 08:24

Surely by Default most people would have a significant break from food while asleep? (It would be quite feasible to leave 12 hours between dinner and breakfast without missing any meals?)

I thought that until people found I that I fasted and we spoke about it.

I know a lot of people who said they would struggle with even 12 hours as they don’t go to bed until midnight. They snack all eve until bedtime and then have breakfast at 7/8.

Even before fasting, I would have dinner at around 6 and then not have breakfast until 8am, my entire life.

But some people do snack until a late bedtime.

Delatron · 26/07/2023 09:59

WisherWood · 26/07/2023 08:21

They say it is good for the body to have a rest from having to work at digesting food all the time.

There's a book called the Circadian Code which discusses this and other things. I have found that giving my stomach a good 12 hours off from digesting food does make me feel better, although whether that's suggestion or not is anyone's guess. It helps me stop snacking in the evening because I find it easier to say 'no, your stomach needs a rest' than 'no, don't eat that snack'. I'm not overweight but since the menopause I have found my weight will creep up, and this is a good way for me to maintain my weight.

I don't refer to it as fasting though. I see it as a fairly normal, natural eating pattern.

12 hours is fine though that’s 8pm say to 8am. That’s pretty normal eating. It’s the 16 hours I would have an issue with.

Eddyraisins · 26/07/2023 09:35

Weightlosstipsneeded · 25/07/2023 13:41

I don't think I can cope with the dry mouth/breath that fasting makes you have. I have fasted before and it was unbearable - I was brushing my teeth several times a day and using copious amounts of mouthwash, it was miserable.

See I love a bit of keto breath. Though feel sorry for anyone around me. Feels like I am literally breathing the fat away.🤣

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/07/2023 09:21

Beneficialchampion2 · 25/07/2023 22:33

You should probably see a doctor, your symptoms sound indicative of a health condition. Probably related to blood sugar/insulin.

When I was size 8 in my youth I was like this. It’s just a fast metabolism I think, not a medical problem

AtomicBlondeRose · 26/07/2023 09:11

Or maybe that’s just not the window that works for you. There’s no rule saying it has to be between certain times. You might do better eating heartily in the morning.

AtomicBlondeRose · 26/07/2023 09:10

Clock watching really suggests you’re eating quite emotionally/from boredom. A morning “ritual” (coffee sitting in the sun if there is any, yoga, a rub or walk) might help break the automatic “must eat” association. This is something I find useful about IF - you’re forced to deal with emotions and boredom without reaching for food!

Cracklecrack · 26/07/2023 09:08

This is really good to hear thanks. I find it really difficult to sustain. Have only ever managed it for 6 weeks at a time and I found myself completely clock watching. I’m on annual leave and trying to not eat between 6 and 10.

AtomicBlondeRose · 26/07/2023 08:28

@Fizbosshoes - you’d think so, but I was listening to a podcast where they said a recent study showed it was common for people’s “eating windows” to be 15 hours long - they were snacking/drinking caloried drinks late at night and eating as soon as they got up - that’s hardly any time for the body to do it’s work.

Interestingly the idea that breakfast needs to be as soon you wake is quite recent. In medieval times it was common to head off to work on just a drink. They would break mid-morning and eat properly then. We’re evolved to have long gaps between meals. It’s a carb/sugar-heavy diet that causes the intense cravings and hunger between meals and leads us to think we’ll pass out of we don’t eat every couple of hours. Funnily enough this is quite well known elsewhere on MN but not in this thread!

AtomicBlondeRose · 26/07/2023 08:25

It doesn’t have to be noon. You can start and end whenever you want. But I find skipping breakfast very easy. I have one tea and some black coffee and water. I don’t get hungry, feel faint or dizzy. Your body adapts to it and I feel LOTS BETTER without the constant swings of hunger/blood sugar/food cravings. You feel better not worse! Everyone who can’t do it because they feel weak and dizzy - if you tried, the weakness and dizziness would go as your body would adapt to not being constantly in search of sugar (because that’s what’s happening) and you would be free of feeling like shit every few hours. Which seems like a good thing to me?

Fasting isn’t about being hungry! You aren’t hungry, that’s the whole point. Eating “little and often” makes you far far hungrier. If you fast you can eat anything in your eating window but you’re no longer searching for sugar and carbs due to extreme hunger so you can relax and eat proper good food.

Fizbosshoes · 26/07/2023 08:24

Surely by Default most people would have a significant break from food while asleep? (It would be quite feasible to leave 12 hours between dinner and breakfast without missing any meals?)

WisherWood · 26/07/2023 08:21

They say it is good for the body to have a rest from having to work at digesting food all the time.

There's a book called the Circadian Code which discusses this and other things. I have found that giving my stomach a good 12 hours off from digesting food does make me feel better, although whether that's suggestion or not is anyone's guess. It helps me stop snacking in the evening because I find it easier to say 'no, your stomach needs a rest' than 'no, don't eat that snack'. I'm not overweight but since the menopause I have found my weight will creep up, and this is a good way for me to maintain my weight.

I don't refer to it as fasting though. I see it as a fairly normal, natural eating pattern.

Seriously79 · 26/07/2023 08:16

Can you break this down for me.

So you wake up - do you drink anything? Water, tea, coffee?

Then you don't eat until noon - don't you get hungry? 🤔 I'd worry that I'd get a headache or the shakes.

Then after noon, you eat normally?

MaryBeardsShoes · 26/07/2023 07:37

Society wants women small, hungry, and docile. EAT THE FOOD.

marblesthecat · 26/07/2023 07:31

Anotherparkingthread · 25/07/2023 13:07

This is actually a misconception. You only become hungry when your body has had something to eat and your blood sugar starts to fall again. You won't feel hungry at all as long as you stick to just coffee etc without sugar. Your appetite will return to normal when you break fasting period after your first meal.
Size 8 at 5ft 9 and have fasted since my teens. Health benefits are great.

I'm a type one diabetic and I'm used to eating more in the morning and less as the day goes on. I'm always hungry in the mornings even if I wake up with sugars outside of my target range because my body is used to eating at that time so I don't think blood sugar dropping is the only cause of hunger.

EsmeSusanOgg · 26/07/2023 07:29

This really does depend on how your own body works.

Boredofmyguts · 26/07/2023 07:24

Everyone and their metabolism is different. It’s true we were made to have longer periods between food but depending on your medical conditions fasting can make things worse. I stop eating 3 hours before bed due to reflux issues, so I usually have a 13 hour gap between dinner and breakfast (and wake up hungry). I’d rather skip dinner than breakfast.

KvotheTheBloodless · 26/07/2023 07:22

It definitely works for some people. It's not a magic pill, though, and for some (me) it can lead to disordered eating for life (anorexia and bulimia).

Given that we have far more folk with obesity than with eating disorders, I'd still say it's worth trying, but be aware that it's not suitable for anyone who suffers or has suffered from an eating disorder.

Desperatenow1 · 26/07/2023 07:13

sigfey · 25/07/2023 21:09

re the claims on diabetes - I'm less of an expert but Diabetes UK seems to disagree with your blanket statement There's plenty of research (up to date research) that advocates fasting for diabetics

They talk much about managing the risks of fasting in unavoidable settings (e.g., religious reasons) and how for for some people it will not be safe to do despite extra monitoring - they're certainly not "advocating" for it! @Desperatenow1

....This can help you to understand how fasting could be a risk to your health, how to reduce this risk or whether the risk to your health is too high.

Fasting clearly works well for some people, but no idea why you're so hell bent on pushing it as a cure all for patient groups for whom it's dangerous!

I am not hell bent at pushing it, I am just open minded about it, rather than blanket stating it not safe. I have posted ONCE about diabetics and that was in answer to another post. I have said is there is plenty of research to refute the claims that it is dangerous. If you were to undertake fasting as an option to help your health it would need to be managed, much like diabetes needs to be managed if you don't fast I guess.

Personally, if I was a diabetic, I would do some varied research.

Got to love the drama queens and hysterical posters that turn up on threads like this 😂

hollyblueivy · 26/07/2023 06:22

There is a good podcast on Diary of CEO about fasting.

They say it is good for the body to have a rest from having to work at digesting food all the time.

16:8 I think they mentioned where you eat only 8 hour block during a 24 hour period.

KajsaKavat · 25/07/2023 22:55

Fasting is really bad to suggest to people recovering from eating disorders or who are prone to disorderly eating so yes I think YABVU