Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To encourage you to fast?

335 replies

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 12:58

If you want to lose weight and keep it off.

I fast from 8pm to 12 pm. Usually have my first something around 1pm

I haven't actually changed what I eat. I make sure I have some nutrient rich food in me but generally my diet is a bit shit Blush

Anyway, I've gone from a size 16 to a size 10. This happened within 3 months. It's been 9 months now and I've kept it all off! Remaining at a size 10

I don't eat breakfast, ever.

When I was in my teens, I almost skipped breakfast because I genuinely forgot to eat. The same happened early twenties but then after I had my son, I started eating breakfast!

Since that time I went from a size 10 to a size 16.

So yeah, for 9 months now, I just haven't eaten breakfast but haven't restricted myself really and still don't have a perfect diet by any means

I am remaining a size 10 and it's working. I suppose I'm an 'all or nothing' person. And I find the fast easy to stick to because I can eat 0! Sticking to 0 is easier than sticking to 3 sensible meals a day, for me Grin

Now I just have lunch, snack a bit tbh, and then dinner, also snack a bit but not loads as find I don't want to

When I ate breakfast, I found I was hungry all the time!

So glad I did this and took the plunge. Just thought I'd share

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Cookiedough123 · 27/07/2023 14:43

This is really interesting! I lost weight a few years ago from around 14st to 10st and found my ideal weight to be between 10.7-11.7. Since lockdown and after having a baby and breastfeeding made me soooo hungry I’m now at my heaviest of 15st 6! I haven’t got the patience to calorie count (what worked last time!) whilst also looking after my 9 month old so I’m going to give this a go! I’m an awful snacker especially in the morning! Thanks for posting.

Cheesusisgrate · 27/07/2023 13:53

AtomicBlondeRose · 27/07/2023 13:22

Why would the billion dollar weight loss industry want to encourage fasting? It’s free! You don’t need to join a club, buy an app, pay an advisor, take meds or even buy any special food. Trust me, no company likes the idea of something you can’t monetise.

They make tons on their sites via ads and books, and newspaper articles, via advising, many things. The fact that they don't sell you ovepricwd blended food doesn't mean there are no money in it. Faating is usually also advertised with some diet alongside.

henlee · 27/07/2023 13:52

AtomicBlondeRose · 27/07/2023 13:22

Why would the billion dollar weight loss industry want to encourage fasting? It’s free! You don’t need to join a club, buy an app, pay an advisor, take meds or even buy any special food. Trust me, no company likes the idea of something you can’t monetise.

Of course fasting can be monetised, anything in the wellness industry can be.

Books, youtube channels, apps, "special" food for when you break the fast, "special" supplements to make it easier, blood tests to show when your ideal fasting window is.

If you don't care that you're pushing crap, all these things can be monetised

JoeyRamoney · 27/07/2023 13:50

smilesup · 27/07/2023 08:57

To be fair it was a nutritionalist that advised me to fast, alongside some other tips. The other tips are about eating far more protein and more variety of veg. I have therefore stopped eating so much carbs

I've lost a stone in about two months (11 to 10 stone) and feel so much better (menopause and fibromyalgia a heady mix of fun).

Because that worked for YOU.

As we can now see through the comments section, it wouldnt work for others for a myriad of reasons.

Therefore, telling complete strangers to fast is bollocks as well as dangerous.

AtomicBlondeRose · 27/07/2023 13:22

Why would the billion dollar weight loss industry want to encourage fasting? It’s free! You don’t need to join a club, buy an app, pay an advisor, take meds or even buy any special food. Trust me, no company likes the idea of something you can’t monetise.

smilesup · 27/07/2023 08:57

JoeyRamoney · 25/07/2023 13:43

Oh wow, the billion-dollar weight loss industry must be quaking in its boots....

Perhaps its time to tell every nutritionist, dietician and fat person that you have cured obesity. Bravo!

To be fair it was a nutritionalist that advised me to fast, alongside some other tips. The other tips are about eating far more protein and more variety of veg. I have therefore stopped eating so much carbs

I've lost a stone in about two months (11 to 10 stone) and feel so much better (menopause and fibromyalgia a heady mix of fun).

WisherWood · 27/07/2023 08:47

determinedtomakethiswork · 27/07/2023 00:42

You really think that women have a problem sleeping at night because they haven't had a breakfast 18 hours before?

According to experts on sleep and circadian rhythms, what you do throughout the day, including the morning, affects your sleep pattern. Evidence on the relationship between sleep patterns and breakfast eating are trickier, but you can read things like this, if you're interested https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6579371/

Breakfast Habits Are Associated with Mood, Sleep Quality, and Daily Food Intake in Healthy Adults (OR08-02-19)

Optimal eating patterns and sleep quality are key components to achieving a healthy lifestyle. Although increasing evidence illustrates associations between daily food intake and sleep quality, limited data exist with respect to whether specific eating...

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6579371

hollyblueivy · 27/07/2023 08:28

Nodancingshoes · 27/07/2023 07:01

Tempted to give this a go. What kind of things are you eating during the '8' window? Approx how many calories?

Basically just lunch and dinner with fruit as snacks.

High protein, low carb and making sure to get some fibre - plenty of water.

At least 8k steps

Freetodowhatiwant · 27/07/2023 08:24

mumlikeaboss · 25/07/2023 21:44

It's crazy isn't it... Makes me so frustrated.

These days I request bloods, and when the results come back I basically make my own decisions re meds, based on the numbers, and tell the GP what dose I'm going to be taking 😏😏😏

They seem to be okay with me doing that... They just can't apparently be bothered to do the thinking themselves and give me good advice!!

This is what I do. I actually buy all my Thyroxine in Spain where you just get it over the counter. I can't remember the last time I saw my GP about it, they seemed to know nothing and be very behind on the 'normal' levels. The last time I saw an endo was maybe 15 years ago and that was similar. I now get a blood test every now and then and adjust my meds according - usually between 125mcg and 150mcg. I feel very sorry for people who don't have this info or are unable to access their own thyroxine and are struggling with doctors saying they are normal when they feel terrible. That happened to me for the first few years too.

Mummyoflittledragon · 27/07/2023 07:51

Nodancingshoes · 27/07/2023 07:01

Tempted to give this a go. What kind of things are you eating during the '8' window? Approx how many calories?

Everyone is different. I can eat about 1600 calories and have lost a stone in 8 weeks. 170cm and bmi currently of about 36.

I don’t eat what most people consider breakfast. I eat 9 or 10 am.

Breakfast Lunch and dinner examples. I eat 3 meals, one lighter.

Proper meals

  • Roasted mixed veg in oil including a little sweet potato. Lightly breaded chicken or a piece of salmon cooked in lemon juice.
  • 2 egg omelette with some grated cheese, lots of lettuce and some tomatoes, big glug olive oil and some balsamic
  • salad (lots of lettuce), tomatoes, with about 30g of cheese, 30g chicken, half an avocado or about 10 olives - I find both too much, big glug olive oil and some balsamic
  • homemade burger and green beans / tender stem broccoli
  • a small amount of risotto with fried or roasted chicken
  • etc

Lighter meals

  • 6 oatcakes with a chunk of Brie and some grapes
  • Tesco smoked German sausage and cheese pack - 6 slices of salami, 3 of cheese and a couple of raw carrots.
  • If I’m extra hungry in the morning, I will eat a smaller portion of oatcakes, Brie and grapes at the end of the meal then will only eat at the end of the 8 hour window with a graze bar as a snack as this keeps me full all day.

Snacks/pudding - a teaspoon of coconut oil with 1/2 to one chunk of olive oil twice a day, a graze bar once a day. I haven’t kicked the craving for sugar yet. I have chronic fatigue and it’s especially hard on days when I feel sick and ill so if I’m going mad for sugar, I eat a couple of jelly babies.

I am not afraid to eat the oils and fats. These represent easily 300 calories a day. I did work it out in the beginning to gauge how much I’m eating but haven’t checked since as I’m eating the same.

I also hardly ever eat pasta or potatoes anymore as they don’t agree with me, rice sometimes. Gluten free, no soy, again due to gut issues. Ideally I’d be cutting the sugar out completely but I’m not well enough to do this.

Nodancingshoes · 27/07/2023 07:01

Tempted to give this a go. What kind of things are you eating during the '8' window? Approx how many calories?

determinedtomakethiswork · 27/07/2023 00:42

LMNT · 25/07/2023 13:22

YABU in the sense that for many women, skipping breakfast leads to cortisol disregulation and sleep issues.

YANBU to recommend intermittent fasting, it’s extremely powerful for weight loss and health in general.

You really think that women have a problem sleeping at night because they haven't had a breakfast 18 hours before?

JamesLondon11 · 27/07/2023 00:20

It's a myth that you need to "fuel your body" first thing in the morning. Your muscles are 100% full of glycogen when you wake up. Your body has turning fat into glucose or pulling it straight from liver stores.

I go to the gym in the morning on an empty stomach and perform much better than if if ate something.

LuckyCats · 26/07/2023 23:58

“Fasting is really bad to suggest to people recovering from eating disorders or who are prone to disorderly eating so yes I think YABVU”
As someone recovering from a ‘not specified eating disorder’ which I suffered into my 20, fasting is a healthy way for me to manage my weight, which I never thought I would have to do and didn’t have to until my middle age.
having to count calories or weigh food would be so triggering for me, I’d be thinking about food and calories all the time and it would take over my mind.
I never weigh myself for the same reason, the numbers get in my head.
with fasting the only thought I have to have about food is if I can eat it at that time or not.
yes, eat what you like, no not yet, wait until later.
I’d argue having to eat constantly without at least a 10 to 12 hour break is disordered eating in itself and not the way human bodies are built to consume.
Anyone feeling faint or lightheaded after a couple of hours of not eating needs to have their blood sugar and thyroid checked out.
New born babies typically feed on a 4 hour schedule because they are growing at enormous rates percentage wise, healthy adults do not need to feed every 4 hours.

WisherWood · 26/07/2023 22:39

Surely by Default most people would have a significant break from food while asleep? (It would be quite feasible to leave 12 hours between dinner and breakfast without missing any meals?)

You would think so but I've found I have to be quite disciplined about it. If you were to wake up at 06:30 and have a cup of tea with milk and/ or sugar, that is breaking your fast, because your stomach does have to digest that. You'd then have to have your final meal before 18:30 and not that many people are home and able to cook within that time. Then if you have a final drink around 20:00 of anything containing milk or sugar etc, your stomach isn't actually getting the downtime it needs.

It's not just your eating - it's anything you either eat or drink that has any calories in it. So people's 'fasting' times often aren't as long as they think they are.

FuzzyCaoraDhubh · 26/07/2023 16:38

I'm sorry to hear it @Appleofmyeye2023 That sounds very difficult. Wishing you well.

LoobyDop · 26/07/2023 16:21

I’ve been doing a soft 5:2 for about ten years. “Soft” because I have around 800 calories on a fast day rather than the 500 they say. I find it the least painful way to avoid gradual stealth weight gain and stay round about the same size- not least because I’m a natural gannet. A couple of fast days a week allow me to eat whatever I want at weekends without paying the price.

AtomicBlondeRose · 26/07/2023 16:15

Then you can start your eating window in the morning and finish eating earlier in the day.

blackheartsgirl · 26/07/2023 16:12

What if you have to take regular medication in the morning with food. Fasting won’t work then.

surveythebest · 26/07/2023 16:06

Luxell934 · 26/07/2023 10:12

Just wondering how much actual weight you lost in those 3 months going from a size 16 to a 10?

I don't know. I've never looked at scales and always requested medical professionals not to tell me my weight due to a history of bulimia

But I overheard them when I was at my biggest at an appointment, and my weight was about 13 stone something!

OP posts:
Delatron · 26/07/2023 15:19

Appleofmyeye2023 · 26/07/2023 15:08

So we were following the old 800 cal Mosley version. It was about 200-300 at one “meal” then a break of the fast with balance of calories
we’d typically eat the 200 at around 11am - egg and veg type thing and then have balance of calories at 5:30 to 6 pm - that was usually chicken and veg , or just a vegetarian, or maybe a fish and veg

we’d do fasting on a Tuesday and Thursday

It didn’t really trigger on first fast day of the week, and ok on Wednesday , then come Friday i was usually ok next day through normal breakfast and lunch , and then Friday tea (still keeping it light) I’d eat at 6-7pm and within an hour off it would go. Not every time at first, but gradually over 3 years got more and more frequent. And also started to happen after Friday breakfast or even on the Wednesday

as it wasn’t every single time, and then started to happen at other times, it took me a long time to twig - and for the consultant to point it out

I can’t eat a main meal after 7pm now without ending up in the bathroom for next 3 hours within 1 hour of the meal - makes going out for dinner almost impossible,

Oh how awful for you. Thank you for sharing, this needs to be more well known.
I hope there is research being done in to why this happens?

I know lots of people are Michael Mosley fans but 800 calories is so ridiculously low. I wonder if it puts stress on the endocrine system and this leads to the problem. I really hope it improves for you.

OneTC · 26/07/2023 15:18

You were only eating 800cal a day?

Appleofmyeye2023 · 26/07/2023 15:10

Sorry, no we’d do the 200-300 at around 9am to get a full 8 hours between eating during day. It was a long time ago 🙄.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 26/07/2023 15:08

So we were following the old 800 cal Mosley version. It was about 200-300 at one “meal” then a break of the fast with balance of calories
we’d typically eat the 200 at around 11am - egg and veg type thing and then have balance of calories at 5:30 to 6 pm - that was usually chicken and veg , or just a vegetarian, or maybe a fish and veg

we’d do fasting on a Tuesday and Thursday

It didn’t really trigger on first fast day of the week, and ok on Wednesday , then come Friday i was usually ok next day through normal breakfast and lunch , and then Friday tea (still keeping it light) I’d eat at 6-7pm and within an hour off it would go. Not every time at first, but gradually over 3 years got more and more frequent. And also started to happen after Friday breakfast or even on the Wednesday

as it wasn’t every single time, and then started to happen at other times, it took me a long time to twig - and for the consultant to point it out

I can’t eat a main meal after 7pm now without ending up in the bathroom for next 3 hours within 1 hour of the meal - makes going out for dinner almost impossible,

Appleofmyeye2023 · 26/07/2023 14:23

I did fast diet for 3 years. Lost only about 1 stone . But did enjoy the freedom it gave in a wired way. The literature does now point to this not being effective at large weight loss, but is effective for other things

but, I am one of many people who have developed Postprandial diarrhoea and vomiting. Even after I twigged that it was breaking a fast that bought it on, and stopped the fasting diet , I now still get it if I don’t eat regularly. In other words I no longer have any flexibility in even leaving 5-6 between having something to eat.

Im 8 years post stopping fasting. My condition often rules my life. I have had horrendous public accidents , I take spare clothes with me if travelling or think meal times may be disrupted. I take antispasmodic and anti diarrhoea tabs before travelling or going out routinely. I not only have diarrhoea but violent bowel cramps and vomiting. It comes on within an hour of eating even small amounts of food post fast of longer than 5-6 hours, and the attack lasts 3-4 hours till everything is ejected. I am left exhausted and still in pain for rest of the day.

yes, it could have developed independently from fasting, but the fasting set it off and it doesn’t even take full fast to result in an attack

im not the only one …there’s acres of correspondence on boards like fasting sites about this.

what really annoys me is lack of warnings by those advocating fasting. I had a lot of hospital tests etc which all came back negative. Even thought I told Gp and consultants that I did do fasting, they didn’t connect it, until I was finally referred to a good one, who basically pointed it out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread