Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Argument with husband about protecting dog

135 replies

rankings · 25/07/2023 12:25

My husband and me had a situation on the beach yesterday where he was wearing our 5 month old baby in the carrier, and a staffie off a lead ran up to our dog. We didn't know if the staffie was friendly or not but the owners were frantically calling it back so the atmosphere quickly turned panicked and I grabbed my 3 year old and dragged him away from the our dog and the staffie. My logic always being to create distance between the dog and my children. Of course I would absolutely hate to see my lovely dog hurt or killed, and please can no one imply different, but I also would never be able to risk my kids for any dog, no matter how much I love them. Anyway my husband who was wearing our baby tan towards our dog and the staffie and was trying to pick our dog up. I was furious as not only the act of bending down trying to pick up our dog could of led to the staffie being able to reach and bite my baby, picking up the dog could also lead to the other dog jumping up to try and get to him and the baby getting caught in the middle. I think he massively put our baby at risk. The staffie thankfully did nothing other than jump up and scare us/our dog but it's more what could of happened

It led to a conversation about what would happen in future when out with kids and dog and my husband said he would never be able to walk away and leave our dog to be attacked but this just makes me feel terrified to let him go out with the dog and the kids together especially without me there.

AIBU to expect him to prioritise the kids and put distance between him and the dogs both ours and the one potentially posing a threat?! I really do love our dog but I won't risk my kids lives over my dog potentially living another 5/6 if we're lucky

Before anyone starts that Staffies are gentle or whatever it's more just about that situation of what to do. Would have same reaction if it was a JR or a XL and want to create distance

OP posts:
Chickenwing2 · 25/07/2023 18:34

I think your husband has reacted in the panic, and it's instinct to want to save the dog. We don't always make the best decisions in these moments.

I would have done the same thing as him, and in the end it was fine and both dog and baby are Ok.

Est1990 · 25/07/2023 18:23

rankings · 25/07/2023 18:10

Even if I was alone with my dog if he was attacked by a dog I don't think I could reasonably fight off I wouldn't get involved. I'm not going to risk my life for a dog. I don't think you need to risk your life for a dog to be a responsible dog owner. Why would any sane person especially one who has kids actually risk their life over their dog? My kids need a mum.

I can't fight a staffie if it turned nasty, no chance would I send my husband off with the kids and take my chances with a potentially aggressive dog. Should I never go out anywhere with my dog because I'm not willing to die or get attacked for him?

You dont need to risk your life. You can through stones, you can shout for help. But the way you are talking (obviously this is just from reading) it sounds like you would just sit and watch and in the end blame everyone else.

Every scenario turns out very dramatic to you too.
You are so focus on blaming your husband when you should be focusing on learning from this near miss and improve your couple's ability to manage a dog and 2 small children.
Just take as a learning opportunity not a blaming one.

Midnites · 25/07/2023 18:15

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 25/07/2023 13:20

But you panicked over something that didn't happen.

The owners "frantically" calling their dog back probably thought it might jump up at you or pinch your picnic (if you had one). If it was a risk to anything it's highly unlikely to have been off lead.

Be honest, you wouldn't have had reacted like that to a poodle or a pug would you?

Oh wow, someone reacted to a hench, intimidating looking dog more than they would a cavapoo. How surprising.

Why do people get offended by people being scared of their horrible, aggressive looking dogs? Are we supposed to pretend they look friendly and cute and not cross the road to spare your feelings?!

rankings · 25/07/2023 18:10

Even if I was alone with my dog if he was attacked by a dog I don't think I could reasonably fight off I wouldn't get involved. I'm not going to risk my life for a dog. I don't think you need to risk your life for a dog to be a responsible dog owner. Why would any sane person especially one who has kids actually risk their life over their dog? My kids need a mum.

I can't fight a staffie if it turned nasty, no chance would I send my husband off with the kids and take my chances with a potentially aggressive dog. Should I never go out anywhere with my dog because I'm not willing to die or get attacked for him?

OP posts:
Est1990 · 25/07/2023 17:41

Firstly, the person at fault is the other owner!
But I would focus on preventing and planning future situations.
1 person is responsible for the dog and the other for the kids everytime you are out or as soon as a 'threatening' situation arises.

And yes, not safe to walk your dog and toddler+baby on your own (but i genuinely thought this would be common sense). So maybe you guys need to work a bit on that. Being responsible dog owner is a bit like driving...you need to be also anticipating other's drivers behaviours.🤷‍♀️

He should have probably apologised for acting on instinct and put your baby in a potentially dangerous situation but don't ask him to say he would just leave your dog to 'be attacked'. If you love your pet you can't just sit and watch, you can't!

VeterinaryCareAssistant · 25/07/2023 17:19

Hugasauras · 25/07/2023 15:13

Oh and she's walked off the lead too, just to upset MN even more Grin

I have four off lead gasp!

tootallfortheshelf · 25/07/2023 17:09

3dogsandarabbit · 25/07/2023 15:25

To be honest, a toddler, baby and a dog on the beach is a recipe for disaster. Too many adults and children about on a beach for a dog to cope with.

I agree!

Hibiscrubbed · 25/07/2023 15:38

Hugasauras · 25/07/2023 15:13

Oh and she's walked off the lead too, just to upset MN even more Grin

Same. I think we’re in the minority. Seems to be a lot of panicky owners who wanted a dog because they look nice and create a lovely image, but don’t actually understand dog behaviour enough to read and prevent situations. And certainly can’t cope with kids and dogs simultaneously.

Jongleterre · 25/07/2023 15:35

Picking up dogs is stupid.

It exposes the belly and whilst the Staffie isn't a hunting breed, a sighthound MAY see the exposed belly as easy prey.

It also puts the person who has picked up their dog, their fingers, hands and face at risk of being nipped or bitten if a dog is leaping up at the dog they've picked up.

Two of my Whippets are as placid as anything but show them an exposed belly and they want to move in for the kill.

Your husband who had a baby strapped to him was very foolish.

lljkk · 25/07/2023 15:35

yes it sounds dramatic & is exceedingly unlikely to happen

dramatic to assume a bounding over dog must be a threat, too

3dogsandarabbit · 25/07/2023 15:25

To be honest, a toddler, baby and a dog on the beach is a recipe for disaster. Too many adults and children about on a beach for a dog to cope with.

HulaChick · 25/07/2023 15:24

*anymore than I would..

HulaChick · 25/07/2023 15:24

I'm with your DH and would never leave my dog to be potentially attacked, anyone than I would my child. I'd defend both. If it was in a field of cows, I would then let my dog off the lead and let it make its own escape (as this is the safest option) but I would rather try & kick off another dog attacking mine rather than walk away.

However, a lot of people are irresponsible dog owners and don't train their dogs properly.

Mistymist · 25/07/2023 15:23

@tootallfortheshelf are you this thick irl too?

Everywherenowhere · 25/07/2023 15:19

MyCatPlaysPiano · 25/07/2023 14:44

She (not unreasonably) thought the baby was safe. I wouldn't feel the need to take my baby away from DH if I thought there was immediate physical danger. In OP's eyes, she had the older child, DH had the baby.

Its not ok for no one to gave the dog though when there are two adults present. The husband should have taken the children, OP should have dealt with the dog.

If you can’t look after children and dogs, don’t do both at the same time or dong have a dog.

I agree @MyCatPlaysPiano no one has forced op to have a dog. She has one and she brought it on a walk with 2 children. She is responsible for the dog. I’m not saying dove into a fight but if in that position I would’ve shouted at DH to grab 3 year old and move away and then I would’ve tried re call my dog to me and shout at the other dog to get away.

MrsMitford3 · 25/07/2023 15:17

ThisThing · 25/07/2023 14:04

You were the one in the wrong here OP. You should have stayed to sort your dog out. Your husband would then have been able to take both children away.

I agree with this from @DogsParty. You just left him and your baby. Why? He needed to have the children as he had the baby on him, you needed to help your dog. Now you’re annoyed with him. If I was him, I’d be pissed off with you.

Me too.

This did not have to be so dramatic.
You walk away with dog and DH brings DC.

Hugasauras · 25/07/2023 15:13

Oh and she's walked off the lead too, just to upset MN even more Grin

Hugasauras · 25/07/2023 15:12

I walk my dog with my two young kids every day and have done since DD1 was born 4 years ago. I've never had any problems, but I am an experienced dog owner with a well trained dog. We love our walks all together!

Missingmyusername · 25/07/2023 15:12

It all sounds very dramatic when nothing actually happened.

Yes your husband was foolish but you’ve no idea how you would react- you could freeze. Remaining calm and assessing the situation is better than blind panic, easier said than done.

The media hypes every story to create maximum shock value.

“I agree, he was offering the baby as 'bait' to the dog to distract it away from his dog 😱” ^Jesus - you need to put the internet down, unless that’s sarcasm lol.

MyCatPlaysPiano · 25/07/2023 15:10

I also agree with OP's concern about her DH walking the dog alone while with the baby, since it doesn't seem like he would leave the dog in order to keep the baby safe if necessary.

I don’t think anyone should walk dogs and have children. You simply can’t be in control of both. It would be irresponsible.

GoodChat · 25/07/2023 15:07

Logic would have suggested he removed the children and you retrieved the dog.

I wouldn't leave my dog, neither would DP.

Hugasauras · 25/07/2023 15:03

It all just sounds a bit of an overblown shambles to me tbh.

QOD · 25/07/2023 15:02

hmmm. my dd is 24 so can fight for herself but I would lay down my life for my wee chi.
I honestly think though that if dd was a helpless baby that I would have maybe thrown myself over the dog AND baby? or legged it with baby? I didn't have a dog until dd was 19 so chihuahua is my baby

Wonder if this is a mum/dad thing? (sexist comment alert)

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 25/07/2023 15:02

I understand him acting on instinct this time.

but him openly stating that he wouldn’t prioritise your DC’s safety over your dogs? That would be a genuine dealbreaker.

he definitely shouldn’t be allowed to leave the house with a child (or two children!!) and the dog!

I rarely suggest this: but would you consider leaving him?

WeWereInParis · 25/07/2023 14:57

MyCatPlaysPiano · 25/07/2023 14:44

She (not unreasonably) thought the baby was safe. I wouldn't feel the need to take my baby away from DH if I thought there was immediate physical danger. In OP's eyes, she had the older child, DH had the baby.

Its not ok for no one to gave the dog though when there are two adults present. The husband should have taken the children, OP should have dealt with the dog.

If you can’t look after children and dogs, don’t do both at the same time or dong have a dog.

I wasn't debating that point. I was responding to what I thought was an unfair criticism of OP that her instinct was to leave her newborn.

Of course OP and her DH could solve this in future by her wearing the baby, and him then being able to do whatever he saw fit when it came to the dog. I also agree with OP's concern about her DH walking the dog alone while with the baby, since it doesn't seem like he would leave the dog in order to keep the baby safe if necessary.