Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not understand the concept of masking

322 replies

tattooedteagal · 25/07/2023 06:54

I'm trying to understand better due to my son's autism, but the notion of masking ADHD or autism doesn't make a lot of sense to me. Surely if you understand social cues enough to put on a convincing facade throughout your childhood or adulthood, it contradicts one of the core definitions of autism. Feel free to correct me. I'm not saying I'm right (I'm probably wrong) I'm just struggling to understand.

I have ADHD and it was picked up on when I was 14 so I'm obviously crap at masking. It's caused me a lot of issues and I don't want to gatekeep ADHD, but it annoys me when people think they might have it because they get irritated at slow drivers or have a clutter drawer in their house.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
surveythebest · 25/07/2023 08:08

MintJulia · 25/07/2023 08:06

OP, imagine always being the one who doesn't get the joke. After a while people call you sour or humourless, say you are no fun to be with, avoid you, exclude you.

To avoid this, you laugh, even though you have no idea why it is funny.

It's exhausting and stressful. I've been doing it for 50 years. I can't wait to retire so I don't have to cope with colleagues any more.

I've done this - started laughing so I don't look like the odd one out who didn't get the joke

Sadly, quite a few people have noticed and then said something like 'Why are you laughing? Go on then, what is it that's funny then?'

Sad humiliating

IDGAF97 · 25/07/2023 08:07

Oh lord reading this I let out a big sigh like I felt it I've never been able to explain it before but you have said it perfectly i was diagnosed with ADHD and ODD at 15 I didn't understand it at young and never pretend to be honest I still don't fully understand it now I was never intelligent or academically smart i never fit in at school never had friends and never understood why as I got older the behaviour I have now is copied from others around me when I get home and can be me I'm a completely different person I find it hard to make friends now because my behaviour changes so much like the more I know you the more my barrier comes down and my I don't know weirdness I guess comes out I'm not badly behaved or nasty or anything I'm just extremely hyper can be "abit much" and i didn't realise we weren't all like that untill I was older sorry for rambling this is what I do thanks for writing this though it's been an eye opener sucks I'm 26 this year and only really now am I learning more about it but as my son is going through the process now of school and we are both finding it quite difficult I'm trying not to rub off on him. Xx

MintJulia · 25/07/2023 08:06

OP, imagine always being the one who doesn't get the joke. After a while people call you sour or humourless, say you are no fun to be with, avoid you, exclude you.

To avoid this, you laugh, even though you have no idea why it is funny.

It's exhausting and stressful. I've been doing it for 50 years. I can't wait to retire so I don't have to cope with colleagues any more.

BogRollBOGOF · 25/07/2023 08:06

Grouser · 25/07/2023 07:31

For me masking is that I'm doing things on manual while others are driving an automatic.
For example, if I'm talking to someone I sometimes will be manually counting in my head to make sure I'm leaving the appropriate gap so there's room for them to talk but not an awkward silence (and I tend to have a set number that I count to), my NT DP inputs that gap naturally and can sense how long to leave it without thinking about it and gauge it based on human factors rather than a set definition like me. That sort of talking to someone from work in a non work setting, sets of a flow chart from me of a ticklist of whst I know is politeness eg i have to check which what way my feet are pointing etc, but also a lot of deliberate choice of responses eg when this happens you must respond with eg if they are walking, you should keep walking, if they say "anyway then" you should stop the conversation

Sometimes this means my interactions may not look that different to my DP, but she just has a natural feel for these things, she can sense when a conversation is dying out and her body naturally does the right "I'm interested cues"

My other explanation is that for me, I often feel "foreign'. In my head, my thoughts or what I want to do pops up, and I have to translate that into other people's language all the time. In the same way I would do as a clunky gcse German speaker. I can speak some German, but you might guess I wasn't fluent. It's not my natural language, it's not what I think in, and it's not my knee jerk automatic eg if you bash your knee you'll shout in English. To constantly have to translate your thought into another language is really tiring, but also sometimes it means that it's easier to withdraw rather than put lots of effort into every interaction.

When my Dp lived abroad and was suddenly in a different culture where the rules were different, eye contact was different she struggled more than I did because she's used to being fluent. She wasn't used to having to think about the level of eye contact etc.

That's pretty much the analogy I used to then 9yo DS driving home from him being diagnosed; I wasn't expecting such a definitive diagnosis to be made so "easily" and I was reeling at the time, but he needed to know what the appointment was about and what it meant.

DH has an automatic. I drive a manual which I'm well used to. I've driven the same make for 10+ years because it fits my ergonomics. When I get into DH's car, I'm still driving and doing all the observing and reacting required for driving, but the controls aren't in the same place. I've got a dialogue chuntering through my head of "don't use my left side" and my left hand flaps for non-existant gears when I change speed, the controls feel odd and clunky, my right quad burns because of the awkward angle of the accelerator etc. I'm still driving but there's more mental effort and I get physically tired much quicker.
That's what it must be like for DS getting through most days, manually vetting most interactions, battling sensory input.

Another analogy is like every day being like an all-day job interview. Every one puts on their best, polished front for an interview and it can be done for short phases, but to do it all the time, you'd lose your sense of self, you'd be exhausted when you get in, you'd begin to dread the day ahead when you get up each morning.

And if you're masking with autism, it's not just manually filtering your way through unwritten laws of social communucation, you're probably also battling physical urges to stim, to hide away, manage body language, and brain-mashing sensory input like that clock on the wall that ticks out of synch with your heart beat, or the faint hum that no one else seems to hear, or the way that someone's nostrils whistle when they breathe.

It was DS's regular explosions the moment of stepping out of the school doors when he could let the mask drop, once cuminating in a 4 hour meltdown that lead us to investigate/ diagnose. He is exemplary at school, but at great personal cost. He can't do anything other than zone out for at least two hours after school. Now at secondary, I judge from his head position as he walks up the road to the car if it's a radio off, and wait in silence until he can talk day.

We all have a best, polished front, but with autism it's having to be in that mode pretty much constantly to socially survive. You may not know that your doing it, but the extent of it impairs your ability to function in wider life. We hear a lot about meltdown, but shut down is another significant trait where you just can't process anything else.

InvincibleInvisibility · 25/07/2023 08:02

The difference is that we all need to learn social cues and behaviour but once learnt it's easy for an NT person to follow them (and pick up new ones).

Both my DSes have ADHD. They were at the same school from age 3 to 11 (DS1) and 8 (DS2). It's a VERY strict religious school, where the DC are graded out of 10 every week for their behaviour and it impacts their overall grades.

My DSes always had almost perfect behaviour marks. We had zero complaints from school. DS1 had communication difficulties (with peers and teachers) but that was just dismissed as being shy (or in one notable case, insolent. Until I pointed out to the teacher that he has difficulty chatting to his friends too and she realised it was true and backed off).

At home however it was completely different. The coke bottle analogy totally applies to my DC.

An extreme example of masking: my DS1 was 10. Doing reasonably well at school. Had 2 good friends and was included in a larger crowd too. Excellent weekly behaviour grades. In the space of 4 months he tried to run away from home twice ("I don't deserve a nice home I deserve to sleep in the street"), tried to cut his wrists with a knife 3 times, tried to strangle himself in the playground (another mum told me, supervising staff hadn't noticed) and tried to jump out of 3rd floor flat window 2 times.

He just wanted the pain inside to stop and he felt like he didn't fit in this world despite all his efforts. And my god did he make a lot of effort. It was heartbreaking.

[Update 2 years later: we've moved a long way away and he goesto a much more relaxed school, he's taking ADHD meds, and is absolutely loving life. He's top of his class (they rank the kids here) and we no longer have the huge angry outbursts because the pressure is off].

JasonOsCubanHeels · 25/07/2023 08:00

my adhd brain is never quiet - I’ll be thinking about a conversation I had a week ago, thinking about what I might have done or said differently, while two different songs or a movie scene are playing on a loop in my head (right now it’s the courtroom scene from legally blonde). I’ll possibly be thinking about what I’ll have for dinner at the same time. I can’t stop it so I have to concentrate extra hard on normal conversations so as not to appear a total weirdo. Couple that with all the other adhd traits - it’s exhausting.

so it’s like basic French in a French speaking country but the little bit of Spanish you know is going round in your head too and it wants to come out but you know that’s inappropriate. You try and stop the Spanish but then that means you’re not paying attention to the native French speaker in front of you. Then they notice that you’re acting strangely and that’s super stressful to someone who is masking because it means you failed.

Jujubes5 · 25/07/2023 07:59

I have had difficulty making friends all my 50+years despite all my masking - I honestly don't know what I'm doing wrong but others detect something which makes them avoid me.
So when others say 'doesn't everyone do this' well if you have lots of friends and enjoy socialising - you're probably not doing it to nearly the same extent as a ND.

TheOutlaws · 25/07/2023 07:59

@Imdrivinginmygetawaycar

Feel free to ask all the questions, would be interested to hear about your job too!

I’m sorry that school are being unhelpful, they need to read up on autism in girls.

SockGoddess · 25/07/2023 07:55

I know some people don’t like it when people say “but isn’t that what we all do?” and think it’s like saying “we ll have autism” - but I don’t think asking this question is bad. It may mean you are realising you also “mask” in an ND way, but it could be just describing the way most people do adjust their behaviour to the situation and have for example a work “self” and a different persona with friends or when relaxing. That’s normal, but IME the difference with masking is that it totally exhausts you and you’re very stressed afterwards.

I wonder about it too as I do have ASD and ADHD in my family, my DC have some traits and I sometimes think I do, but then lots of things don’t match. Being a massive introvert also involves feeling exhausted after social interaction, but I don’t feel like I copy other people or “pretend to be normal”, it’s more like I’m just a bit shy, crap at small talk but sometimes really hit it off with someone and can chat away happily and easily (including taking turns etc).

There’s also broad autism phenotype where you wouldn’t get a diagnosis as such but have some tendencies, often occurring in family members of people with ASD. So I think it’s a normal process to wonder “does everyone do this, or is there something unusual about how I’m doing it?” And there can be grey areas and misdiagnosis.

IncompleteSenten · 25/07/2023 07:54

My eldest son masks. He knows he has autism. He knows he is different. He can see how others behave and he tries to be like them. That means not stimming. Watching what he says and how he acts. Trying to not show how loud or sudden noises distress him etc etc.
All to try to fit in to an NT world that does not accept him as himself.

The stress that causes him is enormous. He needs to stim. He needs his routines. He needs to cover his ears at an unexpected noise.

But he knows what other people say and do if he does.

So he comes home overwhelmed, exhausted and very upset and here he is safe to be himself so he stims and talks about his favourite topics and yes he shows the distress he's been trying desperately to hide all day.

This is why so many people with autism end up with mental health problems.

NT inability to accept people who are different is what is causing these problems.

That said, not every autistic person can mask. My younger son can't. He stims and shouts and lashes out because the world is pure torture for him day in day out. He cannot filter out any sensory input. Imagine blinding lights, loud noises, scratchy clothing, horrible smells and overwhelming taste and texture your entire life. How well could you function if that was your reality?

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 07:53

Daleksatemyshed · 25/07/2023 07:49

I know it's not a one size fits all situation but can I ask about accommodations? Lots of posts mention making accommodations for people with ND but they never really say what they mean by this. I think more people would be open to the idea if they knew what they were being asked to do/ not to do

It's a minefield and I think 'ND' should not mean things like severe ASD/non verbal etc types

For example, I am a capable, literate woman who has a degree and family. My son has the same diagnosis nowadays since my Asperger's would just be autism that he has Hmm yet he will never be out of nappies, smears, can't speak a word and is a danger to himself and other people if not supervised 24/7. His care team for respite now need 2-1 for care.

Accommodations would mean a whole host of things for him. For me, maybe more time to process a request? So world apart.

RegainingTheWill2023 · 25/07/2023 07:52

Sorry I meant to say you are right @user1471530109 that masking is having to work really hard to fit in and is exhausting.

LittleSwede · 25/07/2023 07:51

I wasn't even aware I was masking at work and in social situations until I was in my early 40s. I kept getting burn out from working and found it impossible to keep up with everything that other people could do as part if daily life as I just felt completely exhausted all the time. It made me ill.

Now I have adjusted my expectations of myself and try not to do too many things that mean I have to mask. I also allow myself to unmask around people who are safe to be around.

Let me tell you what happens when I end up masking frequently without a chance to recharge my social batteries. So on Friday DD (also autistic) was invited to an End Of Term party at a friend's house (and I stayed and talked to the other parents there for several hours), I then had a 3 hour hair dressers appointment (social chit chat) on Saturday, a rare kids party invite for DD Sunday (again I have to stay which means talking to people) and a playdate yesterday (slightly better as the parent knows I'm ND and I'm in safe-ish company).

All four involved me having to mask to a certain extent (making eye contact, small talk and focusing on the topic of the conversation, clues on when to speak, what to say, not interrupt, talk too loud, too much or too intensely and so on. Basically avoid looking and acting too weird so DD gets invited to these things again) and today I feel totally wiped out and fluey. I am not working at the moment but if I did I'd be off sick. Such is the extent of the exhaustion that follows masking, for me. I wouldn't normally have so many things on so am aware that I sort of knew it was too much but it seemed unavailable.

Just typing that was exhausting 😴

Jujubes5 · 25/07/2023 07:50

One thing I think is that my Adhd brain is always going fast.
So it's probably hard to 'chat' as whilst I am making conversation, my brain is as usual thinking madly, running ahead with scenarios, info, so also looking interested in the other person, listening to what they say and making the correct expressions is not easy because by then my brain is 3 steps ahead.
Masking is a funny word imv as it suggests a flat expression when in fact you are doing all the things you think are expected of you, eg raising your eyebrows in suprise at their comment, smiling empathetically etc. The opposite.

Oatycookies · 25/07/2023 07:50

Imdrivinginmygetawaycar · 25/07/2023 07:04

Actually not masking would likely lead to less meltdowns. Its not masking vs meltdowns.

An autsitic person ideally would have an environment and support so that triggers are minimised and meltdowns are infrequent. Meltdowns are like the crisis point so ideally we don't want to reach crisis.

Masking is about fitting in with people. Neurowilde has some brilliant graphics about autism I could dig out this evening. When an autistic person is having a conversation they may be hyperaware of all the things they should/shouldnt be doing (oh eye contact, oh not too much, oh I have spoken too long, I need to look interested, who was it again they're taking about, have I asked enough questions. Do I look silly. Are they expecting me to agree with them on this or is their tone that they think it's ridiculous...."

Constant masking, especially at school, is exhausting.

Exactly. I remember when I was 14 a friend of mine pointing out I made no eye contact. To this day I find myself hyper fixated on getting the ‘right’ balance with eye contact especially if it’s someone I don’t know very well, because I don’t want to have too much /too little.

Imdrivinginmygetawaycar · 25/07/2023 07:50

They're refused so far 🙄.

But on another level I'd so love to ask you All The Questions! (I wont) I did a second degree in psych so I could train as an Ed psych but this after having kids we moved and it wasn't going to be feasible.

I do autism education though so it scratches my itch but I really did want to be an ed psych...

RegainingTheWill2023 · 25/07/2023 07:49

user1471530109 · 25/07/2023 06:59

I must admit, I'm not a fan of the term masking either. My DD is autistic and I feel the term indicates that the 'real' person is the one who is having a meltdown/shutdown and that any other time, she is covering it up. It's not like that. The meltdown is due to being overwhelmed.
I'm not sure on what term I'd prefer, but to me, masking is having to work really hard to fit in. This in itself is exhausting.

Masking doesn't mean covering up a meltdown. It means consciously adopting behaviours that fit better in the NT world. Prolonged masking can lead to meltdowns as it is so overwhelmingly exhausting.
It can be simple things like suppressing a stim when out in public. Or using social rules/conventions in interactions that don't come naturally but ease relationship

Daleksatemyshed · 25/07/2023 07:49

I know it's not a one size fits all situation but can I ask about accommodations? Lots of posts mention making accommodations for people with ND but they never really say what they mean by this. I think more people would be open to the idea if they knew what they were being asked to do/ not to do

TheOutlaws · 25/07/2023 07:48

Hi @Imdrivinginmygetawaycar

Yes, I’m a teacher and about to apply for EdPsych doctorate.

Whenever I’ve had to write a school-based account of a girl’s behaviour for an ASD assessment I look for sensory and social clues. So things like:

  • hates loud noises, general classroom chatter, soft noises, any noises, finds auditory discrimination tough in a classroom, has perfect pitch, issues with showers/clothes
  • Finds it tough to fit in, has limited affect, strange voice perhaps, takes instructions literally, very slow and deliberate, one intense friendship or on the edge of social group, people-pleasing, school anxiety

There are loads more but perhaps teachers might consider these things before writing a school account.

calmcoco · 25/07/2023 07:47

Imdrivinginmygetawaycar · 25/07/2023 07:22

And no its not the same as what we all do by a question of degree.

A bit like saying we're "all a bit ocd"
Or were "all a bit tired" to someone with ME
Or all our legs get tired sometimes to someone who can't walk...

It's minimising what it's like completely.

I agree with this.

surveythebest · 25/07/2023 07:46

My son is severely autistic. He can't mask. I don't know if he knows what it would even mean, but he sure as hell doesn't care!

I have Asperger's (it's not diagnosed that way anymore), and I mask, a lot.

Unpopular opinion but I like masking and yes I want to present as 'typical' to the world, thanks.

Bouncyball23 · 25/07/2023 07:43

Dd8 awaiting diagnosis will mask, she tries to fit in doing things she doesn't want todo because everyone does it, even little things like using hand drier in public loo she hates them they hurt her ears but she will push through that an use them as quickly as possible because everyone else does even tho I tell her we don't have too. Altho as she's getting older it is getting harder for her to mask.

Velvian · 25/07/2023 07:43

I think the thing for my DD and me to some extent is that, she understands there are rules and works so hard at getting it right, but doesn't quite hit the mark.

She (we) over shares, she can be tactless. Joins in conversations, but goes too far with the facts on a topic.

It is easy to see the mask. I can't really explain those that are better at masking though. DS is probably ND (there are more physical/health clues but he seems so sociable and popular, although doesn't have many good friends. I don't have much insight into what DS might be hiding socially.

AuntieMatter · 25/07/2023 07:42

I have ADHD, and also have a role working with neurodivergent people in my job.

I know myself that I learned to do certain things to fit in e.g. not fidgeting, sitting still, holding my arms a certain way, not constantly interrupting people, asking people about themselves. I have to put a certain amount of effort into these things and they add to my stress. That's masking.

Also important to keep in mind that neurodivergent people each have a different set of social skills. They don't generally have zero social awareness or ability.

I work with a man who paces and swims the whole time as he knows it is "safe" to do so with me. But in many situations he suppresses this as he has learned it gets a negative reaction. But he has also found this suppression very distressing and exhausting.

TheOutlaws · 25/07/2023 07:40

@Littlefidget2

As per PP’s comment, have you considered that you might be autistic and your DS has inherited your neurodivergence?

I deal with parents on a daily basis who don’t recognise their children’s neurodivergence, because it’s the same as theirs!

Swipe left for the next trending thread