Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think our current way of living is unsustainable?

81 replies

goldenlikedaylight · 24/07/2023 22:54

The number of sick days in 2022 was at a record high. I myself had 2 months off from work last year because of my mental health just crumbling beneath me. I've heard of so many adults who have also taken sick leave for mental health, or have had to take time out from working because of it. I just think the way modern life is set up at the moment is not sustainable, and it's breaking people. Does anyone else feel the same?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Perihellopause · 25/07/2023 22:22

AuntieJune · 25/07/2023 14:22

I think a lot of it comes down to the failure to value traditional female work. Motherhood but also bolstering the community through social contact, volunteering, using local shops etc.

I'm not in any way proposing a return to two gendered spheres but there should be a way to value domestic labour and caring work, whether paid or unpaid, more.

A four day week would be a good start.

Couldn’t agree more.

Yorkshirelass04 · 25/07/2023 22:15

@onefinemess who would know who needs antidepressants other than someone's doctor?

Soapyspuds · 25/07/2023 21:15

How would you change it though? People are chasing material possessions to the detriment of family and community but I don't think anyone will want to change. Plus times have always been hard, perhaps there was a golden period in the latter half of the 20th century but would you rather live in the 1930s or in the 19th century

The first answer on this thread is the best.

We all have the chance if we want to compete with others or simply live in the way that makes us happy.

The less I care about why I look to others the happier I am. Although I learned to stop caring what 99.9% of people think in my early twenties. I only care about the opinions of my close friends and family.

Baconisdelicious · 25/07/2023 21:07

Why do we continue to have high levels of depression, burnout and anxiety as a society if life is so good? Blaming it on people being greedy doesn’t sound plausible to me. Or is it greedy to want to be happier?

no, of course not. But how do you define happiness? I do think many of us are dissatisfied with what we have. And there is an absolute tendency to focus on what we don’t have, rather than what we do. Human nature to compare ourselves with the next person. I do think it helps to be have a modest outlook on life, to work on being grateful for the small stuff, however twee it might feel. of course, this is only possible when your basic needs are met and with a failing health care system, people being in pain, or genuinely struggling mentally are not getting the help they need. It’s,no good being grateful for a windy day if you can’t pay your rent. But it is very much worth recognising that if you can pay your rent, that’s a positive. End of. You don’t need to over analyse it, say but ‘we should be able to pay rent, we work, I’m not grateful for that’ because that causes dissatisfaction with what you do have and becomes difficult to manage mentally.

Bovrilla · 25/07/2023 20:42

Quite teaching and got a far less stressful but lower paid job. Get to WFH 3/5 days.

I'm poorer but my mental and physical health are definitely improved in just a few months.

But I am very lucky our mortgage is relatively small, so we could afford for me to take the financial hit. The smaller income still stresses me out, but the gains elsewhere have been far greater. Especially the fact I see me kids more, and the whole household is calmer

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 20:33

AnxiousFairyQueen · 25/07/2023 18:48

@onefinemess just to add. Your first sentence makes no logical sense. I mean, of course those things affect mental health or why would so many people be taking antidepressants?

Taking medication when they don't need it perhaps.

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 20:04

@onefinemess of course office/computer work can be stressful! Ambulance call handlers for a start, they burn out incredibly quickly because of the horrific stuff they are hearing day in, day out. It makes you wake up in the night because there's things you can't forget

My job isn't overly stressful but I'm shouted/sworn at most days or told how useless I am which gets a bit.. wearing

Covidwoes · 25/07/2023 19:58

I do think we have a 'work work work' attitude in the UK. DH was recently headhunted by a company with the offer of a £10k pay rise. He turned it down. They wouldn't offer flexible working (he currently WFH two/three days a week which helps me with the nursery and school runs), and he would have been commuting every day. He has since heard that the company really aren't family friendly, so we dodged a bullet there. We are so relieved he turned it down! You only have to read lots of threads on MN about people worried about taking time off when poorly. We are work obsessed and working ridiculously long days seems to be a mark of honour in some work places. It's not right!

ooohoobigsummerblowout · 25/07/2023 19:36

goldenlikedaylight · 24/07/2023 22:54

The number of sick days in 2022 was at a record high. I myself had 2 months off from work last year because of my mental health just crumbling beneath me. I've heard of so many adults who have also taken sick leave for mental health, or have had to take time out from working because of it. I just think the way modern life is set up at the moment is not sustainable, and it's breaking people. Does anyone else feel the same?

Looking at your original message again OP as the thread got me off track a few times. I think there are many valid points here along with a very wide range of experiences and opinions.

I also sometimes wonder about your last point / question, and I certainly think about it in a slightly different way to what's mostly been covered in the thread. Partly because I don't think there's a right and wrong answer - things are different today than any other time in history, and so has every other era been. If we look back, every generation / era was plagued with concerns of something along the lines of "we're now more isolated / rude / overworked than before". It's all relative as others have said.

There is much out there in the way of this discourse, how current expectations could be considered greater than other times / generations and there have been significant changes to lifestyles from a range of inputs. I think there are many different types of hard work as other posters have said (and one is not better or more righteous than another), and there are also many societal shifts and developments of all kinds that make our lives complicated, many of which are complexly and intrinsically linked.

Some of this was covered in Celeste Headlee's book Do Nothing which helped me with perspective on some of these topics, and things like Project 333 helped me focus on the simple things in our control that make life simpler and more straightforward - but these things won't appeal to everyone, I know.

I hope that you get to a better balance, and feel assured that there is much you can control.

Lastly, MH is clearly a hot topic. I do think those of us with the greatest resilience would do well to support others with empathy, as when the moment comes and you have to accept or come to understand your resilience is not "fixed" and does in fact know some bounds, there may not be many people ready or willing to help if you've used your resilience as a bar to measure others by when it's a deeply individual and complex characteristic.

Arewehumanorarewecupboards · 25/07/2023 19:18

I did feel the same so I changed it. Move jobs, moved house, created a new life.

PomTiddlyPomPom · 25/07/2023 19:12

I think it is far too easy to sit on the Internet and self diagnose all sorts of conditions such as anxiety and depression.

I've done loads of quizzes online that say I have anxiety/depression/three weeks to live because of a lump etc.
There is bugger all wrong with me except for being tired due to an auto immune condition and a family plus working full time!
The problem is, once someone gets their online 'diagnosis' they start to believe it is the cause of all of their problems and live their life accordingly. Before Dr Google appeared when people felt nervous or anxious they just rode it out, only the most extreme cases would have been diagnosed by a professional. I can't remember the last adult under the age of 30 that I spoke to that didn't drop their anxiety into the conversation at every available opportunity.
Life like this is unsustainable. If the entire population develops anxiety and depression who will do the jobs we rely on for survival? If every farmer, paramedic, consultant, carer etc suddenly diagnosed themselves with anxiety and refused to go to work we wouldn't last long as a population.
I do think the Internet and modern communication styles are the root of all evil, we are 'available' 24/7 no matter what. We are no longer trying to keep up with the neighbours but now people follow influencers, why do we care what some random woman that we'll never meet is wearing?
If I could go back in time and make sure the Internet was not invented I would do it in a heart beat!

AnxiousFairyQueen · 25/07/2023 18:48

@onefinemess just to add. Your first sentence makes no logical sense. I mean, of course those things affect mental health or why would so many people be taking antidepressants?

AnxiousFairyQueen · 25/07/2023 18:45

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 14:43

None of which is serious enough that it would affect your mental health.

We don't have poor housing in the UK, even the most rank, damp, dodgy, bodged in over an off-licence with questionable electrics is a Palace compared to normal housing for 98% of the people on the planet. In fact, by WHO standards, if you have a roof over your head, a fridge and some spare change in your pocket, even 10p, then YOU are wealthier than 98% of the people currently alive.

You think working at a computer is stressful! 🙄

You can leave your house anytime or God Forbid! talk to your neighbours, that's self imposed isolation.

Wages don't go as far? Yeah, that tends to happen sometimes. When I was in Uni, I lived in a house share and ate pot noodle with mayo for three years (and for the four after) the kitchen sink was live, something to do with the earth wire attached to the plumbing, we git around it by turning off the mains when we needed to do the dishes. But the economy ebbs and flows, in a few years it will be OK again.

We do not have poor health care. You might have to wait a few hours in A&E, but your broken leg will be fixed for free. In other countries you would just be crippled for life or have to pay thousands for a doctor.

As for social media causing stress! Yeah, maybe don't use it. Poof! social media stress gone!

You seem to be lacking a bit of empathy. Have the Pot Noodles affected your brain?

Maybe it would be worth looking inwards and questioning whether you’re being the nicest person you could be.

Destinedforfakeness · 25/07/2023 18:30

Assignedtoworryyourmother · 24/07/2023 23:04

My mental health is fucked and I've had 3 days off in the last 10 years because I had (proper) flu. I'd rather crack on if it's all the same to you.

So what are you saying we should just not take time off when we are ill? Feels quite toxic.

HarveyDanger · 25/07/2023 18:27

SnackSizeRaisin · 24/07/2023 22:58

How would you change it though? People are chasing material possessions to the detriment of family and community but I don't think anyone will want to change. Plus times have always been hard, perhaps there was a golden period in the latter half of the 20th century but would you rather live in the 1930s or in the 19th century?

I think people are less resilient nowadays

OneMoreCookieMonster · 25/07/2023 18:26

I think it's simply really. People have stopped giving a shit. There's no resilience, responsibility, accountability and the sense of entitlement is unreal across all age groups. I've come to the conclusion it's not just gen x or z.

How do we fix the problem?

I have no clue and nothing constructive to add there. It would require a huge cultural shift happening again (covid really fucked attitudes towards work and life in general up big time)

It's hard not to fall into the same mindset as your contemporaries.

With stress, poor mental health etc they are hard to prove if a person actually is suffering from them and gps are too quick to write sick notes and sign ppl off. It's also hard for employers to enforce anything for fear of litigation or bad reviews/social media etc

HorseyMel · 25/07/2023 18:20

If it is unsustainable then, by definition, it will stop at some point.

Byllis · 25/07/2023 18:10

Sweetashunni · 25/07/2023 17:10

Because of the Internet.

The things people want are essentially material things in one way or another.

Even if it were as simple as putting everything down to this one cause, which I doubt, I hold the companies that invest huge sums in ensuring their SM platforms are so addictive responsible rather than the manipulated users. This goes more so for young people.

continentallentil · 25/07/2023 17:54

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 14:20

What?

You think people today have to work hard?

Tell that to the children who did 12 hour shifts, six days a week down the mines, or who regularly lost limbs working in textile mills.

The vast majority of people today don't "work hard", they might not like their job, but nobody who works in an office environment "works hard", same for schools, universities, shops, restaurants, you name it. None of it is "hard work", boring perhaps, but not "hard".

You could quit your job and get another if you don't want to do it anymore. The 30% can be someone else's problem.

That's my point, this whole "I'm too stressed to work" thing. Most people who say it don't seem to be able to back it up with anything tangible.

A firefighter who says "My mental health has been affected by the last decade of pulling dead bodies from the wreckage of cars and burnt out buildings" they have a point.

But someone saying "I can't work, my mental health is too fragile from that new admin system they introduced, I'm so stressed", well that just sounds like nonsense in comparison.

I certainly don’t think it’s down the mines hard but when I was younger I did 60 to 70 hour weeks at a desk and on locations for years.

It was quite hard. Always interesting though, never boring. Quite a bit bullying mind you.

Now I am reaping the benefits so no complaints really, and I have never had time off for stress, although I missed endless family and friends events for years and that takes its toll.

Some freelance-y industries are quite brutal still.

Tulips2507 · 25/07/2023 17:53

Unsustainable in terms of the environment/climate change yes.
Unsustainable in terms of life quality/stress then no. We have it way better than in the past but we don't realise it. It's all relative.

Wenfy · 25/07/2023 17:49

My mental health personally has never been better since Covid, but I’ve always made an effort to take care of it just how I take care of my physical health. I go for walks, I make an effort to frequently meet friends and family who make me feel good, I work remotely so am sure to book regular ‘virtual coffees’ with colleagues. I use childcare when I need to, and chase the money in my (meaningful) profession - so I don’t think ambition causes MH issues.

In fact ambition has gotten me out of some horrific workplace situations. At some point you just need to look after yourself and your family and fuck anyone else.

Ginmonkeyagain · 25/07/2023 17:47

Well factoris exsiit still - you could get a job in one of those? Or a meaningful office job? I work in an office job but on regulation that protects vulnerable consumers so feel a lot of satisfaction in what I do.

cleverliterarynamehere · 25/07/2023 17:47

LMNT · 25/07/2023 13:40

Have a read about Economic Degrowth and the movement behind it.

This would transform many people’s lives.

This sounds interesting

continentallentil · 25/07/2023 17:46

It’s a rough time in the UK and the world.

I haven’t had any sick days for a few years personally and can’t think of anyone at work who’s had many.

Miajk · 25/07/2023 17:45

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 14:20

What?

You think people today have to work hard?

Tell that to the children who did 12 hour shifts, six days a week down the mines, or who regularly lost limbs working in textile mills.

The vast majority of people today don't "work hard", they might not like their job, but nobody who works in an office environment "works hard", same for schools, universities, shops, restaurants, you name it. None of it is "hard work", boring perhaps, but not "hard".

You could quit your job and get another if you don't want to do it anymore. The 30% can be someone else's problem.

That's my point, this whole "I'm too stressed to work" thing. Most people who say it don't seem to be able to back it up with anything tangible.

A firefighter who says "My mental health has been affected by the last decade of pulling dead bodies from the wreckage of cars and burnt out buildings" they have a point.

But someone saying "I can't work, my mental health is too fragile from that new admin system they introduced, I'm so stressed", well that just sounds like nonsense in comparison.

I think you're missing a really big piece of the puzzle.

  1. It's different when hard work is a necessity. Working in factories 12 hours a day to improve society, while incredibly hard, had a purpose. Working as a corporate slave to make some people at the top even richer is a miserable way to spend your life. Humans want to feel like they're making a valuable contribution
  2. Were being squeezed for everything and told to be grateful for sick days off or other very basic things. Why? We could all work a bit less if the wealthiest were willing to just give up their obscene bonuses or tax dodging

The kind of stress that comes from having a meaningless job, taking part in stupid 5 stage interviews, working unpaid overtime, graduating with ridiculous debt, just to know for many young people they can only dream of owning a house? It's very different.

I worked 60 hours a week and could barely afford to live. I'd rather work in a factory 12hrs a day back then, when at least that wage could support a family and buy a house for 2x my yearly income, not 12x.

Swipe left for the next trending thread