Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We should get more legal annual leave.

188 replies

Theworried2 · 24/07/2023 20:51

Even though we currently get 5.6 weeks leave as a minimum for full time employees plus weekends, this still means we spend 64% of days in our working lives in work.

Surely to ensure better mental and physical health, this amount should be raised (perhaps closer to the 13 weeks children get at school).
it doesn’t make sense that as soon as you leave education, your free time dramatically reduces.

At the very least, to reduce additional costs for employers, everyone should have a legal minimum weeks (e.g.5 per annum) of unpaid leave if they want it. This shouldn’t just be confined to parents.

if people are properly rested, productivity may rise which could help solve the UK’s productivity puzzle.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
LolaSmiles · 25/07/2023 08:08

Jesus, yeah, I can't see ANY way this couldn't be abused and figures fiddled to get free money!
Given our current government has done sweet eff all about their mates lining their pockets, I find the obsession that your average small business owner and workers are lazy crooks to be laughable.

It reminds me of how quick Jo Public is willing to come on Mumsnet asking if they should report their neighbour for having their boyfriend round too many nights as it might be benefit fraud, but seem not bothered one jot about the amount of taxpayers money that's lining the already huge bank accounts of the well connected.

There's a nasty rush to the bottom in this country when it comes to workers wanting reasonable terms and conditions. The fanatics who wrote Britannia Unchained are probably sitting around laughing as average workers turn on each other doing a pathetic pick me dance on who's the most willing to grovel for crumbs.

Lovetotravel123 · 25/07/2023 08:05

I agree, OP. Because I have a child and want term time only work, the only job open to me is teaching. I have a lot of skills that employers could use but can’t because I need more than 5 weeks’ leave. And before everyone pounces, yes, I have used holiday clubs in the past but that gets harder as the kids get older and I don’t want my child sitting on a screen all day because I am working.

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 08:01

LolaSmiles · 25/07/2023 07:47

But what about small companies, that are not making millions and billions of pounds?
Many many people work in companies with 25 staff or less. They are not making this type of money. You seem to think everyone works for places like BT/virgin/barclays bank or some global conglomerates
Most of the examples being given were about waiting for things in large organisations.

The government could choose to have support available for small businesses. They throw enough money at millionaires every year. I'd have no issues with some of that being redirected to help small businesses with turnover under a certain amount/under a set number of employees instead.

Jesus, yeah, I can't see ANY way this couldn't be abused and figures fiddled to get free money!

"We have the most productive non-working, sat at home on their arses, definitely not working or producing anything, employees in the country.

Bring it on!

Free money for all!

Work? Don't be silly, just sign up to not work for us, you get paid, we get paid, everybody gets paid!
😂

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 07:57

Theworried2 · 24/07/2023 20:51

Even though we currently get 5.6 weeks leave as a minimum for full time employees plus weekends, this still means we spend 64% of days in our working lives in work.

Surely to ensure better mental and physical health, this amount should be raised (perhaps closer to the 13 weeks children get at school).
it doesn’t make sense that as soon as you leave education, your free time dramatically reduces.

At the very least, to reduce additional costs for employers, everyone should have a legal minimum weeks (e.g.5 per annum) of unpaid leave if they want it. This shouldn’t just be confined to parents.

if people are properly rested, productivity may rise which could help solve the UK’s productivity puzzle.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Oh, I love a good laugh in the morning.

Seriously though, work isn't a babysitting service for bored adults who just want someone to bankroll their navel gazing, eco-friendly, sustainable as fuck backpacking trips to the Lake District.

In the nicest way possible OP, you need to grow up.

LolaSmiles · 25/07/2023 07:51

Another alternative to increasing annual leave could be to improve working conditions day to day, ensure better maternity/paternity pay, have a fairer wage for all, ensure that everyone has appropriate sick pay etc and that way quality of life in the workplace would increase.
Then staff departments and organisations properly, unlike what happens at the moment where everything is understaffed, existing workers are doing more than their role, and then getting sick or burning out.

It would probably lead to more productivity, people would feel more rested from their weekends and then there'd not be the need for additional annual leave.

I'm open to a lot of reforms that don't involve average people crawling around for crumbs and fighting against other workers who want appropriate conditions and pay.

LolaSmiles · 25/07/2023 07:47

But what about small companies, that are not making millions and billions of pounds?
Many many people work in companies with 25 staff or less. They are not making this type of money. You seem to think everyone works for places like BT/virgin/barclays bank or some global conglomerates
Most of the examples being given were about waiting for things in large organisations.

The government could choose to have support available for small businesses. They throw enough money at millionaires every year. I'd have no issues with some of that being redirected to help small businesses with turnover under a certain amount/under a set number of employees instead.

Threenow · 25/07/2023 07:46

Tinkerbyebye · 24/07/2023 21:38

Can tell you don’t run a business you have no clue

take your idea of unpaid leave, which by the way most employees won’t be able to afford to take who covers the work? Others in the team do they burn out, or they employ someone extra do an extra cost to the company

we already gave good holiday entitlement

It's nice to see a sensible post! All I'm getting from this thread is that people are wanting to be paid not to work.

Stopthatknocking · 25/07/2023 07:44

LolaSmiles · 25/07/2023 06:33

A lot of objections seem to be based on "but you'd have to wait for..."

The people at the top are making millions of billions of pounds.

The people at the top have chosen not to staff customer service phone lines appropriately because they'd rather line their pockets than employ enough people to get rid of the "we are expecting a higher than usual volume of calls" message. It's a deliberate choice!

If a change to improve working conditions causes a substantial decline in service it's because the greedy people at the top are choosing to continue lining their pockets, not because a HCA, checkout staff, hospitality worker had annual leave.

People need to avoid a rush to the bottom on working conditions, stop workers fighting between themselves and start asking questions of the people at the top.

But what about small companies, that are not making millions and billions of pounds?
Many many people work in companies with 25 staff or less. They are not making this type of money. You seem to think everyone works for places like BT/virgin/barclays bank or some global conglomerates

AvengedQuince · 25/07/2023 07:28

deuxgarcons · 24/07/2023 21:04

We actually do well compared to some countries eg the US where there is no entitlement to paid leave at all but people generally get around 10 days paid depending on the employer. Our legal entitlement is 28 days FTE.

I read that medieval peasants worked 150 days a year. Though, if course their home labour would have been a lot more than today!

GroutScrubberExtraordinaire · 25/07/2023 07:19

Fourth highest?

I've not seen a list that even puts us in the top 10.

Order these by the most and you have to scroll a looong way down to find the UK

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Listoffminimumannuallleavebyy_country

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 07:10

WhatADrabCarpet · 24/07/2023 23:01

A quick google tells me that the UK has the fourth highest amount of annual leave already.

What do you propose OP?
Is it that we create an army of people to take on a couple of weeks work to provide more annual leave for existing employees?

Maybe go part time? But you want the same money though don't you?

Be careful what you wish for! This article focuses on the financial rather than the more lifestyle related reasons people go for part time over full time, but in a society where we already don't have enough workers, if you don't like it cut your hours is, well, maybe a risky approach. I say this as a long term part timer.

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/13/full-time-part-time-work-no-longer-pays-uk-economy

Also, where did you see that we get the 4th highest? Google seems to throw up wildly varying accounts. I think you can get quite different figures depending on whether the question is about legal minimum with bank holidays, legal minimum without and what people actually take on average.

‘It’s just not worth it’: why full-time work no longer pays in the UK

Britain has a shrinking economy and a worker shortage – so why aren’t part-time workers increasing their hours?

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/feb/13/full-time-part-time-work-no-longer-pays-uk-economy

Elvis1956 · 25/07/2023 06:54

Theworried2 · 24/07/2023 22:30

@Elvis1956 Wouldn't more holiday incentivise some recently retired people to come back to the labour force so there wouldn’t be as much of a labour shortage.

also if the leave was unpaid, people would demand fewer goods and services (they have less money) so inflation wouldn’t rise?

As someone who has gone part time at 53 and will be closing down their business at the end of the year ahead 55 no it won't. I have had enough of working.
Productivity will fall in increasing holiday. For example if each year you make one "thing" a day in your factory job and work for 233 days per year (rough guess of 52 weeks,less weekend, bank hols and 4 weeks holiday) you make 233 things....5 more days holiday...228 things. Simplified approach because the real reason why productivity is low is the lack of investment in capital ie the tools, machinery etc to do the job efficiently in the UK.

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 25/07/2023 06:44

I think if conditions improved and cheap flexible childcare was available then that holiday allowance would be enough. FYI a lot of places in Denmark close for 3 weeks in July, so everyone can get their time off. You don't get any choice about when though.

labamba007 · 25/07/2023 06:40

I own a small business, my employees work flexibly and remote. They get 25 days plus bank holidays. I try to do everything I can, but unpaid leave for parents would put me out of business (as odd as it sounds, but work just wouldn't get done). I don't know what the answer is though.

GoodChat · 25/07/2023 06:39

We all know who would be the people to take the fall of the unpaid leave if it was so easily accessible. It would be women, particularly women with children.

LolaSmiles · 25/07/2023 06:33

A lot of objections seem to be based on "but you'd have to wait for..."

The people at the top are making millions of billions of pounds.

The people at the top have chosen not to staff customer service phone lines appropriately because they'd rather line their pockets than employ enough people to get rid of the "we are expecting a higher than usual volume of calls" message. It's a deliberate choice!

If a change to improve working conditions causes a substantial decline in service it's because the greedy people at the top are choosing to continue lining their pockets, not because a HCA, checkout staff, hospitality worker had annual leave.

People need to avoid a rush to the bottom on working conditions, stop workers fighting between themselves and start asking questions of the people at the top.

GroutScrubberExtraordinaire · 25/07/2023 06:31

Otzi · 24/07/2023 22:18

It's really not enough especially as wages haven't gone up in fifteen years. Feels like a fucking treadmill.

Agree with this.

Low wage growth means we're all working a day a week for free by now. I'd rather have a 4 day week than extra holiday days.

Lincslady53 · 25/07/2023 06:20

I was self employed and used to get no more than 1 or 2 weeks holiday a year. As it was in high street retail, our customers expected us to be open 7 days a week. If we closed on a bank holiday we would get complaints. We employed 2 to 3 staff. It was difficult enough with 5 weeks holiday, if it was 13 weeks it would have been impossible to function without employing another member of staff. To afford their pay we would have had to increase our prices, as would every other business, which would lead to prices across the board rising. Some businesses could afford to give this amount of leave. Most couldn't.

Brewskii · 25/07/2023 01:07

monpetitlapin · 24/07/2023 21:04

As someone who doesn't get close to 5.6 weeks (LMAO) I agree we should all get 6-8 weeks to allow for medical appointments (for self and DCs), days when kids are sent home from nursery, days when your car is in the garage and they can't get a part for a day or two, etc.
I have 2 days of AL left and we are not having a holiday, single day off or even staycation this year, it's all gone on crap from the list above, mostly medical appointments.
It would really take the pressure off. If my DCs are sent home from nursery two more times IDK what I'm supposed to do as far as work goes, I'm absolutely screwed, and there are 5 more months left of the year.

If you are in the U.K. then you will get this time off. It’s the legal minimum.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 25/07/2023 00:47

My company allows me to buy extra leave, I just can't afford to do it. I when I did the sums it just wasn't worth it financially for me. I think you'll find that most people are the same, otherwise they'd already be working part time.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/07/2023 00:07

You've got the right to find a part time job, OP.

Allywill · 24/07/2023 23:45

I agree that the 4 day working week would be better. Virtually all studies done on this say that productivity increased and stress levels reduced, however it will take years and years for this to become acceptable. It took roughly a decade for the accepted working week to change from 6 days to 5 however it may be accelerated by the use of AI.

badg3r · 24/07/2023 23:44

I live in a Scandinavian country where the mentality is totally different. We get a lot more leave, people leave work earlier, everyone is legally entitled to three weeks off in a row over summer. Hairdressers, some shops, cafes etc in many areas shut for a month or so over summer. Even the vending machines at work are not stocked in July! And if kids are sick there is a special different sort of leave you can take called "looking after children" which is on an as need basis and in addition to the generous parental leave. This summer most in our team took five weeks or more off in a row, a mixture of holiday and parental leave, both men and women. It is normal here - and seems to work fine, although I don't understand how!

Sunshinesally78 · 24/07/2023 23:30

I get 7 weeks, plus BHs and the days between Xmas and NY, personally I think that's alot and I struggle to use it all, certainly not complaining but working in a small, specialist team means someone is usually on leave, so the working day is filled with covering my own work and a portion of someone else's. My standard work day is 7.5 hour but it's realistically 8/8.5. I was on leave last week and went in twice to catch up on stuff. I didn't have to but it would only then add to my list when I got back