Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We should get more legal annual leave.

188 replies

Theworried2 · 24/07/2023 20:51

Even though we currently get 5.6 weeks leave as a minimum for full time employees plus weekends, this still means we spend 64% of days in our working lives in work.

Surely to ensure better mental and physical health, this amount should be raised (perhaps closer to the 13 weeks children get at school).
it doesn’t make sense that as soon as you leave education, your free time dramatically reduces.

At the very least, to reduce additional costs for employers, everyone should have a legal minimum weeks (e.g.5 per annum) of unpaid leave if they want it. This shouldn’t just be confined to parents.

if people are properly rested, productivity may rise which could help solve the UK’s productivity puzzle.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 13:08

@PaperSheet I get you, I've worked in the NHS and done night shifts etc
I'm frustrated because one of the medications they want me now to have my bloods done the week before exactly
But there is no solution as to how I can have this done. No annual leave left as I've used it all for hospital appointments

PaperSheet · 25/07/2023 13:05

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 12:59

@MPY24 I work hours I don't want to, including weekends and from 8am - 7pm
Maybe some would be happy to do a later shift or an earlier one, once a week. If they were open until 5pm I could get there

There's no solution, and if I can't have my bloods done, I can't have my medication
9-3 isn't suitable for anyone that works FT and has chronic illnesses

I actually agree with you that clinics etc should find ways to be open more suitable hours for working people. I'm more just pointing out to the people that think every job should be fully flexible with weeks and weeks of holidays/unpaid leave should be the norm and would work fine.
Not many people want to work unsociable hours. They do it yes because they know its part of the job, but too many people these days seem to think the hours they work should be optional. Claiming its not good for work/life balance. Which may well be true. But SOME ONE needs to do these jobs. Someone needs to be working until 8pm in the blood place. But "not them as they have kids".

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 12:59

@MPY24 I work hours I don't want to, including weekends and from 8am - 7pm
Maybe some would be happy to do a later shift or an earlier one, once a week. If they were open until 5pm I could get there

There's no solution, and if I can't have my bloods done, I can't have my medication
9-3 isn't suitable for anyone that works FT and has chronic illnesses

MPY24 · 25/07/2023 12:55

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 12:48

I just wish blood clinics would do one late night or a weekend
I have bloods every 12 weeks for one issue, and every 8 weeks for another. Clinics are 9-3 weekdays and none on a Friday afternoon
The hospital aren't happy when I don't have them done but if I've run out of annual leave I'm stuck!

And this is where problems start arising. People want their nice office jobs to be more flexible and for people to work less but they want appointments and activities to be available more often. What if all the blood staff only want to work flexibly and in term time only? What if they can only open 2 days a week as all the staff are on holiday during August with the kids.
Years ago I used to work in an Orthodontic Clinic. NHS so mainly kids. We were open until 8pm 3 nights and week and Saturday mornings. We would still have parents complaining that we weren't flexible enough because "their child had school and also had after school clubs they couldn't miss". Unfortunately some people have to work hours they don't want to. It's just life. Not every business can give their staff total control over their hours and holidays.

Bonfire23 · 25/07/2023 12:48

I just wish blood clinics would do one late night or a weekend
I have bloods every 12 weeks for one issue, and every 8 weeks for another. Clinics are 9-3 weekdays and none on a Friday afternoon
The hospital aren't happy when I don't have them done but if I've run out of annual leave I'm stuck!

MidnightMeltdown · 25/07/2023 12:47

The fact of the matter is that most people's pay relates to 35 hours pw for about 45 weeks worked.

@RosesAndHellebores

Does it? My contracted hours are 37.5 hours a week. I thought that was the norm. 35 seems low.

I get 30 days annual leave plus bank holidays. It definitely doesn't feel like enough.

Brits work the longest hours in Europe.

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 12:31

Your calculations are wrong. It's not 28 days minimum, for starters. It's 20. Employers don't have to grant bank holidays as extra, and some don't. You've also left out commuting, which for many workers is unavoidable and a significant time sink.

Really though, telling people they just need to change their mindset and work will seem like it takes up less of their time is ludicrous. Full time jobs mean most people can't do much other than the job and associated activities on the days they're working, and the majority of their days are working days. Shockingly enough, they've noticed. The solution to this isn't spending less time on our phones. People are voting with their feet.

akkakk · 25/07/2023 10:46

it is worth considering the history - if we go back 50+ years, generally speaking there was a pattern of woman at home and man out to work and most people above a certain age in marriages - now obviously ignoring the sex based bias in that and the often tricky natures of some of those marriages - the advantage it brought was the different balance in time at work.

365 days x 24 hours = 8,760 hours in a year
28 days off minimum + 104 weekend days = working 233 days p/a max.
233 days x 8 hours = 1,864 hours worked of 8,760 i.e. an 8 hour day means that someone works for 21% of the year = c. 1/5th of the year at work and 4/5 of the year not at work (in which to sleep / commute / go on holiday / etc.)

8 hours sleep per night = 365 x 8 = 2,920 = 5,840 waking hours a year.
therefore work is 32% of waking hours or c. 1/3

so straight away there is a challenge there that only spending 1/5th of your life at work doesn't seem al that high... even 1/3 of waking hours doesn't seem all that high either.

however, when couples 50 years ago were one at work and one at home, instead of 1/3 of the couple's time effectively it was 1/6th of the couple's time involved that work (housework and children existed both then and now).

So, working patterns have had a large effect - however we have a society driven by the need for two to work (housing prices largely driving that), and we also have a more fragmented society with many more couples split up / single people not marrying etc. leading to a higher % of single people making it even more challenging.

So, what are the options?

  • the OP suggests that some magic money fund simply pays people the same and allows them to work a lot less - not practical and will never happen.
  • a correction in the housing market could help - but rising population numbers / increased split households / house purchases from abroad (e.g. London) / other reasons mean this is unlikely
  • people look at how they spend their time

with today's set up (and acknowledging that it is not identical for everyone) work is still only 1/3 of waking hours - so if that seems like a huge burden and an enormous amount of time - then what are those same people doing with the 2x that amount of time which is free and available?

back in 2021 Ofcom reported that on average UK adults were spending c. 1/3 of their waking hours on TV and streaming and social media etc. (https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-58086629) If so, then that is 50% of their free time. If you consider that time with children / housework / sorting out bills / all the odds and ends jobs take up quite a bit of time - it is hardly surprising that people feel they don't have enough time...

so, it would seem that the easiest way to fix this is not to invent magic sources of money and kill the economy (typical - it is someone' else's responsibility approach!) but instead, audit our own time - perhaps drop that 1/3 of our life which is TV / internet and use that time for things which are more healthy - exercise / hobbies / reading / playing games / time with friends and family / nice meals with a good bottle of wine - that sort of thing!

take ownership of your own time - a full time job is a minor part of the hours available to ourselves, so we really have no justification for complaining in this society - esp. when on average we throw away the same amount of time again on watching cats on a screen!

Stock image of a woman watching TV

Nearly a third of waking hours spent on TV and streaming, Ofcom says

Older people have been watching more linear TV while on-demand is a big hit with younger audiences.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-58086629

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/07/2023 10:10

I'm one of few people in my team without kids and I haven't once been able to take all of my leave because the parents use all their annual leave and then unpaid parental leave, and we still need someone in doing the work. Big public sector organisation.

I'd welcome this in theory as long as in practice it didn't just end up with some people covering even more of the work because their colleagues need the leave more.

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 10:09

Bank Holidays are pretty unfair, no getting round it.

ErrolTheDragon · 25/07/2023 10:04

I'd like to do away with some of the bank holidays and choose when to take time off myself.

That one is useful - the rest of my team is in the US so they're happy for me to take different days in lieu of the BHs. It's especially handy where we live as the roads get somjammed on them it's best to stay at home.

It won't be possible for all jobs but for some it may be worth asking about.

gingerguineapig · 25/07/2023 09:58

I don't think I need more leave personally but my employer does allow people to "buy" more leave so if you've got kids or eg elder care responsibilities or a hobby you want to devote more time to you can take the financial hit and get another week's leave (I think that's the max though)

I'd like to do away with some of the bank holidays and choose when to take time off myself.

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 09:36

It's probably quite telling that sectors with the least flexibility are mostly suffering from real staff shortages at the moment. People vote with their feet. The current model isn't working too well, we know that much.

PaperSheet · 25/07/2023 08:59

In these threads people only ever consider office type workers. Retail/ medical/hospitality etc are never thought about because it quite frankly wouldn't work. You can't have hospitality or medical staff all choosing their own flexible working hours. Taking 6 weeks off over the summer etc. I work in medical and I already get patients complaining at me if I dare take a week off that coincides with school holidays as that's when they wanted their child to attend to see me. Basically everyone wants their job to be flexible, but all other jobs available to suit them. "I want to take the whole school holidays off. But I want all activities, restaurants, medical things open throughout so I can go with my family."

Schmoana · 25/07/2023 08:53

the 4 dayweek would be less hours, not cramming in the current 9to 5. Companies have trialed it and found productivity doesn’t fall, people are healthier and aren’t off sick with stress so much etc

mastertomsmum · 25/07/2023 08:51

We used to be allowed to work evening invigilating shifts in return for leave. I work in an academic library and you could take leave or pay. However, one of the management team figured out how many hours the institution was ‘losing’ in terms of day job work. They capped how many invigilations per week were permitted and said it could only be for pay. That’s pay at the invigilation rate. So they then had trouble getting the evening roles that needed more experience filled and made one evening shift per fortnight compulsory for new roles.

GoodChat · 25/07/2023 08:44

Schmoana · 25/07/2023 08:15

One of Jeremy corbyns policies was for a standard 4 day working week. That was a good idea. He was thinking of the impacts of robotics and AI as well as health and well-being.

I'd rather work a 5 day week than work 4 long days.

DodoOnHoliday · 25/07/2023 08:39

@Oakbeam - yes, I can’t see that employers will resist the temptation to just cut jobs. However, our professional bodies and leaders are ‘selling’ this to us and to our employers with the spiel about freeing up time to add value in other ways. And, actually, in the short term that does seem to be happening.

Conspicuously absent from the discussion is any hint that the work lives of actual employees may be improved.

theemmadilemma · 25/07/2023 08:38

I think it's enough. It's substantially more than many US companies give.

The other piece is work/life balance, flexibility and supporting your staff. I'm lucky enough to work for a company of mainly remote employees (globally) with a big focus on the above. I can send my guys take out, give them extra days, all number of ways to make life a little easier and better. It counts for a lot.

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 08:33

It’s funny that we keep talking about four-day weeks and similar schemes while in reality hours are longer than ever. There was a thread the other day about how 9-5 has become 9-5:30 or 6. I recently changed jobs myself and my new contracted hours are half a day more a week than with my previous employer.

Meanwhile, more people are working part time instead. Worth thinking about whether there are any dots to be joined here!

Oakbeam · 25/07/2023 08:24

In my own profession talk about AI and other aids is all about letting them do the routine work while we add value in other ways when it could be about cutting out the routine work, leaving the more interesting stuff roughly as it is and enjoying shorter weeks.

Or fewer people.

DodoOnHoliday · 25/07/2023 08:22

sparklelikeadiamond · 24/07/2023 21:07

I would like to see fewer hours per week as the norm.

It’s funny that we keep talking about four-day weeks and similar schemes while in reality hours are longer than ever. There was a thread the other day about how 9-5 has become 9-5:30 or 6. I recently changed jobs myself and my new contracted hours are half a day more a week than with my previous employer.

Not that it makes any difference because I worked in excess of the new hours at the previous place anyway.

I’d like to see shorter hours and more creative flexible working, but in order for that to happen employers en masse would have to allow employees to benefit from labour-saving technology rather than employing fewer people or loading on other tasks. In my own profession talk about AI and other aids is all about letting them do the routine work while we add value in other ways when it could be about cutting out the routine work, leaving the more interesting stuff roughly as it is and enjoying shorter weeks.

honeypancake · 25/07/2023 08:17

If employees' productivity and mental health increases as a result, then it surely won't be that bad for businesses to increase annual leave time

Schmoana · 25/07/2023 08:15

One of Jeremy corbyns policies was for a standard 4 day working week. That was a good idea. He was thinking of the impacts of robotics and AI as well as health and well-being.

CatsOnTheChair · 25/07/2023 08:11

There are already posts on MN about people not being able to get leave when they want it. If people had more leave, the chances of all parents, plus partners of teaches, others who want time off round Xmas/Easter/summer holidays getting it would be slim.
Lovely as it sounds, I think it would cause chaos and resentment - and I say that as a wife of someone whose DH was told he could "never have Xmas off as Y took it off every year to fly home and see his family". That policy changed when it was pointed out DH would like to spend Xmas day with his family once in a while. Noone else in office celebrated Xmas, so noone else was bothered.

Swipe left for the next trending thread