Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We should get more legal annual leave.

188 replies

Theworried2 · 24/07/2023 20:51

Even though we currently get 5.6 weeks leave as a minimum for full time employees plus weekends, this still means we spend 64% of days in our working lives in work.

Surely to ensure better mental and physical health, this amount should be raised (perhaps closer to the 13 weeks children get at school).
it doesn’t make sense that as soon as you leave education, your free time dramatically reduces.

At the very least, to reduce additional costs for employers, everyone should have a legal minimum weeks (e.g.5 per annum) of unpaid leave if they want it. This shouldn’t just be confined to parents.

if people are properly rested, productivity may rise which could help solve the UK’s productivity puzzle.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
StormShadow · 25/07/2023 19:00

akkakk · 25/07/2023 18:17

It might not be based on evidence of productivity, but the structure of the economy is a delicate balance and it includes expectations of salaries and hours worked - tied into that is everything else including house prices commodity prices etc - tied in several ways from how much it costs to employ labour to make the commodity to how much a business believes they can charge based on levels of spare cash…

you can’t simply change one aspect without massively affecting all others and simply giving everyone more holiday (or doing less work for the same money / getting a pay rise - all the same economically) will simply push inflation even higher…

I have no disagreement that how it is structured now is not ideal, but it is naive to believe as per the OP that you can simply allow everyone to work less and it will some how magically balance out the same…

and as to my calculations- unless you can show where the maths is wrong, we have no choice but to accept that <1/3 of waking hours is work - so each person could indeed benefit from asking the question as to where they spend the rest of their time - and if c. 1/3 of time on average goes on social media and tv / streaming there is a big answer… for those who want more free time maybe they need to start by looking at where they are spending their time now and taking responsibility for it - yes of course there are edge cases where there are challenges but not for the vast majority of the work force…

In terms of the one third, the problem you have there is getting people to attach any importance to the way you've chosen to present the issue.

If people feel they're working too much and have options, as many do, they absolutely do have a choice to instead frame their thinking another way. Such as how they have to spend most of their time on most of their working days. They don't have to decide they're going to spend less time on the internet rather than less time working or in work related activity, just because you reckon they need to.

I don't think OPs suggestion is necessarily the answer either fwiw, nothing that oversimplified is. But we certainly won't find it by dismissing the lack of evidence regarding productivity as you do here. That actually matters a lot. You talk about things not magically balancing, but that's essentially what we expect to do now. Shockingly enough, it's not working. Yet we continue not only to go in blind, but to pretend we can carry on doing so.

akkakk · 25/07/2023 18:17

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 18:04

Your personal takes on how our working conditions can be described aren't accurate information. If you want a discussion based on facts, that's undermined by making subjective opinions such a central part of your posts.

In the UK, we do indeed have low productivity, and we also don't have enough workers. It doesn't follow that people 'need' to behave in a way that might benefit wider society, even if we could all agree on what that might be. Nor does it matter that you think assessing work as a percentage of

Work frequently doesn't pay, or doesn't pay enough for an individual to feel it justifies the effort. In some cases, ie if the person gets a lot of their income from top up benefits, there's a stick that can be applied, but quite often there simply isn't. The relevance of wfh here isn't whether either of us think it's a good thing or not (like you, I'm an advocate) but the fact that it's a subject where posters often wrongly think their opinion on the choices others make about their work is somehow of importance.

We face big problems at the moment, on that we agree. It's going to take a lot more than telling people to reframe their mindset and work harder to deal with them. And the fact is that the working hours and patterns we have now don't exist because of any evidence basis that this is how we're most productive. People just assume. There's so much more to it than that.

It might not be based on evidence of productivity, but the structure of the economy is a delicate balance and it includes expectations of salaries and hours worked - tied into that is everything else including house prices commodity prices etc - tied in several ways from how much it costs to employ labour to make the commodity to how much a business believes they can charge based on levels of spare cash…

you can’t simply change one aspect without massively affecting all others and simply giving everyone more holiday (or doing less work for the same money / getting a pay rise - all the same economically) will simply push inflation even higher…

I have no disagreement that how it is structured now is not ideal, but it is naive to believe as per the OP that you can simply allow everyone to work less and it will some how magically balance out the same…

and as to my calculations- unless you can show where the maths is wrong, we have no choice but to accept that <1/3 of waking hours is work - so each person could indeed benefit from asking the question as to where they spend the rest of their time - and if c. 1/3 of time on average goes on social media and tv / streaming there is a big answer… for those who want more free time maybe they need to start by looking at where they are spending their time now and taking responsibility for it - yes of course there are edge cases where there are challenges but not for the vast majority of the work force…

UsingChangeofName · 25/07/2023 18:17

LolaSmiles · 25/07/2023 07:47

But what about small companies, that are not making millions and billions of pounds?
Many many people work in companies with 25 staff or less. They are not making this type of money. You seem to think everyone works for places like BT/virgin/barclays bank or some global conglomerates
Most of the examples being given were about waiting for things in large organisations.

The government could choose to have support available for small businesses. They throw enough money at millionaires every year. I'd have no issues with some of that being redirected to help small businesses with turnover under a certain amount/under a set number of employees instead.

This Government (and quite frankly, every Government in living memory, not just this one) won't even fund a basic level of staff in places they are supposed to fund (Ambulance service, A&E, Social Care, schools, prisons, courts, CAMHS and adult mental health services, police, etc etc etc).

They are hardly going to start paying out to replace people who are not at work due to this extra annual leave, even in the services they are responsible for, so to suggest any Gvmnt is going to subsidise businesses so their employees can take more holiday, is laughable.

UsingChangeofName · 25/07/2023 18:13

PaperSheet · 25/07/2023 08:59

In these threads people only ever consider office type workers. Retail/ medical/hospitality etc are never thought about because it quite frankly wouldn't work. You can't have hospitality or medical staff all choosing their own flexible working hours. Taking 6 weeks off over the summer etc. I work in medical and I already get patients complaining at me if I dare take a week off that coincides with school holidays as that's when they wanted their child to attend to see me. Basically everyone wants their job to be flexible, but all other jobs available to suit them. "I want to take the whole school holidays off. But I want all activities, restaurants, medical things open throughout so I can go with my family."

Exactly.
It seems to be " I want time off, so I can go and do.....X", without really thinking through who is staffing X

luckylavender · 25/07/2023 18:12

Theworried2 · 24/07/2023 20:51

Even though we currently get 5.6 weeks leave as a minimum for full time employees plus weekends, this still means we spend 64% of days in our working lives in work.

Surely to ensure better mental and physical health, this amount should be raised (perhaps closer to the 13 weeks children get at school).
it doesn’t make sense that as soon as you leave education, your free time dramatically reduces.

At the very least, to reduce additional costs for employers, everyone should have a legal minimum weeks (e.g.5 per annum) of unpaid leave if they want it. This shouldn’t just be confined to parents.

if people are properly rested, productivity may rise which could help solve the UK’s productivity puzzle.

Totally ridiculous. We really are becoming totally workshy

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 18:04

akkakk · 25/07/2023 17:51

I have no particular stake in the game - you are welcome to be a capitalist cog or a free spirit - really doesn’t bother me, but we need to at least have a discussion framed around accurate information :)

the OP posited the concept that implied we were working for 60%+ of our lives conveniently ignoring the weekends and that even when we are working it is a minority of our day

as my figures show we actually work c. 1/5 of our year and only c. 1/3 of waking hours - so what exactly is taking place in the vast majority of our waking hours that means we have no spare time - clearly not work as that is only 1/3

and yes work is hard - that is why we do it for payment and it is why we have weekends and holidays to recuperate…

as a society whether capitalist or communist / socialist - if you want a strong economy (which allows us to support a welfare state and be compassionate to those who are less fortunate) then it needs a society of people who put in the effort, not shirkers who want someone else to always take responsibility / want everything for nothing and someone else can pay… I think there is a degree of needing to tell certain parts of society to grow up and realise that life is not always easy, it is not laid out on a plate for you and you have to work to gain…

no apologies for that - nothing to do with any type of politics - pure simple economics. Covid has not helped, the number of people who were paid to have a long holiday seems to have transformed society into expecting that to continue - it can’t - it was paid for by magic money that was created by the government and which we now need to pay back into the economy…

wfh is great - I have been an advocate for over 20 years and have been doing it that long, but it doesn’t work for every company and it does cause issues - there is also a mixture of approaches from those who undoubtedly are more productive to those who spend more time walking the dog and ignoring the job they are paid to do - there are also many other reasons why it can help to have people in an office either more often or permanently…

we have fantastic working conditions in the UK, so the concept that people should work less and some magic fairy will pay for it is basically nonsense, yes every job is different and there is always room for discussion but no-one is entitled to lots of money and a reducing commitment ;)

Your personal takes on how our working conditions can be described aren't accurate information. If you want a discussion based on facts, that's undermined by making subjective opinions such a central part of your posts.

In the UK, we do indeed have low productivity, and we also don't have enough workers. It doesn't follow that people 'need' to behave in a way that might benefit wider society, even if we could all agree on what that might be. Nor does it matter that you think assessing work as a percentage of

Work frequently doesn't pay, or doesn't pay enough for an individual to feel it justifies the effort. In some cases, ie if the person gets a lot of their income from top up benefits, there's a stick that can be applied, but quite often there simply isn't. The relevance of wfh here isn't whether either of us think it's a good thing or not (like you, I'm an advocate) but the fact that it's a subject where posters often wrongly think their opinion on the choices others make about their work is somehow of importance.

We face big problems at the moment, on that we agree. It's going to take a lot more than telling people to reframe their mindset and work harder to deal with them. And the fact is that the working hours and patterns we have now don't exist because of any evidence basis that this is how we're most productive. People just assume. There's so much more to it than that.

akkakk · 25/07/2023 17:51

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 17:35

You and @BodegaSushi right, I've checked. Apologies. It was still a ridiculous argument though, and the fact that you left commuting time out makes it even weaker.

Full time workers are, aside from a few who do a smaller number of longer shifts or other unusual patterns, having to spend the majority of their days in a way that doesn't allow them to do much else other than work. You don't reframe that by spending less time on your phone. The whole post reeked of telling people they just need to change their attitude a bit so they can be more compliant cogs in the capitalist machine.

People also quite clearly do not 'need' to change their mindset. What you mean here is that you would find it convenient for them to do so. It's exactly the same as when posters who don't like wfh say that people need to get back into the office. Nope! People can and do vote with their feet.

Rather than comparing their position to medieval peasants (who did at least get quite a lot of feasting days!) they instead reduce hours, quiet quit, retire early and do all kind of things that don't involve giving themselves a little pep talk so they can carry on not being disruptive. The status quo is quite clearly not working, and no amount of platitudes will change that.

I have no particular stake in the game - you are welcome to be a capitalist cog or a free spirit - really doesn’t bother me, but we need to at least have a discussion framed around accurate information :)

the OP posited the concept that implied we were working for 60%+ of our lives conveniently ignoring the weekends and that even when we are working it is a minority of our day

as my figures show we actually work c. 1/5 of our year and only c. 1/3 of waking hours - so what exactly is taking place in the vast majority of our waking hours that means we have no spare time - clearly not work as that is only 1/3

and yes work is hard - that is why we do it for payment and it is why we have weekends and holidays to recuperate…

as a society whether capitalist or communist / socialist - if you want a strong economy (which allows us to support a welfare state and be compassionate to those who are less fortunate) then it needs a society of people who put in the effort, not shirkers who want someone else to always take responsibility / want everything for nothing and someone else can pay… I think there is a degree of needing to tell certain parts of society to grow up and realise that life is not always easy, it is not laid out on a plate for you and you have to work to gain…

no apologies for that - nothing to do with any type of politics - pure simple economics. Covid has not helped, the number of people who were paid to have a long holiday seems to have transformed society into expecting that to continue - it can’t - it was paid for by magic money that was created by the government and which we now need to pay back into the economy…

wfh is great - I have been an advocate for over 20 years and have been doing it that long, but it doesn’t work for every company and it does cause issues - there is also a mixture of approaches from those who undoubtedly are more productive to those who spend more time walking the dog and ignoring the job they are paid to do - there are also many other reasons why it can help to have people in an office either more often or permanently…

we have fantastic working conditions in the UK, so the concept that people should work less and some magic fairy will pay for it is basically nonsense, yes every job is different and there is always room for discussion but no-one is entitled to lots of money and a reducing commitment ;)

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 17:39

liondreams · 25/07/2023 17:37

I do think better rested people are more productive. A bit like the four day workweek has been massively successful even proving increasing productivity. So yes OP I agree!

It is quite interesting how many people on the thread have blithely assumed that more hours is more productivity and fewer hours is less productivity. That's a massive generalisation. It really depends. And we know some workers have cut their hours specifically because of the demands placed on them.

liondreams · 25/07/2023 17:37

I do think better rested people are more productive. A bit like the four day workweek has been massively successful even proving increasing productivity. So yes OP I agree!

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 17:35

akkakk · 25/07/2023 14:29

sorry - you are wrong:
https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights
28 days minimum - though you are correct they don't have to include bank holidays... still needs to be 28 days minimum though (very few exceptions to that)

and yes, people do need to change their mindset, we have a country where increasingly it would appear that people do not wish to work, but still wish to get paid - quite how that builds an economy I don't know. The reality is that 1/3 of waking time working is small - just be thank that you weren't around in medieval times ;) and yes, of course commuting takes up some time - but again, a lot of people do have a choice as to where they live and how long they commute - the point is we all have choices, but wanting it all without having to work for it is not a viable choice!

You and @BodegaSushi right, I've checked. Apologies. It was still a ridiculous argument though, and the fact that you left commuting time out makes it even weaker.

Full time workers are, aside from a few who do a smaller number of longer shifts or other unusual patterns, having to spend the majority of their days in a way that doesn't allow them to do much else other than work. You don't reframe that by spending less time on your phone. The whole post reeked of telling people they just need to change their attitude a bit so they can be more compliant cogs in the capitalist machine.

People also quite clearly do not 'need' to change their mindset. What you mean here is that you would find it convenient for them to do so. It's exactly the same as when posters who don't like wfh say that people need to get back into the office. Nope! People can and do vote with their feet.

Rather than comparing their position to medieval peasants (who did at least get quite a lot of feasting days!) they instead reduce hours, quiet quit, retire early and do all kind of things that don't involve giving themselves a little pep talk so they can carry on not being disruptive. The status quo is quite clearly not working, and no amount of platitudes will change that.

BodegaSushi · 25/07/2023 17:16

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 12:31

Your calculations are wrong. It's not 28 days minimum, for starters. It's 20. Employers don't have to grant bank holidays as extra, and some don't. You've also left out commuting, which for many workers is unavoidable and a significant time sink.

Really though, telling people they just need to change their mindset and work will seem like it takes up less of their time is ludicrous. Full time jobs mean most people can't do much other than the job and associated activities on the days they're working, and the majority of their days are working days. Shockingly enough, they've noticed. The solution to this isn't spending less time on our phones. People are voting with their feet.

Oh dear, I hope you haven't been cheating yourself out of holidays for years. Statutory minimum is 5.6 weeks. If you work 5 days, that's 28 days. Employers can take BH from that entitlement, where you get them off as part of the 28 days. Some employers included it as extra.

Depending on the industry you work in, you may even be required to work BH, but you get another day instead. If you work a 5 day week, you have to have 28 days at a minimum, it's a legal requirement.

CashmereDarling · 25/07/2023 17:14

I did 4 days a week for a while and it was perfect. 52 Fridays off a year!
I could definitely live with that on a permanent basis.

BasiliskStare · 25/07/2023 17:07

I think 20 - 25 days plus Bank Holidays is fine. Some companies as people have said could not operate properly with more weeks ( even if unpaid. ) Work has to be covered.

Try working in the US

BodegaSushi · 25/07/2023 17:03

WhatADrabCarpet · 24/07/2023 23:01

A quick google tells me that the UK has the fourth highest amount of annual leave already.

What do you propose OP?
Is it that we create an army of people to take on a couple of weeks work to provide more annual leave for existing employees?

Maybe go part time? But you want the same money though don't you?

Who's got the highest? Why can't we aim for that? Grin

Pablacass · 25/07/2023 16:55

Blimey you wouldn't want to be self employed. You can have as much time off as you want but you don't get paid. It focussed the mind!

I think you're being totally unrealistic.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/07/2023 16:39

@mayorofcasterbridge They do try but keep getting threatened with people going to HR and calling in sick instead (both of which have happened in the past). It's fair to say that they could try harder but I also see how it's easier for them to promote the desirable family friendly narrative if they let the parents have first dibs.

mayorofcasterbridge · 25/07/2023 16:18

fitzwilliamdarcy · 25/07/2023 10:10

I'm one of few people in my team without kids and I haven't once been able to take all of my leave because the parents use all their annual leave and then unpaid parental leave, and we still need someone in doing the work. Big public sector organisation.

I'd welcome this in theory as long as in practice it didn't just end up with some people covering even more of the work because their colleagues need the leave more.

Your manager needs to deal with that - it should be fair.

We get 31 days, plus SHs and an extra day at Christmas. We can always work up flexitime (though it was taken from us for 3 years since Covid and I really missed it!)

Now as I am getting older, I tend to think about how much of my life has been and is being, spent working! I was also able to do 'family friendly' for a few years where I took a month off in the summer and the deduction from my salary was taken out monthly. Could have taken two months but we could cover the rest with annual leave.

I think I'd prefer a 4 day week than more bank holidays.

PartingGift · 25/07/2023 16:09

This is why I went part time. Extra day of freedom every week. Wish I'd done it years ago.

DodoOnHoliday · 25/07/2023 16:08

Katieweasel · 25/07/2023 13:54

I manage a team of 10. We all have been at the company a long time so we all get 32 days plus bank holidays. We also all buy an additional 5 days a year as well. So that works out as 45 days each! It's almost a full time job managing the holiday calendar as it is!

That’s very much on the generous side at present though. When I was looking for a new job I considered the acceptable leave box ticked with either 25 plus ability to purchase extra OR 25 increasing with service. In each case topping out at 30 days. I never saw both and I never saw anything that would allow me to get to over 30 plus BHs overall.

I think your entitlement would already make a huge difference to most of us!

GroutScrubberExtraordinaire · 25/07/2023 15:46

it is a reduction from a standard working week of 40 hours, to 35 hours. We already have this in many roles

Genuinely, do we? I was on a thread a couple of weeks back in which people were talking about how they never really saw 35 hour weeks anymore (except maybe the civil service?). Certainly, all my roles have been 37.5-40 hours - in IT.

35 hours over 4 days is just shy of 9 hours a day. That would be lovely! Grin

KnittedCardi · 25/07/2023 14:32

Looking around, in the countries where this is being trialled, it is a reduction from a standard working week of 40 hours, to 35 hours. We already have this in many roles. This can be spread out or compressed, but it doesn't necessarily mean more days off, just more flexibility.

akkakk · 25/07/2023 14:29

StormShadow · 25/07/2023 12:31

Your calculations are wrong. It's not 28 days minimum, for starters. It's 20. Employers don't have to grant bank holidays as extra, and some don't. You've also left out commuting, which for many workers is unavoidable and a significant time sink.

Really though, telling people they just need to change their mindset and work will seem like it takes up less of their time is ludicrous. Full time jobs mean most people can't do much other than the job and associated activities on the days they're working, and the majority of their days are working days. Shockingly enough, they've noticed. The solution to this isn't spending less time on our phones. People are voting with their feet.

sorry - you are wrong:
https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights
28 days minimum - though you are correct they don't have to include bank holidays... still needs to be 28 days minimum though (very few exceptions to that)

and yes, people do need to change their mindset, we have a country where increasingly it would appear that people do not wish to work, but still wish to get paid - quite how that builds an economy I don't know. The reality is that 1/3 of waking time working is small - just be thank that you weren't around in medieval times ;) and yes, of course commuting takes up some time - but again, a lot of people do have a choice as to where they live and how long they commute - the point is we all have choices, but wanting it all without having to work for it is not a viable choice!

Holiday entitlement

Holiday entitlement or annual leave - information for employers and workers on entitlement, calculating leave, taking leave, accruing leave and disputes

https://www.gov.uk/holiday-entitlement-rights

LlynTegid · 25/07/2023 13:58

I think we should be looking more at common time when as many people are not working.

I'd start with closing shops on Christmas Day, Boxing Day and New Year's Day.

Katieweasel · 25/07/2023 13:54

I manage a team of 10. We all have been at the company a long time so we all get 32 days plus bank holidays. We also all buy an additional 5 days a year as well. So that works out as 45 days each! It's almost a full time job managing the holiday calendar as it is!

RosesAndHellebores · 25/07/2023 13:26

@MidnightMeltdown it depends on the contract. Our admins are 35, supervisors up 35 to 40, senior staff as required.

I don't think I've ever worked 9-5 in 40 years of working.

I do think the NHS is unbelievably inflexible regarding the needs of working people. If I need an appointment at my convenience, I have to pay for it. My consultant works privately between 6 and 7.30 and so do the nurses at the private hospitals so they can and do and it's clearly what people need and want. If that weren't the case, they'd hold their NHS clinics from 5 to 7.30 and their private patients would be willing to pay between 9am and noon, and presumably be kept waiting for nearly two hours due to late clinics.