Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Move school terms to allow spring/autumn holidays?

114 replies

MrsRobinsonsHandprints · 24/07/2023 20:27

Sky news have just had a report about the fires in Greece where two commentators, who were in the travel industry, argued that British school holidays need to be changed/broken up so that people could holiday in the spring and autumn when the climate was more temperate, and that travel in the summer months should be scaled back. They touched on the fact that school summer holidays were set due to farming and that Greece needed tourism.

Interested on your thoughts on this exact issue, changing holiday dates.

Whilst there are no thread police this is a forum to talk about ideas/flights of fancy. Yes we all know that some people think holidays are the devil, that think berating people is the answer to climate change, but actually talking about other things is also OK, so please froth elsewhere.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Shinyandnew1 · 25/07/2023 12:54

because there is no real consensus about on what would be a better alternative

I think this is the case in England as well-too many people want different alternatives so it won’t be changing any time soon!

Bunnycat101 · 25/07/2023 12:24

I had a look at the Welsh consultation and wouldn’t fancy any of the alternative options. It’s probably why they haven’t been changed because there is no real consensus about on what would be a better alternative.

It seems like the kids make the most progress in the autumn term so wouldn’t necessarily want to shift that. At primary level I’d quite like 2 weeks in May/June but appreciate that doesn’t work for secondary. There also tend to be many more camps at summer and Easter as I guess it’s more financially viable so there is a risk that by spreading holidays you actually reduce childcare provision.

BogRollBOGOF · 25/07/2023 09:30

My two are currently spread across two LAs. The secondary has a more even spread of holiday across the half terms. The primary is the more traditional pattern. The downside to me at present is needing to be around for 3 weeks at Christmas, 2 in Feb, 2 in April, 1 in May, 7 in Jul-Sept, 2 in Oct as the max spread of both sets as their timings are a bit out of synch.

I prefer the spread of the secondary, and the more consistent dates work better for autistic DS1. He gets more time to relax through the year. He often finds that a week isn't enough to unclench before school looms again.His summer is a little shorter, but that works as he's not the type to fill it with action packed adventure anyway.

DH is not a heat seeker so we've dabbled with a few Oct/ Apr holidays over the years and they are the dregs of the tourist season as its cranking into action/ winding down. I've sat on gorgous sunny beaches in my coat while Britain basks. I'm fairly hardy for swimming, but it's too cold for the DCs to try. One October I swam a mile in an empty pool, but had to get out because I was freezing and the shivers kicking in. If the British holiday goes past Oct 31st that year, forget it.

We do UK holidays in the summer.
But July/ Aug is the wetter half of the British summer. Some years have been grim washouts for spending under canvas. Last year was a write off due to the aftermath of very sensitive asthma following the heatwave.

The best months in the UK and Europe tend to be May, June, September, but they're the least likely to get tweaked to gain holiday.

DisquietintheRanks · 25/07/2023 09:04

The thing about having 6 weeks in the summer is that it gives a lot of families the chance to go away for a week or two without everyone trying to go at the same time. And for those who aren't travelling there is (at least in theory) some summer weather to enjoy.

SparkyBlue · 25/07/2023 08:39

monpetitlapin · 24/07/2023 21:33

I'd quite honestly rather have 13 weeks off in the summer all at once (and be able to take that time off work as unpaid leave) to have epic adventures with the DCs across June, July and August and come back to work in September feeling ready to knuckle down. No one in schools is concentrating on much in June and July anyway. I'd like to be out and about rather than looking out of the window wishing I wasn't stuck at a desk trying to explain to Jane in Procurement why it's definitely her job to procure something.
Totally impractical to actually do this but it would be awesome nonetheless.

Irish secondary schools get this. We finish end of May and back start of September(possibly last week in August). It's a pain in the backside. Primary school get 8 or 9 weeks off.

Somewhereovertherainbowweighapie · 25/07/2023 08:33

In Australia we get 2 weeks in spring autumn and winter and about 6 weeks over summer. The winter holidays are usually full of sickness, so we don’t go anywhere.

Quisquam · 25/07/2023 08:30

Spring and autimn are often miserable (rather like this summer! 😂) and thus shit for being on holiday

We go to Scotland at the end of August. They tell us May is the best time. Last year, we went to Greece on May 19th - it was 28 - 30 every day, and the swimming pool wasn’t cold at all! Likewise, we’ve been to Florida in May and August - weather wise August was much worse! More humid and loads of tropical storms as it’s the hurricane season!

strongcupofTea · 25/07/2023 01:38

No I love the 6 weeks with my children. It's our favourite time of year. They've already shortened the Christmas holiday to the point we feel less Christmassy then we used to as it's all so rushed.

strongcupofTea · 25/07/2023 01:36

bellamountain · 24/07/2023 22:25

I work term time only and would welcome a shorter summer holiday and a couple of extra weeks tagged on elsewhere. For primary education this could definitely happen. 6 weeks is a long time for young children and they do actually regress by the time they go back.

Why would they regress? My children have always flourished being at home and out and about in the sunshine. Mine were like different children after lockdown. School sucks the life force out of them.

strongcupofTea · 25/07/2023 01:30

BungleandGeorge · 24/07/2023 20:34

There are at least 2 weeks at Easter, one week end of May and one or two weeks in October already. Plenty of time to go on holiday! Controversial but perhaps people jetting off on holiday is not helping with climate change and we shouldn’t be encouraged 🤷‍♀️

Not everyone Jets off in the summer holidays..ever heard of haven ?

thaegumathteth · 25/07/2023 00:32

We already get two weeks at Easter and two weeks in October

ZiriForEver · 25/07/2023 00:18

Potential inspiration - some EU countries have a part of holiday purposefully desynchronized.

In my country, there is a 6 weeks period during which every "county" has one week off, smaller regions are grouped to those slots to have similar population and reasonable geographical spread. And the schedule for those 6 weeks rotates every year. Historically, it was to allow everyone to go to the mountains/skiing (some snow was less than 2 hours drive for huge majority of the population).
It supports mostly domestic/local tourism, creates relevant winter holiday season, and means people aren't competing for few holiday places pricing each other out.

IamAlso4eels · 25/07/2023 00:14

I work in education and like the holidays the way they are now.

By the time it gets to July, the children are done. They're hot, they're tired, they've got as much learning stuffed into their heads as they can and they are in dire need of a break. The six weeks gives them a chance to recharge before moving to their next year group/key stage/portion of the curriculum.

Behind the scenes, there is a lot goes on in the six weeks that can't easily be done at other points of the year. It is safer and simpler to do certain maintenance and improvements while the school is empty - painting, wiring, new additions, large scale repairs, etc.

It's an opportunity for planning, prepping classrooms and resources, any urgent training, recruitment and so on.

Our school is semi-rural and some of our families are involved with farming while others are involved with the tourist industry. The six week break allows for work in these areas. We also have some pupils who are not originally from the UK and the holiday gives them the opportunity to go visit family abroad for an extended period, the same goes for some staff.

miniaturepixieonacid · 25/07/2023 00:04

shinyandnew - how old are the children at those independent schools? To be fair, where I work, our N, F, Y1 and Y2 classes do only go from 8:30 - 3;30 (or 4;30 if they choose enrichment programme) but the older children go to 4;45, 6;00 or 7;30 depending on age and enrichment choices. Or they board. So it varies a lot but they are usually getting significantly longer by Year 5ish. I wasn't really thinking about the little ones because I don't teach down there.

That's a rural boarding school though. I don't know if it's true of, for example, city day schools. I also don't know if those independent schools without the longer hours also get the very long holidays though.

Shinyandnew1 · 24/07/2023 23:56

I’d take 5 weeks in the summer for a 2 week October half term. I’d rather have 2 weeks at Whitsun, but that wouldn’t work well with public exams.

The comments about a private/public schools having longer holidays because they have long days is interesting. I know several friends with children at independent schools and their school day is no different to my DC-they start at 8.30 and finish at 3.30.

BorderlineCool · 24/07/2023 23:54

I'm in Scotland. We have 6 weeks in summer (we break off around 1st July). We also have two weeks in April, two weeks in October and two weeks at Christmas. I feel it's perfect.

miniaturepixieonacid · 24/07/2023 23:52

Teajenny7 · 24/07/2023 21:47

Please may I have
2 weeks in October
3 weeks at Christmas so I can celebrate New Year in style
2 weeks in February
3 weeks at Easter
2 weeks in May
6 weeks in the summer.

Pretty Please😂

Work in a private school and you'll get something very similar to that. I get approximately:

2 weeks in October
3 weeks at Christmas
1 week in February
2.5-3 weeks at Easter
1 week in May
8 weeks in Summer

Senior schools get even more - 9 week summers.

In return we work 1-3 hours longer per day than state schools, Saturday mornings (not universal to all independents but common) and loads of evening events/duties but I would say it's worth it for knowing you're never more than 6 weeks away from a decent break.

I think State schools should do what Nottinghamshire (I think) does - 5 week summer and a 2 week October half term. The October break, regardless of weather, is my favourite because it's such a long term. It feels like a perfect break in terms of length and timing - whereas an 8 week summer is totally uneccessary!

macrowave · 24/07/2023 23:47

CandyLeBonBon · 24/07/2023 22:29

European schools finish in June and go back in august (ish).

Makes sense.

I'd be all for adopting a more European approach to school holidays and school hours generally.

"European schools"? Which country?

What on earth is a "more European approach" - the 13-week break in Italy, the 9-week break in France, the 6-week break in Denmark?

Shinyandnew1 · 24/07/2023 23:44

This thread has occurred every July on MN every year since I joined. Some people want more holiday at February and Easter so they can go skiing, some want more time at Christmas so they can go off and visit family, some want less time in the summer because they don’t want to pay for the childcare. There is no one solution to everyone’s wants.

I don’t think the holidays will change because there is no agreed consensus for an alternative. We also already have one of the shortest summer holidays in the world-I don’t think it will be made any shorter.

DrCoconut · 24/07/2023 23:31

My ideal would be a shorter Christmas holiday to allow more time off in summer when (at least theoretically) the weather is better. I don't like the time between Christmas and new year at all, it's just really depressing, dark early and lots of things are closed. Extra time in the summer would make annual leave pressure a bit less for parents too as there'd be more time to choose from. We have some of the shortest summer holidays going compared to other countries.

CruCru · 24/07/2023 23:14

The thing is, would the change to term times be made compulsory for all schools? Private schools probably won’t adopt the new terms (in particular boarding schools - they have a really long summer break and many children go back to their home countries). Grammar schools (and other state schools with a relatively affluent intake) may also choose to stick with the old terms if their teachers like the long summer.

The risk is that a long summer break becomes something that only “posh” children get to have. Children of different backgrounds will mix even less than they do now - because the holidays won’t match.

VaccineSticker · 24/07/2023 23:13

Autumn and spring on the Med are a hit and miss. Reason why people visit these countries in the summer is because of the guaranteed warm sunny weather that’s suitable for a beach holiday. Visiting in Autumn and Spring is fine as long as you are not expecting to go swimming. The sea will be warm in Autumn but weather might be ify. However the sea will be cold in Spring while weather can be ify too. Oh they don’t heat their pools either.

Crispynoodle · 24/07/2023 23:12

I agree! And I'm a teacher! For years now the best of our UK summer is in June, so 3 or 4 weeks off then! July is always a washout so school then! Perhaps a week or two in August.

Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 24/07/2023 23:09

I think there is something to be said for the magic of 6 weeks of no school, no routine, time with parents, playing out and getting into scrapes.

That does assume a certain level of either neglect or privilege though.

PeskyRooks · 24/07/2023 23:03

Selfishly, I would love it if we had 2 weeks off in the summer and 6 weeks off in December and January! I bloody hate getting the kids up on those cold pitch dark mornings!