Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Parents of a child with autism- I'd value your feedback

261 replies

Flounder2022 · 24/07/2023 16:33

Sorry this ended up longer than I expected!

I was at an interactive museum today with my son and his friend. They really wanted to experience one exhibit that a little girl was on - it involved a large screen with touch points that took you through the entire human body. It was quite detailed so lots to see but could only be used by one person at a time. The waited patiently for a good while- 10 mins initially. They then decided to go to another screen close by and returned about 3/4 mins later and again waited. All in all we waited approx 20 mins. It was clear we were waiting for that particular one as it was in a little room of its own and we waited at the door. Eventually I asked the dad is they would be much longer to which he replied yes most likely. I asked if there was any way we could have a turn for a few minutes. He said no as she had autism and wanted to stay on it. He then said I could say it to her if I wanted but that he wouldn't be forcing her to move.

I told him I wouldn't not be saying it to her as she was not my child nor was I asking him to force her but maybe he could have a conversation with her. I'll admit my back was up by this point, not because of what he said but how he said it. He was so rude and dismissive. (the above is not the entirety of the conversation but the main jist of it.)

He then told me he was going to speak to management about me and walked off. We left the area then as waiting any longer was futile. Shortly afterwards I saw him re-enter the area (I have no idea if he spoke to staff). I approached him and said that had he acknowledged our presence, that he was aware we were waiting and explained that they might be there a while we could have moved on. He said we should have done so anyway as his child was entitled to spend as long as she wished on the exhibit. I told him consideration for others (from him) was not too much to ask.

Was I out of line here? I'm very aware that he angered me a lot with his attitude and the dismissive way he spoke to me that I may not be clearly seeing the situation.

Thanks!

OP posts:
AllOfThemWitches · 24/07/2023 20:23

How do you know it’s enough though? You have absolutely no idea what is a reasonable adjustment because you don’t know the people involved.

They obviously think autistic children ought to be held to the same standards as neurotypical children. Imagine being that ignorant and showing it off as though its something to be proud of.

blueshoes · 24/07/2023 20:22

ZairWazAnOldLady · 24/07/2023 20:17

How do you know it’s enough though? You have absolutely no idea what is a reasonable adjustment because you don’t know the people involved.

It is enough adjustment, more than to an NT kid. No one person trumps the other in a public place. It is a reasonable compromise.

ZairWazAnOldLady · 24/07/2023 20:17

blueshoes · 24/07/2023 20:11

Not sure about trumping this and that. OP and her dc have already waited 20 mins. That is enough special accommodation.

How do you know it’s enough though? You have absolutely no idea what is a reasonable adjustment because you don’t know the people involved.

Vinvertebrate · 24/07/2023 20:16

It’s often the case (in my experience) that people are less tolerant of a disability that they cannot see and while OP can’t be expected to understand the ins and outs of this child’s autism I wonder if the real issue is that she can’t imagine how a child cannot be able to comply with basic give and take

Absolutely this. Nobody would dream of making comments about the physically disabled that have been made about autistic children on this thread. If they did, they’d be banned. Rightly so.

LuvSmallDogs · 24/07/2023 20:16

blueshoes · 24/07/2023 20:03

Let me write in full sentences. I understand there are people who are slower to get the gist of things, even though it is in context.

Making excuses for the dad's behaviour ... there you go.

And what would your excuse be for being rude?

ItsNotRocketSalad · 24/07/2023 20:15

TherapySquirrel · 24/07/2023 19:31

To an NT person, yes. There is a high liklihood that the Dad is also Autistic and didn't pick up on that. He interpreted the question literally and answered it literally. It would also explain why he was unable to see the situation from OP's point of view and was singularly focused on meeting his own child's needs, instead of conforming to unwritten social rules re not monopolising the exhibits.

He very clearly understood that the OP's children were waiting to use the exhibit and had been for some time. He wasn't confused, he was a prick.

DyslexicPoster · 24/07/2023 20:13

I don't think you was out of line OP, but I'm trying to bring my dc with ASD to be the best version of themselves they can be.

There is a big section of parents who totally submit their child's ASD especially if it's PDA.

I don't think there is right or wrong way to parent ASD kids but I do this way for a easy life as I don't want to be abused primarily by them as they grow up.

However this man was rude, aggressive and imo ( flame me) give us all SEN parents a bad name.

The more I submit to my PDA child the more other people tell me she is rude and entitled. My dd isn't stupid and she can learn. That can be safely and within her comfort zone.

I fully belive ASD AND also being a arsehole isn't mutually exclusive. He could have chosen to explain to you nicely but he didn't.

Skinthin · 24/07/2023 20:12

PinkyU · 24/07/2023 20:06

Turn taking means you wait your turn, not someone else gives up there’s for you.

I’m not sure I’d send the message to my daughter that she needs to make way for boys who just can’t wait or find something else to do in the interim, or that them wanting a turn overrides her already using it.

Nah. Turn taking means you learn to take turns, that’s both give and take. You wait your turn, because you expect others to give it to you when they’ve had theirs. It’s a rule/
principle based on reciprocity. You absolutely do need to teach your daughter this, regardless of her or anyone else’s sex. 🤦🏼‍♀️

blueshoes · 24/07/2023 20:11

ZairWazAnOldLady · 24/07/2023 20:07

Well yes, most people know that. It’s clear in this case that the OP feels her children’s needs trump the disabled child’s needs. It’s clear the father in question feels his disabled child’s needs trump OPs needs. It’s often the case (in my experience) that people are less tolerant of a disability that they cannot see and while OP can’t be expected to understand the ins and outs of this child’s autism I wonder if the real issue is that she can’t imagine how a child cannot be able to comply with basic give and take. Autism can be very baffling to the ignorant. It’s fairly baffling to some of us who aren’t.

Not sure about trumping this and that. OP and her dc have already waited 20 mins. That is enough special accommodation.

ZairWazAnOldLady · 24/07/2023 20:07

whatevss · 24/07/2023 19:19

"OP was trying to avoid upsetting her children, the Dad was trying to avoid upsetting his."

Do you know that disabled people are legally entitled to 'special' treatment? Not equal treatment. Special treatment that adjusts services to meet the needs that arise from their disability.

The child just needed a bit more time. You'd think her dad was asking for the moon. How fucking dare he advocate for his kid. Worst dad in the fucking world!

Well yes, most people know that. It’s clear in this case that the OP feels her children’s needs trump the disabled child’s needs. It’s clear the father in question feels his disabled child’s needs trump OPs needs. It’s often the case (in my experience) that people are less tolerant of a disability that they cannot see and while OP can’t be expected to understand the ins and outs of this child’s autism I wonder if the real issue is that she can’t imagine how a child cannot be able to comply with basic give and take. Autism can be very baffling to the ignorant. It’s fairly baffling to some of us who aren’t.

PinkyU · 24/07/2023 20:06

Turn taking means you wait your turn, not someone else gives up there’s for you.

I’m not sure I’d send the message to my daughter that she needs to make way for boys who just can’t wait or find something else to do in the interim, or that them wanting a turn overrides her already using it.

10HailMarys · 24/07/2023 20:05

cyncope · 24/07/2023 17:00

If it was an adult using an exhibit and you wanted a go, would you have told them to move?

I don't think autism is particularly relevant to this. Person A was using something and hadn't finished with it. You had the rest of the museum to look round. It might have been disappointing for your child not to get what they wanted but that's life sometimes.

Once you'd asked the dad if they'd be long and he said yes, you should have just accepted it and moved on rather than keeping on at him and then finding him again to have another go! Just leave people be.

It’s a public space that is meant to be shared. Why should one child (or one adult) monopolise one activity and other children miss out, when the obviously fair and considerate thing to do is for them all to take a turn?

Why do they OP’s children have to be the ones who miss out entirely because ‘that’s life sometimes’ while the other kid gets what they want?

The fact that one child is autistic doesn’t mean that they get to have everything they want while other children have to go without.

blueshoes · 24/07/2023 20:03

LuvSmallDogs · 24/07/2023 19:34

Making excuses, as though it was something I did? 🤣

OP's not exactly great either of course, trying to police a disabled child using a museum exhibit and then coming here to stir up the usual "ASD is never an excuuuse".

Let me write in full sentences. I understand there are people who are slower to get the gist of things, even though it is in context.

Making excuses for the dad's behaviour ... there you go.

AmericasfavoritefightingFrenchman · 24/07/2023 20:00

Wenfy · 24/07/2023 17:33

I have an 11 yo DD with ASD - she would have been terrified as soon as you asked the question and would have stopped playing (and enjoying herself). Your one comment might have ruined her day and forced us to go home. I would have been furious with you for being so entitled as to enforce a time limit for an attraction when the organisers didn’t.

My 3.5 yo doesn’t have ASD but is a toddler and like any toddler struggles with rule taking. I would not have forced him to come off in the absence of any official notifications.

Ok @Wenfy, I get that the perceived confrontation in that situation could be very upsetting to your DD. Sometimes I struggle with reading judgement into tone where it doesn't actually exist, and then I feel even worse once I realise my misunderstanding. It can definitely spiral and I'm an adult. I wouldn't intentionally provoke that reaction.

But, I'm really curious that you think it is entitled to want the opportunity for a turn at an event or attraction? And about how you navigate what to teach your DC if you think turn taking is not a necessity of life?

For instance, if my DS, who has additional needs and is probably autistic, was there he would have been super into that kind of science-y interactive exhibit, would have been looking forward to it, would have probably researched it and been keen to try it out before we got there. He would have been struggling to hold himself back from asking for a turn in his excitement, but he probably would have had some success because we've worked really hard on learning about patience and turn taking and why they are important. We talk about respecting the other person's turn and their enjoyment, so that they will respect ours.

He would have been devastated if you refused to facilitate a turn after 20+ minutes of waiting. We might well have had to go home in that situation. I would have been furious with you for being so entitled as to think that your DD or your toddler deserved unlimited private use of the facility to the detriment of everyone else in a public space. I would have been furious that you thought her additional needs trumped the needs of any other disabled or ND person in attendance.

Soapboxqueen · 24/07/2023 19:57

Usernameunknownfornow · 24/07/2023 19:50

How would the OP have known the girl was autistic if OP didn't ask the dad if her children can have a turn.

I wouldn't have asked at all, additional needs isn't a factor. If there's plenty of other things to be doing, I would have directed my child to those things.

In fairness, my ds would have been very vocal in his displeasure so no-one would be in any doubt he wanted a turn.

I take the view that, if the child has additional needs which is why they are hogging an activity, wherever possible, I'd rather they had the extra time. If the child and parent are just entitled, I'm unlikely to get the result I want without some confrontation which I can't be arsed with.

So eitherway, there isn't much to be gained.

Skinthin · 24/07/2023 19:52

TherapySquirrel · 24/07/2023 19:38

Of course there is a recognised social norm that one person/ child doesn’t hog an exhibit/ activity in a public space for too long when other people are waiting. Same in a playground. That’s just how it works.

Again, this is not necessarily obvious to ND people. You are taking it for granted that every adult understands unwritten social rules and has the capacity to model them for their kids. One of the most challenging aspects of Autism is that everyone expects you to know "that's just how it works" when actually social norms and the rules of "polite" behaviour are utterly bewildering to some ND people.

Yes I can understand that the Dad might have been ND and not understood that. (Or maybe he was NT and knew full well but just a lazy/ selfish dick).
However. I was responding to a poster who was arguing that regardless of disability OP had no right to expect them to move on as there was no time limit on the exhibition and therefore OP was the one being unreasonable and selfish.

Usernameunknownfornow · 24/07/2023 19:50

Soapboxqueen · 24/07/2023 19:31

Tbh OP I probably wouldn't have even asked. I would have just kept coming back and checking to see if the girl had moved on.

If I had asked, I would have understood that it can be very difficult to move an autistic child on from something. Sometimes even with lots of planning, support and modelling, a situation can go tits up. Sometimes you know that you are on the cusp of a meltdown and it's just safer to not rock the boat.

Sometimes you have the energy to be understanding and explain and be patient. Other times you don't and can't be arsed with yet another person thinking that you're doing something wrong by supporting and advocating for your child.

I think just chalk this up to experience OP

How would the OP have known the girl was autistic if OP didn't ask the dad if her children can have a turn.

IAmNoLady · 24/07/2023 19:39

I have a child with ASD and last time we visited a museum we sat on the floor in a quiet, fairly hidden part of the museum for 20 mins because he was so wound up by the noise and busyness.

My son is 10, so not age appropriate behaviour. At the time, I was so concerned with keeping him safe and regulating him, that his wellbeing trumped any passers-bys.

Maybe this dad was being a dick. Maybe he was trying to navigate through a tough situation. Maybe he is still grieving that his child doesn't 'cope' like others.

All I know being a parent of af a child with ASD is bloody hard.

TherapySquirrel · 24/07/2023 19:38

Of course there is a recognised social norm that one person/ child doesn’t hog an exhibit/ activity in a public space for too long when other people are waiting. Same in a playground. That’s just how it works.

Again, this is not necessarily obvious to ND people. You are taking it for granted that every adult understands unwritten social rules and has the capacity to model them for their kids. One of the most challenging aspects of Autism is that everyone expects you to know "that's just how it works" when actually social norms and the rules of "polite" behaviour are utterly bewildering to some ND people.

Skinthin · 24/07/2023 19:37

TheFormidableMrsC · 24/07/2023 17:45

It's people like you who give SN families a bad name. What a dreadful attitude.

And her toddler doesn’t even have SEN! Right little monster that child is going to grow up to be…

LuvSmallDogs · 24/07/2023 19:34

blueshoes · 24/07/2023 19:19

I see you are making excuses. Sure, that could be the case. Except, he did not do it in the heat of the moment. He presumably would have already removed his dd from the exhibit to go to make the complaint. He went all the way to try and put OP in her place. Dick.

Making excuses, as though it was something I did? 🤣

OP's not exactly great either of course, trying to police a disabled child using a museum exhibit and then coming here to stir up the usual "ASD is never an excuuuse".

Skinthin · 24/07/2023 19:32

cyncope · 24/07/2023 17:13

So why not do other stuff and come back at the end?

Why do you get to decide the time limit for this exhibit and not the person using it?

@cyncope your take is just not it.

Of course there is a recognised social norm that one person/ child doesn’t hog an exhibit/ activity in a public space for too long when other people are waiting. Same in a playground. That’s just how it works. There doesn’t need to be a specific time limit on every activity for that to be managed . All it requires is for people to have basic levels of curtesy and consideration for others. Obviously young children can’t always be expected to manage that which is why it is up to their parents to intervene.

TherapySquirrel · 24/07/2023 19:31

ItsNotRocketSalad · 24/07/2023 18:30

Well yes, "will you be long?" means "please hurry up as I'm waiting and you've had long enough."

To an NT person, yes. There is a high liklihood that the Dad is also Autistic and didn't pick up on that. He interpreted the question literally and answered it literally. It would also explain why he was unable to see the situation from OP's point of view and was singularly focused on meeting his own child's needs, instead of conforming to unwritten social rules re not monopolising the exhibits.

Soapboxqueen · 24/07/2023 19:31

Tbh OP I probably wouldn't have even asked. I would have just kept coming back and checking to see if the girl had moved on.

If I had asked, I would have understood that it can be very difficult to move an autistic child on from something. Sometimes even with lots of planning, support and modelling, a situation can go tits up. Sometimes you know that you are on the cusp of a meltdown and it's just safer to not rock the boat.

Sometimes you have the energy to be understanding and explain and be patient. Other times you don't and can't be arsed with yet another person thinking that you're doing something wrong by supporting and advocating for your child.

I think just chalk this up to experience OP

Clymene · 24/07/2023 19:26

This is the first thread on MN where the parents of autistic kids are behaving worse than the parents of NT kids. Bravo OP!