Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To return to MN after a decade & think it’s changed a lot

114 replies

ExNorfolk · 24/07/2023 16:32

Do you think MN has changed in the last decade?

Observations: to me it seems that people are more stressed, more aggressive & quicker to judge, and less tolerant and supportive. Possibly more right wing. Users maybe older? 45-55 instead of 35-45 (which would make sense if it’s the same users a decade on)
These are generalisations. I’ve lurked and read about 100 threads in different forums. AIBU was always a bit of a brawl. But the general rise in snark seems to me to be more widespread.
(yes, I know I don’t have to post here, and could go somewhere else). I am just interested to know your experience

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WeetabixTowels · 26/07/2023 16:37

Threenow · 26/07/2023 01:14

I agree with this. Everyone gets anxious, sad, stressed, but on MN it's all elevated to a mental health issue, which only minimizes it for those who actually do suffer from one.

As for those with no coping life skills, I am amazed at how little some posters can deal with, how everything becomes such a huge issue and drama. How have we got to this stage? I don't know anyone in real life who is like this, most people seem far more resilient and pragmatic.

Agree with this.

I also don’t know any kind of families IRL that are like MN families. There are SO MANY posters who start a thread ‘I have 5 children all with ASD/ADHD!’

I knew a few with one child who has ASD or ADHD but HOW do they even get 5 diagnoses?! What is their family life like?! See also so many children who are non-verbal or home schooled. I like to think my circle is diverse but really it’s nothing like the MN make up

CurlewKate · 26/07/2023 12:21

To be honest, I think it's a bit pathetic to give a person the same present 4 times running. It's not a "leave him"
situation, but certainly shows lack of thought and emotional intelligence..

Coatimundi · 26/07/2023 09:58

Oh yes, I saw the earrings thread. It was mad.

pastatriangles · 26/07/2023 09:46

GroutScrubberExtraordinaire · 26/07/2023 08:25

Absolutely @Tessisme - like the recent thread about a lady whose husband bought her the same earrings a few times over.

She wasn't offended, was genuinely happy in her marriage and it started as a light hearted thread.

Before long she was told he didn't love her, never loved her, probably didn't buy the earrings himself and got his non-existent secretary to buy them for all his girls. Was accused of lying because the shop she claimed sold them didn't really sell them (spoiler: they did). The earrings were shit and looked like they cost £3 (spoiler: they cost £350 ish). Further along, she didn't know what real love was and some posters felt sorry for her for having such low standards in her marriage and should leave him.

It was mad how dark it got!

I posted about a minor problem with my child's school and was accused of lying/trolling because of a million tiny irrelevant points ('no school does that' type of thing). It's pointless posting here just to get attacked. There are better and more supportive groups to be part of.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 26/07/2023 09:45

Smartphones have brought the Internet to a far wider range of people, so it's not surprising that posters here come from more varied backgrounds than they used to. I have the impression that there are more posts from people who struggle with literacy than there used to be. Some posts make little sense. Also, many more people than before take things very literally, don't get obvious jokes, don't spot obvious sarcasm, etc etc. You never used to see (light-hearted) in a thread title because it wasn't needed.

isthismylifenow · 26/07/2023 09:41

GroutScrubberExtraordinaire · 26/07/2023 08:25

Absolutely @Tessisme - like the recent thread about a lady whose husband bought her the same earrings a few times over.

She wasn't offended, was genuinely happy in her marriage and it started as a light hearted thread.

Before long she was told he didn't love her, never loved her, probably didn't buy the earrings himself and got his non-existent secretary to buy them for all his girls. Was accused of lying because the shop she claimed sold them didn't really sell them (spoiler: they did). The earrings were shit and looked like they cost £3 (spoiler: they cost £350 ish). Further along, she didn't know what real love was and some posters felt sorry for her for having such low standards in her marriage and should leave him.

It was mad how dark it got!

This was awful. A few other recent ones spring to mind too.

What I have noticed though, yes there are a lot of trolls and fake posts, and it seems that many posters try to get in quick to test the facts. To try to be the one that caught out the troll.....to be the best armchair detective of the day... But in the process of doing this, the nitpicking has become ridiculous. I think it stops some people for posting and asking for advice, as they know the chances of them getting steam rolled for something completely unrelated, is very possible.

Crikeyalmighty · 26/07/2023 09:34

@TwinsPlusAnotherOne totally agree. And there now seems some far more extreme posters from the 'I've got £2.40 to last me 20 days' to the 'I can't find a house I like with a £4 million budget' - This in itself I think creates both envy and nastiness - I'm not sure it was ever that diverse before and whilst diverse in life is good it does create issues on forums

Brk · 26/07/2023 09:28

People are more deliberately nasty now, there are obviously a lot of members who just joined to troll mums. AIBU was harsh and very blunt a decade ago but it wasn’t cruel.

Tessisme · 26/07/2023 09:14

I saw that one @GroutScrubberExtraordinaire!

GroutScrubberExtraordinaire · 26/07/2023 08:25

Absolutely @Tessisme - like the recent thread about a lady whose husband bought her the same earrings a few times over.

She wasn't offended, was genuinely happy in her marriage and it started as a light hearted thread.

Before long she was told he didn't love her, never loved her, probably didn't buy the earrings himself and got his non-existent secretary to buy them for all his girls. Was accused of lying because the shop she claimed sold them didn't really sell them (spoiler: they did). The earrings were shit and looked like they cost £3 (spoiler: they cost £350 ish). Further along, she didn't know what real love was and some posters felt sorry for her for having such low standards in her marriage and should leave him.

It was mad how dark it got!

Tessisme · 26/07/2023 07:53

There is a lot more thread derailment now, which in itself causes huge amounts of squabbling and nastiness. A poster comes on and asks a question like 'AIBU to ask my neighbour to give back my lawnmower?' with details of said problem. A few relevant/sensible answers follow, then something like 'What type of lawnmower is it?', 'I've never heard of that. Are you American?', 'Get some of that artificial grass. Problem solved.' You shouldn't be using a lawnmower, it's bad for the environment/butterflies/bees', etc etc. By the end, most people have forgotten what the original question was and the OP has disappeared, having had their entire character called into question over a household appliance.

I had my first ever deletion in 16 years the other day because I got far too wound up by a thread derailment and then very unhelpfully became PART of the derailment by engaging with it - which is basically taking the bait. Time for me to stay away from the bun fights I reckon. Some of the boards are great like 'What Are We Reading', 'Arts and Crafts' and 'Style and Beauty' (although I've seen things turn a bit nasty on there from time to time😬) but AIBU is brutal. And sometimes Chat can get pretty nasty too.

TwinsPlusAnotherOne · 26/07/2023 07:51

I used MN about 15yrs ago. Rejoined again more recently.

What I liked, before, was the general sweeping level of intelligence. I'd ask things that I knew I would receive well thought out responses. Actually useful and I'd use the advice, it was like a high level pool of personalised information at my fingertips. If someone didn't agree, they would generally post something very funny to get their opposing view across.

It felt, socially, like The Cambridge Footlights. Now, it feels like Vicky Pollard has infiltrated. There are still well thought out responses, but it's one of those, followed by several "yeah but no but" which dilutes the thread completely. I can't establish whether it's due to being hard of thinking, or deliberately misinterpreting just to have something to post outrage about.

There's a reason my threads now, are no longer any deeper than gravy recommendations. If I want proper important advice, I type the question into Google, then click on similar Mumsnet threads from 2009 ish.

Endlesssummer2022 · 26/07/2023 07:10

It used to be funnier and more supportive. It’s now more right wing and spiteful but I think that’s a reflection of the political environment and the current mood of the country as a result.

helpddgrow · 26/07/2023 06:44

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for privacy reasons

helpddgrow · 26/07/2023 06:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for privacy reasons

AnImaginaryCat · 26/07/2023 06:40

I think there was always snipping, nastiness, and overtly serious posters.

However there does seem to be an decrease in frivolously daft threads started purely to be silly and that remain daft and silly.

Threads about things like "which way do you hang your toilet roll?", that would run and run with faux anger and outrage. (And even then you'd have some unhappy posters on them loathing it all but thar wouldn't take over.) The anger and outrage are real now
The unhappy poster more frequent (or persistent maybe). For whatever reason.

Also i think while many of the long daft threads were "had to be there" so wouldn't seen funny to posters looking back to them if you weren't involved at the time. But there really does seen to be far less humorous.

CurlewKate · 26/07/2023 05:51

I'm also back after along gap-and one thing that hasn't changed are the threads about how Mumsnet has changed and it used to be funnier and kinder and more compassionate!🤣. That being said, I do think that the tone of the site feels much more right leaning. And, sadly, much more anti feminist.

Coatimundi · 26/07/2023 05:34

I don't think anyone is foolish for starting threads outside AIBU. I have had a lot of support from most people. Just a couple of weirdos who like to advance search.

CrazyArmadilloLady · 26/07/2023 05:32

I mean, yeah, it’s changed. 10 years have passed.

I just treat the place as a diversion.

I think you’re a fool to start threads on here. It’s utterly brutal. I use the place as somewhere to pass time on threads other people are misguided enough to start.

Threemyopicmice · 26/07/2023 05:22

IMO it's got so far left it's coming around for the second time.

If you complain about immigration you're automatically a knuckle-dragging fascist.

I am surprised at how many women are married to idle husbands yet still keep having kids with them. These kids then grow up into idle entitled teenagers and appear on other threads years later.

Every week we have a thread about a female who's partner has gone to a strip/lap dancing club.

So many women post to say they have been cheated on. It's depressing.

Just about every day we have a thread bashing government members.

It's getting boring.

calyxx · 26/07/2023 05:13

Agree, I was here 15 years ago and there were a bunch of smart, funny women with a strong take on parenting dilemmas, and good discussions. Still pick up some good ideas but there's so much snappy nastiness and not much wit. The reputation around trans stuff means a lot of women have left, too, and there have been some truly unpleasant posts eg about pride.

Coatimundi · 26/07/2023 05:08

Been on here for years. Am going through a difficult time in my marriage. Now I namechange every few weeks because there are a couple of posters who stalk me across various boards to fact check me and berate me for not sticking to every detail of my story ( I change small details so am not outed). That's the change. ( And I don't even post in AIBU).

foreverbasil · 26/07/2023 04:11

It's a lot less witty and a lot more angry. I hate to see the pile-ons. I think in the past people would give thoughtful and individual responses especially on the relationships board ....now it's immediately ' LTB' for even slight transgressions.
I hope women feel they can still come here in their more difficult days but do have concerns that the aggressiveness of some posters would put them off.
I got fantastic support here for a horrible situation, I'm not sure it would happen now.

Sycasmores · 26/07/2023 03:43

Not opening your door when someone knocks appears to now be commonplace....honestly I think 10-20 years ago it was generally higher functioning women. Today it seems to have a high proportion of fairly stresses low functioning women waiting to pounce.

coxesorangepippin · 26/07/2023 01:49

Well the really funny comments are few and far between let's face it

Seems to be a lot of autism/anxiety/ADHD excuses going around all the time too

Definitely changed a lot

Swipe left for the next trending thread