Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my child a psychopath?

205 replies

Cindertoffebuns · 24/07/2023 15:56

I have 4 kids. All girls
They have adhd and we do our very best to manage this in a variety of different ways. We are very firm at home.

Today they went to a holiday club. DD 2 picked a ball up and threw it at DD 3 hurting her. Apparently this was before a game had started. She then didn’t bother to say sorry or check if she was ok ect. Just thought it would be a laugh to hurt her and run off. She is 10. Sister is 8.

Asking if she is likely a psychopath as she didn’t stop and check and she’s going into year 6 this year, that’s not normal is it.
For context she is the child that is the most mean spirited out of all of them. Always has to take things too far or ruin the day by hurting somebody.
She does have autism but can’t see this as an excuse tbh. Day 1 of the summer holidays and I could have relied on her to ruin them.
I know that sounds mean but I’m exasperated and her sisters are starting to really feel the impact of having to be around her so much.
The rest of us are so nice, why is she so mean spirited?

OP posts:
Scirocco · 24/07/2023 18:05

Psychopathy is a serious psychiatric diagnosis, not something to label a child with because they do some things you don't like.

Rather than thinking of your DD as 'mean spirited' (which isn't a nice thing to say at all about your child), can you think of anything you actually like about her and that she's good at, and encourage her in that?

Splitting your children into one being 'all good' and one being 'all bad' is only going to hurt them and you.

Pufflebow · 24/07/2023 18:05

The way you describe your children is appalling

one is lovely and lights up the room, she’s nice, she’s like the rest of you.

the other one is different, mean spirited, not like the rest of the family, ‘always’ ruins everything. She’s not normal.

theres no way the kid isn’t picking up on how you think about her.
you also clearly have no idea about autism or about psychopaths but you’re willing to dismiss one and diagnose another.

Maybe you’re struggling to teach her kindness and empathy because you seem to be struggling with it yourself

LanaDelRaybans · 24/07/2023 18:03

Do all 4 of your children have ADHD? What ages?

MamaGhina · 24/07/2023 18:03

What was the consequence for this behaviour?
My DC with ADHD is impulsive, sometimes mean, often doesn’t think things through but he certainly understands a punishment and what it was for.

beeswaxinc · 24/07/2023 17:54

PinkyFlamingo · 24/07/2023 17:48

I dont think you do. Otherwise you would know its tne old nature nurture argument and is not always about trauma.

Exactly. @BiscuitsandPuffin sorry but your post made me angry with your very clear and deliberate misinformation coupled with your claim that you "work in this area".

You may well do but you clearly don't have a competent grasp on the scope of the causes (and the main crux which is that there is no single identifiable cause) of this condition.

Telling a mum who's concerned about their child that it can only be caused by awful, significant trauma seems very off.

Lavenderflower · 24/07/2023 17:54

It is very unlikely. Perhaps, she requires more support - can you contact CAMHS or school.

JusthereforXmas · 24/07/2023 17:50

User68253 · 24/07/2023 17:38

I have a 16 year old with ASD and ADHD and I honestly used to Google signs of a psychopath a lot, because she had no remorse/guilt/fear/inhibition about anything at all and only very occasionally showed empathy and I wasn't sure it was genuine or acting. But I am relieved to say she does have empathy and remorse now, it started to develop between age 10-12, her whole personality actually changed, she is very much an introvert now when she used to have no inhibitions.

My nearly 15 year old still doesn't show ANY emotion at all, he is however hardworking, well behaved, mostly trustworthy and mostly gentle... I don't really worry that hes a secret psychopath.

He has always seemed introverted though.

Really the only time he ever wavers at all on trustworthiness and gentleness is with his brother because they play rough and egg each other on. Hes fine with his sister though.

gavisconismyfriend · 24/07/2023 17:49

It may seem completely unprovoked but might actually relate to something that happened previously that your DD has been struggling to process and was finally unable to hold the emotions in any more.

PinkyFlamingo · 24/07/2023 17:48

BiscuitsandPuffin · 24/07/2023 16:46

I work in this area.
Psychopathic Personality Disorder is caused by an extremely traumatic major event in very early childhood that takes away the main caregivers or destroys any trust in them e.g. severe child abuse of the most extreme sort.
If your child hasn't been horrifically abused as a baby/toddler, it is extremely unlikely she is going to develop PPD.
We're talking about people who survive the sort of shit you read about in the papers e.g. if Baby P had survived.
It doesn't just spontaneously develop. So unless there's a big drip feed coming, you've got nothing to worry about.

I dont think you do. Otherwise you would know its tne old nature nurture argument and is not always about trauma.

xyz111 · 24/07/2023 17:43

I'd read that a child with ASD has the emotional age of 3 years younger than them. So sometimes they don't see the consequences of their actions, or understand why something is "wrong".

JusthereforXmas · 24/07/2023 17:43

My 13 year old broke my 3 year olds arm when he tackled him as he ran across the park... never said sorry.

I took 3 year old to hospital so figured DH would sort it. He and his family saw no reason to apologize as it 'must be an accident'. Then insisted 6 hours later (when we got back from hospital) was 'too late' to say sorry.

My DS is not a psychopath, he is however a bit of an oaf.

What happened is simply a case of not considering hes nearly 5x the size of his siblings (hes big, like 6 foot and well built) and a lack of fore thinking about the possible consequences of what he is doing.

As for not apologizing, it seems every man and his dog will happily tell kids now a days they don't bloody have too. They make out we are unreasonable if we expect basic decency. So what hope do the next gen kids have.

VanillaApples · 24/07/2023 17:43

VanillaApples · 24/07/2023 17:36

Qualified in ECCE here - I’d say this is relatively normal sibling behavior, especially between two older kids, and especially for kids who have trouble already regulating themselves.

Discipline her as you normally would (example: she threw the ball, she doesn’t get it back until she apologizes, etc). Ask her how she would like it if a ball was thrown at her? Teach that actions = consequences, and if she doesn’t respond, then worry or look into other behavioral therapy.

Something I picked up on in your comments is you said (paraphrasing) Day 1 of holidays and you knew she would ruin it. Be careful how much of your communication is non verbal. Maybe you think you’re not showing her your level of concern or dislike of her behaviors, but your non verbal communication could be wildly different. If your daughter is picking up on your nerves or concerns, it could be fueling her too.

Plus, she’s 10. Psychically, a lot of changes are going on in her body and mind. Add those to an additional need, things are going to be very off for her.

Honestly I think you should spend some 1 on 1 time with her. Get her talking, do something she’s interested in, and actually communicate WITH her

Meant to be physically not psychically 😂😂😂

PinkyFlamingo · 24/07/2023 17:43

OlympicProcrastinator · 24/07/2023 16:15

A two year old diagnosed with ADHD? Really?

Someone who hasn't read post properly really.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 24/07/2023 17:39

I see she gets her empathy from her mother

AllTheChaos · 24/07/2023 17:38

Not implying that Op’s child is btw, just saying that where a child is, diagnosis is possible at that age.

User68253 · 24/07/2023 17:38

I have a 16 year old with ASD and ADHD and I honestly used to Google signs of a psychopath a lot, because she had no remorse/guilt/fear/inhibition about anything at all and only very occasionally showed empathy and I wasn't sure it was genuine or acting. But I am relieved to say she does have empathy and remorse now, it started to develop between age 10-12, her whole personality actually changed, she is very much an introvert now when she used to have no inhibitions.

AllTheChaos · 24/07/2023 17:37

pikkumyy77 · 24/07/2023 15:58

No she is not a psychopath. No diagnosis can be given such a young child.

At 10 years old? A diagnosis is possible - I don’t know how it’s done but a family friends child was diagnosed earlier and educated in a very specific environment as a result.

VanillaApples · 24/07/2023 17:36

Qualified in ECCE here - I’d say this is relatively normal sibling behavior, especially between two older kids, and especially for kids who have trouble already regulating themselves.

Discipline her as you normally would (example: she threw the ball, she doesn’t get it back until she apologizes, etc). Ask her how she would like it if a ball was thrown at her? Teach that actions = consequences, and if she doesn’t respond, then worry or look into other behavioral therapy.

Something I picked up on in your comments is you said (paraphrasing) Day 1 of holidays and you knew she would ruin it. Be careful how much of your communication is non verbal. Maybe you think you’re not showing her your level of concern or dislike of her behaviors, but your non verbal communication could be wildly different. If your daughter is picking up on your nerves or concerns, it could be fueling her too.

Plus, she’s 10. Psychically, a lot of changes are going on in her body and mind. Add those to an additional need, things are going to be very off for her.

Honestly I think you should spend some 1 on 1 time with her. Get her talking, do something she’s interested in, and actually communicate WITH her

Defiantjazz · 24/07/2023 17:35

I’m not calling her a psychopath I’m asking if she could be 🫣

Because she threw a ball at her sister ?

BelindaBears · 24/07/2023 17:34

I can remember hitting one of my brothers over the head with a tennis racket when I was maybe 9 and he was 5. Wasn’t remotely remorseful. I’m not a psychopath I was just frustrated by an annoying sibling and wanted to bash him.

Jumprope309 · 24/07/2023 17:32

What I got from your OP is that your daughter is the scapegoat child and she know it.

Do you tell her she ‘Always has to take things too far or ruin the day by hurting somebody’
Has she heard you say you expect her to ruin the summer holidays on day 1?
Do you think she might have picked up you think the rest of her sisters are ‘so nice’ and that you think she’s ‘mean spirited’ .

Even if you haven’t said it, she knows.

marchdays · 24/07/2023 17:30

Differences with empathy and understanding other's feelings and even caring about how others feel will most likely be due to her autism.

I totally get the wondering if she's a psychopath, I've had similar worries about my ds as he has exhibited a similar lack of concern for his siblings. (He has now been diagnosed with autism which explains so much.)

It is hard, but regardless of how our kids are we have to give them unconditional love and some days we just have to get through. Solidarity

Doingmybest12 · 24/07/2023 17:30

It is wearing and hard when one child seems to be out of step. It isn't beyond the realms of normal behaviour I don't think for siblings. I think you've got to accept the child you've got and I am sure she'll get there in terms of her impulse control and empathy in time. It must be hard for her too if she has a different nature to the rest of the family. It will be ok but it must be hard work with all of the children, hope you find time for a breather.

JonahAndTheSnail · 24/07/2023 17:28

Does she seem to enjoy the holiday club? Maybe she's struggling with having to be sociable in an unfamiliar setting. Could just be sibling jealousy, my brothers would do things like that to each other a lot at that age to try to get the other one into trouble.

Swipe left for the next trending thread